10 ms·
Frankly, I hope YouTube (and Google in general) dramatically overdo it with the censorship, "curation", and deplatforming of "irresponsible" content, purely so
by keiferski 8y ago
Frankly, I hope YouTube (and Google in general) dramatically overdo it with the censorship, "curation", and deplatforming of "irresponsible" content, purely so that it forces an independent, non-corporate model to be developed.
Having one company be the sole gatekeeper for the overwhelming majority of the web's video content is not a solution.
- beaconstudios 8y agothe accelerationist model of web centralisation. It depends on how much of the populace actually cares, or if YouTube draws most of its revenue from casual viewers watching trending videos that are not likely to fall foul of these practices.
- sametmax 8y agoBecause it worked so well for radio, tv and newspapers.
- foota 8y ago... Yes?
- kzcqt 8y agoA site like youtube requires so much CPU/GPU power, storage capacity and bandwidth that it's highly unlikely that a new competitor[] will appear, and completely impossible to decentralise. []If we don't count the likes of Facebook, Microsoft, etc as competitors, since they would manage the site in the same way Google does.
- krapp 8y agoPlenty of other video streaming sites exist. Competition certainly isn't impossible, and competitors don't have to operate at Youtube's scale to be viable, assuming they target a niche demographic.
- kzcqt 8y agoA competitor would need to operate at youtube's scale for it to be considered a serious competitor. Otherwise, we wouldn't be having this conversation, given that websites like Dailymotion and Vimeo exist, but no "youtube stars" use them.
- krapp 8y agoNot every competitor has to be "serious" to be successful. And what about Twitch? Plenty of "personality" driven content there.
- kzcqt 8y agoTwitch is not a competitor of youtube. Twitch is specialised in live shows. They don't let you upload videos, and they delete old videos of past broadcasts pretty often.
- krapp 8y agoIf user attention is split between Twitch and Youtube then they are a competitor. Same for Netflix. Same for Pornhub. Same for Vine when that was a thing.
- stcredzero 8y agoIf user attention is split between Twitch and Youtube then they are a competitor. Same for Netflix. Same for Pornhub. Same for Vine when that was a thing. But if you focus attention to political commentary specifically, then YouTube is clearly the dominant giant. In that context, they are a defacto monopoly.
- rchaud 8y agoIt really wouldn't. YT makes a big deal about vanity metrics like "10,000 hours of video uploaded per hour" (or something like that), but the 80-20 rule still applies. A giant chunk of uploaded content is never even watched.
- mtgx 8y agoBandwidth has nothing to do with it. If a site was super-popular, I'm sure they'd get the VC money. That's really not the issue. The issue is getting people to put their videos on other sites, too.
- MBCook 8y agoAnd you don’t think the VCs would drive them to try to keep their content ‘clean’ the way YouTube is?
- enitihas 8y agoI don't think any new platform is going to be able to compete with YouTube at all with the current regulations. How will any new platform comply with new EU copyright laws, or remove unlawful videos as quickly as YouTube? (e.g the unfortunate New Zealand terrorist attack)
- Mirioron 8y agoThey won't. I suspect that that kind of regulatory capture is the point of these laws in the first place.
- enitihas 8y agoI don't think so. Most people ( and a lot of people on HN) really believe that online platforms should be able to suppress such unlawful videos. And it's not a completely unreasonable position.
- 4ntonius8lock 8y agoYou are right. Personally, I question how many people would support authoritarianism if we didn't have the regulatory capture environment we currently have. There is such a powerful system of indoctrination in the US. But then I think of experiments that deal with human nature. Of how 65%~ of people in the milgram experiment gave the dangerous shocks even while hearing people plea... It paints a picture of human nature I guess I want to blame on something 'out there' and not 'in here'.
- stcredzero 8y agoMost people ( and a lot of people on HN) really believe that online platforms should be able to suppress such unlawful videos. "Such unlawful videos." So basically, the government should be able to declare content "unlawful" and it's okay so long as public sentiment goes along with it? Basically, you've simply thrown out Free Speech. I can understand why someone would find the video of the shooting shocking. Personally, I've chosen not to view it. However, if Free Speech isn't an absolute right, then it's simply broken. Habeas corpus, the Presumption of Innocence, and due process -- what if the government could just suspend those things when it felt like it? Those human rights would simply be broken. The difference between a just society and an unjust one, is that the just society extends the same rights and protections to all its citizens, no infringements, no exceptions. A society with Free Speech extends the right of speech and the right to read/hear that speech to everyone without infringement as well. The interesting thing about the Weimar Republic, is that almost all of the laws covering human rights had an "out" for the government, allowing them to suspend the right, "for the common good" in emergency situations. As a result, the subsequent regime didn't have to change many laws to operate as a totalitarian regime.
- neilv 8y agoIt's starting to look like we're getting more of a regulatory moat. (In the Warren Buffet sense of "moat", as barrier to competitors.) An additional concern, at least in US tradition, is when once-again-centralized monopoly venues are being mandated (or given permission?) by politicians to censor or "curate" everyone's speech. I'm pretty sure I was taught in school that we consider that a bad idea here. I generally favor a healthy amount of decentralization, that the remaining big guys be more common carrier (and stop claiming rights to people's communications), and a renewed individual sense of responsibility towards society (not gaming social media, playing to metrics, manipulating our lesser selves, etc.).
