10 ms·
Huawei reviewing FedEx relationship, says packages 'diverted'
- the-dude 7y agoNot to a CIA "load station" ? https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa-upgrade-factory-show-cisco-router-getting-implant/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa...
- wybiral 7y agoThey were documents. Why wouldn't they have just intercepted them in-place instead of sending them to the US? It doesn't make sense to be anything other than an error and Huawei being paranoid (rightfully so, but still).
- peterwwillis 7y agoPossibly because if the USG were caught reading foreign companies' documents on foreign soil it would be a violation of countless international treaties, which would make the ongoing trade and infosec tensions worse, versus "whoops, this landed on our doorstep, we can do whatever we want on our soil". The fact that this can be easily chocked up to a logistical error is good cover.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 7y agoLet's be honest, America has been violation of so many treaties and rules they themselves have written that it really doesn't matter anymore. Some countries retaliate, but with different methods.
- the-dude 7y agoThey just want you to think they were documents. The question is why ...
- wybiral 7y agoAre you now implying that Huawei is lying about them being documents to cover up what they were actually shipping or something? (I genuinely can't tell if this is a joke or not)
- the-dude 7y agoMy comments so far have been very tongue in cheek, I must admit. To me, it appears as a Chinese way of saying they are are as much at the mercy of US logistics as the Western World is at the mercy of Huawei's logistics ( 5G ). edit: even it when it is not true, the message comes across.
- Scoundreller 7y agoDunno about Huawei, but I’ve definitely sent door keys and thin EEPROM programmers as « documents » to save on shipping costs. They tend to have fewer customs issues too since they go through a separate stream in a lot of countries.
- partiallypro 7y agoThey could be being paranoid, or they could be feeding mistrust of American corporations because the US has lead people to mistrust them. Russia has used similar tactics in the past to counter US measures.
- cyphar 7y agoThe NSA has broken into Huawei's systems in the past[1]. I think it's more than reasonable for them to explore the possibility that this is a continuation of that pattern. [1]: https://techcrunch.com/2014/03/23/latest-snowden-allegations-nsa-hacks-huawei/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/03/23/latest-snowden-allegations...
- partiallypro 7y agoRight...but the NSA wasn't so stupid in the past to leave a FedEx redirect message during an intercept. So, that's why the entire theory is nonsense. If they were intercepting, Huawei would have no idea, and would not be left with a FedEx change of status.
- samstave 7y agoMaybe the trucks were Snowed-in and No Safe Arrival times Could be Indicated on the trAcking number.... ——- You are transparent. I see plans within plans ——
- threeseed 7y agoI wonder what the backstory is to this. You don't issue a press release for two missing packages. And since they were "important commercial documents" I am assuming that US intelligence must have intercepted them for some reason.
- pushpop 7y agoThe back story could just as easily be a shipping error and Huawei trying to drum up anti-American sentiment as a counter to all the bad press the US have directed their way. Sure, it’s highly suspicious that a Hauwei shipment end up in America but equally it seems unlikely FedEx would be dumb enough to advertise that fact on their tracking page if they were ordered to divert said documents. I’m not suggesting there isn’t something deeper going on that governments are keeping classified, however if there is then they’re doing a good job of keeping it a secret by making this trade war sound like petty bickering.
- samstave 7y agoAnother backstory is that huwai has long believed to be backdoring to chinese intel just as cisco has since the mid 90s... We arrested their cfo in canada and have been on attack with them since. The actual question is - the US has been doing this against them for quite some time now Mr smith. So... Did huwai just realize, or do they have enough anomalous tracking that they are leaking public to measure reaction. Look, dont be a fool - WWIII - as Einstein stated, is not nuclear, its informational - and we are in the midst; Echelon <— nobody believed this existed in the 80s and 90s Carnivore <— att guy went to jail for revealing this Stuxnet <— israel fucked that one up Duqu <— scary that this dropped off the map PRISM <— one of many of the trackers Lots more: too many. Etc Etc There are a lot of subs in that list and a lot of ghosts we dont know about... But only a moron would think that cyber war is NOT in full force
- Gibbon1 7y agoI operate on the idea that everyone has been back dooring and breaking into everyone else's stuff forever. I remember a picture I can't remember the details now but think the East Germans discovered a tunnel from West Berlin into a phone vault in East Berlin with a bunch of taps installed. That was in the 1960's. The Soviets were planting microwave recording devices on the east coast in the 1970's. The US has been tapping under sea cables since the 1970's. Maybe earlier. Everyone's been trying to spy on everyone else. Commercial companies are either willing partners cough facebook cough or haplessly in the middle. Notable they threw Joseph Nacchio in prison for not playing along.
