19 ms·
Uber Drivers Are Contractors, Not Employees, Labor Board Says
- derekp7 8y agoI wonder if a simple change to Uber's app would fix all this -- let drivers set their own rates, and customers could pick from a number of drivers nearby based on how close they are, and what rate they charge. And/or let customers put out a bid for the rate they want to pay, then any driver can accept that bid and get the fare. That way drivers could be more legally considered contractors (they set their own rates), and none would feel underpaid (after all they get paid the rates they set).
- thanatropism 8y agoThis actually exists in Rio. Yellow cab drivers agitated for banning Uber and instead the city government made them a ride hailing app where they can choose how much to discount over full price. I haven’t used it, but know people who do. It’s kind of up to consumers to figure out how much to pay vs how much to wait.
- maximente 8y agothese apps exist in Colombia, probably other knock offs i'm not aware of as well
- LeoPanthera 8y agoThis is exactly how Sidecar used to work. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sidecar_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sidecar_(company) Sidecar was acquired by GM after it shut down at the end of 2015.
- uber-employee 8y agoFYI, Sidecar did this in 2013 - you could set your own price, both as a rider and driver. Then, when you request a ride, it would be more like market-making, with you getting matched with the driver whose price is closest to your requested price, but under it. I personally tried using this many times - it was a poor experience for riders. I can imagine it wasn't very pleasant for drivers either. The theoretical ideal price for a ridesharing trip changes in realtime and depends on many different factors like how many drivers are nearby, how many other riders are nearby, each driver's willingness to drive to your destination, etc. Letting riders and drivers set their own prices would make the market significantly less efficient, and would make both the experience for both sides of the marketplace quite miserable, especially during events like demand spikes. There is literally a several hundred-strong organization at Uber (Marketplace) whose single focus is to make a maximally efficient marketplace. It's honestly kind of dismissive to suggest something like this, and to call it "a simple change". Disclaimer: the above is not meant to be a representation of how Uber pricing works, just my own theoretical musing
- TeMPOraL 8y agoHonestly, even trying to achieve the "theoretical ideal price" based on supply and demand is already screwing up with the market. Regular people are not like HFT algorithms, with infinite pools of money available and ability to turn opportunity cost into profit. Having a stable and predictable price is important when deciding whether or not order a taxi/rideshare at all. (At least, that's my experience. I wonder what your data has to say on it.) As a customer, I'd be happiest if taxi companies charged a rate per-km, that's calculated off their consumables + car amortization + some reasonable profit margin. I think drivers may be happier too - recent personal experience with myTaxi shows this. They offered a promotion in which the passenger would pay a fixed cost known immediately in the app, but which calculations changed every day or so. Some days, it would become a good deal for the drivers; other days, the drivers would be working at a loss. I had a lot of problems getting a ride when using this promotion, and chatting with the drivers revealed that they instinctively ignore those requests, as from their POV the profits are unreliable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fergie 8y agoYes. From the article -> "given that drivers cannot set prices or market their personal services to potential customers. The driver’s entrepreneurial opportunities are almost “completely circumscribed by the company’s control of the price,” she said."
- paulddraper 8y agoImportant: > The memo released on Tuesday, which was dated April 16, has no long-term value as a precedent and can be reversed by a future general counsel. Its immediate consequence is to render moot three formal accusations, filed in different parts of the country, that Uber had violated federal labor law. The memo instructs the board’s regional offices to dismiss the charges if the people who made them do not withdraw them first.
- threezero 8y agoI’m guessing (hoping, really) that Peter Robb is out at the NLRB in two years and someone far less right-wing replaces him. The biggest issue is that the NLRB hasn’t been pro-worker in a long time.
- wavefunction 8y ago>The board’s general counsel, an appointee of President Trump ah!
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoOne of the symptoms of our current political paralysis is the over-reliance on executive agencies to set policy instead of Congress debating and passing laws. Instead of trying to get net neutrality through law, we depend on the FCC trying to shoe-horn ISP into an old law designed for phone companies. Instead of explicitly talking about what protections people who sign up for the "gig" economy should get, we try to shoe-horn them into either employees or contractors when in reality they are in a gray zone and we don't have the political will to conduct a debate on what we should do. The downside is instead of having an open debate about the pros/cons and having a law with some staying power, the situation changes depending on the whims of whoever is President and who they appoint to various administrative positions.
