8 ms·
I feel like it might be a cause of being a bit older but my (single) mother always said that women and men were equal in worth not aptitude. Her exact words we
by dijit 8y ago
I feel like it might be a cause of being a bit older but my (single) mother always said that women and men were equal in worth not aptitude.
Her exact words were “men and women are equal but different, in many ways they’re complimentary” she then explained that some men look down on women because they didn’t value how women think about things. She also said the same is true of some women viewing men.
Later she would say that men and women are equally shitty to each other (when I was being abused at school by girls who knew I could not physically retaliate).
I currently hold these views and neither feminism nor men’s-rights-activists seem to ascribe to those values, at best they pay lip service to the notion that we’re (on average, and grossly generalising) complimentary.
I remember a small blurb about “judging a fish by its ability to climb a tree” in reference to our education system-
Maybe it’s a old way of thinking. Maybe my mum wasn’t right at all, but I don’t understand why we can’t celebrate our differences instead of expecting women to fit in to men sized roles. Or alternatively making a “middle-ground” box which has to fit both sexes.
If anyone wants to alter my way of thinking; I’m completely open to it- I am perfectly willing to accept that I’m old fashioned or incorrect here.
- jstanley 8y agoI don't really have a horse in this race, but the reason women might want to fit in to man-sized roles is because all the high-paying roles are man-sized.
- mpfundstein 8y agoAnd because money (and power) is all that counts nowadays right? There was a time where it was not a shame if a woman chose to stay at home. Nowadays, people toll their eyes if my wife tells them about her (very own) choice..
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoI think this post was made in bad faith to the argument of the poster. Money and therefore power matter a lot in a society in which you must purchase almost all of your basic goods with it. housing, food, water, etc. Up to a certain point money does track with quality of life, and the point in which it ceases to be the case is well above median wealth. If we were to evaluate that it is normal for women to have less paying jobs because women’s work is worth less pay, then the knock off effect is that women aren’t worth a quality of life equal to men on average. Also, I am under the impression that rolling ones eyes at a choice to stay at home is a continued devaluation of women’s work. The upkeep of a living location and the caring of any little humans is a significant labor, such that upon outsourcing is often equivalent to a median yearly salary of a single person. However because there isn’t a common framework to evaluate worth beyond money in the society I live in, unpaid labor isn’t valued.
- wccrawford 8y agoWhile I fully agree that people should accept that some people are driven by things other than money, and even beyond that, it should be perfectly socially acceptable to be driven by other goals instead... People who are driven by money, no matter gender, skin color, etc shouldn't be held back from it because of preconceptions about their ability. Only their actual ability should matter.
- UncleMeat 8y agoYet the us does not have mandatory maternity leave. Money is choices. That people must sacrifice it in order to do things like raise children is evidence that our society does not value homemaking.
- AvocadoPanic 8y agoOr that our society values self-sufficiency and two-parrent households where one parent cares for the children in the home.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoI'm not sure this follows. Is the idea that lack of maternity leave will cause two-parent households? What is the mechanism?
- dijit 8y agoI don't really have a solid response to that argument other than that I think we as a society need to stop emphasising traits that are predominantly held by men and start appreciating the traits that are predominantly held by women, those traits are incredibly valuable. To give a concrete example: Dame Caroline Haslett who was the President of the Women's Engineering Society in Britain created objectively the safest electrical outlet and plugging mechanism ever conceived (as long as you don't step on one). There was no such mandate for it to be so safe, you could argue that a man could have done exactly the same but I'd rather consider that she was being extremely empathetic as to how the device would be used and that safety in this area would quite literally save the lives of men, women and children. A world without her contribution would be a lesser one, but I would argue that it was made with her femininity, not with how much she filled a man-shaped role.
