11 ms·
Plausible Deniability and Gaslighting in Fighting Ad Blockers
- wehack147 7y agoDo you need hackers for hire? Do you need to keep an eye on your spouse by gaining access to their emails? As a parent do you want to know what your kids do on a daily basis on all social networks in others to make sure they're not getting into trouble? Whatever it is, Ranging from Bank Jobs, Flipping cash, Criminal records, removal of mugshots ,DMV, Taxes, crypto currency fraud investigation Name it, they can get the job done .contact at www.assuredhacks.com .. its that easy . try them out today .
- 781 7y agoThis is truly one of the best long-cons in the tech industry history. Invest 10 years into creating a browser and get the whole industry and it's developers to love it, push it and develop solely for it, so that you can reap the benefits now. They learned from the best - Embrace, Extend, Extinguish. Even as recently as last year, saying that Google would eventually abuse Chrome market dominance would got heavy downvotes here.
- a_imho 7y agoOr Google is actually scared. We have been hearing for years how adblocking is not an issue to be addressed, yet they are desperate to put the adblocking genie back into to bottle.
- panpanna 7y agoMore likely Google bean counters went to chrome team and demanded they start generating money or at least stop loosing other divisions money. The good news is that Firefox and soon Edge are on all (important) platforms and support ublock origin
- breakingcups 7y agoHow long will Edge support uBlock if their upstream makes architectural changes to prevent it and its kind?
- endorphone 7y agoIf that was their intention it was poorly achieved given that most users can switch to alternatives such as Firefox or Safari with close to no downside. Chrome has very close to zero lock-in. I'm just an outsider but I do think Google's intentions with Chrome were of course self-serving, but overlapping user interests: They knew they are dependant on the web, so they worked to make a browser that made the web experience better, faster, stronger, etc. Blocking the most aggressive exploitations while trying to make the outcome one where their business could survive and still grow. Most knew there would come a day when they would start to turn the screws, though (in the same way that Microsoft apologists would talk about that company only using patents defensively...until they started suing everyone), and that day has come. Ah well, to Firefox we all go.
- ycombonator 7y agoJust moved all my bookmarks from Chrome to Firefox and don't miss a thing. I hope Firefox positions 'import bookmarks' feature prominently.
- arwhatever 7y agoSame here, switching is a very small hassle. I hope chrome's web metrics are plummeting in reaction to this.
- dessant 7y agoWhile the controversy centers around ad blockers, the most important aspect of the Chrome extension API changes seems to have been missing from the discussions of the past few months. You will not be able to fully control every aspect of a request in your own browser, despite installing extensions that run priviledged code that you trust. HTTP headers can no longer be freely edited, unless they are part of a limited whitelist blessed by the Chrome team. This kills innovation in the browser extension space in its tracks, and ad blockers are just a subset of use cases that will be impacted. The changes will inevitably find their way into Chromium forks which do not have the resources to maintain the deprecated API while merging upstream changes, further limiting choice and hindering innovation.
- dictum 7y agoI understand the challenges at scale, but there's definitely a decade-long trend towards locking down devices and software from user changes, because any API or configuration that's accessible to knowledgeable users is also accessible to malware and social engineering. This coincidentally aligns with business goals (watch our ads, replace your phone every 2 years, sync everything to our cloud because anything else is risky and cumbersome, do not integrate our devices with a non-blessed solution etc.) but for some reason discussing these goals is frowned upon. Correlation does not imply causation, but an event can have multiple causes at once, and only some are allowed in polite discussion, and not everything should be attributed to only malice or only stupidity.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- _jal 7y ago> but for some reason discussing these goals is frowned upon Well, the reasons are obvious - execs don't like having their motives questioned by the little people, especially when those motives are self-serving and bad. How dare you question your betters? One reason of many I banned Google.
