12 ms·
A new credit bubble gets ready to burst
- nabla9 7y agoAlternative source for the article here: https://www.greenwichtime.com/business/article/A-new-credit-bubble-gets-ready-to-burst-13911193.php https://www.greenwichtime.com/business/article/A-new-credit-...
- dang 7y agoSwitched to that from https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/the-shadow-banks-are-back-with-another-big-bad-credit-bubble/2019/05/31/a05184de-817a-11e9-95a9-e2c830afe24f_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/the-shadow-b....
- cascom 7y agoThe huge difference here is leverage. The typical bank in the US is levered ~5-12x which means, many of these "shadow banks" are unlevered, this creates an entirely different dynamic
- RandomInteger4 7y agoAre there any ways to hide leverage?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- miketery 7y agoYes, by inflating asset values.
- samsonradu 7y agoCan you please elaborate?
- all2 7y agoI'm assuming the logic goes something like: If we are leveraged at 100% when we take the real valuation of assets into account, then, if we jack up the valuation on assets we hold, then we can chip away at the leverage ratio and get it to go down.
- rmah 7y agoUS banks, overall, have the highest reserve ratio in recent history. US banks currently have a reserve ratio of nearly 100% or apx 1x leverage (see https://seekingalpha.com/article/2484795-u-s-banks-are-now-operating-with-100-percent-reserves-is-full-reserve-banking-the-next-step https://seekingalpha.com/article/2484795-u-s-banks-are-now-o... for more details). IIRC, the reserve requirement for large banks is 10% and historically, as cascom alludes, this is about where most US banks were at (i.e. about 5x to 10x leveraged) historically. But the that has not been the case for almost a decade now. So US banks have plenty of capital assets to offset loan losses. The "shadow banking" services that are rising are coming about because normal banks are unwilling to take on even moderately risky lending. Their demands for loans are now extremely stringent, especially for smaller and middle-tier business customers. This demand is thus being filled by different, non-traditional, sources, i.e. "shadow banking". The situation in overseas, especially Europe, is very very different. Many large European banks are currently operating with reserve ratios of only a few %. I don't know if this means there is less "shadow banking" in europe or if they just have far too much sovereign debt on their books.
- rcar 7y agoThe comparison being made in that article is sort of a weird one and is not really reflective of banks' true reserve ratios (nor is the ~100% M1/reserve deposits that they were excited about true any longer). On https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=o4OS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=o4OS I've included updated source data from that article, and you can see that M1 has continued to grow while fed reserve balances have fallen, but neither was ever close to M2 (which includes things like savings accounts and small CDs). A better indication of banks' leverage is Total Equity to Total Assets, which is similar to the Basel Tier 1 capital ratio: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/EQTA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/EQTA This has steadily gotten healthier over time overall as banks have tended to reduce their leverage over the last few decades.
- RandomInteger4 7y agoIs this why I've been seeing signs advertising something like "learn how to flip houses like a PRO! Call 555-555-5555" popping up around my little suburban town? Also bank managers hitting up my elderly relatives for home equity loans again. It feels very much like we're in 2002-2005-ish again.
- klyrs 7y agoIndeed. Despite all of the objections to the "startup party is over" story, this and that combine to feel like another collapsing bubble.
- subpixel 7y agoI suspect that if you call the house flipping number someone will try to sell you a course or seminar, not loan you money.
- RandomInteger4 7y agoMy point was that I'm seeing signals that we're repeating history. Why do these home flipping courses pop up? You think they just come out of thin air? No. It means that there are market conditions that would allow an entrepreneur to sell their information. What do we know about the pre-crash market in association with these signals? We know that (1) these things sound like a get rich quick scheme and (2) that they legitimately were a get rich quick scheme, because they actually worked up until the crash where many people were left holding the bags (houses that could no longer be flipped given the post-crash market conditions).
