9 ms·
Google internet balloon spinoff Loon still looking for its wings
- ravenstine 7y agoI hate to be that guy, but won't this contribute to the depletion of our helium reserves? What would be so bad about hydrogen in relatively small balloons? It's not like they'd all be little Hindenbergs, right?
- grenoire 7y agoNot sure, I just imagine people attempting to shoot them down for absolutely no good reason. You would at least want to make them not blow up (especially aviation organisations).
- andrewflnr 7y agoIf they're high enough, blowing up might actually be the safest option. Better that all the hydrogen burn off up there than on the ground, when it doesn't have enough to be bouyant but still enough to do damage.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoIt's going to be a disaster in R&D or when you want to land them down for some maintenance...
- ravenstine 7y agoWon't they be way up high? Even if one blew up, it'd be too high to hurt anyone. In fact it'd probably be tough to make one blow up from that distance. The best one could do is shoot at it, which won't ignite the hydrogen.
- grenoire 7y agoI think you are underestimating the effort people will go through to go viral on LiveLeak.
- TylerE 7y agoHydrogen doesn't explode. It burns.
- dredmorbius 7y agoHydrogen is explosive -- the flame front and thermal expansion exceed the speed of sound -- at concentrations from 18% - 60%. It is flamable at concentrations as low as 4% to as high as 75% (and to 95% in a pure oxygen mix). Hydrogen very much can and does go "boom". https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/8498/how-explosive-is-hydrogen-gas https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/8498/how-explo... http://people.clarkson.edu/~wwilcox/Design/flamlim2.pdf http://people.clarkson.edu/~wwilcox/Design/flamlim2.pdf
- hedora 7y agoIn this context, the hydrogen mix is nearly pure, and therefore not explosive. The hydrogen in the leaking balloon would be well above 60%, so it should burn at the source of the leak. The same effect is why natural gas stoves don’t explode in normal use.
- nradov 7y agoThe balloons will fly higher than anyone with civilian weapons can hit. And shooting a hole in a hydrogen balloon wouldn't cause it to blow up anyway. The gas would just leak out.
- casefields 7y agoCan't someone just launch A cube sat with an incendiary attached? Don't know how they would hit it, but theoretically wouldn't that get you within reach with a weapon that mortals can afford?
- IAmEveryone 7y agoSomeone could shoot their neighbor, set fire to every kindergarten, or make a sequel to Titanic. But, luckily, people tend to use their energy and creativity for better endeavors.
- inflatableDodo 7y agoOn this logic, we wouldn't have planes though.
- stronglikedan 7y agoThese balloons don't carry people. People are more inclined to create property damage for entertainment than they are to murder people.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoDo balloons use a significant portion of the total helium production? I cannot find the number but I believe the vast majority is used in industrial processes, not these large balloons...
- mNovak 7y agoTechnically balloons use "balloon gas", which is essentially helium thats not pure enough for industrial applications. So I doubt a few hundred of these make a meaningful dent.
- MisterTea 7y agoAre you saying that helium, a non reactive noble gas, can not be purified, or more properly, separated from other gas components?
- onion2k 7y agoDo balloons use a significant portion of the total helium production? The problem is that we can't make new helium, and the rate at which it's being used far exceeds what we capture from natural gas production. A decade ago this was considered a serious problem. https://phys.org/news/2010-08-world-helium-nobel-prize-winner.html https://phys.org/news/2010-08-world-helium-nobel-prize-winne...
- 7y ago
- cm2012 7y agoThere isn't really a helium shortage.
- seieste 7y agoWhy does everyone think there is?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- yoz-y 7y agoThere were several articles written about it. https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucelee/2019/05/24/there-is-a-helium-shortage-what-you-need-to-know/#2908ff5070b3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucelee/2019/05/24/there-is-a-... Afaik the jist of it is that once it is used it escapes the atmosphere and there is a finite amount of it.
- nradov 7y agoThere isn't technically a shortage because the government hasn't imposed any price controls. However the price has increased drastically in the past 10 years. My gas costs for scuba diving are way up.
- lonelappde 7y agoPrice increase indicates a shortage, since the purpose of a price increase is to select which sunset of consumers receive the product when not all can. Price increases are either free market rationing (a response to shortage) or a disappearance of readily accessible inputs.
- nradov 7y agoThat's not how shortages work. A shortage only exists when some external constraint prevents the market from clearing.
- avocado4 7y agoThe plan has always been to move to cheaper hydrogen but it's logistically difficult because it's explosive (so everything needs to be done automatically & remotely at the launch site).
- hedora 7y agoHydrogen balloons are much safer than people realize. The outside of the Hindenburg was made of solid jet fuel (which also happens to be decent airtight paint), which is what made for the really dramatic pictures. (Safer != inherently safe, to be clear)
- nielsole 7y agoIf you are without valuable payload in 18-25km height there is nothing you can harm really even if you blow up. so maybe it may even make sense to add a self-destruct (ignition) of the balloon, if it malfunctions.