- ajross 8y agoI'm sorry, what? The "over-reliance on executive agencies to set policy" is just shorthand for "congress can't pass these laws". But that's not because some passive voice nonsense about "political paralysis", it's because these are partisan issues. One party doesn't want these laws to pass, and won't vote for them. It's not a passive structural problem. There are good guys and bad guys here. If you actually care, it's time to take a stand.
- glitchc 8y agoTake a stand against who? The politicians are empowered by regular Americans who support them. Your neighbors and friends.
- Fomite 8y agoIt's possible it's time to confront your neighbors and friends.
- ajross 8y ago"Taking a stand", in the sense used here, refers to taking action to effect change. Call up your neighbors and tell them who to vote for. Tell all your friends who you are voting for, and why. Excusing this as some kind of structural problem with "political paralysis" sounds, to me, like you're a nominal republican who hates republican policies but is reaching for an excuse to avoid hanging out with dirty hippies and AOC. But the hippies are right, here, if you care about these issues.
- inkaudio 8y agoUber drivers are fighting the wrong fight in this case. They should focus on fighting for a minimum wage that accounts for expenses. Uber's edge is not their technology, their edge is the ability to burn billion dollars a quarter subsidizing rides. Uber is masking customer demand and this sort of behavior is anticompetitive and should not be allowed in an industry as critical as transportation. Case in point, when Uber/Lyft was forced to pay their drivers a minimum wage that accounted for expenses, Uber and Lyft stopped accepting new drivers in New York City. They were force to act according to true supply and demand. Link: https://www.theverge.com/2019/4/29/18522885/uber-lyft-not-accepting-new-drivers-nyc-rules-supply-demand https://www.theverge.com/2019/4/29/18522885/uber-lyft-not-ac...
- ralusek 8y agoWhat do you mean "true" supply and demand? What was happening before was true supply and demand. They offered a rate, people were capable of consenting to the terms while accounting for expenses, and they did. Then an intermediary stepped between the consenting transactors and told them that they could no longer accept those terms, and now those transactions can no longer transpire, regardless of whether or not both parties would like to engage. How is that true supply and demand?
- romwell 8y ago>They offered a rate, people were capable of consenting to the terms while accounting for expenses See, on party here has a lot more data on said expenses, and all the incentives in the world to be misleading about them. The existing demand was not "true" under the reasonable assumption that nobody wants to work for less than minimum wage after expenses.
- gridlockd 8y ago> The existing demand was not "true" under the reasonable assumption that nobody wants to work for less than minimum wage after expenses. That's an unreasonable assumption, especially when that "minimum wage" is 17$.
- 8y ago
- colluphid 8y agoSelf driving cars can not happen quick enough.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoHere in Australia, most drivers seem to be using several other apps (Didi, Ola, etc) at the same time as Uber. So in that sense, they are a contractor in my eyes.
- wvenable 8y agoThey also, obviously, set their own hours and choose at any time to work or not work.
- sgustard 8y agoPer https://legal.uncc.edu/legal-topics/contracts/contract-checklist/independent-contractor-rules-thumb https://legal.uncc.edu/legal-topics/contracts/contract-check... "If the worker is not integrated into the institution's operations and the right of control is not obviously apparent (no training, no work hours, no reports), you are reasonably safe as long as the relationship is short-term and the independent contractor has other customers." I would say "integrated into the institution's operations" is the very definition of Uber drivers. (What is Uber except for a network of drivers?) And as far as "right of control": here's an app that tells you exactly where to go, who to pick up, what route to follow, how much to collect. Many drivers are not "short-term" nor have other "customers."
- wvenable 8y agoThat's dependent on your definition of integrated. Uber drivers never go into Uber's offices. They never meet Uber staff or managers (the actual employees of Uber). That's possibly as far from "integrated" as you can get. Uber drivers have a very similar relationship to Uber as it's customers do -- but you wouldn't argue the customers are integrated. They may be essential for Uber's business but that is different. Customers are also essential. Contractors can be essential.
