13 ms·
Chrome extension manifest v3 proposal: comment from uBlock Origin author
- juststeve 7y agomore comments here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20044430 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20044430
- samayylmao 7y agoIf I search for ublock with google I don't get a result pointing to ublock in the google chrome app store. I do get results for: firefox, opera, microsoft. coincidence?
- saagarjha 7y agohttps://google.com/search?hl=en&q=ublock%20origin https://google.com/search?hl=en&q=ublock%20origin
- GraemeL 7y agoI followed the link logged in to Google, in a private window and through a VPN in another browser. The results were the same and in the same order in each case: Firefox addon, uBlock.org, Gorhill's Github, Wikipedia, MS store, Reddit, Twitter and the Opera addon. The Chrome addon doesn't show up until the top of the 3rd results page. The suggested searches were for adding every major browser apart from Chrome to the search. If you add Chrome to the query then uBlock for Chrome appears as the top result. Seems kind of a strange failing that Google search needs such a specific query to get a result for a chrome addon that their own store page claims has over 10 million installs.
- saagarjha 7y agoEvery time I tried, I got the Chrome Web Store, uBlock.org, gorhill/uBlock, the Firefox addon, Wikipedia, How-To Geek, and the Microsoft Store. Somewhat interesting, I think…
- thekyle 7y agoFor me the Chrome Web Store is the first result. It's actually somewhat strange since I'm on Firefox and you'd think Google would know better.
- type0 7y agoI had recommended uBlock Origin to a of couple of non techy people, both of them ended up installing the regular uBlock instead, now I don't even bother.
- drewg123 7y agoTo see how Google feels about ad blockers, all you need to do is look at Chrome on Android & the fact that it does not allow extensions at all. I have personally used Firefox on Android for years because of this. I predict Firefox will see a large uptake in market share if ad and content blockers become ineffective on desktop Chrome. I've finally switched to Firefox on the desktop now that U2F support is here, and it looks like it was just in time.
- devoply 7y ago> The deprecation of the blocking ability of the webRequest API is to gain back this control, and to further now instrument and report how web pages are filtered since now the exact filters which are applied to web page is information which will be collectable by Google Chrome. Which means in the medium run they are looking to deal with ad-blockers altogether because if you can instrument what rules are applies to pages by the most popular blockers you know exactly how to get around those rules. Basically this is a way to dump all that data into Google's pockets so it can slowly but surely get around all of that.
- jmkni 7y agoOne of the big downsides of using iOS over Android is the lack of an adblocker. Overall I still prefer it (iOS), but definitely a pet peeve of mine. Edit: nevermind, I'm an idiot!
- haraball 7y agoI'm happy with 1Blocker [1] for blocking ads on iOS. [1]: https://1blocker.com/ https://1blocker.com/
- jmkni 7y agoAh thanks, will check it out!
- dkoston 7y agoCurious about this. Are you expecting something different than going to the safari settings and enabling a third party content blocker? What are you looking for that isn’t offered by that feature?
- StavrosK 7y agoPlease switch to Firefox, it's better: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/new/?redirect_source=firefox-com https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/new/?redirect_source=f... If your favorite feature works slightly worse in Firefox, consider that its interests align with yours, unlike Google's.
- pmlnr 7y agoMaybe it's time for a new firefox ad in the Times. https://blog.mozilla.org/press/2004/12/mozilla-foundation-places-two-page-advocacy-ad-in-the-new-york-times/ https://blog.mozilla.org/press/2004/12/mozilla-foundation-pl...
- garganzol 7y agoFrom the looks of it, Mozilla Inc. is Google's darling. The rarely disclosed amounts in ballpark of tens of millions are being paid by Google on (somewhat) yearly basis. They call it donations but a few people see something else here. For example, when it comes to web standards, those two (Google and Mozilla) act in a good/bad policemen role play. Need to push DRM under the table? No problem. HTTPS? No problem either. Mind you, it's all in the name of a greater security! Hardly anyone can see that it's all come down to Google's evil strain on The Free Web.
