14 ms·
Intel VISA Exploit Gives Access to Computer’s Entire Data, Researchers Show
- ccnafr 8y agoThis article appears to be blog spam after an interview ZDNet had with the researchers, which seems to include a lot more info on this. Appears Intel is trying too underpin this as unexploitable (shocker!!!), citing a patch from last year. Researchers say that there are multiple ways to turn this debug mode on besides those.
- DennisP 8y agoOops, didn't notice that. The article I posted has two links other than the zdnet link, but they're also contained in the zdnet article. Totally support the admins repointing to this if they want: https://www.zdnet.com/article/researchers-discover-and-abuse-new-undocumented-feature-in-intel-chipsets/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/researchers-discover-and-abuse...
- spectramax 8y agoIt looks like a shady website. Also the title needs to be changed to remove VISA. It could mean Visa(traveling), VISA(credit cards). Zdnet titles it well “Researchers discover and abuse new undocumented feature in Intel chipsets”
- detaro 8y agohttps://www.blackhat.com/asia-19/briefings/schedule/#intel-visa-through-the-rabbit-hole-13513 https://www.blackhat.com/asia-19/briefings/schedule/#intel-v... has link to presentation slides Other articles: https://www.zdnet.com/article/researchers-discover-and-abuse-new-undocumented-feature-in-intel-chipsets/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/researchers-discover-and-abuse... https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/03/29/intel_visa_hack/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/03/29/intel_visa_hack/
- wuschel 8y agoOut of interest: What would one consider as the most secure, commercially available computer architecture? Are there any open, vetted computer system out there? How do projects such as the Raspberry Pi fare in terms of security?
- sabujp 8y agoThere are many, but you'll sacrifice either price or performance to get it. The problem is that for hardware qualification/testing/development, remote management, etc many vendors have started opening up these backdoors.
- shakna 8y ago> Out of interest: What would one consider as the most secure, commercially available computer architecture? Define your limits. For the everyday, you won't get far. Intel, AMD and others have all been shown to have problems like this, or at least things they specify for government agencies. However, tiny computer architectures like MIPS, AVR and the like probably don't, simply because they tend to be too small. They don't have the memory for advanced backdoor techniques... But are trivial to access their memory if you have physical access. Straight-up RISC-V is too new to truly trust security, but looks fairly great... Until you realise that almost everyone is going to add their own proprietary extensions to it, and those extensions may well include things like VISA. --- The Raspberry Pi uses a Broadcom ARM chip. (Which model you get does have different models of the particular SoC, and the two main chips are vastly different). I don't have enough details about the particular chip to tell, but ARM does have it's own remote management system. It may or may not be part of what Broadcom offers, and may or may not have undisclosed abilities to offer to clandestine agencies.
- MisterTea 8y ago> Straight-up RISC-V is too new to truly trust security, but looks fairly great... Bad analogy because Risc-V is an instruction set, not a physical microarchitecture. Back doors and side channel attacks could still be possible when implementing risc-v as a uarch. The same applies for any ISA be it MIPS, x86-64, Power, Arm, Spark, PA Risc, Alpha, etc. They're just different programming languages implemented in hardware. And like software, hardware can have bugs too, though patching is much harder or impossible.
- spaceribs 8y agoGetting real tired of hearing about how our monopolistic glorious chip-maker leaks data like a sieve, almost as if there's some sort of monetary benefit to doing so...
- hiccuphippo 8y agoHow do I find out if this debug mode is enabled?
- huffmsa 8y agoIntel's recent string of "what the fuck" failures are what happens when a monopolist emerges and goes unchallenged for a long enough period to become lazy. May the market penalize them in kind.
- close04 8y agoUnfortunately the market probably won't. Intel still has enough clout and resources to incentivize OEMs to sell as many Intel systems as possible. For consumer hardware most buyers are completely oblivious to the situation but they are most likely familiar with the Intel brand. For enterprise the inertia is a lot higher and they are probably waiting to see that AMD manages to deliver for an extended period (multiple generations) before considering wider scale adoption.