- devoply 7y agoCould you not plant something on these devices then find them like mythical WMDs never found to justify things against Huawei?
- wybiral 7y agoThey were documents.
- WestCoastJustin 7y agoRouting mistake?
- threeseed 7y agoYou often get the tracking number either before you send the item or as you are sending it. I think it would be suspicious if you sent a package and weren't given one.
- simonk 7y agoThe packages are being delivered in the end, they just seem to be going through the US first.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mangogo1 7y agoChina is collapsing economically, demographically, financially, morally, spiritually, and running out of friends. This trade war (and eventually, complete disentanglement between US and China), is driving the old men in communist party nuts. Thus a ton of erratic behaviors from China and Huawei.
- close04 7y ago> FedEx spokeswoman Maury Donahue told Reuters the packages were “misrouted in error” and that FedEx was not requested to divert them by any other party. Scout's honor. Sounds a lot like Huawei saying it was just a coding error. Would they get away of a spying accusation with this? If it can happen in the US (FedEx, Cisco) it can surely happen in China. It's strange seeing people defending this as "probably an error" and perfectly acceptable when coming from one side but definitely intentional and totally unacceptable from the other. The hypocrisy is strong in this one... P.S. For the casual observer, please note that this comment is not about which company is guilty and how (un)acceptable that may be.
- rgbrenner 7y agoThe difference is that Huawei has a board of CCP members that sits within Huawei and has say over their actions. While FedEx is an independent company that operates within the US, and has access to US courts to defend themselves. It's 1st party vs 3rd party, when it comes to government influence. Huawei is assumed to be working at behalf of the CCP because the CCP has management control over the company. It's like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Do you doubt that the US government has control over them? They are "independent" government sponsored companies with oversight by the US government... just like Huawei. Everyone knows Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac implement policies put in place by the US government. That's their job. But when it comes to Huawei, we're all suppose to ignore the CCP control? China likes to have state-run companies (far more than the US does). The consequence is that no one trusts you. If they don't like it, and want to build trust with their customers, then they can liberalize their markets (or at least let Huawei be a fully independent company).
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoHuawei executives make management decisions at Huawei, not the CCP. I presume that what you're referencing is the existence of a CCP group at Huawei. As I understand it, all Chinese companies above a certain number of employees have a party section. That doesn't mean that the CCP controls those companies, any more than having a union means the AFL-CIO controls an American company. Huawei is subject to the same sort of potential government pressure, however, that American companies might face. If the US government sends a national security letter, American companies have to quietly comply.
- jedberg 7y agoAnyone who has shipped with FedEx knows how somehow everything you send goes through Atlanta. I'll bet this was just one of those "logistical efficiency" gone wrong kind of things. Or US intelligence requested the documents be diverted. Either is about equally likely I'd say.
- axaxs 7y agoI tend to agree with the first half... Maybe I'm a bit tin-foil, but I feel like if intelligence was involved they'd just intercept it en route, and wouldn't bother sending it all the way back to the US, especially in a trackable way for that matter...
- jedberg 7y agoThe second half was more of a joke. I agree with you, they would probably hide it, unless FedEx was dumb enough to mess up and show it when they shouldn't.
- munk-a 7y agoHonestly, FedEx has a tracking system... I wouldn't be surprised if they were unable to avoid somehow altering the destination information of the package unless the NSA stole the items off the back of their delivery truck - it may also be FedEx throwing up a canary about government shadiness but... The truth is probably that FedEx is just terrible at their job and goofed it.
- exit 7y agoi find it hard to believe any intelligence service would a.) literally reroute the package, instead of having some field agents in the origin country deal with it, b.) not suppress revealing the actual route on the fedex tracking website.
- jedberg 7y agoAgreed, it was more of a joke.
- brd529 7y agoHaving done logistics this happens all the time in international parcels. I saw 0.5% of parcels have some massively weird routing error to countries that made no sense. If this had been a us govt request they wouldn’t have scanned the packages at the sorting facilities in the US!
- zupreme 7y agoSo many US corporations are sacrificing potential billions in global comsumer confidence and flat-out revenue loss backing the “trade war”. What assurances are they getting which makes them willing to take the leap, I wonder? At the end of the day any losses have to be explained to sharebolders, regadless of political loyalties.
- JeremyBanks 7y agoThe asurance that their company won't be shut down for violating a federal embargo?
- CamperBob2 7y agoTrump has proven loyal to the farmers, at least, to the tune of redistributing over $15 billion in taxes to compensate them for the harm done by his administration's trade policies. I'm sure the rest of us will receive similar consideration.
