5 ms·
I just wish the automobile LED retrofit market was more advanced. Most newer non-LED cars will report bulb faults because LED resistance is too low. The workar
by Scoundreller 8y ago
I just wish the automobile LED retrofit market was more advanced.
Most newer non-LED cars will report bulb faults because LED resistance is too low. The workaround of a resistor seems to defeat the purpose. Reprogramming ECUs is a pain.
You’d think someone would sell a competitive kit for common cars that do it all, but they seem non-existent.
Reducing electrical loads by a few hundred watts should pay for itself over a few years if you drive enough.
- coolspot 8y agoI find LED stop lights very annoying because they flicker.
- Robotbeat 8y agoThat’s also something that could be fixed with a better implementation. (Higher PWM frequency and/or a capacitor to smooth out the PWM signal.)
- copperx 8y agoWhy is PWM necessary at all? Are the power savings of PWM worth the assault on the senses?
- alacombe 8y agoit isn't, it's just easier to generate/control from whatever dumb microcontroller than a current source.
- solarkraft 8y agoIt's cheaper and easier to implement than "real" voltage regulation.
- ksec 8y agoExcept it wont be fixed because many don't see it as flickers, most don't find it annoying, and the people making the purchasing decision only cares about cost and not quality.
- Scoundreller 8y agoIt's a big problem for the movie industry ;)
- swiley 8y ago>The workaround of a resistor seems to defeat the purpose. P=VI. I=V/R. V=12 => P=24/R. I don't quite understand how a resistor defeats the purpose of LEDs, they're more efficient because you get more light per watt not because resistance is low.
- tyingq 8y agoLikely talking about load resistors that are installed in parallel with the LEDs, converting energy to heat solely for the purpose of making the "incandescent bulb is bad" sensor happy.
- ridgeguy 8y agoIf as GP said the bulb fault is sensed as resistance is too low, putting a resistor in parallel with the LED will reduce the resistance even further. I think it's the I^2R loss in a (series) resistor that makes using a resistor problematic from the POV of energy savings.
- tyingq 8y agoThe sensor is looking at current draw. If it's too low, it assumes a burned out incandescent. Basically, the LEDs are too efficient and look like a burned bulb. The resistor in parallel draws enough current to make it happy.
- solarkraft 8y agoThen resistance is not too low, but too high.
- taneq 8y agoThe reason you need the resistor is that the LEDs pull too little current, not that the voltage drop across them is too low.
- 01100011 8y agoI wish we could regulate the CRI and color temp of LEDs sold for headlights. I've had a few dangerous situations at night because of some idiot with poorly aimed, blue-white LEDs. I thought it was well known that lower color temps reflect less off moisture and perform better as headlights? I worry we may be causing eye issues by blasting people with intense blue light when their eyes are adjusted for darkness.
- tsjq 8y agoah man! so much of this problem in my country too. these clowns fit the blue-white headlight bulbs purely for style / fashion !
- dzhiurgis 8y agoNot related with car headlights, but related to temperature: 3 days ago I learned prefer blue light in some of the rooms in house. Apparently yellow is sheepish, blue is good for reading. My theory was: southerners prefer blue, people with little sun exposure - yellow. Have you noticed anything similar before?
- 01100011 8y agoI dunno... I think I used to prefer 2700k at home and now I'm settling on 3300k, although sometimes even that seems frustratingly yellow now. I'm getting older and presbyopia is really setting in now. I'm from CA(formerly southern, now the bay area).
- waste_monk 8y agoI go with Warm lights for relaxing spaces e.g. bedroom, bathroom, living room, and Cool lights for workspaces e.g. the shed, kitchen, laundry... It feels "right" to me having a lighting distinction between the types of spaces.