- sschueller 8y agoSolutions are being worked on like peertube: https://joinpeertube.org https://joinpeertube.org
- amelius 8y agoOk, but what happens when somebody uploads a video that (by accident or not) contains copyrighted content? Who is liable? The original uploader? All the peers who are hosting it? The viewers? And how quickly can the content be removed?
- seattle_spring 8y ago> Frankly, I hope YouTube (and Google in general) dramatically overdo it with the censorship, "curation", and deplatforming of "irresponsible" content, purely so that it forces an independent, non-corporate model to be developed. Just like people got what they wished for when Voat was spawned from Reddit?
- diminoten 8y agoYeah, I'm all about the idea behind letting people express themselves without being censored, but the stark reality is that the people pushing the envelope here are saying some pretty damaging things about other people in a hurtful and escalating way. I don't know how to square these two thoughts.
- r_smart 8y ago'Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me.' Granted, it's aspirational.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoHave you thought about the possibility that our language has been constructed to give people like you more ammunition against others? And given other less ammunition to use against people like you? Words like "bitch", "bossy", etc. Also cultural norms for what kinds of emotions you interpret as "too much" if it’s a woman but “oh crap I should listen” if it’s a man, etc. I have no idea who you are, so just a question about where you’re at in thinking about this. And do I understand correctly your proposal? That we should all aspire to be unaffected by the words of others. And if someone is negatively affected by words it is their failure, not the failure of the speaker or the failure of the group they are in together.
- r_smart 8y ago|the possibility that our language has been constructed to give people like you more ammunition against others? The idea that the language was constructed is pretty silly. It's such a twisted hodge-podge of borrowed ideas. Besides, other languages with far different heritages will hold very similar words and terms as ours. As for the idea of having more ammunition, You'd have to actually provide some evidence for the idea that there's more plentiful / harsh language available to 'people like me'. Particularly when I've seen both of the words you cite used plentifully towards a broad swathe of people. |That we should all aspire to be unaffected by the words of others. Yes. |And if someone is negatively affected by words it is their failure, not the failure of the speaker or the failure of the group they are in together. Not exactly, no. A person being an asshole is an asshole. Your reaction to it doesn't absolve them of that behavior, even if you responded positively for some reason. However, letting some random asshole ruin your day by saying something you don't like is just setting you up for constant failure, as you are so easily driven into a negative emotional state. I'm suggesting a coping strategy, one among many, to guide a person in navigating a world full of adversity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nemothekid 8y ago>Having one company be the sole gatekeeper for the overwhelming majority of the web's video content is not a solution. I struggle with this line of thinking because it's not specific enough. YouTube doesn't act as a gatekeeper for most video content. You can upload almost anything you want as long as its not grotesque or copyrighted. What most people mean when they say YouTube acts as a gatekeeper is "will YouTube pay me for the content I upload". And the problem with that is the advertisers, not YouTube - a handful of large advertisers decided they didn't like a lot of the content on YouTube and refused to pay for it. The beef is with the advertisers, not YouTube. I do have a problem with the videos YouTube decides to promote and surface, but when it becomes to the topic and censorship and deplatforming, the argument almost always boils down to "Proctor and Gamble need to pay me to upload content whether they want to or not", which I find asinine. YouTube is obligated to provide you with a sales team.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoI mean, I regularly publish to youtube but I have explicitly avoided monetization of my account. I am not trying to get paid for my content, yet I know that I am at the mercy of youtube's algorithm. I want people to see my content and don't like the idea of a single group being in charge of how it is distributed. I am willing to use it for now, but I long for a decentralized replacement.
- Scoundreller 8y ago> a handful of large advertisers decided they didn't like a lot of the content on YouTube and refused to pay for it. The beef is with the advertisers, not YouTube. No, the beef is with YouTube. They could offer advertisers the option to pay more and only advertise on “high-quality” content, or pay less and advertise everywhere. Make it a slider with example videos and let them select what they’re comfortable with. Instead, they went with no choice and arbitrary demonetization cutoffs. If P&G doesn’t like my shaky repair videos on niche products that nobody else has made, fine. But P&G shouldn’t dictate what’s worthy of advertising or not for every other advertiser AND publisher.
- v7p1Qbt1im 8y ago
- vkou 8y ago> Having one company be the sole gatekeeper for the overwhelming majority of the web's video content is not a solution. Anecdotal experience: Most people discover most videos they watch through hyperlinks/word of mouth, not YT recommendations, and nothing is stopping you from self-hosting a video. YT is not like a social network (which become quadratically more valuable, and exclusive, with their number of users). There's no walled garden, its consumed passively, and its competition is, in fact, a click away.
- MiddleEndian 8y agoExactly. The ideal alternative to YouTube is the internet itself. Given the choice, I'd rather visit worldclownhistory.com than visit the worldclownhistory YouTube channel.
- tracker1 8y agoYou don't have to look any farther than Gab and Dissenter to see what happens when someone tries to create free speech respecting versions of things.
- atomical 8y agoThere's a bit of bias in the commentary on Gab, especially considering everyone at YC hates Andrew Mason. Not that he doesn't deserve it...
- tracker1 8y agoI get it on all sides... however, it's worrisome to me that the support of censorship is moving so far as to ban access to such (opt-in) tools.