5 ms·
What would you call it then? Otherwise it's just entitlement to something because you can't buy it - "oh look, this movie is not available to purchase in my cou
by gambiting 8y ago
What would you call it then? Otherwise it's just entitlement to something because you can't buy it - "oh look, this movie is not available to purchase in my country, I guess I'm getting it for free!". It's not anyone's god-given right to be able to get every media ever released - if it's not available in your market then either import it, or....don't get it?
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoYou’re over thinking it. No loss has occur. We’re willing to pay.
- chii 8y ago> It's not anyone's god-given right to be able to get every media ever released participating in culture is required by many, esp. the young. If they can't easily get it via a legitimate means, piracy is the default. Not watching it is not an option.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoI strongly support this perspective. If you create a culturally relevant work then prohibit people from legally participating, you probably deserve disparagement and the forfeiture of your rights.
- nikbackm 8y agoBut it can hardly be culturally relevant in a country where it's not available, or? Unless everyone pirates it.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoThis is one of those comments that flips between supporting my previous comment or arguing against it every time I blink and reread it.
- flukus 8y agoCulture isn't always local to your geographic location, there's people around the world discussing tech culture right here, there's people living abroad but still connected too and part of the local culture. One of the common analogies for China's lack of respect for intellectual property is the US doing the same (copying books) when it was young and poor yet still culturally English.
- chii 8y agoin an increasingly globalized world, literary media has become culturally relevant anywhere in the world. In the past, when localized media is the only option, locking out regions from purchases wouldn't have been an issue (since nobody would've known about it). But now the internet exists, and information being global means that literary media must also be global. To be denied an opportunity to participate in its consumption is to deny the right to participate in cultural exchange and communication. I think that's wrong, and therefore, this justifies piracy for those individuals who would otherwise be denied due to cost/availablity reasons.
- gambiting 8y agoThis is such an English-speaking-centric view it's incredible. There are great works of art - movies, books, music, games that exist outside of the anglosphere, they never appear outside of their respective countries and are never translated, yet I don't see people complaining that the lack of their translations is " is to deny the right to participate in cultural exchange and communication". You just....can't consume them. It's not the end of the world, no one is being done some great injustice, that creative work is just not available to you right now. How is that different? Perhaps only in that it's much better? If I want to watch a Russian TV show and there is no translation, either I have to wait for the translation or....learn Russian. If I can't legally buy Game of Thrones in my country I can always pay for a copy in a country where it is available and have it sent to me. It's not as convenient, but it is possible. To say that there is some harm being done by not making it available and the only solution is piracy sounds like self justification.
- chii 8y ago> [art] outside of the anglosphere... never appear outside of their respective countries and are never translated, yet I don't see people complaining i m sure the complaints exist. I m also sure that english works is more popular than non-english works (due to english simply being the international language). My view isn't anglo-centric at all - you can make the same argument about anime. I watch anime on crunchyroll, but i used to use torrents. The illegal method is the only option as a high-schooler who cannot afford the prices required to get a DVD set. I m glad that crunchyroll has worked to a legal means for this media. The argument here is that streaming companies (esp. disney) is attempting to restrict their works, which has significant cultural impact, by making _their_ streaming service the only way to consume this work. This mechanism makes the price of the media higher, and people would need to pay multiple services to get the full coverage of all media they need to consume.
- eric-hu 8y agoI agree with you, but I can't help but think of the case of the Wu Tang album they sold to Martin Shkreli. Part of the terms of sale was that it couldn't be copied. I do believe a company shouldn't be able to hold a piece of culture hostage. I also believe in a creator's right to decide how their work is consumed. I'm not sure how to reconcile these two things.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoHave you ever come across Matthew Barney's The Cremaster Cycle. As far as I'm aware it was never published for mass consumption. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cremaster_Cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cremaster_Cycle
- 0815test 8y ago> It's not anyone's god-given right to be able to get every media ever released People used to say exactly that about music, and then Spotify came around - along with multiple DRM-free download stores. Now these things are very much seen as "God-given rights" by many. Yes, video is especially complicated because of how costly it is to create in the first place - this is why the closest thing to a plausible solution is going to come in the form of disruption from below. Some sort of "Netflix 2.0", focusing on a somewhat more heavily-curated experience than YT does today, and skimping on challenging technical details - maybe not even providing full-HD content of any sort! Vimeo could easily enter that space.
- XorNot 8y agoThere's a certain irony that Spotify is by all accounts terrible for actually supporting artists though.
