8 ms·
Darpa wants to make a better, more secure, version of WhatsApp
- ape4 8y agoDon't they have one already!
- wnevets 8y agoThe title makes it sound like they want to use whatsapp, not that they want encrypted chat.
- quadrature 8y agoAgreed, i think the title is a bit misleading.
- ralph84 8y agoTrust us, this totally isn't another Dual_EC_DRBG
- LeoPanthera 8y agoDarpa had absolutely nothing to do with Dual_EC_DRBG.
- ralusek 8y agoDRBG = DaRpa BuG
- sdinsn 8y agoDARPA's not doing this for shits and giggles; they want to use it (or later iterations of it) for military communication. They also want to open source it.
- mrguyorama 8y agoIt's exactly how Tor came about.
- Zhenya 8y agoIsn't that called Signal? Maybe just put the funding into extending that?
- YeahSureWhyNot 8y agoI tried signal, much more inferior to WhatsApp in terms of functionality and usability
- cwyers 8y agoThere are real tradeoffs between functionality and usability that any "more secure" chat service would have to deal with.
- afiori 8y agoIn this Telegram made many nice choices. It can be end-to-end secure but it is also a viable Whatsapp alternative. Sticker, channels, bots and supergroups are essential to attract communities.
- cwyers 8y agoWhatsApp is default end-to-end secure, and Telegram is not. Recommending Telegram as a more secure alternative to WhatsApp is malpractice.
- emerongi 8y agoPut effort into improving usability of Signal then? I don't understand.
- chipperyman573 8y agoA lot of the issues can't be solved without relying on an authoritative 3rd party (which is what facebook, whatsapp, skype, etc do). For example, because all messages are p2p, you can't view conversation history that isn't stored locally or sent by the other party upon request (which may not include deleted messages, etc).
- qmarchi 8y agoIt's mildly entertaining that we have calls for a more secure and trust-able version of an encrypted chat service, but other agencies in the executive branch are calling for loopholes and vulnerabilities for the same encrypted channels.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoOriginal solicitation is from June 2018, not clear that this story is anything but a reheating of that announcement, found here: https://www.fbo.gov/index?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=c244cde44f811d49db4df4a90a8b5573&tab=core&_cview=1 https://www.fbo.gov/index?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=c244cde... (As an aside, it is always a bit unsettling when a federal function is represented by something that looks like a link farm. I mean, I know you elected Trump and all, but "FedBizOpps" probably predates him by a decade)
- YeahSureWhyNot 8y agoAside from the typical encryption worries here are some features I would love to see being offered on a alternative messenger app -ability to give out your alias or username to people to reach you on whatsapp instead of a phone number, something you can change later after banning the contact. -transcribe voice messages to enable search among them. -ability to hide the fact that i have listened to their voice message. -ability to hide the fact that i am on whatsapp network and receive 'add to contact' requests from people where i can accept or reject without them knowing i actually rejected. -hide the 'online' in conversation window when im reading the message. -save my chat history in the cloud so that i dont lose everything when i move from iOS to Android or vise versa. -ability to save incoming and outgoing media attachments to the cloud for access later -full desktop support for video and voice calls -ability to record the calls, and have their transcribed texts easily searchable. -ability to ignore certain kind of messages from certain people such as 'allow text messages only, no calls, no pictures, no videos.' etc.
- amelius 8y ago- ability to add custom emoticons to your library, and ability to share them
- meruru 8y agoI think most if not all of that is possible with matrix.org.
- TypingStuff 8y agoMatrix should have improved XMPP rather than added yet more fragmentation.
- AmericanChopper 8y ago>save my chat history in the cloud so that i dont lose everything when i move from iOS to Android or vise versa. Implementing this could make key management either less secure, or more difficult for users. If the user still had access to both devices, it wouldn’t be too bad. But if you want the users to be able to ‘recover’ their message history on any device, then you’d need to use something like the mnemonic seed phrase, which isn’t an improvement in UX, or security. The audio transcribing sounds difficult too, as you’d have to do it all client side if you wanted to preserve the security model.
- pvorb 8y agoDo we really need yet another chat app? I think there are far too many of them. Can't we go back to XMPP again and make everything compatible like it was ten years ago?
