9 ms·
The thing that makes me very concerned is the lack of context in these discussions of fake news of the history and continuing use of government propaganda. I h
by ilaksh 7y ago
The thing that makes me very concerned is the lack of context in these discussions of fake news of the history and continuing use of government propaganda.
I hope young people who are familiar with "fake news" but not necessarily as familiar with the history of propaganda and censorship will study that history.
The big issue is there is enthusiasm for censorship, and the problem with censorship is who gets to decide what is real information and what is fake. The interests with the most power will have more control over information as censorship increases.
Because the same power that is supposedly only used to suppress propaganda from some other country is used to suppress internal dissent or criticism.
This is actually very dangerous for multiple reasons. One big reason is that propaganda (internal to the country, i.e. by the same people who will be deciding what is fake news) is usually critical in terms of jump-starting and maintaining enthusiasm for wars.
- wazoox 7y agoCase in point, the "fake news" law in France: it basically asks Facebook and friends to 1° detect abuse, propaganda and "fake news" 2° remove it automatically. So they're handed altogether the power of police, jury and executioner. They're already much too powerful, and they were just given much more power for free. What will become of free speech under these conditions? Do you think Twitter will flag Macron's tweets when he spouts out blatant lies, which is actually quite often?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoIsn't that just the power every Editor wields? Perhaps its inappropriate to consider Facebook the 'publisher' of everything on the site. But its not more power than any other publisher possesses (choosing their own editorial staff).
- golemotron 7y agoIt's fully appropriate to consider Facebook the publisher of everything on their site. They exercise editorial control.
- cameronbrown 7y agoPoint is that many disagree they should. If we take that Facebook is a critical network owned by a company, just like the internet is a critical network owned by many companies, is it not reasonable to assume it is infrastructure and not a publisher? Not saying I agree or disagree, just playing devil's advocate.
- root_axis 7y agoFacebook is definitely not a "critical network". It is a privately owned network operated by a corporation, it is not "critical" or even necessary, in fact, studies suggest increased use of Facebook correlates with poor mental health. Certainly, nobody needs access to Facebook.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI agree in principle, but as a news publisher, you practically have to use Facebook to stay relevant. Same goes for Google to a lesser degree. All the laws like the EUs article 13 were tools in the fight between publishers and the internet giants. They just have the masses of users.
- anoncake 7y agoYou agree in principle that nobody needs Facebook while acknowledging that somebody needs Facebook?
- riskable 7y agoAs a business you need a way to engage with potential or existing customers. Yesterday that "way" was to pay newspapers, the Yellow Pages, etc to place ads. Then it moved to banner ads on various websites and today they use Facebook and Google (and other publishers/communities where people gather). If both Facebook and Google were to disappear business would just use whatever replaces them. The companies aren't essential. The service they provide is. The good news is that service can be provided by basically any business. It's just a problem concentration/monopoly that they're the current focus.
- duxup 7y ago>So they're handed altogether the power of police, jury and executioner. I have that on any given site I make by default.
- anoncake 7y agoAs long as your site is small enough that having that power does not give you significantly more power than any other citizen has, that is not a problem. The threshold for "small enough" is of course fuzzy and debatable, but definitely lower than 2.3 Billion users.
- ryanmarsh 7y agoSerious question: is celebrity gossip allowed? It’s a major source of ad revenue in the news business and has been for quite some time. There’s no way to tell what is fake and what is not? Not to mention nobody cares if it’s fake. They love the gossip. How is this handled?
- beepboopbeep 7y agoThis is an absurd slippery slope falacy.
- wazoox 7y agoIf this was happening in isolation, that could be. But it's also happening in a general atmosphere of extreme police violence (6 months of constant protests, 1 dead, 5 hands ripped off, 23 eyes gouged, 3000 persons jailed for no discernible reason), authoritarian policy, and extending surveillance -- and no proper counter-power, making Macron almost indiscernible from his distinctly fascistic, official main opponent. Later this week, in European elections, prepare to see a landslide of far-right parties of various racist, xenophobic flavours in all countries. A slippery slope? Looks like an oily slide into chaos indeed.
- mistermann 7y agoSee: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-05-20/australia-election-is-not-the-only-one-the-new-right-is-winning https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-05-20/austra...
- save_ferris 7y agoWe're already seeing a similar effect through privately run communication systems like Facebook too, though. Facebook has clearly failed to take responsibility to combat fake news, as some of the most serious solutions to the problem pose existential threats to their entire business. On top of that, we're also seeing high-profile figures and politicians pushing propaganda successfully without the need for censorship (the Obama birtherism conspiracy, the Jade Helm conspiracy, etc.) Whether or not they're willingly doing so is up for debate, but some of the conspiracies being pushed are inflammatory, ridiculous, and damaging to our civil discourse. The heads of major political parties get to decide what is real information and what is fake now; they don't need censorship to do this. Look at how many plainly absurd lies this administration has pushed about the most inane things (the inauguration attendance) to the most serious things (Trump dictating the false statement on the June 2016 meeting, etc.) There's just no longer an incentive to have a good-faith debate on anything.
- darkpuma 7y ago> "The heads of major political parties get to decide what is real information and what is fake now; they don't need censorship to do this." I don't need a car to get to work. I've got a bicycle and five miles on a bike is nothing. But the car sure as hell makes it easier.
- save_ferris 7y agoIn your analogy, you get to work either way. In either case, our discourse continues to suffer. So what choice do we have? Maintain the current system and watch our process devolve slowly, or permit regulation which runs the risk of creating a power vacuum? Our system suffers in either case. We're talking about damage control at this point; not actually fixing the problem.
- ralusek 7y agoI have good faith debates all the time, and I can count on one hand how many times I've been arguing with someone that is relying on incorrect facts. People actually don't tend to disagree on facts very often, they disagree on conclusions. I don't want a political entity determine which conclusions are correct, because that is the job a long and public negotiation.
- whatamidoingyo 7y ago>I hope young people who are familiar with "fake news" but not necessarily as familiar with the history of propaganda and censorship will study that history. What inspired me to learn about it was none other than a youtube video title "Rule From the Shadows: The Psychology of Control". Sure, it sounds like it'd be a conspiracy theory video, but it's far from it, listed all sources, and recommended books which were discussed. Those books being: The Crowd by Gustave Le Bon, Crystallizing Public Opinion, and Propaganda by Edward Bernays, Sigmund Freud's nephew. That video on youtube really changed the way I view the world, especially media and "groups" of people, like antifa, the alt-right, or what have you. When you see the words of Le Bon or Bernays in action, it sends a shiver down your back. The downside being that most people will assume you're crazy or paranoid if you start talking about Bernays or Le Bon. "The conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized habits and opinions of the masses is an important element in democratic society." - Edward Bernays