- whatshisface 8y ago>but I'd rather consider that she was being extremely empathetic Believing science is one thing, but that sounds like exactly the sort of "gendered narrative building" that feminists are trying to fight against. When they say stuff like "gender roles are fictional," a large part of it is due to people inventing stories in their heads about gender roles that aren't true. I think that it's fair to not try to add anything beyond what's demonstrably there.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AlexB138 8y ago> I think that it's fair to not try to add anything beyond what's demonstrably there. Why? If peoples' experiences and psychology (in my layman's understanding of agreeableness) show that women tend to be more empathetic than men, it seems perfectly reasonable for them to suggest that that may have benefited an inventor in a fantastic discovery they made. People have no obligation to buy into others' narratives. Groups can claim whatever they want is fictional, it doesn't mean everyone else has to censor their speech accordingly. I thought the person you were responding to was making a very thoughtful point, and one that was very respectful of women and the valuable insight some of them have that is often overlooked.
- threeseed 8y agoDid you choose your role just because it is high-paying ? Or were there are other factors e.g. stimulating, flexible, empowering, creative etc. Because pretty sure women are selecting roles for a range of different factors as well. You know because all women aren't the same. Just like all men aren't the same.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoDefinitely the money. I can think of several career paths that likely would likely have made me happier but I didn't pursue them because I was able to do computer programming and why throw that potential money away.
- dijit 8y agoThat's actually quite sad. But you said it yourself: "several career paths would likely have made me happier". What's the point in living if not to be happy? Money is just a means to avoid unhappiness. It's been proven time and time again that after a decent income money does not increase happiness.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI've yet to find the point where more money doesn't make me happier. Money buys a lot of things that make you happy. Money is also more much more capable of making one's family happy than a job I like more than my current one is. It's not like I hate my job. I just like it less than the blue collar stuff I did before I got my degree. I don't have a trust fund. I have to make my own living and I optimized for doing that. Waxing poetic about "occupational fulfillment" is something the upper classes do after they've been upper class long enough to forget how well they have it. I don't care what other people think. Money is making me happy. My property is covered in classic cars in various states of disrepair, my fridge always has beer in it. My life is quite comfortable thanks to money. The ease with which money can be converted into things that bring me joy is unparalleled. Not taking all that for granted probably helps a lot.
- tomohawk 8y agoThe worst jobs out there are male dominated, and we don't see some big push to get more women working in them. https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2019/04/20/the-worst-jobs-in-america/39364439/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2019/04/20/the-worst-jo...
- burkaman 8y agoDid you actually look at this list? 1. Taxi Driver: Uber and Lyft have significantly increased the number of women, and there are lots of efforts to get more women involved. https://www.gosafr.com/ https://www.gosafr.com/ is one example. 2. Logger: This is probably the kind of job you were thinking of. Logging is completely male dominated, but there are some small efforts at change: https://www.pressherald.com/2019/03/17/the-axe-women-loggers-of-maine-emphasize-maines-forestry-heritage/ https://www.pressherald.com/2019/03/17/the-axe-women-loggers... and https://www.tigercat.com/between-the-branches/logger-girl/ https://www.tigercat.com/between-the-branches/logger-girl/ 3. Newspaper reporter: Majority male, but not overwhelmingly. Definitely a big push to equalize the field: http://www.womensmediacenter.com/reports/the-status-of-women-in-u.s.-media-2017 http://www.womensmediacenter.com/reports/the-status-of-women... 4. Retail salesperson: Majority women. 5. Enlisted military personnel: Hard to summarize here, but issues around women in the US military come up quite frequently in Congress and elsewhere, and the history of increasing participation and equality is long. 6. Corrections officer: Women were 37% of adult officers and 51% of juvenile officers in 2007 (http://www.corrections.com/articles/21703-women-as-corrections-professionals http://www.corrections.com/articles/21703-women-as-correctio...). There is a push to increase equality: https://www.correctionsone.com/women-in-corrections/ https://www.correctionsone.com/women-in-corrections/ 7. Disc jockey: Hard to find exact stats, but it's the same story as everywhere else in modern society. Used to be completely male dominated, now women are increasingly entering the industry and fighting against entrenched stereotypes. A random article: https://www.laweekly.com/music/women-djs-are-out-there-clubs-and-festivals-just-need-to-book-them-7091548 https://www.laweekly.com/music/women-djs-are-out-there-clubs... 8. Broadcaster: Feel like I'm starting to repeat myself. It's the same story as everywhere else in the media. Look at the Women's Media Center and other organizations for evidence of a push. 9. Advertising salesperson: Is this the kind of job you thought was on this list? Majority women, apparently: https://datausa.io/profile/soc/112011/#demographics https://datausa.io/profile/soc/112011/#demographics 10. Painter: Seems to be similar to logging. I honestly don't know why. Presumably it's historically male (like everything), and it's not a particularly desirable career for anyone. etc. Industries like logging and painting are outliers. There are some jobs that are so physically demanding that men have a significant innate advantage, but there's no natural reason for any industry to be 95+% male.
