5 ms·
Seems to ignore two things... a) Your ISP is almost always in the same legal jurisdiction as you are. A VPN need not be. b) A VPN has some incentive to deliv
by tyingq 8y ago
Seems to ignore two things...
a) Your ISP is almost always in the same legal jurisdiction as you are. A VPN need not be.
b) A VPN has some incentive to deliver on privacy. Your ISP does not.
It's fair to call out that a VPN isn't perfect for either privacy or anonymity. But it clearly can be better than your ISP.
- wglb 8y agoSo what protection does a foreign VPN provider have from the NSA? The answer: None.
- manquer 8y agoIf your threat model includes NSA you need to reconsider lot more than just a VPN
- blackflame7000 8y agoWindows Defender oughta do it /s
- auslander 8y agoDisk encryption, firmware lockdown, home security with notifications, burner phones, Tails and Tor (via VPN), IRC, fleet of hacked Windows machines to route through, 10 online identities.
- raxxorrax 8y agoI always recommend users to pick a VPN service in a country not on friendly terms with domestic agencies. Sure, that country gets your data but have a harder time correlating it with anything. In my circle, VPN use starts to be requested by non-technical users that just want to minimize their digital footprint. Seems amazing to me, since people spend 200$+ on a service for a year, so it seems rather important to them. No reason not to use globalization to your own advantage.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoA foreign provide surely has more, in the legal realm, than a domestic one?
- amdavidson 8y agoWhat legal protection from the NSA does a foreign (to the USA) provider have? Signals intelligence from foreign sources is the NSA's exact mission. At least the NSA has a purported requirement not to do domestic spying, even if Snowden proved that's not being followed.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoI was thinking that a domestic entity has no protections from the NSA, they have to open up if NSA says so "for national security reasons"? Whilst a foreign entity has not requirements to do so. Both domestic and foreign entities are subject to the same practical abilities; ergo a foreign entity is safer? As for "no domestic spying", I thought the five-eyes group spied on each other to order so as to circumvent those requirements in domestic law??
- rtpg 8y ago> b) A VPN has some incentive to deliver on privacy. Your ISP does not. Regarding this point, I think a good strategy here is to acknowledge that ISPs, like most organizations, don’t want to add to their workloads. Of course they aren’t privacy centric, but appeals to them oriented around _not_ having to store a bunch of logs or set up a bunch of processes can help to unite more people around initiatives to make things better for everyone If everyone has the same ideals then it’s easy to team up. But even if everyone has different ideals, you might all still be wanting 90% of the same result and can still team up!
- Dylan16807 8y agoLogs are worth a lot of money to advertisers if your customers can't effectively avoid the process.
- AstralStorm 8y agoAnd a lot of money to a lawyer who will sue the ISP under privacy laws if it comes to light. It has to be clearly stated in the signed contract that your data will be shared with third parties, in what way and how they will be processed. The company involved would definitely lose any Privacy Shield provisions for the EU and potentially peering rights. Losing enough peering is identical to being disconnected. Class suit of this kind is easy.
- kakarot 8y agoI didn't get any money when my cell provider was caught multiple times selling my location history to anyone with a buck, including dangerous vigilantes.
- Dylan16807 8y agoIn the US they can share all the site IPs they want. If you make them put it in the contract, sure: "We'll share it with all these ad agencies for the purposes of targeting." That doesn't help me at all!
- thinkloop 8y ago
- despera 8y agoNo it cannot be better. It can be only equally good or as bad as your ISP. Just because they claim that they protect your privacy that's just a blind faith. Users trusted PureVPN claims for protecting their privacy but all it took was an FBI investigation and through court documents to find out that they actually were keeping logs, despite all their claims.
- feanaro 8y agoIt cannot be better but it is a matter of blind faith to trust they are better?