- hackermailman 7y agoThe Huawei 'war' is between the 5 Eyes Alliance countries and China, not just the US. If you live in Canada, Australia etc, you have persistent propaganda being released in the media warning of the evils of Huawei 5G hardware. My cynical view is Huawei has some sort of edge on competitors to quickly deploy 5G around the world (state subsidies possibly), and the 5 Eyes Alliance will lose their 'information dominance' as once expressed by Gen Alexander, so the option was to start flexing against Huawei with 1980s cold war style aggression to slow them down.
- vinay427 7y agoThis seems to assume that the 5 Eyes alliance has backdoors in products by the competition: products by continental European companies (Ericsson, etc.) that don't have a notable history of this. That's a strong assumption to make.
- hackermailman 7y ago
- SheinhardtWigCo 7y agoHanlon's razor applies here. If there was truly something nefarious going on, why would FedEx update the tracking status to say that the packages were re-routed? Why not just say they were held up in the sending or receiving country?
- sparkling 7y agoIncompetence?
- gkoberger 7y agoThere's lots of other potential reasons: maybe their system can't handle overrides, or maybe it's a canary so people know it's the government rather than their fault? (But I do agree overall that it's probably nothing)
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoyou ever dealt with a big corporate? that's like asking "why are there software bugs when programmers know how to code!" of course, there's the other side of that coin, in that of you've got a big enough company and enough of a complex package network, the probability that you'll find packages routed erroneously or in bizarre directions approaches 1. Given that we do not know the details of the packages, either their contents or supposed reason for rerouting, but we do know that Huawei has made a media story of this (a couple of packages rerouting is nothing to get in the paper about, and they could have kept quiet if they were genuinely concerned), about the only thing we can really take away from this is that is likely part of the public relations/propaganda jostling currently going on between US/China corporates.
- viraptor 7y agoPotential reason - they do not have a system that can split public/secret stops. They need tracking to be available for internal purposes (actual delivery) but never built the filtering features. (Or there is, but needs boxes to be checked explicitly and the box wasn't checked. Is there anyone from FedEx to throwaway comment? :-) )
- 7y ago
- djsumdog 7y agoI really hope any US Commerce dept plans against Huawei completely backfire. Imagine in two years if Huawei has a stable, strong alternative to Android that takes over the Asian markets and even gets imported by American enthusiasts through 3rd party channels. I'd like to see someone break the Apple/Google dual-olopy.
- quink 7y agoAnd next thing you know everyone in Germany will suddenly have an epiphany and switch to WeChat and get themselves a QQ. Dumbest thing I ever heard.
- sixothree 7y ago> I'd like to see someone break the Apple/Google dual-olopy. I am not sure that will happen here. But it sure does seem like that is the trajectory for China.
- quink 7y agoIt’s not the trajectory, apart from a reliance on ARM the Android experience in China is pretty independent of anything overseas already, lacking the Play Store and all.
- sixothree 7y agohttps://www.techradar.com/news/huaweis-os-to-be-rolled-out-next-month https://www.techradar.com/news/huaweis-os-to-be-rolled-out-n...
- oxfordmale 7y agoIt looks like Huawei's retaliation to Trump's ban. They must have been combing Fedex deliveries for mishaps they could use to build up a case Fedex is working together with US intelligence agencies.
- floatboth 7y agoWell, it's called FedEx, of course it expropriates your packages to the feds,
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago>Reuters could not verify the authenticity of the records. Shown the images of the tracking records, FedEx declined to make any comment, saying company policy prevented it from disclosing customer information. // So they're confirming that the images are customer data, which makes them authentic. If they weren't authentic then they wouldn't be customer information, no? >FedEx spokeswoman Maury Donahue told Reuters the packages were “misrouted in error” and that FedEx was not requested to divert them by any other party. // Which doesn't tell us anything as NSA letters, for example, can IIUC require a company to lie to cover up executive activity. >The U.S. Department of Commerce did not reply to a request for comment on whether the incident might be related to its move on May 16 to add Huawei to the so-called “Entity List,” // Which is basically "hey are you being a shithead?", "oh, no comment!". Not even bothering to deny it?? >FedEx declined to give details on what the exception was in this case. // I mean, it sounds a lot like the response of someone caught with their pants down (ie in the act of committing a nefarious offense). What is clear is that this is more shots fired -- and TBH the message of "you can't trust USA not to be using security letters to pry in to foreign businesses confidential affairs" isn't anything like unbelievable.