- squish78 8y agoWe need more women on the oil rigs
- roenxi 8y agoBut are the high paying roles man-sized or are the men shaping themselves to the high-paying roles? There is evidence that women are judged by appearance and men by financial success. Even a mild effect would be more than enough to skew the outcomes; it would impact the more competitive representatives of each gender.
- MRD85 8y agoIf being an aged care nurse suddenly paid handsomely I would bet that you'd find the field full of men in a mid term. Men make a habit out of taking whatever work makes them the best money.
- strictfp 8y agoThis. I think we have to dismantle roles which have extreme expectations. If you're expected to be available 24/7 and basically abandon your family for your job, it's something which overwhelming selects for men, who have that classic role in society. I think this is the most important question to solve if we want more equal outcome in worklife.
- belorn 8y agoIt not about high-paying roles. The industries that are talked about in gender segregation discussions are those that are high-paying, high social status jobs. A big difference. When I was young the highest paying job direct out of high school was underwater welder. Not many teenage girls are signing up for that program, nor are there much political interest to get 50/50 gender ration for jobs that work in the dark, dangerous, on rusty oil rigs far away from land. In a bit of irony, the same can be said for professions dominated by women. Hired midwifes during the summer vacation months here in Sweden are getting salaries up to 9k a month. Very few people here in Sweden has a monthly pay that high. Demand can skyrocket when you only recruit from half the population, at which point the employer will pay what the market demands.
- threeseed 8y agoIt's not just an old way of thinking. It's frankly a dumb one. There are many women who are physically, emotionally and intellectually stronger than many men. And they are more than capable of doing a "men sized role" just as well as any man. And the situation applies vice versa as well. If you want to celebrate the differences between men and women, whatever that ever means, well then knock yourself out. But generalising the traits of billions of people is frankly insane and guaranteed to insult some decent size proportion of them.
- harimau777 8y agoI don't really know much about the science behind how men and women as populations differ. However, I wonder if it would be possible for society to have a more nuanced approach to these issues: Encourage men and women as individuals to pursue roles that match their aptitudes and personalities even if they do not line up with their sex. Provide wisdom or rules of thumb based on how men and women as populations may differ. However, the problem that I would see with this approach is that humans tend to be lazy in their thinking, so general rules of thumb tend to become absolute rules.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> I feel like it might be a cause of being a bit older but my (single) mother always said that women and men were equal in worth not aptitude. My (also single) dad says that men are smarter and more ambitious than women, that womens' place is at home, taking care of the children and that society is broken because women are trying to do the things that men are naturally better at doing and don't want to do what they're good at. Your mom against my dad. Who wins?
- Veen 8y agoThe one who holds an opinion that’s roughly in line with the modern scientific understanding of gender differences.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoAre you saying that the OP's mom has the opinion she has because she is aware of modern scientific understanding of gender differences? That was not the impression I got from the OP's comment. Not to mention that there seems to be considerable scientific controversy on what this "modern scientific understanding" is -and how else could it be? Science is a debate- I doubt we can settle it by listening to what our moms and dads say.