- nolok 8y agoAnecdotical at best but I upgrade a few dozen desktops a year for my customers during the early months of the year, and this year is the first year in a long time that there was some AMD in my purchases, in fact most of it was AMD. Not by choice, but because 1. it was available, 2. it was the best option (for a branded below 450 euros desktop with ssd, the fight was mostly ryzen 5 with 8 GB of ram vs i3 with 8 GB or ram vs i5 with 4 GB of ram). Lenovo especially had some great offering with Ryzen cpu.
- blfr 8y agoSecurity and price aside, I would expect Ryzen with its many cores to be excellent in office use. Is it?
- close04 8y agoI think any modern CPU is enough for regular office use. You don't really need lots of cores for that. But if you can get them at a lower price point, lower power consumption maybe, and perhaps even better security then why not?
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Yuval_Halevi 8y agoTL;DR Although Intel doesn't publicly disclose the existence of Intel VISA and is extremely secretive about it, the researchers were able to find several ways to enable the feature on the Intel chipsets and capture the data from the CPU. As a per presentation made by the researchers Mark Ermolov and Maxim Goryachy of Positive Technologies at the ongoing Blackhat Asia 2019 conference in Singapore, their exploits of the Intel chipsets don't require any hardware modifications or special equipment. One of the techniques shared by the researchers involved vulnerabilities detailed in Intel-SA-00086 advisory that give access to Intel Management Engine, in turn helping enable VISA. Access to Intel VISA makes the computer's entire data vulnerable and obtainable for the attacker.
- chasil 8y agoThe Core 2 series on LGA775 is the last Intel chipset where the ME can be entirely disabled. This VISA exploit relies in some way on SA-00086, which is a flaw in the ME that cannot be removed in later versions. The me_cleaner script has been able to purge these older chipsets since October of last year. I cleaned two different HP desktops at that time, and uploaded the modified BIOS here: https://github.com/corna/me_cleaner/issues/233 https://github.com/corna/me_cleaner/issues/233 These still suffer from Meltdown and the remediation does exact a performance penalty, but Core 2 is starting to appear as the most manageable risk of all their products.
- samat 8y agoCurious what your threat model is.
- chasil 8y agoThe Intel ME can be accessed over the connected ethernet even when the PC is shut down, as long as the power supply is attached. SA-00086 as an exploit is available through the ME. VISA is available for access by the (compromised) ME. This seems threatening enough to me.
- rzzzt 8y agoI am always confused about this part. Are systems that don't support vPro/AMT/MEBX also accessible over the motherboard's Ethernet connection?
- chasil 8y agoAs far as I know, yes. If you run the Linux ME reporting tool and it is identified, then ME is awaiting provisioning and commands. Every chipset has the CPU that serves the ME, separate from the CPU.
- magila 8y agoAll Intel systems contain ME hardware and firmware, but most consumer systems are not configured to support remote administration via the integrated ethernet port.
- _bxg1 8y agoThe name VISA makes all of this extremely confusing, as there are two other major overloaded meanings for the word
- tyingq 8y ago"Intel doesn't publicly disclose the existence of Intel VISA" An internal-only name leaked..."Visualization of Internal Signals Architecture"
- _bxg1 8y agoYeah, I figured that out eventually, but for the first while I was mentally following multiple possible narratives
- sesutton 8y agoVISA should at least be capitalized like in the original title.
- bo1024 8y agoThe scariest line to me: > Intel doesn't publicly disclose the existence of Intel VISA and is extremely secretive about it So all of my data and everything I do on my computer is flowing through this every day, and nobody knows what it is or what it does....
- arcanus 8y agoDoes this mean AMD is inherently more secure?