- esoterica 8y agoBy your logic craigslist sellers are employees of craigslist. What is craigslist but a network of buyers and sellers?
- dcosson 8y agoIt’s sad that the idea of people being able to get by and live a comfortable life without the benefits from a full time job is so far outside the Overton window that it’s not even mentioned in these conversations. That seems like such an obviously better outcome for everyone - what if we got rid of healthcare benefits and other types of favorable tax treatment that are tied to full time employment so that everyone is in the same boat? Then all contractors, including Uber and Lyft drivers could keep the freedom and flexibility of being contractors (which anecdotally, I have talked to a lot of drivers who really like this aspect of it), but also not struggle as much to get by? (Universal healthcare is one path towards this world but not necessarily the only one, I think even the current healthcare system we have would work a lot better if premiums weren’t paid pre-tax by employers and people had actual choice and paid for their care with real money).
- sushisushisushi 8y agoIt's not really outside the Overton window. Universal healthcare has strong majority support right now. Employers and shareholders benefit significantly by reducing options for workers and by making it difficult for workers to change jobs; the source of the resistance is there, in the plain language of power, not in some imaginary spectrum of what's considered to be acceptable.
- twblalock 8y agoMost employers would love to be able to stop paying for their employees' health care.
- solidasparagus 8y agoUniversal healthcare has decent (but not 'strong majority') support in the abstract [1]. In terms of concrete proposals (i.e. once you've answered the questions of what universal healthcare is and how you pay for it), there is not a single plan that is even somewhat popular. [1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/democrats-have-no-safe-options-on-health-care/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/democrats-have-no-safe-...
- sgustard 8y agoI am forced to treat the people who cut my lawn and clean my house as employees, according to tax law, for funding unemployment insurance among other things. But Uber's labor force, without which literally the company wouldn't exist, are not eligible for the same benefits. The logical next step is that the company has no liability for anything that happens to you in one of their cars.
- prepend 8y agoYou treat your lawn care person and maid as employees? I guess if they are full time. My lawn care is completely contractor based- they provide tools, they set schedule, they don’t have a uniform set by me. They are exactly contractors. Same with my maid. If I for some reason had an estate that required employee Lawncare this would be different and I would hire someone. There’s a definition from the IRS in the US for employee and contractor that’s not exactly black and white but has many tests for who is an employee vs contractor.
- brianwawok 8y agoMany people do not follow this, but https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/hiring-household-employees https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe... > You have a household employee if you hired someone to do household work and that worker is your employee. The worker is your employee if you can control not only what work is done, but how it is done. If the worker is your employee, it does not matter whether the work is full time or part time or that you hired the worker through an agency or from a list provided by an agency or association. It also does not matter whether you pay the worker on an hourly, daily, or weekly basis, or by the job. > Household work is work done in or around your home by the following people. > Babysitters Caretakers Cleaning people Domestic workers Drivers Health aides Housekeepers Maids Nannies Private nurses Yard workers
- bm1362 8y agoFrom that link: > You made an agreement with John Peters to care for your lawn. John runs a lawn care business and offers his services to the general public. He provides his own tools and supplies, and he hires and pays any helpers he needs. Neither John nor his helpers are your household employees. In this comparison, a driver partner offers their services to multiple marketplaces, provides his own supplies, etc.
- coding123 8y agoSo do we need a middle type of worker at this point?
- jppope 8y ago^^This is an incredibly important argument. Many Companies would love a middle road, as well as employees. The funniest part is that most "good" companies already operate on a performance basis. It should be considered
- manigandham 8y agoPeople seem to forget that "professional driver" is an actual job available for close to a century now if you really wanted a full-time position. Uber already works with FTE drivers at higher tiers like Lux and Black. All of the drivers I've asked over 1000's of rides have said they prefer the freedom and flexibility to work on their own time. Yes they want more money, but not at the cost of the flexibility. They already have day jobs, or are students, retirees, business owners, etc, and are making extra income with an opportunity that wouldn't otherwise exist. Perhaps the tiny handful of people who are suing to become employees should just go out and become employees instead of trying to change the rules for everyone else.
