8 ms·
Why do you grab your bag when running off a burning plane?
- lisper 8y agoI used to think that if I was ever in a plane crash I'd want to save my laptop, so now I've gotten into the habit of carrying a small SSD drive with me whenever I travel. I use it to image the hard drive on my laptop. I keep it in a ziploc bag in my pocket. Other than that, I never take anything with me on a trip that I'm not willing to lose. That way if I am ever in a plane crash, the drive, already in my pocket, is all I need to save from among my belongings. Keeping it in a ziploc means it will be OK even if we go down over water. (And, of course, I've got backups at home too.)
- wool_gather 8y agoYou might want to get a better bag if you're worried about submersion. Ziplocs are not necessarily completely water tight out of the box, and they degrade pretty quickly in use (like the constant rubbing that'll be produced by carrying it in your pocket all the time). Wad up some toilet paper in an old ziploc or two and submerge them for a few minutes, then check the paper...you might not like the results. Consider a dry bag like rafters/kayakers use.
- lisper 8y agoA proper dry bag won't fit in my pocket. I do use a fresh ziploc for every trip, but there's a limit to what I'm willing to do to mitigate this risk. I also have backups at home, so if I ever do lose my backup to water that will be inconvenient but not catastrophic.
- fhbdukfrh 8y ago"there's a limit to what I'm willing to do to mitigate risk..." This is a troll right? Plan for a plane crash but not willing to use proper waterproof storage?
- lisper 8y ago> This is a troll right? Nope. > Plan for a plane crash but not willing to use proper waterproof storage? Yep. A ziploc bag costs me about a nickel, takes me five seconds to acquire (because I have them in stock), and fits neatly into my pocket, which is a really important feature for this use case. I don't know of any "proper waterproof storage" with those features. It's possible I'm being foolish, but I'm not trolling.
- detaro 8y agoLots more reasons why you might loose a laptop while traveling, it's not a dedicated plan for plane crashes.
- wool_gather 8y agoFair enough. There are dry bags that are cell phone sized, though, which I would guess is about the same size as your drive.
- spectramax 8y agoPlanning for a plane crash is probably the most ridiculous, insane thing one can do. There is a benefit trade-off of preparation time and being worried all the time. It bothers me when I see people always in “guarded” mode - these people seem to never live freely, enjoy the moment and they constantly worry about someone stealing their wallets or their car. I had a manager at work who would steering lock with a giant steel rod on his brand new Mercedes which has a number of safety/anti-theft systems. I go to the other extreme which is probably also insane. I never use a phone case, put a leather cover on my passport or any of these things. I’ve realized that I have so many years to live and enjoy the products as they’re designed. If I were to buy a Ferrari, you bet your bottom dollar I am driving the shit out of it. Edit: I want to clarify: I wear seatbelts, safety glasses (even when frying something in the kitchen, yes your kitchen is essentially a chemical lab with a Bunsen burner), sunscreen, regular health screenings, go to the dentist, shower, etc. I think people are totally missing my point if your argument is about ignoring safety, sanitation, etc.
- newnewpdro 8y agoBeing prepared and worried are two very different things. If you can't separate those two, that's the problem to address - not simply dispensing with all preparation for the worst outcomes because YOLO.
- formercoder 8y agoI always make sure my shoes are on for takeoff and landing, ensure that I know which emergency exit I will use, and attempt to evaluate my best path to that exit. I don’t feel like it’s a waste to plan for the remote possibility of a life threatening situation.
- spectramax 8y agoI’m not advocating ignoring fundamental aspects of safety, wearing proper PPE, evacuation information, exits, etc. You should be aware of them and use them.
- 8y ago
- dorfsmay 8y agoThis is to save your few hours of works while on widi-less plane? Or do you not use cloud drives?
- lisper 8y agoThat's right, I don't use cloud drives. Where I travel, high speed internet is often not available. Also, I don't trust cloud providers. "The cloud" is a synonym for "someone else's computer." I want my data on hardware that I own and control.
- shawnz 8y agoWhy don't you just encrypt the data before uploading?
- lisper 8y agoBecause that doesn't solve the problem of not having an internet connection. Also, it's not that I don't trust providers not to read my data, it's that I don't trust them not to lose it. I have no way of knowing what goes on behind the scenes at a cloud provider. For all I know, they are one hardware failure (or one financial failure) away from losing my data.
- shawnz 8y agoThey have obligations to their corporate customers which would require them to have architecture in place to protect against that kind of scenario better than any home user could on their own. Plus you could hedge your bets by just backing up to multiple providers (i.e. Google Drive, Onedrive, Dropbox). What are the chances that all three would fail simultaneously?