- dijit 8y agoI believe the difference between our comments is that I have never had to discard her words before; thus I'm sharing them and trying to illicit a response which is either contradicting or confirmational. your comment: > My (also single) dad says that men are smarter and more ambitious than women, that womens' place is at home, taking care of the children and that society is broken because women are trying to do the things that men are naturally better at doing and don't want to do what they're good at. Men are smarter at what exactly? Mathematics? Although the question of whether there is a gender difference in math seems like a simple one, the answer is complicated. Overall there are only small differences in boys’ and girls’ math performance; those differences depend on the age and skill level of the student, what type of math they are attempting and how big of a dissimilarity is needed to say that boys’ and girls’ math performance is truly different. Ambitious? Again, Ambitious at what? travelling the world? starting and sustaining a family? or is it solely on what dollar amount is ascribed to an hour of your day? A womans place is at home is about as sexist an argument I have ever heard. By that logic my "place" is running around the jungle with a spear? please don't argue such bad faith. If I were to try to dig into what your argument actually is then I would assume you dislike my comment because it leans heavily on what my mother said. We're I arguing in bad faith I would probably say that you're rejecting her logic so outrightly because she is a woman. But I'm going to try to argue something else. I'm going to ask what smart and ambitious mean mean to you.
- erentz 8y ago> and neither feminism nor men’s-rights-activists seem to ascribe to those I’m not that old yet but feminism to me growing up was always that men and women should have the same opportunities and treatment, but never that they were the same. Maybe I’m wrong but that’s more of a recent phenomenon which claimed for itself the title of feminism - I doubt the original feminists would agree with it, but I don’t know. (I find it sad because to me it’s turned a serious movement for which very brave women had to fight hard into a joke.)
- WillPostForFood 8y agoThe conundrum for modern feminists is that we are becoming more aware that we are becoming more aware of the power of genetic outcomes. So when equality of treatment and opportunity doesn't get all the way to equality of outcome, then more radical ideas become tempting, and science can get tossed out the window.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Viliam1234 8y agoIf some differences are caused by biological reasons, and some differences are caused by social reasons, then by removing the social reasons for inequality we achieve two things at the same time: 1) men and women become more equal; 2) the remaining reasons for inequality become predominantly biological (because the social ones are reduced, while the biological ones remain). But it is easy to make a completely opposite conclusion, such as: "if some differences are social, then all differences have to be social". And then, when trying harder does not change things anymore, it is only a proof that we need to try even harder.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoThe history has informed our intuitions here. Many things used to be described as biological that we now suspect are social. And those things have been used to prevent people from doing things they wanted to do. My take is: don't describe things as biological unless you are damn well sure that they are. We (as a society) have been wrong too many times before.
- Mirioron 8y ago>I currently hold these views and neither feminism nor men’s-rights-activists seem to ascribe to those values, at best they pay lip service to the notion that we’re (on average, and grossly generalising) complimentary. Interesting. I've never really got the impression that Men's Rights Activists ascribe to any specific notion like that. To me the movement seems to be about shedding light on the injustices of our legal systems where men get screwed over: divorce court, custody of a child, alimony, punishments seemingly not being equal between the sexes. I guess they also have an element of fighting against social injustices such as false claims. I might be wrong though. I might simply be seeing only the things I care about in their movement, since I see it so rarely.
- bluGill 8y agoIf you follow the men's right movement you will notice that they regularly have to spend a small amount of time shutting down those going beyond "divorce court, custody of a child, alimony, punishments seemingly not being equal between the sexes" to those who want to put women "back in their place". Most seem to be the former, but the later does exist too and they want to join the group.
- belorn 8y agoThe feminist movement has their share of misandry, but society tend to ignore that minority of the movement and focus on the social issues that the movement highlight. In the end it doesn't matter if either movement has bad apples. What matter is if we want a society that make abortion illegal or a legal system that base judgement on gender.
- Nav_Panel 8y ago> I feel like it might be a cause of being a bit older but my (single) mother always said that women and men were equal in worth not aptitude. I actually like this line a lot, because it points to several of the problems in modern society. It makes you ask the question: "on what grounds is worth judged?" And then you realize that, without a clear way of thinking about "worth" (which is something organized religions provided), we, at least in the US, fall back on "economic value", which is determined by "aptitude". So we can pretty quickly see the philosophical pit we've fallen into: if "worth" and "aptitude" are intertwined, then the statement admits women are indeed "worth less". I want to agree with that statement. But, there's a problem: how can we come up with a method of judging worth that doesn't rely on some sort of "over-human validator" (e.g. God)? Or alternatively, how can we come up with a broadly acceptable method of judging human worth, without falling into the pitfalls of Abrahamic religious practices?