- dang 7y agoPlease edit the nasty bits out of your comments here, even if someone else missed something you thought was obvious. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- RandomInteger4 7y ago
- yardie 7y agoFor those looking for a non-paywalled link: https://outline.com/yR7ZNK https://outline.com/yR7ZNK
- temp129038 7y agoIf SF, I'm seeing ads all over for 1) Brex (corporate credit cards for startups) and 2) Zerodown (pitching no down payment for homes). It would be quite something if tech and not banks caused the next great recession.
- nugget 7y agoI just looked up Zerodown. How does their model account for the foreclosure risk if there's a real estate recession?
- rhizome 7y agoCorporate jingle-mail? It's not like there's any real-world penalty for walking away, and everybody there still gets paid until their last check. Same as any other startup failure, just with REO bargains on the back end.
- IshKebab 7y agoMuch higher interest rates presumably. I don't think there's any fundamental reason why you shouldn't be able to buy a house without a deposit. A deposit just shows you can be sensible with money, and therefore the loan is much lower risk for the bank. But if a bank is willing to take on the high risk in return for very high interest rates there's no particular reason why it shouldn't be possible. It may end up being exploitative, like payday loans, but not necessarily.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoMy argument is that zero-percent down loans will always end badly, because if you don't have the discipline to pull together even a measly 5%, you don't have the discipline required for home-ownership. And it's not like banks can charge payday-loan like rates on a mortgage, because if you can't afford a small down payment you also can't afford high monthly rates. These types of loans always increase when credit is cheap, and then they end badly (sometimes very badly) when the economy eventually turns.
- not_a_moth 7y agoReally seems like Wall Street is in love with the term "shadow banking", because it implies "can't regulate it". Yet we know exactly who the participants are, the types of firms, and their practices. Step 1 to better regulation of creative rent seeking is to stop treating it like it's nebulous.
- lbotos 7y agoIsn't the root of the problem this: > To fund all this loan-making, the shadow banks have turned to insurance companies, pension funds, university endowments and wealthy investors, offering them a chance to buy into a diversified pool of loans that offer returns ranging from 6 percent to 13 percent, depending on the level of risk they are willing to assume. If some hedge funds and "wealthy investors" want to take on risky investments that are "unregulated" I'm all for it. Would you agree the risks for systemic collapse come in when it's straddled onto say insurance companies or pension funds?
- belorn 7y agoThe root issue of credit card bubbles is not that hedge funds and investors may loose on risky investments, but that those same investors are so interconnected with society that society has to bail them out if they end up loosing it all.
- dd36 7y agoAlso that the executives can bail before it gets too bad.
- bastawhiz 7y agoWhat shape would the regulation for the latter look like? Should policy holders or pensioners have the ability to veto these investments? I don't want someone to lose their pension over a poor investment by a greedy fund manager. But I also can't think of how you'd draw a line where the investment is "too risky", or rather "too high of a risk to justify the effects on the persons who would be affected if the investment fell through".
- duxup 7y agoHas there been a time when someone wasn't calling a bubble?
- blackbrokkoli 7y agoHas there been a time where there was no bubble forming?
- ilaksh 7y agoI suspect that there cannot be effective regulation of any industry without a technological overhaul to money such as moving to cryptocurrency and smart contracts. Especially now with new technologies coming up all the time, companies will just go around the laws. Doing something like that is pretty far-fetched and would require a new type of technological government. But to me there is a structural problem with the relationship between money and government (in their current low-tech forms) in society.
- vageli 7y ago> But to me there is a structural problem with the relationship between money and government (in their current low-tech forms) in society. Can you expand on this? Your comment intrigued me.
- ilaksh 7y agoThe primary motivator for people is money. Government attempts to regulate all aspects of behavior, but it cannot effectively control or monitor the exchange of money. The most obvious symptoms of this are usually called corruption. It is less obvious (but still obvious to me) that corruption is just the tip of the iceberg. The problem is structural. Government cannot be effective because it is superceded or corrupted by the real motivator. The solution is a high tech type of money that is integrated with government.