- flukus 8y ago> It's not anyone's god-given right to be able to get every media ever released It's also not media producers god given right to gouge customers and have the government enforce a monopoly on their products, or to even exist. Ideally we can reach a compromise that suits everyone, but at the moment it's media companies that are over reaching, they'll even happily gimp their own products so that pirated versions are better.
- DanBC 8y ago> if it's not available in your market then either import it, You're saying this is the moral and legal option, but the copyright holders lobbied hard to make this illegal. That's why there are no stores in my country offering imported DVDs for sale. It's illegal to import these if you're a business. I have to go to a foreign company and import the disc strictly for personal use. So, I get a DVD / BluRay from a different region. How do I play this? The shop where I bought the player is forbidden, by law, from telling me how to convert my player into a multi-region player. People aren't saying "I want this for free". They're saying "allow me to pay for it". They're also saying "the easier it is to pay for something the more people will pay for it".
- iainmerrick 8y agoif it's not available in your market then either import it, or....don't get it? Given that importing is often intentionally blocked by region-locking, it’s a straight choice between “don’t get it” and piracy.
- treerock 8y ago> What would you call it then? 'Copyright infringement'? 'Piracy' is a bit of a loaded term. http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/words-to-avoid.html.en#Piracy http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/words-to-avoid.html.en#Piracy
- tomohawk 8y agoThe whole point of copyright (originally) was to encourage content holders to make the content available to the public by providing protection if they did so. If the content holder is not making their content available in a reasonable way, they should have no such protections.
- mywittyname 8y agoI find it difficult to accept a copyright claim on commercial content never sold in a country. In my views, if you cared about getting paid for the content, then you would have sold it legally in that country. IMHO, refusing to distribute content is essentially forfeiting any commercial claims to its distribution.
- XorNot 8y agoGame of Thrones is notable due to the use of VPN-blocking, and credit card blocking. There are people who pay for HBOgo, do so through some forwarder which makes their credit card appear to come from a US bank, and then have to find a VPN service to actually watch it with. Multiple steps in this transaction - completely unncessarily due to the nature of the underlying technologies - cost the consumer money, to circumvent protections implemented by HBO (or more likely whatever BS contract their parent company signed), for the express purpose of preventing the consumer paying HBO to lawfully watch their content.
- goostavos 8y agoSo, something is sold exclusively in Target, but isn't sold in, say, Best Buy. You only have a best buy near you, therefore you're... justified in stating they have no commercial claims to the content they own and chose to distribute through Target? I'm not sure I follow your argument.
- fifnir 8y agoOf course you don't understand, cause you completely slaughtered his argument.
- SkyBelow 8y ago>It's not anyone's god-given right to be able to get every media ever released Or maybe it is? Different people have different views on what counts as rights and I've yet to hear of a case of God clarifying which group of people is right. Some people believe it is their God given right to keep others from modifying their own equipment in certain patterns by sharing information. Others disagree. Consider libraries. If I built a file sharing system that allowed only one person to watch the movie at a time, but allowed as many people as wanted to watch it if they were willing to wait their turn, how is this any different than what a library does? Yet that would also be considered a form of piracy. Is running a library not a God given right.
- m_t 8y agoLibraries pay for the content they provide. That's the only thing you forgot to plan for in your hypothetical system.
- SkyBelow 8y agoI did plan for it, I just didn't call out that the original copy of the movie was purchased because I didn't think that would be the defining factor on if my plan was acceptable or not. So as long as I pay for the original copy and only allow one person to view it at a time, my plan is acceptable?
- Kaiyou 8y ago“One has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws.” ― Martin Luther King Jr. Following the letter of the law isn't always the right thing to do.
- nradov 8y agoIt's a real stretch to equate civil disobedience over equal rights with access to mere entertainment content. No one really needs to watch Game of Thrones or whatever.
- Kaiyou 8y agoJustice isn't something that requires a certain threshold of magnitude. Maybe it's mere entertainment. Doesn't justify injustice.
- antepodius 8y agoI think people, in general, don't care too much about whether something is legal or not when it comes to deciding whether it's actually moral or not. Things are moral or immoral whether they're legal or not. If some corporation isn't selling the rights to view a file in your country, and it's a pain to get them the 'legal way', I think a lot of people would look at the situation and think- "well, nobody's going to prosecute me for this. Even if I think piracy is immoral in general, this entity has made it a pain for me to get their product without pirating- they obviously aren't counting on my money. They've waived their moral right to complain about me not paying to look at their tv show- and in the lack of enforcement of the law, that moral right is all that matters to me. I'll just pirate it. If they don't want my money, they won't get it."