9 ms·
Can someone point out where the article says why it's slower? I'm having difficulty unpacking: "The new theory was inspired when Jafferis began thinking about
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
Can someone point out where the article says why it's slower? I'm having difficulty unpacking:
"The new theory was inspired when Jafferis began thinking about two black holes that were entangled on a quantum level, as formulated in the ER=EPR correspondence by Juan Maldacena from the Institute for Advanced Study and Lenny Susskind from Stanford. Although this means the direct connection between the black holes is shorter than the wormhole connection—and therefore the wormhole travel is not a shortcut—the theory gives new insights into quantum mechanics."
Why is the wormhole not a shortcut?
- philipov 8y agoBased on the colloquia I watched by Lenny Susskind, the problem is that you can put something into a wormhole, but to get it out the other end, you have to carry the encoding you get to the other end of the wormhole to decode the output. Because the distance to the singularity grows at the speed of light, the length of the wormhole is essentially infinite. It is only the operator you get from putting the object into the wormhole that lets it tunnel through that infinity, so no shortcut. EDIT: Here is the lecture I'm referring to: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nEDFh8ma9zM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nEDFh8ma9zM
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoSo we've uncovered the universes version of cyptography?
- TomMarius 8y agoNative cryptography, I'd say
- jessermeyer 8y agoIt's more just the encryption method without decryption.
- lawlessone 8y ago> Because the distance to the singularity grows at the speed of light, doesn't our universe expand at the same speed?
- adrianN 8y agoThings are moving away from us at a speed proportional to their distance. The fastest objects are actually faster than the speed of light.
- FrancoisBosun 8y agoI thought nothing could move faster than light?
- philipov 8y agoSpecial Relativity states that no two objects may pass each other faster than the speed of light. Space itself isn't bound by this restriction. To wit: no thing can move faster than the speed of light, but space is not a thing. Space is dynamical. It can stretch and expand and even break, but it doesn't move. The result of this is a cosmological horizon that prevents these objects from communicating, because the distance between them is growing faster than light can cross it. This is the same reason you can't escape a black hole.
- pbhjpbhj 8y ago>and even break Spatial discontinuities? Can you tell us more, please?
- philipov 8y agoHow about another lecture by Leonard Susskind? I'm just repeating his ideas! The gist of it is that the connectivity of space is related to the patterns of entanglement between particles in the quantum foam. If you were to break that entanglement, you could disconnect two regions of space. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9crggox5rbc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9crggox5rbc
- logfromblammo 8y agoSo... Two entangled wormhole apertures function as Star Trek style transporter pads. Feed mass into one hole, scanning it as it goes in. Transmit the pattern to another aperture of the hole, using electromagnetic energy at the speed of light, and when that end ejects a mass, apply the pattern to it, so it resolves into an exact copy of what you put in. The distance the mass travels may be shorter than the distance the energy travels, but it can't resolve exiting mass as that object until the information--that had to travel at the speed of light--arrives. So you could potentially use a wormhole as a suicide machine that transports a copy of you, that thinks it actually is you, to a distant location no faster than the speed of light, in zero subjective time for the thing that will then think it's you. Is that a reasonable interpretation?
- ben_w 8y agoI don’t think the suicide booth model of a teleporter fits a quantum teleporter model, only the 3D printer teleporter model. From a quantum point of view, all (e.g.) electrons are indistinguishable excitations in the same field, and it’s the pattern that makes you “you”. If you’ll forgive a bit of poetic licence, quantum teleportation seems more like Discworld magic, where you have to exchange two identical sized lumps of matter.
- lloeki 8y agoThis sounds like the science-fiction version of a cryogenic scam.
- pontifier 8y agohttp://existentialcomics.com/comic/1 http://existentialcomics.com/comic/1 Edit:Lol, someone else also had this link as a reply to a similar thought.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Terr_ 8y ago> the problem is that you can put something into a wormhole, but to get it out the other end, you have to carry the encoding you get to the other end of the wormhole to decode the output. That sounds a lot like how entangled particles can't be used to communicate faster than light. While you can make observations immediately, you can't turn them into useful information about the other end, at least not until you get missing data which has to reach you by normal means. Hence the focus on using entangled particles as a kind of tamper-detector or "reusable random one-time pad", rather than for transmitting information.
- philipov 8y agoThat is precisely the lesson of the ER=EPR principle, which states that every entangled pair really has a 1-qubit wormhole connecting it, and the space inside a macro-scale wormhole is the consequence of combining all those tiny wormholes together. Wormholes are entanglement.
- eigenschwarz 8y agoThe Average Null Energy Condition (ANEC) makes it so there can not be a traversable wormhole joining two otherwise disconnected regions of spacetime. So by construction, any infinite null geodesic (a light ray) which makes it through the wormhole must be chronal (causally connected). This means there can be no traveling faster than light over long distances by going through one.
- FakeComments 8y agoYou don’t really explain how the assumption leads to the conclusion — and I’m left with the impression you used many words to say “they just assumed you can’t”. Could you elaborate? Edit: Looking into energy conditions further, they are literally assumed restrictions on the equations because physicists felt some predictions were unphysical. I’d really like if someone could explain if there’s any justification to what I was responding to beyond “well, because we assumed it should work that way”. I think it behooves the physics community to be honest which claims are conclusions and which are their assumptions, and the specific reasoning that leads from assumption to conclusion.
- Filligree 8y agoWithout negative matter, it's impossible to build a wormhole that's shorter than the distance through normal space. This piece of math shows that it may still be possible to build a wormhole which isn't shorter than that distance. Obviously that wouldn't be much of a shortcut, but the potential research and (maybe) real-world applications are still impressive.
- FakeComments 8y agoThat’s not what I was asking. I was asking about the particular usage of the average null energy condition as justification to rule out wormholes: why isn’t that just begging the question by assuming your conclusion? and how does that particular assumption actually lead to the conclusion there can’t be wormholes? It’s interesting the downvotes for asking someone to support a scientific claim, and be clear where they’re making assumptions versus reaching empirical conclusions.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]