11 ms·
Renting an apartment vs owning a house is not necessarily a bad financial move. Depends on a number of factors. For instance, if you anticipate moving within a
by chrisco255 7y ago
Renting an apartment vs owning a house is not necessarily a bad financial move. Depends on a number of factors. For instance, if you anticipate moving within a certain time frame, between closing costs, mortgage fees, commission, etc...it can cost more to own in the first 3-5 years, especially if prices are stagnant. Also, there are hidden costs of home ownership not necessarily factored in for, like repairs, maintenance, etc that are just implicitly included in rent. Finally, one can use the savings from paying rent to invest in the stock market and generally get a higher return than real estate.
- Bombthecat 7y agoEspecially in Germany, where there is a new law coming out every five to ten years where you need to isolate your house or build solar or replace your old gas heater etc etc etc. Its all in the name of environment protection. But makes owning a house more of a risk then anything else..
- cheschire 7y agoIf you establish regular communication with your Gemeindeverwaltung, and simply get approval for all changes and renovations, you will never be surprised.
- ccozan 7y agoI live in Germany and I never heard of this "need". Nobody forces you. Yes, you may want to change your old heating (that's what I do), but you get a lot of subvention from the state. You do this, then you also get some good terms on taxing etc. Same with electricity. You get a better insurance policy if you have it new.
- foepys 7y agoActually, you have to replace your heating every 30 years. Unless you are exempt, which is becoming more and more unlikely. See EnEV §10.
- Bombthecat 7y agoA ton people don't hear about stuff like that,until they need a new credit for all those things...
- ccozan 7y agoTrue ( I didn't know! ), but is damn 30 years!! I'm not sure that they last so long, especially the gas-based. And I am getting an exempt, because I am using Holzpellets ( not sure how are they called in English ) EDIT: Wood pellets, that is.
- pjc50 7y agoI would be astonished to find any heating system more complicated than an open fire that lasted more than 30 years.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoHere in the US steam boilers routinely last that long as long as your water quality isn't too terrible and you do some teeny tiny bit of maintenance. The natural gas ones tend to last longer than the oil ones but both often have a many decade service life. The radiators and pipes themselves last upwards of a century. Wood stoves last basically indefinitely (i.e they are only taken out of service when the building owner decides they're sick of using wood) but you're probably gonna have to do something to make the seams seal better every several decades. Fireplaces last as long as the masonry they're made from (~250yr and counting) as long as you don't let them fall apart and leak CO everywhere. I know some people who live in a house built in the 1700s and while they have forced hot air for "base load" they use the fireplaces to make the downstairs rooms extra warm almost daily in the winter. That said, this is only one step above your "open fire".
- Bombthecat 7y agoJust checked the paragraph,on the site I found they list related laws .. Jesus,it's worse than I thought.its like a stack of cards.it can happen if you touch one thing,you are forced to renew other things...
- adrianN 7y agoI wish such laws existed in Germany, but I never heard of them. It's still legal to build new houses that depend on fossil fuel for heating and are poorly insulated, even though we need to become carbon neutral in the next fifteen to twenty years if we want to stay below 2° of warming. The Denkmalschutzbehörde can still prevent you from upgrading your windows and adding insulation to your home.
- Bombthecat 7y agoNever heard about the payment for streets in front of your house for example?
- adrianN 7y agoThat seems to be a form of property tax and very different from insulating your house.
- sparkling 7y agoThat "property tax" can - in some cases - cost you 100k Euro or more.
- adrianN 7y agoIn return you get a road to your house I suppose. That seems pretty useful. You can also do your research when purchasing a home and check how old the road is and what the local regulations are. That roads need to be redone every twenty five to forty years shouldn't come as a surprise.
- vintermann 7y agoGermany is special in more ways than one, as I understand owning isn't so heavily subsidized vs. renting there compared to other western countries. It's at least far more common to rent in Germany. You also ran pretty clear of the housing bubble. I wonder if there's a connection there.
- pintxo 7y agoI'd argue that the connection is that owning real estate here is not as heavily supported by the overall tax and financial framework. Two examples: Mortgage payments are not tax-deductible and and you are personally on the hook for the mortgage, as in you cannot send the keys to the bank and simply walk away without debt.
- pjc50 7y agoThose are also true of the UK with its massive property bubble, although curiously landlords can deduct mortgage from tax but owner-occupiers can't. I think the real difference is that Germany has proper tenant's rights and a functioning social landlord system.
- Barrin92 7y agoRenting anything really isn't a bad move. There's not much upside to owning something that depreciates in value. Instead of buying a sofa for 2000$ renting one for 50 and putting the rest of your money into some productive financial asset is actually perfectly reasonable.
- tehlike 7y agoThe calculation gets more complicated with appreciating land, and leverage.
- quickthrower2 7y agoAlso if you pay off the mortgage let's say $2k/m then you are $2k/m better off after tax. Otoh if you rent and invest you need to make $2k/m after tax (so maybe $4k/m before tax, depending on where you live etc.) from the investment to be in the same position.
- tehlike 7y agoYes! You can also do 1031 and things like that to defer taxes. And value adds by doing renos.
- onion2k 7y agoTechnically you're right but the reality is that most people who choose to rent things other than a place to live are doing so because they want to use something that's better than what they can afford to buy on credit or outright. It's much more often about living a luxury lifestyle rathe than pragmatic financial sense.
- durnygbur 7y agoAfter 4 years you paid for the sofa 2400$, "rest of your money" is -400$, sofa doesn't belong to you, and in case of scummy renter you own money for damage repairs and cleaning. Ready for legal litigation?