- ummonk 8y agoYeah, I keep seeing these articles get posted and it makes no sense. Most drivers seem to want to have the freedom and flexibility to choose when they work. That absolutely makes them contractors. The only argument to be made here potentially is that some of the gamified rewards incentives to keep driving might be questionable and make the relationship more employer/employee-like.
- blub 8y agoBeing an employee doesn't imply fixed hours. It does imply having labour protections. And in the US it also implies having healthcare.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoOnly if your employer has 50 or more full time employees and you work more than 30 hours per week. Also, the employer doesn’t provide healthcare, they simply have to offer access to health insurance that covers 60% of your expected healthcare costs, but the employer is free to only pay for 30% or 50% or whatever share of the insurance premium, and leave rest for employee as long as sufficient numbers of employees sign up to prevent the non discrimination testing from failing. In summary, I would say being an employee in the US most certainly does not imply you will have access to healthcare.
- hellllllllooo 8y ago
- whack 8y agoRelying on corporations to help the lower middle class, is an outdated idea. Corporations are expressly designed to create value at the lowest possible cost, which necessarily means minimizing labor expenses. Relying on corporations to achieve universal healthcare and a living wage, is expressly going against what they were designed for. There is a far better way to help the lower middle class: through the government. Raise taxes on the rich, raise the capital gains tax rate, and use the revenue to subsidize college tuition, to provide universal healthcare, and to supplement the earned income tax credit. Let corporations do what they do best: provide services at the lowest possible cost. And start demanding that our government do what it's supposed to do: ensure that the wealth generated by corporations is adequately shared by all.
- newshorts 8y agoagreed. Ordoliberalism is really the only fungible path to ensuring most people in a society get a fair shake.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoThe social market economy has been very successful, but your use of “fungible” doesn’t seem to make sense, unless this is satire.
- jorblumesea 8y agoEurope already does this, to a reasonable extent. So do most developed countries (Japan, Australia, for example). It's really the US that lags behind in almost all aspects of taking care of its citizens.
- gwright 8y ago> And start demanding that our government do what it's supposed to do: ensure that the wealth generated by corporations is adequately shared by all. On what basis do you think this is the proper role for government?
- gwright 8y ago
- dnautics 8y agoHaving been an Uber /Lyft driver I can't even fathom what it would mean for a driver to be an employee with expenses paid. Is the driver driving a gas guzzling F250 entitled to a higher reimbursement for cost of driving than me driving a Honda insight?
- delinka 8y agoIf I owned the company, I'd rather buy vehicles (with which I can reasonably control costs) and provide the vehicle to the driver employee. My second option, as owner, is to offer a fixed reimbursement - per mile, per minute, whatever the economics dictate. I'm not, as owner, going to invite 'come one, come all' with their random expenses and offer to reimburse them all.
- manigandham 8y agoProfessional drivers already exist. Look at any taxi, delivery, bus or transit company. That's what Uber would do. Lease a bunch of vehicles and tell people to drive them for 8 hours a day for a flat rate, and they'll have strict hours and no flexibility.
- Consultant32452 8y agoI think the default is the government reimbursement rate. This year it's $0.58/mi. When I worked at a pizza place in high school drivers were reimbursed at this rate. That's a similar market because pizza delivery drivers drive their personal vehicles and it doesn't matter if you drive a Prius or a Hummer. https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-issues-standard-mileage-rates-for-2019 https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-issues-standard-mileage-rat...
- xivzgrev 8y agoTaxi drivers have usually been considered independent contractors - what is different with Uber? I’m assuming it’s because Uber exercises more control over their income thru price adjustments (which taxi drivers aren’t subject to). I think Uber drivers should be organizing for that kind of protection eg some accountability when Uber wants to drop rev share or fares.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoNot in Switzerland. They're not. At least not according to a 3 week old judgement by the Lausanne labor court, which ordered Uber to pay a driver for the legally mandated notice period after deactivating him.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dalbasal 8y agoI'm not american, so I could be missing some nuance, but in general uber, lyft and other gig-businesses have created a new type of labour. A court or a board is going to approach this by analogy. Is this more similar to "contractors," day labourers, piecemeal arrangements, full time employees.. These gigs don't really fall into a pre-existing categories, or shouldn't. The dynamic is totally different. The issues are different and the whole thing merits its own fraework at this point. It's not difficult to define "gigs" by their features (just like the features used to test the "contractor" definition).