- derefr 7y agoMind you, another way to say that is “malicious extension authors can no longer snoop on all network traffic.” As someone who was, at one point, pitched a project proposal for a browser extension our company could make which would “make users think they’re getting one useful effect, while secretly using their browser as a node in a distributed web-scraping farm to social-network sites they’re logged into” — I’m sure this is more common than people think, and very wary of extensions saying they do one thing while doing quite another (which happens to fit into the same permissions set as the explicit purpose of the extension, making users none the wiser.)
- chii 7y agoone can only hope that firefox steps up its game. May be eventually the new rust engine can push firefox forward with performance, and renew the market from chrome's dominance.
- ses1984 7y agoI feel like no amount of effort on a superior engine will be more effective than Google targeting their own browser for their own apps. The experience using basic Google services like search on Firefox mobile is much worse. You get access to fewer features, like looking for shopping results nearby or setting your location for shopping results near by, and I'm pretty sure it has nothing to do with the technical capabilities of the browser.
- eitland 7y agoSend a note to your local antitrust authority/consumer protection/etc. I've already checked my options and will hopefully be submitting one or more notes now that I got some more time on my hands. If we all do the same it will be noticed. Also many agencies are already looking at Google and will probably welcome it. (Note: I don't hate Google, I just want them to get a lesson or two like Microsoft got. They still earn loads of money but now without trashing my chosen OS.)
- derefr 7y agoIf Firefox really wanted to compete, they could just move web search features more thoroughly into native browser chrome, interacting with the search engine as a raw API provider (i.e. render the DOM in a floating document, then scrape the results out of it and display them in a special “search” URI-namespaced page—the same kind of page Chrome uses to display its native Google search bar!) This would basically commoditize the search-engine space for their users—all search engines would look the same and work the same, just with different browser-exposed features enabled or disabled per provider. So, for example, if Google doesn’t want to expose the ability to set a location, but does expose an API for doing so, Firefox could just provide a native-chrome option on their native-chrome search results display to set that parameter and search again. And, of course, while they’re at it, they could prune out the “sponsored results”, as well. Of course, they’d need to be prepared to lose all funding from Google at that point...
- 0815test 7y agoThere's plausible deniability and then there's sheer barefaced denial. When will the Better Ads Standards protect the average user from having outright malware, browser-jacking, click-jacking etc. etc. delivered via ad networks, potentially including Google's or Facebook's? Do that and 99% of web users will most likely stop caring about any other sort of ad blocking. However, as things stand today, switching to Brave, Firefox or any other browser that commits to making all malicious ads blockable is the only reasonable course of action.
- JoshMnem 7y agoBrave is based on Chromium, so it's vulnerable to Google's future decisions about what browsers should be able to do.
- AJ007 7y agoVery good write up on the Chrome ad blocker issue, and worth reading in its entirety. Based on the comments in other posts on this topic, my view is a little different. I think Google is making decisions that look good in short term models but will be very damaging to them in the long term. In this case, it is simple. If Chrome does a poor job blocking ads they are going to become known as the junk browser. Recall a behavior Google added to Chrome. When you open Chrome, you are presented with what looks like a default Google.com search page. When you click the search field and start typing, instead of appear in the search bar, the search occurs in the URL navigation bar. Google could have trained their users to be certain they went to Google.com to make a search. They didn't. Today Google pays billions of dollars a year to Apple. Google still doesn't seem to have learned that lesson (see AMP and weird ideas on divorcing the URL from the site the user is on.) Not only is Google's revenue growth under threat, but their existing revenue base may very well be too. After GDPR, the EU copyright directive, and changes Apple is making to Safari who knows what 2020 revenue will look like. In my mind, this explains a lot of the sloppy decisions Google's management has been making. If there was no Firefox or Apple, then panic. For now, the panic should lay within Google.