- vinay427 7y ago> So they're confirming that the images are customer data, which makes them authentic. If they weren't authentic then they wouldn't be customer information, no? I don't think that assumption works. Reuters asked for specific customer information: in particular, whether the records were valid. Answering in the affirmative or negative is divulging customer data, and FedEx would be wise to avoid doing so whether or not it's valid.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoYou're right, I skipped over the "decline to make any comment" part. But still, "this is not a valid receipt" doesn't reveal data about a customer transaction.
- elliekelly 7y agoBut then when the reporter comes back a few days later with a different receipt that _is_ valid and FedEx tries to give the canned response about not revealing customer transaction data... they inadvertently have. Because if it wasn’t customer transaction data then they would have simply said as much, as they did the last time. Companies always respond with “no comment” for a good reason: to prevent people from drawing incorrect conclusions by reading between the lines as you are doing now.
- strooper 7y agoNot related to this package delivery drama, but the way we are observing the live demolition of the world largest networking equipment maker and second largest smartphone maker (by number) in the name of trade war will never bring back the confidence in those who are flexing muscle. The illusion of the rule of law, free world, globalization and the reality of control is simply frightening, and worrisome.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> The illusion of the rule of law Rule of law has always been national. International politics are anarchic. Huawei quite clearly broke the laws of the United States (e.g. with respect to Iran), repeatedly and wilfully.
- dmurray 7y agoImporting goods to Iran really isn't a violation of US laws, any more than, say, a twenty year old Huawei employee having a beer in Beijing or driving at 120 mph on a German autobahn. The rule of law is indeed national, and legally the US has very little jurisdiction outside its borders. Extralegally, of course, it has plenty of powers to arrest, kill or torture those it doesn't like.
- chibg10 7y agoThe allegations against Huawei aren't that it "imported goods into Iran." The allegations are that it imported American goods into Iran, which is clearly a violation of US export laws. If such laws didn't apply to third-party distributors of American goods, then the only effect of US sanctions would be have foreign distributors exporting American goods rather than American ones. Huawei appears to have known this as well seeing as Meng Wanzhou had fraudently misrepresented the relevant transactions to the banks it was working with. There was nothing extralegal about Meng Wanzhou's arrest.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoThe allegation is not quite that Huawei imported American goods into Iran. The accusation is that Huawei misled a non-American bank, HSBC, about its relationship with Skycom, a company that is accused of importing some American office computers into Iran. The US alleges that Huawei essentially controls Skycom, and that it hid this from HSBC, a British bank. Since HSBC does business in the US, it would not be allowed to give loans to Huawei. You can start to see how far-reaching American sanctions are. A British bank is being told that it cannot do business with a Chinese company, because that Chinese company allegedly controls a Hong Kong company that imported small numbers of American goods into Iran. As I understand it, these sorts of extensive secondary sanctions are not normal, and are a sore point between the US and many countries, including some of its allies (such as France and Germany). I would be very interested to know what gives the US any jurisdiction to demand the arrest of a foreign executive on foreign territory, for acts committed on foreign territory. Whatever the legal justification, though, this is a very unusual and aggressive step, and one that is transparently motivated by political considerations in the ongoing trade war.
- Jerry2 7y agoPackages were probably getting a free "upgrade". The same upgrade that cost Cisco billions in revenue over the past 5 years. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa-upgrade-factory-show-cisco-router-getting-implant/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa...
- creato 7y agoUpgrades like what? Spell checking? These were packages of documents.
- hrrsn 7y agoThey were just making a backup copy, just in case.
- killjoywashere 7y agoThe Huawei spokesperson said they contained important commercial documents, not equipment: “The recent experiences where important commercial documents sent via FedEx were not delivered to their destination, and instead were either diverted to, or were requested to be diverted to, FedEx in the United States, undermines our confidence,” Joe Kelly, a spokesman for Huawei, told Reuters.
- contingencies 7y agoRegardless of the cause of this particular set of events, corporate media engagement as resistance against state actors is the only logical development that can be expected following the Snowden revelations which confirmed that long-theorized postal interception methods are in use. This creates additional pushback for FedEx who now have to prove they aren't working for US intelligence, or face losing additional customers. While other state actors remain valid threats, given US involvement was proven by Snowden and FedEx is so global I am kind of surprised that neither Deutsche Post[0] nor ZTO[1] nor SF Express[2] shares are up on the news. [0] http://en.boerse-frankfurt.de/stock/Deutsche_Post-share http://en.boerse-frankfurt.de/stock/Deutsche_Post-share [1] https://www.nyse.com/quote/XNYS:ZTO https://www.nyse.com/quote/XNYS:ZTO [2] http://www.szse.cn/English/siteMarketData/siteMarketDatas/lookup/index.html?code=002352 http://www.szse.cn/English/siteMarketData/siteMarketDatas/lo...
