15 ms·
After a $14B Upgrade, New Orleans’ Levees Are Sinking
- apo 8y ago> The agency’s projection that the system will “no longer provide [required] risk reduction as early as 2023” illustrates the rapidly changing conditions being experienced both globally as sea levels rise faster than expected and locally as erosion wipes out protective barrier islands and marshlands in southeastern Louisiana. The article repeatedly refers to sea level rise without noting the contribution of this factor relative to erosion. Equal? Highly tilted toward sea level rise? Does erosion account for most of the problem, and if so how does one separate this factor from seal level increase? Neither the article nor the source document offer much insight: https://www.eenews.net/assets/2019/04/11/document_ew_01.pdf https://www.eenews.net/assets/2019/04/11/document_ew_01.pdf Also from the article: > “I think this work is necessary. We have to protect the population of New Orleans,” Vuxton said. I'm not so sure, especially because the full costs of doing so appear to be so uncertain. How much money will people living in other states be willing to dump into a cause with cost increases as far as the eye can see? It's not like sea level rise is expected to suddenly stop dead in its tracks. Ever-greater engineering efforts are one option. Mass evacuation of the most vulnerable areas is another. There may be options in-between.
- fwip 8y agoI'm not an expert, but intuitively, I'd think that sea level rise would contribute to ground subsidence.
- Gibbon1 8y agoA lot of the current problem in New Orleans is that it's built on deep layers of silt which are slowly compacting. And channelizing the Mississippi has resulted in loss of protective barriers offshore because the silt now goes right out the end of the channel into deep water. Bonus the bedrock itself is slowly tilting sinking towards the gulf. What the place needs is about three meters of compacted fill under the whole city. ALA Galveston TX and Downtown Chicago.
- stevenwoo 8y agoThis says three main factors: 1.)sediment flow changes - we changed flow of Mississippi River to benefit a lot of upstream communities (for flood control/farming/maintaining river boundaries against nature's desire) - continuing to do so robs Louisiana of land mass 2.) subsidence - pumping out water aquifers and extracting oil (without replacing fluids) cause land levels to sink 3.) sea level rise https://www.factcheck.org/2017/03/land-loss-in-louisiana/ https://www.factcheck.org/2017/03/land-loss-in-louisiana/ All three together paint a pretty grim picture of the future of New Orleans.
- tropo 8y agoIt's neither. Erosion and sea level changes are not at all the problem here. The problem is that keeping the lowest point dry causes subsurface water to be removed from the area. Also, that water doesn't get replenished. Things tend to shrink when they dry out, and the land under New Orleans is no exception. It's becoming like a shriveled up raisin or sponge. The more you pump the place dry, the more the place sinks lower.
- nickthemagicman 8y agoIt's not just a few houses built by irresponsible people. Nola has the highest port tonnage in the country. The impact on GDP is estimated in the hundreds of billions. There's also billions and billions of dollars of infrastructure here. Most goods that pass through to the midwest and many through the rest of the country come through here. Without Nola, hundreds of billions of dollars of the economy will go away. Gas prices set a record after Katrina. 14 billion is a bargain to keep this city going.
- kobayashy 8y agoPorque no los dos? Keep the port and relocate the rest of the city. It's not that you need hundreds of thousands people to run port facility. Damn, if you even need 500. The rest of the population are hospitality workers and ambulance chase lawyers.
- selimthegrim 8y agoAsk not whose ambulance is being chased, one day it’ll be thine with that flippant attitude. Not everyone down here is paid by the hour.
- nickthemagicman 8y agoI don't know if you're trolling or just actually ignorant.
- wrycoder 8y agoSea level has been rising at three millimeters a year as long as detailed measurements have been made. There has been no acceleration in that rate. We are, after all, still coming out of an ice age, and the oceans are still expanding due to accumulated heat. Locally apparent changes are primarily due to land subsidence due to sediment deposits or rebound after the ice melted.
- wrycoder 8y agoWell, here is the data: http://sealevel.colorado.edu/content/2018rel1-global-mean-sea-level-time-series-seasonal-signals-removed http://sealevel.colorado.edu/content/2018rel1-global-mean-se...