- 7y ago
- jaabe 7y agoIn Denmark where I live you can loan 1 million Danish kroner at around 5k each month. A decent downtown apartment in a bigger city or a house in the suburbs is 2-4 million. Renting the equivalent is 10-15k, and with renting you obviously skip a lot of the maintenance cost and taxes. On the flip side loans are tax-deductible, meaning you actually don’t pay 20k to borrow 4 million, you pay 12k. It can still be cheaper to rent, at least if you look at the small scale. Because in 30 years, those 4 million will be yours while people who rent will still have nothing. It’s also risky, because maybe those 4 million will really be 1 million. Over all, owning real estate in a safe location is always going to be much better than renting. At least in Denmark. Hell, if you can manage to buy around 15-30 lower-cost apartments in a university city and rent them out, you’ll be able to pay your loans and have enough spare in passive income that you never have to work again.
- Bombthecat 7y agoI doubt that the house would be 4 million. Thanks to reducing population, increased building and housing. Plus who knows how the weather will be, I'm not sure that owning a house is the right thing in 20 years.
- scirocco 7y ago"Buy land, they're not making it anymore" - Mark Twain
- dingaling 7y ago> Finally, one can use the savings from paying rent What savings? Rent as you stated already includes anticipated maintenance costs, property taxes, the landlord's mortgage costs, often an agency fee, plus a margin for the landlord. I don't think I've seen rental rates ever cheaper than a personal mortgage. The main advantage of renting is avoiding long-term commitment but you'll pay a premium for that flexibility. Otherwise there wouldn't be an incentive for landlords.
- xivzgrev 7y agoNo? In San Francisco median rent is much lower than equivalent monthly cost would be on median home. You are correct that rent includes all the costs plus markup. But a big factor is that housing costs (esp in california) remain pretty steady once you buy. So that rent does include the housing cost...from 10, 20, x years ago. Alternatively a developer builds a building and rents out the unit instead of marking up and selling units. So the cost isn’t as high as market price. An example: I recently rented a 1 bedroom in a desirable neighborhood for $3500 per month. Equivalent condos are over $1m dollars in that area. But it certainly didn’t cost the developer of my building $1m to build my unit.
- gambiting 7y agoIsn't SF an outlier in literally every financial question though? I'm currently in the process of buying a house in the UK and our mortgage payments are going to be a lot less than we were paying for rent in the same area. Like, 40% less. If you have any kind of stability and are not planning to move in 2-3 years it's crazy not to buy.
- oarsinsync 7y agoLondon's also a bit of an odd one in that regard. You either need half a million+ for a shoebox or to live way out of town, and run the risk that the foreign-investment-fueled housing bubble collapses off the back of Brexit, leaving you with more mortgage than equity. (This is why I'm still renting...)
- raxxorrax 7y agoIf you are actually moving a lot this might be true. Otherwise probably not and most people renting aren't moving anywhere and just need to get by. Paying rent isn't that much lower than pay off a loan. And in one case you actually end up with property. Additionally, people invest much more in their own homes than rented property. I am not in the US with a high property tax, but I believe this to be true almost universally. Of course, you always pay a price if you commit to anything.
- Xelbair 7y agoI completly disagree. When you are owning a house or apartment - each payment of mortgage builds your own equity. This is not the case with renting, plus when you actually own it and have to move - you can also rent it. Also, rent over here costs almost as much as mortgage(or in some cases - even more) - the only issue is the down payment - so the investment bit is very off.
- Aeolun 7y agoI think it’s very natural that rent costs as much as, or a bit more than mortgage.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- roland35 7y agoThis is totally true and something a lot of people seem to forget about when they want to move out of their apartments to buy a house! I think the most important thing is to wait until you know your living situation is relatively stable (married, family, job, etc) so you can stay in your place 10+ years hopefully. Moving sucks!
- Spooky23 7y agoOnly in very specific, unusual market conditions. Less than 3 years it makes sense to rent, but even then it’s difficult to time it so you align with the lease end. I live in a national average housing market, bought a house in 2006, and save about 30% on a monthly basis as compared to a much smaller two-bedroom apartment. I include mortgage, tax, insurance and a 7% holdback for repairs. Long term, renting is always losing proposition given the low cost of capital.
- andreilys 7y agoThe housing boom of the last few decades is a 'very specific unusual market condition'. Is it realistic for housing prices to keep rising at their current rate? Also in your cost calculation did you include the rate of return you would've made of your principal by putting it into equities? I imagine if you bought in 2006 and held you would be very happy right now.
- Spooky23 7y agoI'm talking about living in a stupid place, like in the 75 mile radius from San Francisco as an unusual market condition. From a cash flow perspective, I'm spending about $20k in housing related costs annually. Given that it was 2006, I did a 15 year 105% ltv fixed mortgage. Renting, I would have saved a few bucks for a few years. Right now, renting a 3 bedroom in a neighborhood acceptable to me would add about $750/mo in costs. Total cash in hand with market returns would be around $10k. Meanwhile, the house will be free and clear in a few years. When we move in 5-7 years, we'll be recovering the original equity, plus capital gains, which will likely be in the $50-150k range depending on the market timing. If the choice was between have near zero housing costs and living on property my family owns or buying a house as an investment, I would agree you that the market is a lower cost, likely higher return investment. Unfortunately, I don't have that choice!
- skizm 7y agoExcept in NYC, SF, Seattle, and maybe a few other HCOL metro areas. HOA fees usually make it a losing financial proposition even on an infinite timeline. There is literally (and not figuratively) no benefit, financial or otherwise, to buying unless you get a really good deal. I know because I'm in the market to buy something and there's not much out there that will "beat" my current renting situation long term.
- barneygumble742 7y agoHas your rent ever decreased or stayed the same over a long period of time?