- chasil 8y agoAMD has an equivalent of the Intel ME that was called the "Platform Security Processor" and is now known as the "Secure Processor." Flaws have been found in it. They are probably not as bad as Intel. Leaving the VISA environment accessible to ME is something that I hope AMD would never entertain out of a wealth of caution for their customers.
- richardwhiuk 8y ago> They are probably not as bad as Intel. Not sure there's any evidence this is likely to be true - except for the fact Intel processors are widely deployed.
- chasil 8y agoAMD did not suffer from Meltdown. We would hope that their architectural restraint would extend to their SP.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y ago> Flaws have been found in it. They are probably not as bad as Intel. It's slightly ambiguous whether you mean 'the flaws in AMD IME-near-equivalent are not as bad as the flaws in the IME' or 'AMD's IME-near-equivalent is not as bad as the IME'. On the 2nd interpretation, it seems that AMD's 'ME' is likely not as powerful/mature as Intel's ME. On the other hand, on certain machines the IME can be disabled or largely neutralised, while I know of no such possibility for AMD.
- everybodyknows 8y ago>VISA's documentation is subject to a non-disclosure agreement, and not available to the general public. - https://www.zdnet.com/article/researchers-discover-and-abuse-new-undocumented-feature-in-intel-chipsets/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/researchers-discover-and-abuse... Back in the 80s, such policies were dismissed as "security through obscurity". So much change, so little progress ...
- amluto 8y agoThis doesn’t discuss when the attack matters. I see at least three ways: 1. If you can do the attack entirely over USB, then you can completely take over a machine via USB and possibly add a very powerful firmware rootkit. The JTAG password seems relevant here. 2. If you get root code execution, you may be able to install a better rootkit. This might be able to extract supposedly hardware-secured crypto keys. 3. The “deterministic RNG” and/or inspection of RNG signals mode might be an interesting attack against SGX — SGX enclaves expect RDRAND to be secure. (If you can take over the ME, I think you can break some of SGX’s platform features, but I don’t think you break the core security guarantees.) I think the JTAG password is the nastiest bit here.
- jeroenhd 8y agoFor the general consumer maybe, but for media distributors the story might be a bit more worrying. Some forms of DRM keep the keys in special areas of the processor such as these and any key leaks might allow for recording or piracy of very stringently controlled content. If the leak is bad enough, the license holder might urge distribution platforms to have certain models of Intel CPU where these exploits are most successful against blocked from playing certain content. I doubt this will happen any time soon but there might just be indirect consequences of such inconsequential data leaks.
- blfr 8y agoIs there any content which was available for streaming yesterday and isn't available on torrents today? DRM stops "casual" pirates. People exploiting CPUs are out of scope.
- 0815test 8y agoTrue to some extent of course, but HD content seems to be better protected. Then again, HD video content also takes up large amounts of bandwidth and storage space (especially with the newer features that are being added over time), which means that we'd expect it to be less common on these platforms anyway.
- EGreg 8y agoThis is why we must all move to end-to-end encryption. We should limit “concentrations of information” just like “Concentrations of power”.
- lima 8y agoClickbait article. Ignore it and read the slides instead: https://i.blackhat.com/asia-19/Thu-March-28/bh-asia-Goryachy-Ermolov-Intel-Visa-Through-the-Rabbit-Hole.pdf https://i.blackhat.com/asia-19/Thu-March-28/bh-asia-Goryachy...
- pytyper2 8y agoIf this is truly for assembly line diagnostics they should add a hardware self destruct to the interlink with those circuits, after VISA serves the intended purpose fry it. Is that a reasonable and technically feasible option?
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "Security researchers have discovered a previously unknown feature in the Intel chipsets, which could allow an attacker to intercept data from the computer memory. The feature called Intel Visualization of Internal Signals Architecture (Intel VISA) is said to be a utility that is bundled by the chipmaker for testing on the manufacturing lines. Although Intel doesn't publicly disclose the existence of Intel VISA and is extremely secretive about it, the researchers were able to find several ways to enable the feature on the Intel chipsets and capture the data from the CPU." Am I the only one reading this and thinking - tho' not surprised - "there's a backdoor baked into Intel chips"?