- vageli 7y agoThat makes sense, but is also a nightmare IMO. The lack of oversight of money means that you cannot be totally barred from participating in the economic system by the goverement. If the government had even more control over money, they could arbitrarily blacklist people from having access to currency. While this sounds like a good tool to use against criminals, recall that, in America at least, there exist things such as the no fly list [0], which impacts people's rights without due process. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Fly_List https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Fly_List
- Hnrobert42 7y agoI question the credibility of an “article” which calls people names, e.g. Wall Street wiseguys.
- chiph 7y ago> And household debt has grown no faster than household income and is concentrated in households best able to pay it back. I'm not so sure about this - what I'm thinking is that the next (current?) bubble is in auto lending. I'm seeing tons of advertisements saying "We will lend up to 72 months with very little down". With the average new car priced around $37500 that's a payment in the mid $500's for someone with good credit. And I suspect the people doing this only have an average credit score so theirs will be higher.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThere's been a lot of apprehension around auto lending for a long time. I'm not sure what a crash would look like though.
- smt88 7y agoVery different from a housing crash in important ways, that's for sure. Vehicles are much more "liquid" -- they're portable and fungible to some extent. A bank repossessing many vehicles will get much more of its money back than a bank trying to sell foreclosed houses.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoWhile I would totally love to see a used vehicle price crash because it would be good for me personally and to stick it to the "hurr durr, muh resale value" types, I'm not convinced that wouldn't have reverberations throughout the market.
- smt88 7y agoI agree it would reverberate. I just don't know if it would be the first domino to fall in a massive economic crisis, the way housing was.
- gizmo686 7y agoVehicles also lose much more of their value than houses. The second you drive a new car out of the dealership, you are underwater unless you made a good downpayment; and it is not uncommon for people financing cars to find themselves underwater on their current one if they want to upgrade (or sell/downgrade to get out of debt). And that is in a good market. If there is a surge in used car supplies, we will see them depreciate even more. In contrast, in a typical market, it is uncommon for houses to be underwater, as they tend to appreciate in value. It took a crisis in the housing market for a large portion to go underwater. A simmilar crisis in a market where underwater is the norm would just push them further under.
- WC3w6pXxgGd 7y agoCreating government regulations in the hope of stopping massive bubbles from forming/bursting is like putting a band-aid on cancer. Just like with cancer, you need to look at the source of the issue: the Federal Reserve. The Fed creates bubbles through 1. Control of the Federal Funds Rate. 2. Inflation. 3. The purchase of bonds and assets from both public and 'private' corporations. Note: private is in quotes since it can no longer truly be considered a private corp when govt gets involved. To still, in 2019, be asking government regulators to solve issues formed by other bureaucratic branches shows that not enough people have learned from history.
- btcbanking 7y agoBitcoin will explode
- arisAlexis 7y agohas a bubble ever existed that was predicted beforehand by many and bursted shortly after?
- pascalxus 7y agoLook up CAPE Schiller index. It doesn't predict bubbles but does give a clue on 10 year future returns
- lone_haxx0r 7y agoAre we still blaming deregulation for the problems generated by regulation?
- apmorrison0 7y agoHello, Warm Greetings, “CAPITAL CITY LOAN & JEWELRY” approves loans from maximum amount of 75,000,000.00 to a minimum amount of 10,000.00 and give out our Loan in USD ($), GBP (£) Or Euro (€). They are Providers of All types of Loans including International Loans & Project Financing / Monetization of financial Instruments. Also offer BG/SBLC for trade purposes and collateral. Contact me for more details if you require any of our services. All commissions are 100% open for brokers/agents.. Thanks, Thomas F Sullivan Capital City loan & Jewelry Mobile: +1 850-745-5201 whatsapp : +1 862-621-9274, Ext. 1882 Email: capitalcityloan@consultant.com