- Fnoord 8y ago(In the USA.)
- C1sc0cat 8y agoId look at what the IRS says as well
- thierryzoller 8y agoContrary to nearly every other jurisdiction in the world. Fun times.
- village-idiot 8y agoI do think it’s probably correct that Uber drivers aren’t employees, setting their own schedule is a huge differentiator in the labor market. But I think that we might need a new classification (and labor protections) for people who are classified as contractors but fulfill such a large percentage of a company’s actual work on a permanent basis. The season temp and the Uber driver that’s mission critical to Uber’s daily functioning are just different from a labor perspective, and should be given different protections and leverage.
- Kaotique 8y agoUber represents the new kind of company where all the risk is pushed to the employee, while all the profits are pulled to the company. Making all your employees supposedly outside contractors facilitates a race to the bottom between these contractors. Same with food delivery companies. The drivers have to provide and maintain the vehicle, organize their own health care, pension and insurance. Some companies even disallow them to work for different companies, which is a direct violation of the contractor dynamic. Recently a Dutch judge ruled that these food delivery contractors were not actual free agents but bound to their one supplier of rides. The judged ruling was that this is not correct as they lacked the freedom to work for other companies. I find it very disappointing that companies like Uber and Airbnb managed to create these amazing platforms but have such disrespect for the wellbeing of their workers or how they affect communities in the world.
- creaghpatr 8y agoIt's the same with industries like film in the US, only difference is the hourly rate gets to be pretty high after a few years of work and presumed advancement.
- Kye 8y agoFilm has unions. Remember the 2007-2008 Writers Guild strike? People dismissed their demand for fair streaming residuals. "Streaming won't go anywhere, give me back my TV!"
- maxxxxx 8y agoIn film you have a chance to be a real freelancer. You have a track record and you can jump between different productions. You can work your way up. An Uber driver has none of this. He will always stay a driver, never move up, have no reputation to increase market worth. It’s a total dead end.
- kevin_b_er 8y agoThis was the designed purpose of these companies. They're more efficient at providing wealth for the top end by taking it from the "employees".
- JulianMorrison 8y agoAnd this is why you need unions. Join the IWW.
- jackschultz 8y agoThe thing that always bugs me with these arguments is that people don't seem to bring up the idea of creating a new legal class for these types of workers. Arguing whether those workers fit contractors or employees isn't great to read about because frankly, they fit in neither. From Uber/Lyft drivers, to Door Dash delivery workers, to any other sort of up and coming on demand work which I'm sure keep coming and evolving, I believe creating a new legal class would be well worth the effort rather than arguing about where they fit in the current system. This type of solution isn't easy. With all the arguments about if the drivers are contractors or employees, creating a new class of workers will easily be just as difficult; instead of legal fees for the law interpretation, it'd be legal fees for law creation.
- SilasX 8y agoAgreed, but I would say that the whole employment/social insurance system is due for a big "refactoring". We have this hodge-podge of sorta-overlapping requirements based on long-obsolete and assumptions and models about how the labor force works that's we're expecting to meet some desiderata that it also incentivizes against. We've already lost the game when we're counting angels on a pin to decide whether you're "really" an employee so your employer can be forced to provide insurance or pay into unemployment. But these things shouldn't be coupled at all. Everyone, regardless of how they get income, should pay into an employer-decoupled fund that can pay out for unemployment or health insurance. That frees up admin costs from employers and cleans up labor markets to compete over things that are actually relevant. Contractor vs employee distinctions should only matter for liability, not for taxes or benefits.
- specialist 8y agoWhy aren't Uber drivers considered franchisees?
- billions 8y agoW2 tax rate is the WORST in the country because regulations make it costly for both, employee and employer. At least as a contractor you can write things off fairly.