- maratd 7y ago> I am kind of surprised that neither Deutsche Post[0] nor ZTO[1] nor SF Express[2] shares are up on the news. Why would they be up on the news? They're just as likely to be engaging in the same behavior, only for a different set of government actors.
- dmix 7y agoIntercepting it in the US or within their own country is one thing. Rerouting a document being sent from Japan to China to the US multiple times is most certainly not a common thing mail services would do for intelligence agencies. Getting a private company operating in a foreign country to do your intelligence work so blatantly is certainly news worthy. Maybe not stock price shifting news though.
- Mirioron 7y agoI think it should affect stock price. Espionage is usually punished pretty harshly and you have no guarantee that said private company won't be charged with it in the future when the political landscape changes in the country.
- munk-a 7y agoI would assume this is part of the US government's recent attacks on Huawei except... I'm familiar with FedEx and their terrible service, so I assume it's just them being as terrible as they always are.
- killjoywashere 7y agoAir shipping from any island in APAC is tricky, speaking as someone on an island in APAC. There are only X number of flights and sometimes things go to places you wouldn't expect based on whatever prioritization rules drive FedEx's optimization algorithm that day. This costs my lab and our hospital dearly, so I sort of sympathize. But I also know a FedEx pilot who flew this area for decades and explained their end of the problem as well. It's a hard optimization problem. For example: it may have gone to Alaska, but that's actually closer to Japan and China than any of their other hubs.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoProbably happens all of the time. The unlawful spying organizations in the United States have no true bounds, especially not trivial things like borders or corporate integrity.
- notaplumber 7y agoWow, I'm surprised Huawei went to the press with this-- but it's certainly bizarre.
- throwh28282 7y agoPeople saying 'just an error tbis ; US doesn't do this' should be reminded that the same scenario played out, nationally, with Amazon routing Jacob Appelbaum's laptop to Langley before reaching him.
- majia 7y agoFedex diverted huawei’s packet through the US by mistake. China telecom diverted internet packets through China because it must be hacking. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18385920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18385920
- lyrachord 7y agoOnly fools believe in some things from the oracle company.
- losttheplot 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7126754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7126754
- nullwasamistake 7y agoWhat kind of sloppy 2 bit intelligence operation informs the customer their packages are being redirected to the US? The article mentioned the packages were in the process of being marked "return to sender" To me, this is clearly a case of not being able to read the shipping label, damage to packaging, or similar. It would make plenty of sense that manual "human" decisions on what to do with undeliverable packages is handled by FedEx employees in the US. I have had mail returned before and it always ends up going to a random place, likely to be hand sorted, and taking forever to make its way back. This is likely a non-story trying to throw shade on US companies to distract from negative press on Hauwei. Besides, the mail was shipped using a US based carrier, probably airmail. A plane can make it across the world in 24 hours, so it might make sense to route certain destinations through the US regardless for logistical reasons. If I could ship something to Europe using China Post I would not be fazed if my package ends up in China at some point. If you don't want something to end up in the US don't ship it using a US based mail carrier that is a private company allowed to send your package in any manner it desires. Hauwei complaining to the Chinese government about how their packages are being routed through the US on the way to their destination by a US based mail carrier, what a joke
- Taniwha 7y agoThis is bad for US companies because it will likely result in the rise of a Chinese worldwide Fedex/UPS competitor - you're already sort of seeing this happening in the bulk mail services that are used to ship stuff form Aliexpress
- meiyoumima 7y agoLook what the US goverment made their company do, like a thief. What I know is, When China grows, he did help the development of Asian countries, even a lot with Australian White country. But what USA do in Asia? Make conflicts and wars again and again to get petrol.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fqye 7y agoI am Chinese, living in China and have been pro-U.S / democracy my whole life. But the recent actions by Trump government, U.S corporations, Fedex etc., and academics (IEEE etc.) made me angry. The U.S government provided no evidence of Huawai spying or backdoor but acted hysterically to kill Huawei. And your corporations and intellectuals are helping it. And there are lots of Chinese like me feel the same. Trump and his China haters are pushing away a large group of influential Chinese elites in all different professions, intellectuals, government officials, (yes, there are a lot of pro-U.S / democracy government officials in China), entrepreneurs, engineers, doctors even who used to admire the U.S. This is far more damaging... There will be cost.