- dorfsmay 8y agoI use a drive cloud provider (pcloud) which I backup with a backup provider (backblaze). The advantage of using providers is that they have paid employee to take care of everyday operations. I'll argue that using 2 different provider protects me from losing all my data if one of them screws up royally, or their business go under. Also, this is my dog-fooding of the solution I recommend to my non-tech family and friends.
- zulln 8y agoI always fly with my passport in my pocket for similar reason. I am fine with losing all tech though, with everything being encrypted and backups with anything important elsewhere that seems like a minor inconvenience.
- kosievdmerwe 8y agoA better reason is fears of theft. Especially in terminals, your bag is much more likely to get stolen.
- bernardlunn 8y agoIf you get off a plane crash alive, your laptop will be the last thing on your mind
- fhbdukfrh 8y agoYou're kidding right? Plane crash? Over water? You'd be lucky to survive, who cares about your hard drive.
- lisper 8y agoPeople survive plane crashes, even over water, all the time.
- rasz 8y agoWhat if you get struck by lightning? Better make that a faraday cage ziploc bag.
- Waterluvian 8y agoI think it reveals that we should relieve people of the choice. If it's not feasible to train and educate people until the proper behaviour is a muscle memory, then maybe we need to find a way to eliminate choice.
- freedomben 8y agowhat do you mean? like lock down the overhead bins so people can't get to their stuff?
- gotts 8y agoExactly. It could have saved someone's life.
- Zealotux 8y agoI thought about this solution as well and I came to the conclusion that it might worsen the situation even more: people panicking trying to force the overhead compartment could slow the evacuation even more. You need just one panicked passenger trying to force the lock to block a whole plane. It would also be a quite challenging technical problem: are compartments locked the whole flight? Are they locked only on emergencies? If so: who thinks of locking them when an emergency occurs? I admit I don't know much about emergency procedures for flight attendants.
- Waterluvian 8y agoIt's far too premature and ill-prepared to armchair solution workshop. My point is that maybe the solution is to funnel humans towards a behaviour rather than hoping for rational behaviour
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 8y agoThere are a lot of things that, if done individually, make sense, but if the whole group does it there is a problem. Leaving your bag behind means that you have to replace it later which costs a lot and takes time. So it makes sense to avoid this trouble. It also makes sense to rush to wards the exit if there is a fire but if everyone does it you have a problem.
- a-b 8y agoThis is a well-known post ussr feature "do not give a #it about anyone but yourself".
- Mirioron 8y agoI wonder why you're downvoted. I live in a former Soviet state and my impression is that the Soviet era taught people to always prioritize your own stuff, because nobody else will care about it.
- freedomben 8y agoI spent some time in Azerbaijan and I was amazed at how much the locals helped us out. We had a mechanical break down and random strangers stopped to help us out. They actually fixed our car and got us back on the road! It was mind-blowing, genuine love for fellow humans and it deeply affected me. That said, of course that's a microscopic sample size in a vast empire. No doubt it's not representative.
- sakopov 8y agoThat is very typical in the Caucasus. I have countless of stories of people going completely out of their way to help out and requesting nothing back in return, but instead maybe even invite you for a dinner with their family. Incredibly hospitable region.
- Mirioron 8y agoIt could be that my experience isn't representative though. But I've found that many people that are helpful and kind eventually get taken advantage of. Even those kind people probably wouldn't bat an eye when it came to stealing from the state though (at least strong the Soviet era). Pretty much everyone knew someone who skimmed things from the state here and there. Many people felt like they had to, because there wasn't always enough stuff to go around. In the case of this story, people might be willing to help you find a place to sleep and even help you get home, but the stuff you lost is your business.
- 8y ago
- michaelt 8y agoWhy would anyone evacuating a plane waste precious moments retrieving his Sudoku book I think part of understanding this is replacing "Sudoku book" with "Passport, travel insurance documents, money, and return plane ticket" Everyone's heard the Kafkaesque stories of people getting stuck living in airports for hundreds of days [1] or having to pay huge sums for hotels and different flights out of their own pockets. Not that I imagine that would happen if you fled a burning plane - but who'd be calm enough to reason that through while their plane was on fire? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_who_have_lived_at_airports https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_who_have_lived_...
