9 ms·
The whole AirPower saga is a weird event in product development. AirPower compatibility was highlighted as a feature in the packaging of the just-released AirPo
by minimaxir 8y ago
The whole AirPower saga is a weird event in product development. AirPower compatibility was highlighted as a feature in the packaging of the just-released AirPods 2: https://twitter.com/itsnicolenguyen/status/1110656926965063680 https://twitter.com/itsnicolenguyen/status/11106569269650636...
There has to be something that caused this abrupt cancellation.
- azhenley 8y agoSomething indeed. I don't understand what the issue could be. I have a few $20 wireless chargers that work just fine. I expected Apple to put one in premium packaging and sell it for $150.
- drakenot 8y agoTheir design had many overlapping coils which dynamically could be activated. This design would allow you to place the multiple devices on the mat in any orientation.
- nickthegreek 8y agoKinja posted a deal on a dual powered mat for $35 yesterday. Crazy to think that Apple couldnt crack this to reach some level of product that consumers would find attractive.
- gumby 8y agoThey wanted you to just toss some devices arbitrarily on the mat and have it "just work". The one you discuss requires alignment, like all others -- for a reason! There's a reason the watch has a magnetic alignment setup. I thought you might be able to use a 2D array of small loops but a little bit of modeling shows that to be a pretty dumb idea.
- randyrand 8y agoIn retrospect, I wonder if a motorized device that moves the coils to match the location of your device would have been a better approach.
- canthonytucci 8y agoI had the same thought. I l suspect that Apple has so little in house experience with moving parts these days that they’d have a hard time shipping a good one that worked this way.
- ghaff 8y agoThat’s what you really want to get too. A big charging mat you just toss everything on. TBH I don’t find wireless charging today a particularly big win. It’s a bit easier than plugging in a cable. Of course, in the watch, it eliminates a port which is a win for other reasons.
- covercash 8y agoI find Anker 24w fast charging bricks and 10’ lightening cables are a pretty reasonable way to quickly charge Apple devices while still using them. I bought a cheap 5w wireless charging pad to throw my phone on while I sleep.
- ghaff 8y agoI don’t even bring my wireless charging when I travel. One more piece of gear to pack and keep track of.
- disc 8y agoI wouldn't either but now that I have one one my desk, nightstand, and coffee table; I could never go back.
- ct520 8y agoyeah no thx. With how long devices last me now and days the only thing that will accelerate my trade in would be the extra battery wear from wireless charging.
- Dylan16807 8y agoUnless it's a particularly hot charger, a slower wireless charge is actually better for your battery.
- sovnade 8y agoMy problem is that every charging cable I get seems to fail eventually. Either the charging port in the phone gets loose, filled with lint, or the cable mysteriously stops working. Even expensive Ankers. Meanwhile my no-name QI charger that I bought for my LG G3 like 5 years ago is still working perfectly. No parts to loosen or clog.
- konschubert 8y agoI am curious what you discovered during your modelling. From a first principles point of view it seems to me like it might just work.
- gumby 8y agoIt's hard (very lossy) to try to couple the B fields when the rings are different sizes.
- konschubert 8y agoBut what if they’re all small and all the same size? In a Grid pattern, like streets between city blocks?
- pwthornton 8y agoThat is not remotely related. Having a mat with two or three separated coils for phones is really easy to do. You basically just glue a few of these together. AirPower was intended to have basically an entire surface of charging pixels. You could place phones, watches, AirPods, and combos of those on the mat in any orientation. There was also no sweetspot. By attemping to make inductive charging mats work really well, Apple ran into some big tech contraints.
- sandis 8y agoThe article mentions (rumored) issues with 3D/overlapping coils that I imagine were needed to allow for multiple device placement anywhere on the mat. >> Specifically, I’ve heard that they ran too hot because the 3D charging coils in close proximity to one another required very, very cautious power management.
- Dylan16807 8y agoIt's not the end of the world if it slows down under multiple devices, and that trivially solves the heat problem. Is it lack of satisfaction with those tradeoffs? Is there a more fundamental flaw somewhere else? It would be nice to know what actually caused this decision.
- skellera 8y agoSelling point is that you can put all your mobile devices on it. So it’s assumed you’re using more than one and it isn’t a quality experience if you have to sacrifice charging speed for regular use.