- martinpw 8y agoThat is only a small part of the data, just 25 years worth of satellite data. There are ground measurements going back almost 150 years. Using all the data shows a clear acceleration: https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/sea-level/ https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/sea-level/ The comment about coming out of an ice age is also not relevant - sea levels have indeed been rising since then, but nowhere near the current rate, so the current increase is mostly unrelated to that. For example: https://www.giss.nasa.gov/research/briefs/gornitz_09/ https://www.giss.nasa.gov/research/briefs/gornitz_09/ Twentieth century sea level trends, however, are substantially higher that those of the last few thousand years.
- wrycoder 8y agoYour first link has the essentially same data as what I referenced - 3.2 mm per year recently. Since 1919, they show a rise of about eight inches. The current rate amounts to 12 inches per century. Your second link is interesting - thanks! It’s not different from what I said. We have come out of an ice age. The interglacial epochs have been historically relatively short.
- martinpw 8y ago
- ausbah 8y agowhat should be done for cities like new orleans as sea levels continue to rise? trying to save them feels like a losing, expensive battle - but "moving a whole city" feels even harder
- redorb 8y agoThere is proper technology for places below sea level. We should learn from the Netherlands - they're masters of reclaiming land from the ocean.
- andrei_says_ 8y agoAnd like Miami, NYC etc. in the coming years.
- acchow 8y agoNYC can probably afford to protect itself without federal funding
- justin66 8y agoAnd they really should, but on the other hand, as a population they pay enough in taxes to the federal government that it's not ridiculous for them to ask for some federal assistance with something like that. (it's also not ridiculous for a major cultural landmark like New Orleans, but that's a more complicated argument)
- 8y ago
- jingalings 8y agoAs a non-American, can someone explain to me why the army was responsible for this work? When does the normal tender/contractor process not occur? Is it a scale or political decision?
- cydonian_monk 8y agoThe US Army Corps of Engineers is generally and historically responsible for waterway dredging and flood control. It's one of their core (peace-time) responsibilities. These are typically large projects that benefit the public good yet are rather complex and lack sufficient financial incentives for privatization. The wikipedia article [1] gives a general idea of how and when this came to be. (Canals.) 1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Corps_of_Engineers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Corps_of_...
- smelendez 8y agoIt is a bit odd, but the Army Corps of Engineers has historically always been responsible for a lot of maintenance of the country's rivers and waterways, dams, parts of the Great Lakes, etc. including flood control.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shizzzzel 8y agoAs an American I know. These levees were built KNOWING that they sink at a mathematical formulate rate. This is FAKE NEWS. The 14 billion dollar cost is a cost rate over a decade or more, lets say 1 billion at 14 years long. This billion a year is the cost to keep adding on to the existing well made and constructed infrastructure.
- arcticbull 8y agoPlease don’t co-opt the phrase “fake news” even if you don’t believe what’s being said is an accurate portrayal — it disparages the news media by implicitly legitimizing self-serving uses of the term. Every time this phrase is used it hurts the fourth estate. The media gets things wrong sometimes, and we should hold them accountable but this isn’t how.
- dfee 8y ago> Emily Vuxton, policy director of the Coalition to Restore Coastal Louisiana, an environmental group ... said repair costs could be “hundreds of millions” of dollars, with 75% paid by federal taxpayers. “I think this work is necessary. We have to protect the population of New Orleans,” Vuxton said. Summed up as: “I think our unsustainable way of life should be subsidized by the rest of the country at a 3:1 rate”. I enjoy NOLA, but how are we going to deal with this at any kind of scale?
- fwip 8y agoHundreds of millions of dollars is barely a blip on the federal government's budget. Federal dollars subsidize all kinds of local and regional infrastructure.
- echelon 8y agoWhat else could be funded with hundreds of millions of dollars? Opportunity cost.
- loktarogar 8y agomoot point when you consider that military spending takes up more than half of the budget
- jjoonathan 8y agoNope. It takes up about a third of the budget and is itself in large part a social program.
- chii 8y agoa "social" program for defense contractors. I m sure they are hurting, and need to make more money.
- jjoonathan 8y ago
- alexilliamson 8y agoY'all questioning whether it's worth saving should stay in New Orleans for a month. There is so much joy there, such a rich culture and long history that we all stand to lose.
- ChoGGi 8y agoWith 14 billion dollars you could move a lot of that culture and history to somewhere with less need for swimming lessons.
- caiocaiocaio 8y agoBetter stock up on picture postcards and souvenirs.
- kobayashy 8y agoNot everybody want's to live as a functional alcoholic in crime ridden city. Besides, The World didn't even blinked when thousands years of mankind history was decimated in Iraq. Move on.