- fencepost 7y agoDon't forget that Chrome reached its dominant market share in large part because every time you went to search for something you were presented with an ad for Chrome. Alternative search engines at this point are hard to come by, AFAIK it's basically just Google and Bing in much of the world, plus whatever has approval in China - most other search is just wrappers around those 2. In that environment it may be hard to get the "Chrome as a junk browser" idea widespread. I still deal with people daily whose goto browser is IE because it's what they've always used.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoThis change will likely come with a push for better ads. Frequently these days you see whole articles that are actually ads. They fact they must bode this low now speaks to the difficulties they're facing in achieving revenue growth. Most web users don't use an ad blocker. Kind of hard to keep perpetual X% YOY growth when you're a Google-sized company. It is impressive for how many years they pulled it off, but those days are probably over.
- PaulHoule 7y agoIt amazes me that Google isn't facing an antitrust lawsuit over the chrome adblocker situation. Of course chrome is going to block everything except Google ads to destroy the competition.
- alexpetralia 7y agoRelevant essay for the uninitiated: https://alexdanco.com/2019/05/30/google-chrome-the-perfect-antitrust-villain/ https://alexdanco.com/2019/05/30/google-chrome-the-perfect-a...
- sasaf5 7y agoAs an oblivious Firefox user on Debian and Android, am I missing something by not using Chrome?
- georgeecollins 7y agoFeatures are missing in Google Aps in Firefox. I use Firefox as well, but sometimes when I want to use Google Docs, I just switch back to Chrome.
- false-mirror 7y agoWhat features are missing? I use Google Docs in firefox and haven't noticed anything wrong.
- callmeal 7y ago>What features are missing? I use Google Docs in firefox and haven't noticed anything wrong. Tracking and cookie slurping. I've noticed that if you turn on privacy protections in firefox, all google sites start misbehaving. And forget about trying to get through a recaptcha without spending minutes clicking on crossroads.
- kreetx 7y agoAs a web dev, Chrome has better PWA support in the developer console. Lighthouse audits are also quite useful. Although Firefox's developer console is pretty good (and similar to Chrome's), then at the moment Chrome is a bit better. I mostly use Firefox, both for browsing and development, but occasionally fire up Chrome, especially for the features mentioned above.
- chaz6 7y agoThis is a very good article, but misses out a critical fact: Google plans on making the old API available to paid enterprise users, which is the final nail in the coffin. I hope that Qt will add a new Gecko backend for QtWebEngine and move away from Chromium/Blink.
- joshuamorton 7y agoIt has nothing to do with paid. Any enterprise chrome users can use the old settings. And afaik, enterprise chrome is still a free download.
- floatrock 7y agoOne way of looking at this is google admitting there's a need for technology that intercepts and tweaks requests, but that's only an enterprise-grade need (intranets, firewalls, block lists, etc.) Consumers however shouldn't have access to those capabilities. The optimistic, parental, or (according to the article) gaslighting reason is consumers will shoot themselves in the foot by installing a spyware toolbar. The follow-the-money reason is 80% of google's revenue is unaffected by intranets, firewalls, block-lists, etc., but IS affected by the consumer use-cases of this tech.
- Kalium 7y agoWhere do I go to get this paid enterprise Chrome?
- qes 7y agoNo payment necessary. https://cloud.google.com/chrome-enterprise/browser/download/ https://cloud.google.com/chrome-enterprise/browser/download/
- cproctor 7y agoFrom a technical standpoint, I don't understand why the adtech companies don't just serve ads via APIs consumed by website owners, and served to clients via the primary domain. This seems like it would obviate current adblocking and third-party cookie blockers. It would add a bit of technical complexity for site owners, but that seems manageable, particularly for b2b relationships. Obviously, I hope this doesn't happen, but it seems like an obvious strategy and I don't see the flaw.
- Ilverin 7y agohttps://slatestarcodex.com/2013/06/14/the-virtue-of-silence/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/06/14/the-virtue-of-silence/
- cproctor 7y agoHmm, good point. Though it's not like we're headed in a particularly appealing direction as it is...
