11 ms·
What if we hired for skills, not degrees?
- erlangNewb 8y agoThat would be viewed as undermining the trillion dollar higher education business. We need universal higher education. What if the next Einstein couldn't afford college?
- imagetic 8y agoI'm be employed and in high demand?
- jseliger 8y agoThat would be good. https://jakeseliger.com/2018/03/12/the-case-against-education-bryan-caplan/ https://jakeseliger.com/2018/03/12/the-case-against-educatio...
- toomuchtodo 8y agoHire for curiosity, grit, and empathy. Everything else can be taught.
- Skunkleton 8y agoWhat a ridiculous over simplification. Those are great qualities, but they also describe most dogs.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoTrades are taught in apprenticeships, IT and SWE can be taught on the job and in boot camps. Barge captains are taught out of high school on the job, same with construction, retail, hospitality. What cant be? Doctors, lawyers, and a few other deep knowledge niches. Some jobs require lots of formal education, most jobs do not. I’d never recommend an MBA to someone now that YC’s Startup School is available online. A gross simplification doesn’t mean the thesis is wrong.
- Skunkleton 8y agoNo, it is wrong or at least unsubstantiated. Why are the qualities listed the most important skills? When was the last time a tech interview focused on "grit", but totally ignored analytical thinking? If its ok to assume an employer will teach you algorithms, why not assume they will teach you to be more empathetic as well?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThe qualities I listed are based on 20 years of hiring and work experience in the tech industry. I encourage competitors to continue to demand algorithm competency and other domain specific knowledge easily referenced. Send the smart, hard working, decent people who need to be taught my way so I may level them up.
- suff 8y agoThe whiteboard is the great equalizer.
- nradov 8y agoAbility to write toy code on a whiteboard has almost zero correlation with actual competence in real software development. It's a lazy, cargo cult interviewing technique.
- Skunkleton 8y ago
- alanfranz 8y agoI think one of the problems of the modern "gig economy" or the general "job hopping" approach to the job market, is that teaching and coaching doesn't work. Why should an employer risk with the education of a worker that may then leave for another company? Such approach worked in the past, when you entered a company when you were 19 and left when you retired (unless the company blew up, of course). Then, you could expect to get 100% training on the job, by your company. Now, you need most skills before entering. And you should expect minimal training.
- winrid 8y agoHeh, I joined as a S/E at my current company when there were only a few engineers at age 19 and am still there six years later.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoYou might be underpaid! Should interview a bit to see what your market value is.
- alanfranz 8y agoThis can happen. But there's no guarantee for the company, that's the "problem". Maybe we should have a "training pipeline" where, then, you must stay in the company at least X years or you need to "pay back" what you received (something similar happens in the military, I think)
- SantalBlush 8y agoThis appears to play a large role in the issue of job training nowadays, and it's almost certainly related to college degrees as a screening tool. There is also a CYA component here. If a hiring manager takes a risk on an applicant with no degree and it doesn't work out, the hiring manager will take the blame for choosing an "underqualified" applicant.
- paulie_a 8y ago> Why should an employer risk with the education of a worker that may then leave for another company? The result is the employer retains that employee.
- Godel_unicode 8y agoThose can all be taught as well.
- alanfranz 8y agoYes, sure. But shouldn't degrees teach (or improve) skills as well? So, shouldn't they be useful, at least for tech/stem/engineering jobs? I agree that strictly requiring a Bachelor even for candidates with years of experience is pointless. But would you hire a zero experience programmer without a Bachelor? Sure, for a lot of administration/sales/marketing positions a degree may be an excessive requriment. But isn't the real problem that a) sometimes universities don't teach enough actual skills and b) they are too expensive?
- maxerickson 8y agoWhy not hire someone you think is smart but inexperienced into a low level programming job? There's lots of chores that don't exactly take a lot of deep knowledge. (Of course the answer is that companies have discarded the idea of having a training pipeline)
- alanfranz 8y ago> There's lots of chores that don't exactly take a lot of deep knowledge. I think you're doing it wrong. I don't work this way. If it's a low level job, I'll find a way to automate it. I want all my coworkers to grow to a good level. At my company, we do train newcomers and young people, and we then hope they stay. But it's an investment that doesn't pay off every time. Other companies just hire experienced developers, by paying more than us... but they don't have a training pipeline. And we can't pay more (we're a small company) because we already spend a lot in training... sob.
- mattkrause 8y agoThe frustrating thing is that how comically adverse some places are to training. One place recently passed on me for an R&D position because I had experience with Torque rather than Slurm. I have a PhD and a bunch of research experience—-it would take maybe an afternoon to figure out how to submit jobs on their system...