- StavrosK 7y ago> The rarely disclosed amounts in ballpark of tens of millions are being paid by Google on (somewhat) yearly basis. They call it donations but a few people see something else here. They don't call it "donations", they call it "payment for having Google as the default search engine". This isn't even news. > Need to push DRM under the table? No problem. HTTPS? No problem either Yeah, God forbid websites deploy TLS. What the hell is this comment?
- snazz 7y agoI’d personally rather have optional DRM and more Firefox users than no DRM and more Chrome users. Encryption decreases the spying power that ISPs have, which can’t be a bad thing.
- xwdv 7y agoI think it will be clear that DNS based adblocking may be the only viable adblocking solution for a while.
- woodrowbarlow 7y agoor maybe just don't use the browser built by an advertising company
- jmkni 7y agoI remember years ago using Peerblock, is that still a thing? When browsers starting adblockers, it became less useful/neccessary.
- gruez 7y agoDNS based adblocking is a last resort because it's so much worse than extension based adblockers, even worse than the manifest v3 that's being proposed. They can't block first party ads, so Google would be fine if you switched to it.
- xwdv 7y agoThird party ads are usually the worst.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoI genuinely don't mind first party ads, FWIW.
- galangalalgol 7y agoIt is a good idea anyway but, chrome can probably figure out a way to resolve dns over http anyway. It will be sold as decreasing the risk o dns poisoning.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoWhat about Pi-hole as a service? Surely someone could set up Pi-hole or similar as a service. $5 a month or something similar. You could point your home network and mobile device to the service.
- devoply 7y agoFrom a strategy perspective now is a great time for all ad blockers to simply abandon Google... causing a massive outflow of users to Firefox and other browsers. There is not reason to keep making this sort of software for Chrome.
- phoe-krk 7y agoAdBlock and uBlock (the non-Origin one) won't leave Google because they profit from their relationship with Google.
- Frost1x 7y agoAh, capitalism at its finest. Should be interesting to watch how this shift will change the web development community who, for awhile, could safely focus on targeting Chromium for the most part.
- diveanon 7y agoI think you are vastly over estimating the number of people who use ad blockers.
- djflutt3rshy 7y agoTrue, but a lot of people who don't, get their browsers installed or recommended to them by people who do.
- diveanon 7y agoWhenever I setup a computer for friends and family I install Firefox and ad blockers for them. Nearly every time I use their computer again they are running chrome as default. For the overwhelming majority of internet users it just isn't a priority.
- Dylan16807 7y agoA lot of people don't know or barely know the difference between browsers, but that doesn't mean they don't care about ads. If you don't install a chrome ad blocker, you should.
- StavrosK 7y agoI used a friend's phone to look at some website and was horrified that the website had added ads everywhere since the last time I visited! Then I noticed he was using Chrome, which doesn't have adblock, and apparently the web is just terrible. Thank God for Firefox Mobile.
- dr0verride 7y agoThanks for mentioning this. I had no idea Firefox Mobile supported add-ons even though I've been using it for a year.
- sudo_rm 7y agoI think add-ons only work on Android though, not iOS.
- lstamour 7y agoiOS has native Content Blockers though, so it’s not as bad, and actually quite battery-efficient!
- StavrosK 7y agoYeah, just browse to the addon page (e.g. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/ublock-origin/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/ublock-origin...) and click "add to Firefox", it works as usual. Not on iOS, though, since Apple doesn't allow real third-party browsers.
- ishan1121 7y agoIf this becomes a reality, we as a tech community must do our part. We must personally leave chrome, ask all our friends and family to stop using chrome and switch to Firefox or Brave. Really show Google what we as a community can do.
- MentallyRetired 7y agoDilly dilly. I'm sharing the Firefox link on Facebook right now. Not a huge deal but I guess I haven't advocated for it yet.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoThe same community that got us into this mess?
- DJBunnies 7y agoIsn't brave just chromium though?