- ar-nelson 7y agoIn the same vein: I've never seen a video site that tried to defeat adblockers by inserting ads directly into the video stream. It seems like an obvious tactic; it could even use JS to prevent fast-forwarding the ads, and that would be a difficult thing for adblockers to detect and remove. The main problem I can see is that you would have to choose between CDN caching and targeted ads. If the video was uniquely generated for each user with new targeted ads, it couldn't be cached. I know that some podcasts use a technique like this, modifying the audio stream at download time to insert recent ads, even if the podcast being downloaded is old.
- kgwxd 7y agoIf I'm not mistaken, the reason the YouTube app ads can't be blocked even with something like Pi-hole, is that they do exactly what you're talking about.
- 7y ago
- draw_down 7y agoI don't think it's particularly helpful to invoke gaslighting here. But otherwise I think this is a fine analysis of the situation.
- ramtatatam 7y agoIt seems It will be better for me to stay with Firefox. Though I must admit sometimes it occures to me that maybe in the future I'll use curl more..?
- paulryanrogers 7y agoIME Curl and even NoScript is becoming nigh impossible to use because of all the JS
- dreamcompiler 7y agoI wish somebody would start a business with 1000 Pi-hole servers on a CDN cloud and charge $10/year to use them. But I don't have a clue how you match DNS lookups to paying customers. Probably have to just punt and make it a nonprofit funded by a foundation like Wikipedia. If anybody wants to build this, I'll help.
- tgragnato 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20012687 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20012687
- dreamcompiler 7y agoWow! Great minds...
- narag 7y agoDomain blocking is really useful, but... is it possible to do more? I mean that uBlock Origin and other adblockers can make a more fine-tuned work, cleaning pages much further, like cookies popups or similar useless crap. I had thought of such a service time ago, but would it be legal? If I do it in my private intranet, it shouldn't be a problem. But a service that would remove ads from known webs and serve a clean versions through a proxy could be accused of plagiarism or something like that. Maybe that's because thay only do the domain blocking part.
- tgragnato 7y agoIt probably has a lot of repercussions on the safe harbor (I guess you’re not a transitory network anymore??), but you should ask a lawyer.. > A service provider shall not be liable for monetary relief, or, except as provided in subsection (j), for injunctive or other equitable relief, for infringement of copyright by reason of the provider’s transmitting, routing, or providing connections for, material through a system or network controlled or operated by or for the service provider, or by reason of the intermediate and transient storage of that material in the course of such transmitting, routing, or providing connections, if [...] (2) the transmission, routing, provision of connections, or storage is carried out through an automatic technical process without selection of the material by the service provider; [...] (5) the material is transmitted through the system or network without modification of its content.
- kreetx 7y agoThis is a very nice write-up. Would be nice if the forces behind the Chrome change would comment.
- xg15 7y agoI don't know, I'm not convinced. I very much agree that Google's conflict of interest regarding ads is problematic and I'd absolutely trust them to look for ways how to get rid of adblockers, but the current issue seems like an unnecessarily roundabout way to archive that. The Chrome team seems to have put a lot of engineering effort into the DNR language and even extended the language to respond to some of the criticism. (Though still far less than what the API would need to be usable). It seems odd to me that they would spend so many resources into implementing something that is not really expected to be used. I feel if they really wanted to get rid of adblockers this instant, they could just tell so openly. Since Chrome has its own built-in filters now, they could just spin it as additional blockers no longer being needed. Instead they're just slightly tipping the scales in favour of site developers. Ad-blockers wouldn't be made impossible with this change, they'd just be made less accurate and reliable. This doesn't make a lot of sense to me.
- chrismartin 7y ago> Instead they're just slightly tipping the scales in favour of site developers. Ad-blockers wouldn't be made impossible with this change, they'd just be made less accurate and reliable. This doesn't make a lot of sense to me. It's the camel's nose under the tent (or the boiling frog). Abolishing all ad-blocking extensions would cause many folks to migrate away from Chrome, so they probably see a more effective strategy in incrementally neutering these extensions at a rate that reduces peak outrage. "What is something we can take away that ad blocking tech relies on?" Today it's an API change, in a few months it'll be some other measure.