- peter_d_sherman 8y agohttps://www.blackhat.com/asia-19/briefings/schedule/index.html#intel-visa-through-the-rabbit-hole-13513 https://www.blackhat.com/asia-19/briefings/schedule/index.ht... Excerpt: "The complexity of x86-based systems has become so great that not even specialists can know everything." We need a new CPU manufacturer. One that is built from the ground up on transparency, auditability, accountability, and Einstein's "as simple as possible but no simpler" maxim. Such an entity cannot, CANNOT be a corporation. The reason why such an entity cannot be a corporation is because a corporation is legally bound to the legal structure in the country in which it operates, and that legal structure may create, one way or another, a door for secret agreements / secret hardware modifications between that company and the host government. In other words, transparent, ethical engineers with NO conflicts of interest -- are no longer running the show... Corporate lawyers and Government lawyers are. That has to change in the future...
- SlowRobotAhead 8y ago>Such an entity cannot, CANNOT be a corporation. How would that work? You want a government designed secure processor... why wouldn’t you figure that the reasons they are insecure now is because of gov involvement? If you want an open source processor... that’s cool, and corporations can/are already do that. Now... with any solution proposed, verify to me that the silicon as designed is really the silicon made, esp when talking about 7nm.
- pytyper2 8y agoCan I enter your factory and inspect the dies as they come off the line before they are sealed? If yes, then you could indeed verify the silicon is as designed. Probably just as you could take a chip that does not work and diagnose the problem, this functionality would seem to be necessary to successfully build a chip/chip factory in the first place. How would you troubleshoot the manufacturing process if you couldn't audit the product for quality/accuracy?
- peter_d_sherman 8y agoCompletely random inspections of product in any stage of the manufacturing process by third parties is a good idea. I don't know the practical reality of any company permitting that, but it's a good idea. Some future chip manufacturing group will hopefully do that. Audits of any form at any time by any party should be permitted, rather than denied.
- otakucode 8y agoWhat exactly is 'Orange Mystery'? From the context of the article they make it sound like it is another known vulnerability, but I went looking and can't find anything related with that name.
- scandinavian 8y agoOrange Mystery (their made up name) is an intended way to get JTAG access to TXE if the CPU is in manufacturing mode. Something that only happens if an OEM forgets to turn it off before shipping. This was the case with Intel Macbooks, before it was fixed. Haven't heard of other manufactures making the same mistake.
- Avery3R 8y agoIIRC CS(TXE/ME) are implemented in the pch, not the cpu. It's also pretty common for consumer gaming motherboard manufacturers to leave it on. I know at least MSI and Gigabyte do
- scandinavian 8y agoIt's common for gaming motherboards to leave manufacturing mode on? Got any info on that, can't find anything on google about this.
- peter_d_sherman 8y ago"VISA... it's everywhere you don't want to be..." <g>
- MrXOR 8y agoUndocumented? a bug? No, a backdoor. big brother (NSA, FSB, ...) inside[1]?? There isn't any datasheet/docs about "Intel Visualization of Internal Signals Architecture" on Google! even documented technologies/features like Intel ME and AMT or speculative execution (Spectre/Meltdown) are (were) backdoors, not bugs! We need open (free) source hardwares (PCH, CPU, GPU, ...) with a complete documentation. [1] https://github.com/CHEF-KOCH/NSABlocklist/issues/31 https://github.com/CHEF-KOCH/NSABlocklist/issues/31 [2] https://software.intel.com/sites/default/files/managed/d3/3c/intel-th-developer-manual.pdf https://software.intel.com/sites/default/files/managed/d3/3c...