- NoGravitas 7y agoNot only is Brave just Chromium, it doesn't even block ads; it just replaces them with ads that pay worst-person-in-the-world Brendan Eich. And is tied to a dubious cryptocurrency scheme.
- filesystem 7y agoThe Brave Ads are opt-in, disabled by default. The idea is that they will incentivize users to enabled the proprietary ad notifications by paying those users (minuscule amounts to be fair) every time they view the ad.
- tedivm 7y agoYes, but chromium isn't removing the feature completely- since it's still allowed to be used in enterprise versions the code is all still there. Brave has already committed to making sure it continues to work.
- sanxiyn 7y agoEverybody, please switch to Firefox.
- rsweeney21 7y agoWould Edge be forced to adopt this change or is this Chrome specific? If Edge can preserve the old behavior then this might be a chance for Microsoft to really hurt Google if they wanted to.
- pedrocx486 7y agoEach fork can choose the path to follow and MS has the manpower to keep that.
- Bantros 7y agoBrave
- elcapitan 7y agoI switched to Firefox when Quantom came out and never looked back. On Android I use Opera, which has a built-in adblocker. I would love to use Firefox as well, but on Android it just seems very sluggish. Especially the scrolling is kind of cruel.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoWhen did you try it? The full release of Quantum on mobile lagged desktop by several releases.
- elcapitan 7y agoI try again from time to time - just did, it definitely got a little better with the scrolling, but it seems like Opera is still ahead quite a bit. That's for some very specific acitivies like quickly scrolling through a twitter feed with the profile pics and embedded images loading just a bit slower on FF, which is annoying. Maybe not the typical experience on average web sites. I found however that while scrolling on news sites that are js-heavy it also jumps and stops quite a bit (I guess when new assets are loaded and it live-updates during the scrolling). Just something I never have on Opera, which is butter-smooth.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoYeah, Twitter is buggy on Firefox mobile. It's the only site I've noticed that on, so I assume it's Twitter's fault, not Firefox. Just another way for them to force you into their app.
- elcapitan 7y agoWell it's only buggy on Firefox, so not sure it is their fault. Probably it's just where you can see the inferior asset loading strategy show up more, but I've seen similar issues with other asset/scroll-heavy sites as well (like news sites).
- kgwxd 7y ago
- kgwxd 7y agoTitle should say "uBlock Origin". I think a new name would really help the tool, even just officially changing to "uBO". Every single thread about it has several people confused over the name.
- mathw 7y agoSomeone has to pay for all this stuff. Adverts are a means to do that. Don't like them? Start paying directly. That would admittedly be an easier argument if online adverts weren't hideous, intrusive, slow, distracting, bandwidth-chewing, performance-destroying, malware-delivering, privacy-violating abominations.
- sanxiyn 7y agoBetter: pay, if and only if doing so removes all ads. It is naive to think that companies wouldn't want to show ads to paid members. It may not be necessary for survival, but companies do love money.
- cr0sh 7y ago> It is naive to think that companies wouldn't want to show ads to paid members. It used to be, back in the olden days of pay-TV, that you'd get HBO, etc in order to not have commercials shown to you. I haven't seen HBO in like forever, but last I recall, they ended up showing tons of "commercials" for stuff they were playing, were going to show, up-and-coming things, "sister station" things, etc. Basically, yeah - you didn't get to hear about the latest and greatest form of Tide or Folgers - but instead you would get anything and everything about HBO and other channels. Great. Today - I don't know what you see. I know for Hulu and other streaming services, it was peddled the same way (pay to get no ads). Now you pay - and you still get ads. Thanks. So I've personally done what they don't want you to do, but they can't stop me: I've stopped watching everything. I don't even go to the movies if I can't help it. The magazines I purchase are super-niche so I don't see any mainstream adverts that way (Nuts and Volts, Servo, 2600). I don't listen to the radio. UB-Origin on my browsers (and with all this being discussed, I'm going to look into switching back to FF as well, and setting up a pi-hole). They still manage to sneak some crap in - and I can't help to see those billboard ads and other things as I drive down the road or whatnot. Amazon also has some ads, and some things I subscribe to require you to see the ads to see the content, but that stuff is usually off to the side and just "filters out" into background noise at best (and most of the time it's for products I either don't want or can't afford; for some reason, I get a bunch of ads for Rolex watches and BMW cars - you'd think they'd run one commercial for a Unimog, but nooooo). Ultimately, I've more or less opted out of consumer popular culture. This crap being discussed, and numerous other issues I see and experience, is just pushing me further off the road. For instance, I intend my next "smart phone" will be one that I build and code myself. It won't look very pretty, and I'll still be tied to a service provider and all that entails, but even if all I have are SMS and voice calling, that'll be enough for me. I'm also in the "slow process" of rebuilding/refurbishing an old Toughbook for general usage, but that is also competing with a couple of other projects, a refurbished TRS-80 Model 100, and a custom built "cyberdeck" I've been contemplating and buying the parts for. Maybe go back to using BBS's too, or some other "dark web" niche of the internet - I dream of a place of freedom, the network I knew back when I started in the 1980s. Not this walled-off mess we're walking...no running...towards.