- guitarbill 8y agoThe only thing you need is your passport. This is because if you de-plane without it, you have to wait for the authorities to confirm your identity, which can take hours. Which can happen if e.g. your plane overshoots a runway in the mildest case. Money is maybe a close second, followed by a phone. (edit: parent was edited to include the part about the "the Kafkaesque stories", so this response seems to duplicate things a bit now)
- Mirioron 8y agoHow is it the only thing you'll need though? If you're not wealthy then the loss of some of that stuff can complicate your life.
- guitarbill 8y agoSuch an event will "complicate your life" regardless. When you're poor, that's always an issue, e.g. if/when your car breaks down. Just one reason why being poor sucks. But should you put others at risk? No. The point still stands, there's an immediate need for identification, everything else can be sorted later.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- booleandilemma 8y agoBecause I didn’t push my code yet, obviously.
- amelius 8y agoBecause it is not fined? I mean, if the options are a 20k fine or leaving your bag, then for most people the choice is simple.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dingaling 8y agoIt'd probably work better as an incentive: $20k compensation for everyone who leaves without a bag.
- azov 8y agoIf we're going to legalize something - how about requiring that airlines (or their insurance) compensate passengers for all expenses related to restoring their stuff lost in an accident? Then the choice is also simple, and it sounds way better than fining or prosecuting accident victims.
- _red 8y agoThis probably has a large amount of 'survivorship bias' embedded in it (no pun intended). People who are frantic, time-critical, but not immediate life-threatening situations probably grab their bag (ie. the landing gear on plane has failed, but plane has stopped on runway intact and not on fire). This probably differs significantly if the plane was ripped in half, or people were choking from thick toxic smoke. Those people probably don't even think about grabbing their bag because they are in active severe pain / dying. Point is, people are making a rational decision that "This is a dangerous situation and I need to get out of here, but I will probably survive", therefore they take their stuff with them.
- dorfsmay 8y agoI'm not sure humans are very rational while in a panic. You hear a lot of stories of people being in life threatening situations and make irrational decisions, and the ones who survived saying they cannot explain why, but this one stupid thing they focused on was somehow extremely important to them at the time.
- tyingq 8y agoSimilarly, I find it odd in those "real life crime" TV shows when cops comment on how someone's affect and demeanor "aren't right" following a murder.
- gist 8y agoArticle did not breach a few points. First, why is there no law or clear punishment against grabbing your luggage in an emergency or otherwise obstructing the safe exit from the plane? If someone were intentionally obstructing others in this or in another situation (burning building) that would clearly be most likely seen as some type of crime. Why not here? Why no announcement on the plane? (Back up by the 'federal crime' as they do with smoking in the lavatory). > Psychologists caution, though, against being too quick to judge. The fact that there should be no judgement or we should not think we would do different does not detract that people might have to get drilled into them not to follow some particular behavior. It's almost as if the psychologists and trying to give the behavior a pass. > That passenger reaching for the bag with his favorite sweater or maybe a present for his kid? He’s probably just acting human. Not really. What is human about prioritizing a 'present for your kid' or 'your favorite sweater'? That's irrational. Non adult. And actually child like. People should not get a pass for doing stupid things. > grabbing for possessions is more common than one might think Actually what is probably happening is people see other people grab things and then mimic that behavior. You see the same type of thing with traffic. One person does a u turn and then a bunch of people follow. > “We have in the past publicly commented on the need for passengers to leave carry-on items behind during an emergency,” said Christopher O’Neil' I wish there were no speeding laws and tickets and the state just gave that type of friendly reminder!
- oarsinsync 8y ago> The fact that there should be no judgement or we should not think we would do different does not detract that people might have to get drilled into them not to follow some particular behavior. > I wish there were no speeding laws and tickets I understand what you’re saying, and as a driver and frequent flier, appreciate both points. Unfortunately, the reality is in absolute numbers: There are large numbers of people speeding daily, and large numbers of people dying on the roads daily, globally. There are orders of magnitude fewer numbers of people flying on planes that perform emergency disembarking events, and more orders of magnitude fewer people dying in these instances. Given the frequency of reminders getting drilled into drivers that speed kills, who continue to speed frequently, how frequent would reminders to not grab possessions in an emergency situation actually have to be in order to be effective? The base premise of the point to not judge is that in an emergency situation, some people are acting on instinct. Meanwhile people who speed are more often making a conscious decision to do so based on their own view of road conditions.
- smbullet 8y agoPaywall and outline doesn't seem to work with NYT.
- amelius 8y agoPerhaps the overhead bins should be lockable from the cockpit?
- VectorLock 8y agoThis is the same thought I had as well and when I thought about it a bit and although it does have some utility draw backs (have to ask the flight attendant to open the bin to get something from your bag) it seems like it would also have some other benefits for safety as well such as preventing people from opening the bins when the fasten seatbelts sign is on, or popping open during turbulence.