- selimthegrim 8y agoGet bent.
- jellicle 8y agoCoastal cities will only be saved if lots and lots of money is spent on them. New York City will almost certainly survive for the foreseeable future (they've already got sea wall plans...). New Orleans, highly vulnerable and lacking money, will not survive.
- CuriouslyC 8y agoI think new orleans will in part survive as a bit of a disneyland city. I can't imagine that there aren't some parts that are worth saving.
- teslaberry 8y agofighting the ocean is a bad idea. just build up like in venice. old tech, old approach, WORKS.just build one extra floor on each building every 50 years and plan for sinkage.
- jayess 8y agoNew Orleans is sinking at a rate of up to 2 inches per year: https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.php?feature=6513 https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.php?feature=6513
- selimthegrim 8y ago1) They certainly don’t blame lack of silt 2) There’s a new power plant going up at Michoud (albeit a bad idea for other reasons)
- gerbilly 8y agoThre's a type of shoreline protection that is free and self maintaining. It's called mangroves. But people know better I guess, so we better keep throwing money at the problem we created.
- chucksmash 8y agoIt's just a headline, but this title makes me sigh. For this thread, it's the title; for others today, it has been the "dose of realism" cynical first comment. It's probably just bad luck, but it feels like the first comment on every thread I've read today has been some variation of "here are the clouds to this silver lining." In this case, it's amazing that we give enough of a damn about each other to allocate the money in the first place. How many people say caring for the less fortunate should be a matter for charities but then don't donate a dime themselves? How many in an honest moment would reply, "that's tough, move to Houston." Yet some among us cares enough to try instead of just rolling their eyes at building below sea level. I'm happy to take more trying and failing if it's in exchange for "serves them right" hindsight or abject cynicism. Proceeding to read the article, over a decade the Army Corps of Engineers raised hundreds of miles of levees. If this were a thread about how the US can't complete big projects any more, that alone would be a ray of sunshine. There are real problems in the world, folks. There's no denying that. But when the people with the ability and the inclination to be doers spend their time wringing their hands or giving themselves over to "the constipation of bittersweet philosophy" that's when there's really a problem. Instead of worrying about the state of the world, spend an hour of your social media/fuck around time a day/week/month doing something for someone else. It'll do some actual good.
- exabrial 8y agoI do that, and I agree: I wish people would spend as much time complaining about other people as they do helping them. Yet, 40% of my paycheck is still taken against my will anyway.
- hueving 8y agoI would rather we spent tax dollars on fixable problems with much more social good per dollar. I'm tired of subsidizing flood insurance for idiots that keep building in areas that flood every 10 years. Subsidizing someone to have a nice home on a Miami beech is not "actual good". L
- perfmode 8y agoTake a hard look at the subsidies you are benefiting from. Be ready to give them up if you’re going to take the holier than thou route.
- modzu 8y ago...and i don't wana swim (sorry, had to, im canadian)
- subpixel 8y agoI was in Algiers Point recently and the river was about 6 feet higher than the ground on the dry side of the earthen levee. All I could think was 'the people who built this levee were not Dutch, this cannot be even remotely safe'.
- selimthegrim 8y agoIn a AP neighborhood Facebook group old timers say they’ve seen seepage since the 70s and can’t report any significant raising
- soulofmischief 8y agoThis is New Orleans we're talking about. Everyone there knows the government is corrupt from top to bottom. This isn't news to anyone inside the city. Some of them can't leave for various reasons. The rest of them just won't. You have to spend time there to understand it. The question is do we want to save them.
- selimthegrim 8y agoThis is the Feds we’re talking about here, not our sainted Orleans Parish Levee board
- Johnny555 8y agoIf the federal government would just do what North Carolina did and pass a law prohibiting basing coastal policies on the latest scientific predictions of how much the sea level will rise, these levees would last indefinitely. https://abcnews.go.com/US/north-carolina-bans-latest-science-rising-sea-level/story?id=16913782 https://abcnews.go.com/US/north-carolina-bans-latest-science...
- spyckie2 8y agoHard facts are hard facts. If New Orleans is going to be under water in 4 years, they will have to do something about it. Actually, we should probably treat New Orleans as a case study and learn from it since due to rising sea levels, a lot of cities may have to evacuate in 10-20 years.
- exabrial 8y agoI know sarcasm never goes well on hn, but perhaps it's time we stop 'giving' the government $14b dollars... ?