- AJ007 7y agoWho is actually calling the shots over at Google? In January, Google announced that Chrome was going to be blocking all ads on domains that had too many ads ( https://blog.chromium.org/2019/01/building-better-world-wide-web.html https://blog.chromium.org/2019/01/building-better-world-wide... ) ; website owners were told to use the new "Ad Experience Report" in Webmaster Tools/Search Console to find out if they passed our not. Months later, my sites never were reviewed. Everyone I asked also did not have their sites reviewed. Now Google has updated the Search Console and this "Ad Experience Report" is no where to be seen. Maybe whoever came up with this idea and announced it never had the authorization to do so. After all, Google's Adsense was happily encouraging web site owners to add ad placements to their websites that were blatant violations of these new rules, including the most egregious, full page interstitials. The UI of Adsense would easily convince a more novice operator to just turn on "auto ads" and have Google blanket their website with ads automatically. Certainly this couldn't have been the plan, follow Google's advice so that your site could never earn advertising revenue from Chrome users again? I suspect Google does have a plan to deal with ad blocking. They might have a few plans. Right now, it resembles someone bashing their own head against a wall. These changes to Chrome precipitate the end of Chrome having a dominate desktop market-share. If it really happens. But no matter what happens, Google is once again a little less trustworthy after.
- fauigerzigerk 7y ago>Who is actually calling the shots over at Google? I think there was a guy whose 20% project was calling the shots but he eventually replaced himself with a GAN or something.
- detaro 7y agoIt's a big company, it's not unlikely that different parts follow different, conflicting plans.
- magashna 7y agoGoogle loves to get 40% into a project and then run away like chickens with their heads cut off
- kretor 7y ago
- OldFatCactus 7y agoI've been resisting the switch to Firefox but this is has finally compelled me to make the jump
- anuraj 7y agoGoogle as an Ad company has interests diametrically opposite to people who want to browse without annoyance. Having a monopoly browser with an ad company should surely be deemed anti competitive. Google should be allowed to keep only one - Ads or Chrome.
- kerblang 7y agoIt sounds like there is some performance-based argument getting shouted over here - something to do with blocking I/O (not blocking ads) - what exactly is google proposing?
- stevenicr 7y agoI use adblocking tools on most sites most of the time, mainly as a security measure and for some privacy. I would be okay if there was a button to allow self-served ads to be displayed, and would be especially fond of something that allowed me to limit certain types of ads, and to only share certain bits of info to the ad-determining-system. So long as ads are served by third party servers I can not stand the lack of security and privacy. If example.com serves ads from it's own server and there is malware in them, then example.com has issues. Currently places like yahoo have served malware and simply blame the third party and portray themselves as duped victims that have no liability. If this thing happens with chrome - and someone is using an adblocker that has been crippled, if then a malvertisement is served, wouldn't google become liable for blocking the security plugin from working properly and therefor causing the infection?