- Dylan16807 8y agoThe phone is the only one that needs a particularly high wattage. If sharing drops the phone speed by a third, that leaves enough spare capacity to do a watch and airpods at the same time (with both of them getting more percent per hour than the phone). That's still a pretty good experience.
- MBCook 8y agoWhat if they couldn’t get the multi coil design to work charging ANYTHING at high power. Maybe it was capable of charging the watch and the AirPods just fine, it was the phone’s power demands that were the thing killing it.
- Dylan16807 8y ago
- sovnade 8y agoApple's plan was to let you place it anywhere on the mat, not on the very small charging sweet-spot. Worth the huge premium it would've sold for? Probably not for a good deal of people, but it would've sold.
- martin-adams 8y agoMakes me wonder if they couldn't get around any patents as wireless charging isn't a new innovation.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- smacktoward 8y agoIt's probably a huge coincidence that https://isairpoweroutyet.com/ https://isairpoweroutyet.com/ launched a week ago. (Probably.)
- RobLach 8y agoIt’s not weird at all. AirPower is a feature that helps sell those AirPods amongst early adopters who would buy AirPods within the first couple of weeks. If you want to kill AirPower, waiting a bit to grab those sales makes sense. You don’t have much to lose and revenue to gain.
- raverbashing 8y ago> There has to be something that caused this abrupt cancellation. Well, there is no way of getting 30W wirelessly (to the device side) without a lot of heat. I guess someone thought they could solve this with smarter power management (and per the John Gruber article this was an issue last year, or even before) but it frankly it does not seem possible (unless Apple discovered room temperature superconductors). It seems the design teams might have some people (higher ups) thinking too much about design and too little about if things are really possible given the constraints of a consumer product (typical MBA BS motivational pushes asides). But it seems they managed to save face before another poor product would hit the shelves.
- Tempest1981 8y agoBuild a Dyson cooling toroid around it? (Said the design team)
- fogetti 8y agoI am not sure why are you downvoted. There is a whole literature on mismanaged software/hardware projects and the culprits of those failures. Not in a small part the reason is often very bad management/design decisions.
- stephenamills 8y agoYeah, you're almost definitely right. Apple is an extremely design-first company, in the sense that the designers have always run the company. This isn't the first time that sticking to a design led to a technical hardware/physics problem. This happened originally when Steven was designing the iPhone 4 with his team and took out most of the antenna lines, leaving only a small antenna line at the top and not the noticeable ugly antenna lines you see on every single iPhone today. Steven's antenna design was incredibly simple and aesthetically pleasing - just one of several incredible advances of the iPhone 4 - but Steven's antenna design led to some radio frequency problems I definitely don't understand which caused the entire "you're holding it wrong" scandal. That is just another example from 2011 or so of designers running the company but running into a technical issue with the laws of physics - there it was just radio frequencies instead of whatever it is here with this AirPower and the the heat or frequencies or something created from the as many as possibly 15 or 32 coils inside of it. There are so so so many examples of where this design-first approach has definitely worked. One example is how the external aluminum case of the 2-pound MacBook from 2015 was designed first, and then once lithium ion batteries were created which had to be custom and have a custom internal chemistry so that they could be stacked on top of each other in a terraced structure. A second example is in Face ID which is very fast and simple conceptually but technically requires a custom chip running a custom neural network and for PrimeSense to miniaturize their Kinect hardware that they created for the Xbox into a the super small menu bar of the iPhone X. The chip team and the PrimeSense team started with a simple concept/design of a user looking at their iPhone, and then filled in all of the extremely technical and multi-disciplinary practicalities. When you start doing something that nobody has done before, you absolutely do not know that it can work. You will fail in every way – Jonathan mentioned that when they were creating Face ID, all that they had for such a long time were failed engineering designs that simply put did not work. Nobody knew that you could miniaturize the Kinect hardware, or that this chip could actually run their custom neural network quickly and with low power consumption to get Face ID. But you can. For MacBook batteries, if you mess the chemistry of these batteries up, the batteries will absolutely explode just like Samsung's did the following year. Nobody knew that you could stack the batteries of a MacBook on top of each other either. But you can. Nobody knew that you could remove most of the ugly antenna lines on an iPhone and just place just one antenna line at the top. Oh wait, but you can't. Nobody knew that you could charge 3 devices at the same time within whatever FCC regulations and still maintain low heat. Oh wait, but you can't (I guess, if that's the problem). The point is that whenever you're doing something that nobody else in the world has done, you can't know it's going to work and you will fail. You will succeed but you will also fail, if you are truly doing creative work. Here, Apple failed. I guess because what they finished in the lab was possible according to the laws of physics but not safe (coils might overheat and catch fire or melt, might explode, might stop a person's pacemaker, and so on).