- pcurve 8y agoIt's not just the levees. The whole damn city is sinking according to article from 2016. https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.php?feature=6513 https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.php?feature=6513 "The highest rates of sinking were observed upriver along the Mississippi River around major industrial areas in Norco, and in Michoud, with up to 2 inches (50 millimeters) a year of sinking."
- rocqua 8y agoIt is crazy they build the system to a 100 year standard. The Dutch delta works are build to a 2000 4000 or 10000 year standard, depending on the area being protected. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_Works https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_Works
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoStealing a line from others, but: That's the difference between the US and Europe. In Europe, 100 miles is a long distance. In the US, 100 years is a long time.
- mukundmr 8y agoI saw a program on Netflix or Prime Video about how rising sea levels are changing the lives of people living in a community in coastal California as the tides flood the streets more and more. People are emotionally bonded to their homes and are unable to decide to move away. This is a new type of problem that is going to happen more and more globally. Maldives is going to be among the first to sink. However, their government has sobered up to that fact and are making plans. These type of events cannot be handled at the local level and government leaders need to coax and guide people to relocate. Then again, we have deniers of climate change and rising sea levels...
- jfoutz 8y agoIs it a new problem? The dustbowl hit, and some people were completely unwilling to move, even though their way of life was unsustainable. Change is inherently hard to deal with. I think one of the big roles of government, and perhaps culture, is to temper the peaks and valleys. Some of us are going to face hard hard choices. Some of those choices are very rapid, like an earthquake. Some of those choices are very slow, like rising sea levels. We pretty much know that there will be earthquakes and rising sea levels. How do we influence people to minimize that impact today? I'm a fan of big cash payouts for flood insurance in exchange for losing the land, ever increasing taxes on the sale of costal properties and converting coastline to national park. When folks homes are inevitably destroyed, make sure they have plenty of money to move. Make it harder and harder to sell property on the risky coasts, and finally when enough homes have been destroyed (50%? 95%? doesn't really matter the higher the fraction, the more painful the change will be), take the land and turn it into parks for everyone to use. I'm not exactly opposed to the very wealthy hanging on to a cabin or a mansion, but there needs to be a clear line that they are living on public land. People can camp in their yard. Maybe it's a stupid idea. We do have an opportunity to unwind the massive, massive risk incurred by allowing, even encouraging, people to live in places where they will fail miserably, eventually. Right now, the risks are low. So the stakes should be low. I have no problems with my tax dollars giving a small bonus for them to move away, and turn that land into national park. In 50 years when they are well and truly fucked - who cares? Maybe stop issuing flood insurance in 40 years. Plenty of time to figure out a plan. But where they are living is increasingly risky. Slowly, gradually make it clear that we as a culture and government aren't going to subsidize that. It's ok if they are super-rich, and can afford to rebuild every few years. but the land will be nationalized eventually. And no one is going to subsidize rebuilding efforts in the very long run.
- apexalpha 8y agoAs a Dutchman it's weird to see people discuss if the ROI on this investment makes it worth it. 1/3 of our country is below sea-level or around 0m NAP. Levees and flood protection are like fashion or politics: they're never finished, not really. I'm glad we do this out ourselves in stead of the EU deciding whether they want to subsidies a bunch of people living in a delta.
- telesilla 8y agoAs I understand it, the Netherlands pays for this maintenance themselves, and not from EU funding? If it were relying on EU funds then I'd expect some kind of European benefit analysis would be required.