- userbinator 8y agoIntel underplayed the exploit and told ZDNet that the VISA issue requires physical access to the machines and the Intel-SA-00086 vulnerabilities have already been mitigated. Am I the only one here who thinks "threat model" and isn't all too worried? Physical access = full control, I've long held that belief and am not happy that this freedom is continually being eroded in the name of ever-increasing ridiculous "security" (a lot of it against the user, for things like DRM, as mentioned in one of the other comments here.) Debugging/"test mode" features are basically present in all modern CPUs. I would not bet that Intel is the only one. Edit: such features have been present in CPUs dating back to the late 70s, so perhaps "modern" isn't needed: see http://forum.6502.org/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=3366 http://forum.6502.org/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=3366 and http://e4aws.silverdr.com/hacks/6500_1/ http://e4aws.silverdr.com/hacks/6500_1/
- deathanatos 8y agoThe next sentence in the article, > The researchers however disagreed with Intel's comments and reportedly said in an online discussion that the patched Intel firmware can be downgraded using Intel ME, making the chipset vulnerable and opening the door for accessing Intel VISA. I agree that "physical access" is a threat that I'm not too concerned about¹. But the researchers don't seem to agree that that's the extent of the issue. ¹If physical access means "disassemble the case and do X". If physical access is "two seconds with an exposed USB port", then that's a different matter.
- mirimir 8y agoRackable servers typically have a locking front cover to prevent that. You can buy CoverLocks for desktops.[0] This Kensington USB lock also looks interesting.[1] The keys are unique, by the way. 0) http://www.computersecurity.com/coverlock/ http://www.computersecurity.com/coverlock/ 1) https://www.amazon.com/Kensington-Cable-Guard-Rectangular-K67719US/dp/B001XUQNDY https://www.amazon.com/Kensington-Cable-Guard-Rectangular-K6...
- cm2187 8y agoWith encrypted drives and TPM you can still raise the bar pretty high before physical access means you have control. You may have control of the hardware, but not of what’s running inside.
- dchichkov 8y agoI was re-reading the 2017 AMT story, it is so strange. How is this even possible? https://www.tenable.com/blog/rediscovering-the-intel-amt-vulnerability https://www.tenable.com/blog/rediscovering-the-intel-amt-vul...
- mkup 8y agoI hope this Intel VISA Exploit will shed some light upon inner workings of Intel Management Engine, its memory states, software modules, their undocumented features etc.
- sabas123 8y agoThe slides mention that they are able to unlocked JTAG for IME cores, so I suspect we should be finally be able to do research into it. Personally I'm curious what doors this will open for understanding microcode.
- JudasGoat 8y agoI mean you could look at it as a 20 channel logic analyzer for free...
- snvzz 8y agoDon't trust the hardware RNG, they said. And people pointed fingers and called them paranoid while laughing.
- voldacar 8y agoGiven the scale of some of the recent x86 exploits that went totally unnoticed by massive chipmakers like Intel (thinking mainly Spectre/Meltdown but this is pretty bad too), is it even possible to build a secure x86 processor? Can anyone really say, given the insane pit of complexity that x86 has become?
- int_19h 8y agoThis one is more like a deliberate backdoor that was left not fully secured. It doesn't seem to have anything to do with x86-the-instruction-set. And stuff like Spectre and Meltdown is all about how they chose to implement it - specifically, optimizations. It is very possible to have an x86 CPU that doesn't try to be "smart" at all, and just implements the x86 spec in the most straightforward way possible... so long as you're willing to pay the perf penalty. It looks like we don't.
- nunobrito 8y agoFor some odd reason Twitter does not permit that I share the link to the security disclosure page. I can post youtube videos, cat pictures but the link to this page gets refused. Here is a video of what happens: https://media.giphy.com/media/kiB8T8qeTHCVdUM2oZ/giphy.gif https://media.giphy.com/media/kiB8T8qeTHCVdUM2oZ/giphy.gif Are we in China yet?