- philwelch 8y agoIf they were gonna do it after the AirPods 2 release, they would have to do it ASAP, or else they'd either have to do extended refunds (and have extra return inventory of an unwanted product) or face a class-action suit from disgruntled AirPods 2 buyers who were promised compatibility with a now-cancelled product.
- _bxg1 8y agoEspecially weird for Apple, who aren't known for vaporware. And even Google wouldn't come out and say "we can't make this work", they'd just stop talking about it until it was eventually solvable down the line, or let it evaporate altogether. It's very odd to see a tech giant just hit a technological wall.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- spullara 8y agoThis sets appropriate expectations. If they don't know when it will reach the quality that they want to ship it is better to cancel it.
- squarefoot 8y agoMy guess is that it's not about quality but efficiency. Assuming the product works as advertised, someone might have pointed out that the power drawn is a lot more than the power supplied to the devices being charged (which to some extent is true for every wireless charger out there), and in a world where being sensitive to green issues is becoming the norm, this might have brought some bad press to Apple.
- MBCook 8y ago> Assuming the product works as advertised The rumors are that it didn’t work as advertised, or even at all. Or when it did it could get hot and catch on fire. I think Occam’s razor applies here.
- rickyc091 8y agoI appreciate that Apple was honest with their communication. Too often have I seen managers/CEOs employ the strategy of avoiding the hard conversation and letting the topic fade away.
- Noctem 8y ago
- duxup 8y agoThat's what always confused me about this. This was very much an announced thing, not some side research project.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- FPGAhacker 8y agoI’m guessing patents.
- notatoad 8y agoI'm guessing the unexpected hype was what caused the "cancellation", and AirPower isn't really any more cancelled than it was yesterday. I'm imagining some engineering teem at Apple telling their bosses "yeah, it's almost ready" and the bosses believing them without really caring, because it's just a silly accessory and no big deal, right? And then since the AirPods 2 announcemen, the internet has been rabid with anticipation for AirPower. announcing it is cancelled is a better PR move than letting that internet fanboy frenzy turn into frustration with delays. I wouldn't be surprised if we see AirPower turn up again in a years time.
- save_ferris 8y agoThis doesn't make much sense to me. Apple is the tech marketing messiah, why would they announce AirPower at a major product demo and think that it somehow wouldn't be hyped? This is a really strange fumble for them. It was also listed as a major feature for the new AirPods, that doesn't seem like something Apple would slap on a box knowing they probably weren't going to ship, especially if was a "silly accessory." I can totally see an engineering team BSing leadership on the product readiness, but there had to be internal pressure on this. Apple knows this looks bad after investors weren't super impressed with the News+ demo.
- chrischen 8y agoThey overpromised and didn’t deliver, to avoid under delivering.
- acomjean 8y agoI think the mea-culpa announcement "This isn't going to be shipped", is better than stringing it along for months and leaving people in the dark. Your right though, their main problem was announcing it too early. There are probably legal ramifications to this. Back in the day "intelivision" announced a keyboard component for their console in ads. They didn't ship.. It kept slipping. Then the FTC (government) started fining them for false advertising. So they finally released one (It was junk, we had one). "Complaints from consumers who had chosen to buy the Intellivision specifically on the promise of a "coming soon" personal-computer upgrade, eventually caught the attention of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), who started investigating Mattel Electronics for fraud and false advertising. " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellivision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellivision
- mackey 8y agoI saw a report on twitter with serial numbers showing build dates of September and November, along with old copyright dates on the boxes on the new AirPods. Combine that with the "Hey Siri" being shown in "Gather Round" video in September, I bet they were hoping to ship the AirPods before the holidays, but were holding out hope that Airpower would work. https://twitter.com/rouven81/status/1110980080170340352 https://twitter.com/rouven81/status/1110980080170340352 https://www.macrumors.com/2018/09/12/apple-hey-siri-support-airpods/ https://www.macrumors.com/2018/09/12/apple-hey-siri-support-...