- jplayer01 8y agoFrom the description, it seems like it's less about the chat app itself and more about developing and designing a new secure protocol and infrastructure that will influence future products by commercial or other entities. They want people to take the tech they develop and make their own stuff more secure, which sounds awesome.
- TypingStuff 8y agoAmen. If anyone wants to be on XMPP with minimal fuss, try https://quicksy.im/ https://quicksy.im/ . This is an XMPP client, with registration based on your phone number.
- jayalpha 8y agoBesides signal, there is also 1. Threema. Swiss based but not Open Source AFAI 2. Frozen Chat. Android client based on Jabber XMMP/OTR
- frenchy 8y agoThere's also Conversations, an Android XMPP client that supports OTR/OMEMO.
- mfkp 8y agoFrozen Chat seems to be removed from the Play Store, and I can't find many references to it online. Never heard of it before.
- jayalpha 8y agoOh, wow. It is on my phone but not in the play store anymore. Strange. https://github.com/Frozenbox/frozenchat https://github.com/Frozenbox/frozenchat
- sixplusone 8y agoAnybody using Wire? I've recently been looking for a skype replacement myself and seems like wire is a pretty good fit.
- afiori 8y agoI always wonder why few people here acknowledge Telegram, is it little know or is it not considered secure enough?
- gloflo 8y agoUnencrypted chats by default. Self-written encryption.
- rrggrr 8y agoSeems like Keybase's key model would work well here: https://keybase.io/blog/keybase-new-key-model https://keybase.io/blog/keybase-new-key-model
- anthony_doan 8y agoThey should invest in the BEAM virtual machine. IIRC, Whatapps is built on Erlang and its VM. There are many benefits in helping an existing project with active developers. If dealing with the politics of managing existing project is annoying, just fork it and make their own branch. The original owner can deal with the merging if they want the contribution.
- abalone 8y agoThis makes it sound like DARPA wants to take some commercially developed tech and adapt it to the military, but just for the record that grossly misstates the relationship and the general history of Silicon Valley. Ever wonder how Siri got her name? From SRI International, a research org largely funded by the DoD.[1] DARPA is the origin of much of the tech, including secure Internet tech. Just one recent example: Tor[2]. It's developed at taxpayer expense and either given away to private industry or "transferred" for a pittance. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SRI_International#Employees_and_financials https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SRI_International#Employees_an... [2] https://www.onion-router.net/Sponsors.html https://www.onion-router.net/Sponsors.html
- toast0 8y agoI don't think there's an official origin for Siri's name. Someone said it was named after a child. I suspect (without evidence) it was named after the female robot in the pilot episode of the Logan's Run who ran Mountain City, a paradise city.
- iDon 8y agoFrom : https://www.sri.com/engage/ventures/siri https://www.sri.com/engage/ventures/siri https://www.sri.com/work/timeline-innovation/timeline.php?timeline=computing-digital#!&innovation=siri https://www.sri.com/work/timeline-innovation/timeline.php?ti... "Siri, the first virtual personal assistant, arose from decades of SRI research in artificial intelligence (AI). The technology was developed through the SRI-led Cognitive Assistant that Learns and Organizes (CALO) project within DARPA's Personalized Assistant that Learns (PAL) program, the largest-known AI project in U.S. History, and joint work with EPFL, the Swiss institute of technology. SRI spun off Siri, Inc. in 2007 to bring the technology to consumers, raising $24 million in two rounds of financing. In April 2010, Apple acquired Siri, and in October 2011, Siri was unveiled as an integrated feature of the Apple iPhone 4S." I'm not verifying that - I just found it via google search "sri Siri" I like the link to Logan's Run :-), it could be also true.
- lonesword 8y agoJust wait till Telegram open sources their code?
- alphagrep12345 8y agoWhat's wrong with the current encryption? I'm told that Signal's encryption technique if very superior and probably the best in the industry.
- staticvar 8y ago> Exist completely within a network I bet this requirements implies working seemlessly between online and offline networks. In which case this project is not just building another XMPP/WhatApps/Signal/etc. They are building another Cabal (https://cabal-club.github.io/ https://cabal-club.github.io/) :-)