- kyriakos 7y agoNew Microsoft Edge may benefit from this.
- ilaksh 7y agoI am trying to switch to Firefox right now. The main challenge for me is I am used to Chrome filling in all of my passwords so there are some that I have forgotten.
- detaro 7y agoFirefox's data import should import passwords from Chrome?
- jnet 7y agoYou can import those into firefox by going to options -> privacy and security -> saved logins and click on import. I just did it yesterday and it worked well.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoI switched back to Firefox just over a year ago. I just go to passwords.google.com when I come across a site I haven't visited since my Chrome days. Admittedly it's a minor inconvenience but it's only once per site.
- driverdan 7y agoUse a 3rd party tool like BitWarden, Keepass, or 1Password for storing passwords. They're cross-browser, cross-platform, and are more configurable.
- forgotAgain 7y agoThe only thing saving Google from an antitrust decree is the lack of an antitrust enforcement will in the US government. Google is taking advantage of it's monopoly position in browsers to help another business area: advertising.
- tannhaeuser 7y agoWhere was this antitrust enforcement you mentioned when Google bought DoubleClick and YouTube, and Fb bought WhatsApp? Antitrust regulations aren't working at all, to the point other markets/nations might have to take steps to brace from the monopoly the US is breeding.
- jknz 7y agoMicrosoft could auto-install a Microsoft branded chromium with native uBlock integration in the next windows update. That would be entertaining to watch. On a related note, if OSes were shipping uBlock powered browsers by default, removing ad blockers would be considered a security risk and a no-go. Hopefully we'll be there one day.
- a_imho 7y agoActually all browser vendors could/should do that except for Google.
- fencepost 7y agoIt's so nice that Google gets to have its own voter ID "it's for security!" movement, and all of us get to play minority voters. Have they cast anyone in the Kris Kobach role yet?
- a_f 7y agoI wonder now that Edge is moving to be Chromium-based that it will take, or be forced to take the same approach? I can imagine Microsoft carving a greater slice of the browser space if they continued to support Chromium extensions whilst Chrome did not.
- suby 7y agoIt won't be forced to take a similar approach. Google is leaving the code in the codebase for enterprise users, so presumably it will just be a toggle / straightforward for them to keep it functional. Microsoft also has the manpower to basically do whatever they want.
- s09dfhks 7y agoswitched to firefox back when the news about chrome potentially blocking ad-blockers broke. At first i was worried my workflow would be disrupted, but literally nothing has changed. I was able to find all my chrome extensions in firefox's marketplace
- wnevets 7y agoUsing the internet without uBlock is a one big dumpster fire. I would drop chrome in a heartbeat and switch to firefox full time If I can't use uBlock.
- jonas21 7y agoI'm struggling a bit to understand the outrage directed specifically at Google over this. When Apple made a nearly identical change in Safari, some people even praised it for protecting user privacy by preventing malicious ad blockers from intercepting every URL you visited. Most people didn't seem to care, and those who did generally seemed happy about it. But when Google does it, people assume the worst intentions.
- thiht 7y agoNo one cares about Safari because it sucks, no one uses it. Chrome is everywhere
- ex3ndr 7y agoIsn’t Apple put neural net to Safari to fight trackers and allows AD blockers on iOS?
- msbarnett 7y ago) There’s no stunningly obvious conflict of interest leading to the conclusion that Apple is undermining ad blockers in order to protect their ad sales business. 2) Safari’s API is less restrictive than Chrome’s proposal. Rules can be updated dynamically instead of requiring resubmitting the extension for approval, for instance. 3) Market share is materially relevant to level of concern. What the mouse does is less concerning than what the 800 lb Gorilla does.
- jzl 7y agoYep. Safari desktop market share is less than 4%. Also Safari does a lot of tracking and cookie prevention out of the box: https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/14/16308138/apple-safari-11-advertiser-groups-cookie-tracking-letter https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/14/16308138/apple-safari-11-...
- Fnoord 7y agoBrowsh + uBlock Origin + Mosh + Tmux = low bandwidth remote browsing