- apexalpha 8y agoWe have a seperate branch of government called Water Boards[0]. They are some of the oldest forms of government in the world dating back to 1255.[1] The water boards raise their own taxes, and we elect officials for it in separate elections. Basically we don't want regular politicians to make budget trade offs between long term safety and short term <whatever they campaign for>. I'm sure we're all familiar with long term planning capabilities of regular politicians. To answer your question: yes. We do fund this our selves. I was saying I'm glad we do it this way in stead of begging the EU for funds. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_board_(Netherlands) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_board_(Netherlands) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoogheemraadschap_van_Rijnland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoogheemraadschap_van_Rijnland
- selimthegrim 8y agoThe Sewerage and Water Board in Orleans Parish is autonomous and exempt from certain civil service rules for much the same reason (although the Mayor appoints the director and can chair meetings). This is not to be confused with the Orleans Parish Levee District, which rightly or wrongly was perceived as having its fingers in too many pots after Katrina so had many of its responsibilities taken over by regional agencies controlled by state government (SLFPA-E and W)
- jillesvangurp 8y agoDutch person here. This is not a technical problem but a mentality problem. Louisiana has been under Republican leadership for some time. Part of the Republican agenda seems to be downplaying the notion of climate change and the associated side effects like e.g. more hurricanes and sea level rises. Well, if nature proves politicians wrong, things get ugly. Put bluntly, Louisiana needs to own that problem and stop relying on federal money and the army to fix things while they pretend this is not an issue and cut taxes and corners on keeping themselves safe. Simple solution, acknowledge the changes that are coming, start planning accordingly and get shit done. I'm pretty sure neither Republicans nor Democrats believe in wet feet as a long term sustainable political agenda. This shouldn't be a political debate. Either you do something about it or you don't. The next time these levies break, there will be a public outrage: heads will roll. So, the pragmatic thing to do would be to come up with a better plan than hoping that won't happen, which seems to be the current plan. And yes, that's going to cost money. Lots of it. The alternative is accepting the likely disasters and then mopping up the damage at much greater cost. Katrina cost well over a hundred billion. The budget for preventing the next such disasters (plural) should be of a similar scale. The good news is that that actually is an investment that can give birth to an industry that is likely to have its work cut out in the next decades as world + dog will be facing the same issues. Also, as I understand it, Louisiana could use some employment opportunities. Big projects like this always have positive side effects. The Netherlands had their wake-up call in the 1953 when a severe winter storm + spring tide flooded a large part of it. The subsequent decades we fixed our infrastructure with some massive projects at the cost of many more billions than are on the table for this in the US. The companies that helped do that still exist today and are involved in very lucrative projects across the globe (e.g. building islands off the coast of Dubai, off shore airports, etc.). I believe there was a fair bit of consulting after Hurricane Katrina as well. Business is booming for these companies. Great return on investment for Dutch tax payers and we got to keep our feet dry.
- selimthegrim 8y agoLouisiana has had an elected Democratic governor since 2015 (who is running for re-election) There is a state coastal restoration plan with a mooted price tag of $50-80 billion
- zilliam 8y agoHarry Shearer has been pointing out the problem for years on his podcast "Le Show", the movie "The Big Uneasy", and other sites. He calls out the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for incompetence, making past and future disasters inevitable: "Those bad floodwalls, of course, are the ones that failed so catastrophically in 2005. The Corps’ plan calls for keeping rainfall outflow in those canals at a set level, above which, the agency believes, the walls might fail. Again. The Corps should know. It designed and supervised the construction of those floodwalls." https://www.huffpost.com/entry/ill-consider-it-criminal_b_174920 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/ill-consider-it-criminal_b_17...
- selimthegrim 8y agoA thousand times this. Sandy Rosenthal and levees.org have kept the drumbeat going.
- zilliam 8y agoThanks for the info. I'll check 'em out. Once, a long time ago, during an extended drought in the South East, I met the Corps's commander general. I asked him if they could use their vast water reservoirs to help alleviate the problem. He explained how this would adversely affect their Byzantine obligations to the power grid, which apparently had a higher priority. I'm not informed or smart enough to criticize his position. But it did shift my perspective on what counts as "a higher priority" for the Corps. And I suspect this is the sort of thing that is at the core of their failures when dealing with the levees. Then again maybe $14 billion dollars just ain't enough.
- GeekyBear 8y agoThe levees along the Mississippi are one of the big reasons why the land around New Orleans is sinking. >When Bienville founded New Orleans in 1718, the delta was more than 400 feet deep at the river's mouth and extended northward on top of that Pleistocene foundation to midway between New Orleans and Baton Rouge. It continued growing southward until the late 1800s, when construction of flood-control levees prevented the river from resupplying the delta with new sediment. And that's when subsidence became a serious problem. https://www.nola.com/coastal/2008/12/part_2_southeast_louisiana_is.html https://www.nola.com/coastal/2008/12/part_2_southeast_louisi...
- doggydogs94 8y agoI do not see why the rest of the country needs to pay for this. I can understand why Holland has to resort to this sort of civil engineering, otherwise their country would cease to exist. For the US, keeping New Orleans afloat is just an unnecessary expense.
- mises 8y agoYes, much of it is below sea level and stupidly expensive to quite literally keep afloat. It's quite the expense, and it's probably best to move. It's not the job of the feds to take money from one state to cover the expenses of another.