- sideaccount 8y agoWhat if my bag contains my identification, prescriptions, inhaler? there are a lot of reasons to want your bag. What if you are a parent who carries things to maintain the health/safety of a small child, does your 2 year old take responsibility for their asthma medication?
- megous 8y agoThen you can carry it on your body while being on a plane. Would that be worth the inconvenience to you?
- Mirioron 8y agoAn inhaler and other medication along with your wallet, phone, and passport would pretty much completely fill your pockets. Also, better hope that nobody pickpockets you because you can't get refills for certain medication.
- megous 8y agoSo perhaps you can carry it only on takeoff and before landing, when there's a higher chance of survival/emergency evacuation anyway.
- sideaccount 8y agoWhat about females who carry everything in a bag?
- ebg13 8y agoWhen you say females, do you mean women?
- sideaccount 8y agoExcellent question, I mean any organism that identifies as female AND elects to wear the stereotypical types of clothing marketed towards females by the oppressive patriarchy that do not have pockets. I personally identify as an attack helicopter, which means I have some extra cargo space and rotor blades that make it easy to land softly if my flight has problems and I am forced to jump out mid flight, which is why I don't use my pockets.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xondono 8y agoWhat I’m wondering is how many of those people complaining on the Twitterverse did so while driving or otherwise putting others at risk. We live to think we’d do otherwise, but if we are honest with ourselves, we know we’d do the same..
- blensor 8y agoWhen I am on a plane. Especially on foreign trips, quite a substantial amount of thoughts goes into not leaving anything behind, and thinking about scenarios what would happen if I lost or forgot something important. Of course everything of those items would be less important in a life and death situation but as my brain is already trained for holding onto my stuff I can understand why this happens. I am not saying that this is a good thing but I think ingrained habits are hard to break.
- alex_young 8y agoDoes the shift to charging for checked bags make this worse? I suspect this choice is new to most people since they used to have that stuff locked away from sight.
- bartimus 8y agoI often have my backpack stowed under the seat in front of me. I could theoretically put it on while still seated. But I'm sure I'll be fractions faster if I'm not wearing it.
- js2 8y agoBecause you don’t act rationally in a disaster: In moments of total disaster — plane crashes or terrorist attacks — something happens in our brains that affects the way we think. We behave differently, often irrationally. Consider the World Trade Center workers who, on Sept. 11, dithered at their desks, calling relatives, turning off computers and pondering which mementos to rescue from their desks even as the doomed jets burned above their heads. In The Unthinkable, Ripley cites a National Institute of Standards and Technology study that showed that those who made it out of the WTC waited an average of six minutes after the plane hit their building before heading for the exit and walking slowly — not running — down the stairs. Ripley searches for patterns in human behavior by interviewing hundreds of people who lived through catastrophes. Quick-witted survivors are surprisingly anomalous. One fellow who made it through a horrific aircraft disaster in 1977 happened to be sitting on the runway reading an in-flight safety instruction card when another plane crashed into his. He grabbed his wife, leapt through a hole in the fuselage, and turned to see his fellow passengers remaining docilely in their seats, immobile. Most of them died within minutes as fire swept through the wreckage. The author concludes that all of us undergo a three-stage process when we find ourselves in mortal peril: denial, deliberation and the "decisive moment," during which the survivor buckles down and acts. The trick, she says, may be to understand our instincts, which, in a crisis, may betray us. Some people run toward infernos, not away, and even in the face of obvious impending disaster, some people just won't move. https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=93033947 https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=930339...
- simplicio 8y agoI'm pretty forgetful, and so over the years I've trained myself to automatically keep a list of stuff I have on me, and do a quick check whenever I move from place to place to make sure I'm not leaving anything behind. Over the years, this has become an almost subconcious process. So I suspect in a similar disaster I might be one of those people grabbing their luggage, just because in a panic I can see myself mindlessly "defaulting" to my usual routine as I get up to try and escape.
- chrismcb 8y agoWhy? I can think of two reasons. Habit. This is pretty powerful. I've deplaned a normal plane at least a hundred times. I've deplaned from a burning plane zero times. Second is, especially in the digital age, my laptop, phone, go pro, all have digital data that is irreplaceable that I may not have backed up yet.
- baconhigh 8y agoi'm first aid / pre-hospital rescue trained and i carry a small first aid kit in my bag at all times. I'm going to be more useful if I take my bag, and I can have it out from under the seat in front of me and around my body in seconds. So yeah, I'm taking my bag.