- Breza 7y agoSpace launch vehicles have self-destruct buttons (including the Space Shuttle) but they also carry enormous kinetic force. A balloon gone wild doesn't need to be destroyed. To your broader point, it doesn't seem especially risky to put hydrogen in modern balloons.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> The outside of the Hindenburg was made of solid jet fuel (which also happens to be decent airtight paint) No, it wasn't, and no, it doesn't. (The usual, but also wrong, story is that it was coated in solid rocket fuel.) https://www.airships.net/hindenburg/disaster/myths/#rocket https://www.airships.net/hindenburg/disaster/myths/#rocket
- steve76 7y agoMight be good in the ocean ... ... ... ... or orbital, to get rid of "space junk". Maybe a health application? What is buoyant and at that size ratio in the human body? Perhaps particles? I don't know. I get paid $0.
- Animats 7y agoThey've been at this for 8 years and it doesn't work yet? Uh oh. That's at the outer edge of Google/Alphabet patience.
- what_ever 7y ago> Its tennis-court-sized helium balloons have demonstrated utility. Over the last three years, Loon successfully let wireless carriers in Peru and Puerto Rico use balloons for free to supplant cell phone towers downed by natural disasters. Disc: Googler.
- dymk 7y ago> But executives at five other wireless carriers courted by Loon across four continents told Reuters that Loon is not a fit currently, and may never be.
- hnzix 7y agoThey've been tested in Oz to gather nav data[0]. It would also make sense to consider them for outback connectivity, where I've heard many people are still using satellite uplink (thanks to the corrupt nerfing of the NBN). [0] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-03/balloons-floating-over-australia-part-of-radical-internet-plan/8584738 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-03/balloons-floating-ove...
- fred_is_fred 7y agoDemonstrated utility in special circumstances, but didn't realize revenue. Alphabet isn't a charity to my knowledge.
- sidibe 7y agoGoogle patience is notorious for services people actually use but they can keep at this kind of thing for a long time. Waymo might be twice as old.
- MegaButts 7y ago
- BurningFrog 7y agoLast I heard, the Loon balloons were just floating in the wind, across the planet. Do they now have a way to keep them over Puerto Rico? If so, how?
- wishinghand 7y agoI remember something about them using weather predictions, machine learning, and ballast to rise up to an air current that would blow them one way, then lower to a different current to blow it back to roughly the same spot.
- jpm_sd 7y agoApparently this technique really works. From a blog post this morning: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6551805844525326336 https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6551805... Meet flight system P-496, which Loon’s operations team brought to a controlled landing this Sunday in the Ica region of Peru, where it was collected for analysis. This balloon was launched from Puerto Rico way back on November 18, 2018 and spent 223 days in the stratosphere, breaking our previous flight record of 198 days. P-496 traveled over 180,000 kilometers, circled the globe once, and spent nearly 140 days of its mission testing navigational algorithms over a defined area off the coast of South America. This successful flight and landing is important for a number of reasons. Steadily increasing balloon duration means each flight vehicle can work longer, bringing more efficiency to our overall operations. Continuing to improve our ability to remain above one location for extended periods of time is key to providing consistent coverage to those below. Landing and recovering our balloons safely is part of our commitment to sustainability in our operations. And analyzing this and other balloons will help us understand the properties that increase balloon longevity, with an eye toward future flights that last even longer. The team is already working to break the 223 day record.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI understand that's a possible way to control things, but I'm surprised it would give that much control!
- tjpnz 7y agoHow would this be relevant with Starlink et el just over the horizon?
- mNovak 7y agoStill very cheap if they can make it work
- the_duke 7y agoBalloons have the potential to much cheaper than shooting a armada of satellites into space.
- Ajedi32 7y agoAn armada of satellites can provide coverage over the entire planet, whereas balloons are limited to a relatively small geographical area. If you consider the cost of covering the entire planet with balloons, I highly doubt Loon is cheaper. If there's any advantage to be had by Loon, it's that they _might_ be able to better serve densely populated areas better thanks to their denser cell coverage, and that they are able to provide service over regular 4G signals rather than requiring specially designed (and slightly bulkier) radio equipment.
- quasse 7y agoFor anyone who is wondering, I looked up the operational height for both systems to compare. Project Loon is about 18km-25km, while Starlink is currently deploying at 550km high.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoDensely populated areas are going to get 5G microcells; maybe 5G backhauls on StarLink if they're remote.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nradov 7y ago
- RocketSyntax 7y agoThis is what capitalism and the free market is all about! Adapting standard products to meet the needs of fringe customers by fundamentally changing the supply chain. Without this crazy entrepreneurial spirit, the government has historically had to step in and subsidize utilities to close the gap (e.g. electricity in rural Texas).
- dr_dshiv 7y agoHere's a vision: growing hydrogen balloons at scale in the ocean.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoOh fine, I'll explain. The balloons are used as an offshore solar field that can gather energy even when cloudy. These thin film solar balloons avoid the corrosion of the ocean because they are floating above the clouds, anchored to a ship below. A portion of the solar is used to generate more hydrogen.
- donalhunt 7y agoAs usual, Alphabet's success is in the algorithms and software space. The experience of building and operating Loon gives a distinct competitive advantage that they can help others with. That's why the deal between Telesat and Loon is not surprising in the least (they are using the knowledge from Loon to aid Telesat's LEO venture). https://www.telesat.com/news-events/telesat-partners-alphabets-loon-design-network-operating-system-telesats-global-leo https://www.telesat.com/news-events/telesat-partners-alphabe...