- okmokmz 8y ago>No it cannot be better. It can be only equally good or as bad as your ISP False >Just because they claim that they protect your privacy that's just a blind faith. Even if this is the case, it does not make your previous statement true
- bigiain 8y agoNot only does my ISP have no "incentive to deliver on privacy, my ISP is _legally required_ not to deliver on privacy. They are by law in the tinpot jurisdiction I live in, required to retain all "meta data" about my internet connection, and provide it to "law enforcement" which has turned out to include not just terrorist and serious drug crime divisions of the police, but also local council garbage services and the taxi commission. All I need from a VPN service is for it to be slightly more difficult to request all the data invading my privacy than the mandatory legal disclosure of it that I'm subject to anyway. Anything beyond time-zone slowness and paperwork incompetence is just a bonus. I prefer VPN providers based in France or Finland or Iceland - on the perhaps vaguely over reliant on bad stereotypes theory that they'll put English language requests at the bottom of the pile, and that the Sydney Taxi Commission won't have an Icelandic speaker on hand to ask them for my internet date records... Even if they keep all traffic logs, and even if they happily turn it over without a fight to anyone who can fake a plausible looking LEO email address from Australia, I'm still ahead in at least some important waays privacy-wise over not running a VPN at all... If they really don't keep logs, or really will push back against LEO requests without proper warrants, even better. But not doing that doesn't;t make them useless...
- peterkelly 8y agoAfter reading the first sentence of your reply I (correctly) guessed which country you were talking about. It's a depressing state of affairs for sure.
- lagadu 8y agoThis is my reasoning behind using a vpn for things other than getting around geoblocked content: I'm adding another layer of international bureaucracy and law enforcement to the process of a copyright's holder getting to me, despite it actually being legal where I live. There's no barrier like international bureaucracy and language barriers. Good luck navigating the courts of 3 countries within the time period that any logs might have to be saved for at the last hop.
- chewz 8y agoPeople from the First World have no idea that porn and politically sensitive content is blocked in so many countries. Youtube is heavily censored - you won't be able to watch Charlie Chaplin movies or some lectures on Greek democracy in Thailand. Also this censoring is poorly executed by some ISPs via simple DNS hijacking. As a result your connection is slow and with terrible jitter. As for the proverbial airport/cafe WiFi - using VPN is not about not beeing tracked - it is about blocking easy access to your laptops filesystem by attacker on the same network. Also if you do not trust commercial VPN provider just set up your own.
- chewz 8y ago> Thailand’s Junta Got Charlie Chaplin’s ‘The Great Dictator’ Blocked From YouTube YouTube caved to requests from Thailand's military-backed government to block a Thai-subtitled clip from the renowned political satire. https://www.indiewire.com/2017/06/great-dictator-blocked-thailand-junta-military-coup-1201848050/ https://www.indiewire.com/2017/06/great-dictator-blocked-tha...
- najra 8y agoWhat would you consider the best/easiest way to setup your own?
- martinraag 8y agoStreisand [https://github.com/StreisandEffect/streisand https://github.com/StreisandEffect/streisand] automates the setup of several different VPN services on cloud providers.
- chewz 8y agoI am running strongswan[1] with IKEv2 on cheap (10$ per year) VPS in Amsterdam, Netherlands. Or you can google for how to set up your own VPN on AWS/Google Cloud free tier. [1] https://wiki.strongswan.org/projects/strongswan/wiki/UserDocumentation https://wiki.strongswan.org/projects/strongswan/wiki/UserDoc... [2] https://medium.com/@tatianaensslin/how-to-create-a-free-personal-vpn-in-the-cloud-using-ec2-openvpn-626c40e96dab https://medium.com/@tatianaensslin/how-to-create-a-free-pers...
- dangerface 8y ago> Your ISP is almost always in the same legal jurisdiction as you are. A VPN need not be. Most of them are registered in five eyes countries, or twelve eyes. If they have anything in the US even if its just a single server they will claim jurisdiction over the lot. There are too many agreements and loopholes to rely on the whole jurisdiction thing. Unless you use a 100% Estonia VPN company and server with no other locations you are not safe, even then its not enough. 5 years ago Sweeden was the safest country for privacy, things change. > A VPN has some incentive to deliver on privacy. Your ISP does not. While they generally don't an ISP can give you better privacy than a VPN, no worries about dns leaks, they can route every one through a low latency mixer etc. I would rather pay an extra £20 a month to my ISP for real privacy than pay a VPN £5 a month for fake peace of mind.
- patrickjburt 8y agoYeah you are right totally agree with you. I m also using purevpn's 100% Estonia VPN company and 2000+ server spread across 180 locations including Estonia and surrounding regions.