- xg15 7y agoYeah, you could imagine some strategy where they modify the API to make adblockers appear progressively more annoying and unreliable to end users, so that eventually, the public perception of them changes. However, this seems a bit like a Xanathos Gambit to me. There are a lot of things that could make this plan fail. It starts with the current backlash of the adblocker devs themselves: They could simply choose to boycott Chrome instead of damaging their reputation. Even if they don't, so far you still have competition to Chrome so differences can be observed: If adblockers perform significantly worse on Chrome than they do on Firefox, it's apparent even for non-technical users that the browser is somehow a factor in this. I agree though, just making a change to web store policy (e.g. disallowing all adblockers) probably wouldn't have cut it - that would risk triggering a Streisand effect where everyone tries to smuggle adblockers back into the store using all kinds of rule-bending. So a technical restriction would probably be needed from their point of view. To be honest (warning, tinfoil hats ahead), I wouldn't be surprised if a long-term goal for Google is to abolish browser extensions altogether. Philosophy-wise, extensions seem completely at odds with Google's vision how the web should behave and how user experiences are designed. Most of their work in the space seems to be about restricting extensions, too - while work that extends capabilities (e.g. support for inspecting WebSocket connections or bringing extensions to mobile Chrome) is postponed.
- 3xblah 7y ago"I think it's fairly safe to say at this point that Google is institutionally incapable of imagining a world without ads, so they're not capable of entertaining solutions that would seriously interfere with the ad ecosystem." I think it is safe to say the same about Mozilla. They, too, rely (indirectly) on the ad ecosystem to survive. An HTTP client that does not deliver ads by default will not be produced by either company. Trying to escape from online ads by using these corporate-controlled browsers is like trying to escape from a wet paper bag without being allowed to damage the paper.
- t0mas88 7y agoGoogle did a similar hypocritical thing with GDPR in Europe. As a Google/DoubleClick customer we lost access to the raw data logs on where our ads were served, Google cited "privacy" and "GDPR" as the reasons. Then within a month Google created a product called "Ads Data Hub" that has the exact same data in it, for paying Google customers, in Google Cloud. So for privacy reasons we cannot process that data in any Amazon (or other competing) product, but surprise surprise, it is available in a paid Google product. Google has zero interest in privacy or even performance. All they care about is abusing their monopoly to push others out of the market and make more money from their own ads. The "do no evil" thing is long gone, it's time they get the antitrust lawsuit they deserve.
- saagarjha 7y ago> As far as I know Apple’s declarative API doesn’t have the same low rules limits as Chrome’s planned one either. Safari content blockers have a limit of 50,000 rules.
- kdeldycke 7y agoFor comparison, activating all uBlock origin registered filter sets takes 281,078 network filters + 210,016 cosmetic filters.
- saagarjha 7y agoYeah, I'm writing a conversion tool and I'm having quite a hard time getting EasyList to fit in the 50,000 limit. I have some deduplication rules in place which takes it quite close, and with cleverer algorithms it might be possible to fit the entire thing, but it's pretty clear that this limit is quite restrictive (plus, there's no guarantee that it will even work on iOS, which will kill the ruleset compiler if it uses too much resources).
- Arbalest 7y agoIs it time for piracy of ostensibly free content? Just so that we can protect ourselves, and perhaps our children from large scale tracking? Any injected adverts into the content stream would either become static, or removed by the release group. Imagine, pirated text content of blogs, just to get away from the new web. The alternative is ToR, i2p or other anonymising web services simply to make the tracking model unviable. What was once a mechanism for persons in oppressed countries and criminals, actually becoming the web of choice to stay out of the tracking traps. Edit: Just wanted to add, the way Stallman gets websites delivered to him via email and an external scraping system.