- alanfranz 8y agoI hope it was an HR screening, not a technical interview.
- rscho 8y agoWhat if higher education did its job and actually delivered skilled people instead of offering "the best campus experience"? Edit: to make myself clear, I absolutely think universities should focus more on thinking than doing. That is not a valid excuse for focusing on campus experience and the like.
- maxerickson 8y agoAcademia has never seen itself that way. It's pretty stupid that a 4 year degree is turning into a checkmark credential. It's a lot of time and effort to invest into something you aren't particularly interested in but need to get some job where the time and effort put towards the degree don't mean a lot.
- bhl 8y agoWhat if we stopped relying on higher education with its high tuition fees to produce skilled workers, and instead focus on community colleges and K-12 education?
- rscho 8y agoI also agree with that. We could also ask parents to actually educate children, but it seems that's too much to ask.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoWhat if Universities were as low cost as community colleges, as they are in most of the economically developed world? High tuition colleges only exist prey on low-talent people trying to buy fake credentials. Anybody talented enough to learn from a college what they can't learn at a lower priced college, can get a scholarship to that college.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- neilv 8y agoThere was a long period in software during which it was ordinary to hire people without degrees, including through at least the start of the dotcom boom. For most software as practiced today, I still don't understand requiring a degree, if one looks at what the practice is actually doing -- you don't need a degree for most of what is currently being done. Separately, it also seemed not-unusual to hire software people for general ability and experience, on the assumption that they could quickly pick up whatever language/tools were needed. This seems to be less common now, outside of new-grad recruiting.
- craig1f 8y agoThis tends to work better with smaller companies. In my experience, in a small company, the CEO is still involved in the hiring process. If he's highly technical, he can conduct an interview, identify talent, and if it doesn't work out, it's his problem. As a company grows, the CEO has delegate to people below him. Whether he's technical or not, hiring managers get involved. If a hiring manager hires someone good, degree or not, everything is fine. They don't get bonuses for hiring people without degrees who work out. However, if an employee has to be fired, there will be a meeting to discuss what red flags there might have been that could have signaled that this person was a mistake to hire. If the hiring manager believes that they'll get in trouble for ignoring the lack of a degree, they're not going hire people without a degree. They might overlook talent, but at least they won't get blamed for messing up and hiring someone unqualified.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoThat's a lot of FUD I've never seen actually happen.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- agent00f 8y agoThis comment gets to the crux of this matter, where everyone recognizes industry coding is for the most part not sophisticated enough to warrant a university degree. The majority of jobs are technician 2 year trade school level, but just happen to be well paid for to scarcity. The same folks wouldn't claim the same for doctors or scientists, etc.
- didibus 8y agoThis seems to be how hiring works in my experience. And today, there's many more roles one can apply too, and different level of schooling one can get. For example, you have System Engineer roles, or Web Dev, or QA Engineer, etc. You've got a lot of bootcamp education options to teach these as well. And if you look at the hiring process, it's all skill based, how good is your knowledge of data structures, algorithms, system design, frameworks, and programming languages. Experience, resume and portfolio is almost completely overlooked, at least beyond the initial HR screen.
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 8y agoEconomics would suggest that it's purely signally: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_(economics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_(economics) The idea that people are hired based on skills is obviously laudable, but _how_ does one verify those skills without extensively testing them? Whereas deep into your carrier, your professional experience can act as a stronger affirmation of your skill, for that first job degrees seem to be the simplest means of signalling your quality. Its obviously going to exclude would-be great employees, but I guess on a cost-benefit level its understandable given that hiring can be a very intensive process for the employer.
- Kaveren 8y agoSee "The Case Against Education" by Bryan Caplan for an argument in favor of the signaling viewpoint.
- agent00f 8y agoThe fact that so many here place so little value in their education (I would guess esp the liberal arts portions) reflects more on them than the edu system.
- ignoramous 8y ago> The idea that people are hired based on skills is obviously laudable, but _how_ does one verify those skills without extensively testing them? One answer to this is to work for your own self, solve problems that you have, go talk to people who have problems and make them what they want [0]. In an essence, become an indie-developer, a freelancer, or start a business, create/contribute to an open source project. This works very well for technology industry because, more often than not, the barrier to entry to make things is not that high at all. The advantages are obvious: 1. If your execution gains traction, you make money or get acqui-hired. 2. Most companies will value your ability to build, even if you fail. 3. Being involved in the right communities might even help you find co-founders, or join other founders on their journey, or be found by prospective employers. [0] http://www.paulgraham.com/hiring.html http://www.paulgraham.com/hiring.html
- paulie_a 8y agoI've reviewed my share of resumes and the education section is the least important part. If it is a new fresh graduate sure, it is a bigger consideration. But far more important is their experience, what have they done since graduation. Hell if someone has 5-10 years experience that section is getting skipped entirely.