- davrosthedalek 8y agoI'm not so sure if human being should have the attribute of "worth" (I formulate it like this because "have no worth" has a different meaning). If they do, you can make ugly calculations: It's worth to kill 300 PAX to save 1000s in the skyscraper the plane is going to fly into. It's worth to kill one prisoner in interrogation because he knows where his partner might have the hostage (or two?).
- Nav_Panel 8y agoWorth doesn't have to be absolute nor quantifiable. To use a mathematics analogy, you can have an ordered set without addition and subtraction, and it could even be roughly ordered so you can't tell the difference between two adjacent elements.
- bluGill 8y agoWorth doesn't even have to be one measure. In math you can have two different ordering functions which give different results on the same input.
- 8y ago
- brlewis 8y ago> I don’t understand why we can’t celebrate our differences instead of expecting women to fit in to men sized roles. Who's asking you to "expect" anything? I think if you assess people's abilities individually everybody's happy.
- wtdata 8y ago> I think if you assess people's abilities individually everybody's happy. It doesn't look like it. A lot of people in science are demanding equality of outcomes for groups (when the outcome is positive). They are well done pass asking for equality of opportunities.
- commandlinefan 8y ago> if you assess people's abilities individually Well, James Damore got fired from Google (and, apparently, blackballed out of the employment market entirely) for insinuating that Google was assessing people's abilities individually. While I think you're correct, the problem is that too many people seem to try to evaluate whether or not everybody's abilities are being assessed individually by looking at the end result rather than looking at the individuals involved.
- drb91 8y ago“From each according to their ability, to each according to their needs.” Equity, not equality.
- tbrownaw 8y agoSo where's that from, and how well has it worked out?
- wtdata 8y agoIt worked great in the West at least, the world was never as equitable and meritocratic as it is today and it is continuously progressing for better according to all factual data.
- ionised 8y agoI'm still confused as to why people are holding meritocracy up as something we should aspire to. Meritocracy was originally devised as a negative concept, simply because the idea of what constitutes 'merit' is subjective and complex.
- Frondo 8y agoWhat? Really? I can think of no better thing for humanity as a species to aspire to than this. "Do your best, help out the world, and your needs will be taken care of." As a goal for structuring society, if that isn't in your top 2 of "things to collectively strive for," I don't think it's a very good society. I grew up on the Star Trek vision of utopia, though, and hope that some day humanity still gets there.
- Frondo 8y agoIn addition to downvoting, I would really appreciate hearing from folks about what's a better way to structure society than "from each according to their ability, to each according to their needs"; and specifically, why wouldn't you want to make sure each individual's needs in the society are met?
- didibus 8y agoI think both are relevant and need debating. The idea of being equal in worth is interesting. How do you define it? Is it a kind of humanitarian worth? That all people are deserving of basic rights, decency and respect? Such would be the case even for handicapped or mentally challenged individuals? Or are you saying that their set of aptitudes, while not identical, sum up to an equal worth in utilitarian terms? Say, for example, taking one of the very strong stereotype, that child bearing is so useful to our societies, that it makes women as worthy as even the strongest of men and their aptitude for heavy lifting? Now, the idea of equal aptitude is relevant as well. There's two main reasons for that. The first is that, some aptitudes, like intelligence, such as talents in mathematics, or decision making in general, has historically been thought of as inferior for women. Yet, there's never been evidence of this as far as I know. In fact, now that we admitted women in higher education, they are out outclassing men in most fields when it comes to grades. So this is a very relevant debate, because bias still exist, that a pretty young woman can't be as smart as a young man. The other reason is the wash of the average. Lots of women are physically stronger then lots of men. Similarly, lots of men are emotionally more adept then lots of women. Thus aptitude shouldn't be characterised by gender, but it should be more individualized. This applies in some scenarios, like not giving women applicants a chance at very physical jobs. Even though some women have the necessary aptitudes.