- wallflower 8y agoSince this topic comes up every few months, there is one major reason why college degrees are often prerequisites for job applications. Pasting the entirety of patio11’s old comment below. > _Are companies really legally disallowed from using IQ tests in the USA?_ Griggs v. Duke Power Company, 1971. US Supreme Court found that a particular use of IQ tests in hiring practices caused a disproportionate impact on African American employees. "Disproportionate impact" can make a facially neutral policy illegal under various US civil rights laws. This is not a blanket ban on IQ testing in employment, but corporations being risk-averse, most of them don't really do it much any more. (This is a very happy outcome for universities, since it gives them a virtual monopoly on discriminating on the basis of intelligence. Since that is really useful to do, all a university has to do is maintain its reputation as being a mostly reliable discriminator, and the actual contents of what it teaches are virtually irrelevant.) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2414062#2414152 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2414062#2414152
- karmakaze 8y agoThe basic premise doesn't make sense. If the candidate has real-world experience, go with that. If they're recent grads assume they know very little and will need on the job exposure to learn. So the most useful criteria is an ability to learn. If there's a better indicator for that than a degree then by all means use it. Skills is only a useful measure if you plan to utilize rather than cultivate them.
- analognoise 8y agoLow priced code jockies with "boot camp" or "self taught" level knowledge are working with industry to try to lower wages, and sure, there are plenty of menial coding tasks out there. Let them have em. A 14-week training program is the "do you want fries with that" equivalent of coding, and will also get pushed down in wage. So once coding like that is at minimum wage, that's... Success, I guess? But good luck having that stay an easy path to the middle class. "Anyone with no formal training and 14 weeks of time can make it to the middle class!" - boy is somebody over extrapolating how fast the labor market is going to correct for this. "Well paid" and "quickly trained" don't exist together for a reason (unless there is another component, like "very dangerous" added to the mix).
- _cs2017_ 8y agoI think some parts of the job market ignore degrees. I know many people who got very solid SWE jobs through the popular recruitment platforms. Those platforms essentially allow people to get an on-site with big tech and startups without ever sharing one's resume: they rely solely on the results of technical interviews to screen for promising candidates. The employer spends ~$5000 to bring the candidate on-site (fees to the recruitment platform, plus the flight/hotels, plus the full day of engineers' time spent on the interviews). So I highly doubt the employer auto-rejects candidates without a degree regardless of their on-site performance. If they wanted to do that, they would have simply asked the recruitment platform to screen people for degree in advance, to avoid wasting $5k on a hopeless candidate. Of course, I'm describing only a specific slice (Silicon Valley, maybe NYC) of the specific industry (software engineering). I guess such disregard of degrees hasn't spread to other parts of the job market because most companies, in most industries, believe that the degree provides useful information above and beyond what can be learned in an interview. Are they wrong in that belief? Or do degrees, despite being such a horrible proxy for skill, still provide a valuable incremental statistical signal about the candidate's likely fit?
- chriselles 8y agoI believe the university system aspires to produce thinkers, but doesn’t. Because it has become utterly polluted by non default government backed loans. If the government removed it’s college loan guarantee, what would happen? Schools would have to transition instantly from offering unnecessary student experience and switch to essential student value. In the automotive industry there are financial disclosure and lemon laws. Car dealers have to disclose their finance profit as well as right if return if vehicle is unsuitable. Shouldn’t the same or similar exist in education? At the very least, universities should have to provide externally audited reporting on graduate employment %/$. I’ve met too many young people with too much student debt. Some will never get out from under it, effectively indentured servitude. So many university degree programs have negative ROI, partly due to the unnecessary experiences to attract student borrowers. Trade school have such a stigma amongst those who aspire to have their children move up the human food chain, but really shouldn’t when you run the math. This is the space that Lambda School and others are disrupting. It’s a BIG space. I suspect when it’s all over there will be hundreds of thousands of “white collar jobs” lost that exist only due to the government backed student loan competition over unnecessary and non value added experience. Basically a repeat of the “manufacturing jobs” lost in the post dot com housing bubble. Leaner and meaner will eventually have to come to the university system, removing a lot of expensive experience and hopefully some of the highly corrosive politics.
- purplezooey 8y agoIf this worked, why wouldn't it have happened already. The answer is college means something.