- golem14 8y agoMy completely uneducated guess is a behind-the-scenes patent dispute or something along those lines...
- sovnade 8y agoIFixit has a good article on it. Basically they couldn't get it to pass wireless emissions standards the way they wanted to do it (put your phone anywhere on the pad to charge not, not directly on the circle, etc).
- Calcite 8y agoLink: https://ifixit.org/blog/14883/what-finally-killed-airpower/ https://ifixit.org/blog/14883/what-finally-killed-airpower/
- georgespencer 8y agoWould be quite rare for a patent dispute to go on behind the scenes. There were a lot of leaks suggesting mass production was due to start. I would bet production did not start, and that early production runs had low yields due to the complexity of the product.
- speedplane 8y ago> Would be quite rare for a patent dispute to go on behind the scenes. Actually the opposite. Most patent disputes are resolved behind the scenes, long before anyone sues each other.
- aluminussoma 8y agoYou are assuming that Apple has great cross-team communication. By many reports, they do not: I've heard that one team does not know what another team is working on, much less the status of that project.
- HeWhoLurksLate 8y agoIt's a Big Tech Corp with known spies in it. You expect everything to be shared? Inter-team communication is just generally bad these days, and mostly because it tends to be the default human behavior. I remember reading a couple of articles about Bell Labs and how they had a huge cafeteria everyone was encouraged to eat in, thereby promoting cross-communication and "cross-pollination" of ideas and insight. I kinda wonder what the Big Tech companies would be producing now and at what rate if they did that instead of letting or encouraging everyone to sit at their desks all day long (mind you, Google seems to be pretty good about that part.)
- developer2 8y ago> with known spies in it Worse than a simple information "spy" would be having a security engineer with intimate knowledge of Apple's security leave the company to co-found a new company whose entire business model is to sell expensive hardware to law enforcement that bypasses Apple's security. Oh right, that actually happened[1]. An Apple security engineer discovered–or baked in–critical security flaws at one of the world's largest technology companies and instead of disclosing them to the company, co-opted that sensitive insider information to start his own lucrative business. I've been waiting for news of this man's reputation, career, finances, and perhaps even his freedom having been taken away; so far it seems he's gotten away with it. I don't buy the apologist explanation I've heard: "he's likely just so good at his profession that he reverse engineered entirely new vulnerabilities after leaving Apple, without necessarily having exfiltrated knowledge only obtainable from within Apple's own walls". If this man had done this to a bank or the government, he'd be rotting in federal prison. But he "only" expropriated this information from a private corporation, so no big deal. /s [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2018/07/26/apple-ios-security-boost-not-stopping-cops-hacking-iphones/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2018/07/26/apple...
- ksec 8y ago>There has to be something that caused this abrupt cancellation. They could have sold a Wireless Charger just like others with their mark up. Instead we got nothing. Also admitting MacBook Pro Keyboard Failure. I believe there is something happening to Hardware Engineering in general.
- AceJohnny2 8y agoMethinks HWEng made a breach in Industrial Design's north flank, and provoked a rout. The tide is turning!
- captaincrowbar 8y ago“Oh my god! The engineers are revolting!” “You’ve worked here all these years and you only just noticed that?”
- usrusr 8y agoLove the picture, but I think it's the opposite: engineering's defence of the announce-o-tron went down for a moment, design pushed into the breach and gained a brief moment of unsupervised access. Now they face the consequences.
- AceJohnny2 8y agoYou're giving me flashbacks of Tesla's beleaguered engineering team.
- hinkley 8y agoThat's not even on the box it's on a sticker on the box. Buy some new stickers and bin the old rolls!
- kwiens 8y agoMy theory: they couldn't make it past the FCC. Managing overlapping harmonic frequencies is incredibly challenging, and gets harder the more coils that you are integrating. From patent filings, it looks like Apple’s ambitious plan was to use considerably more coils than other charging pads on the market. https://ifixit.org/blog/14883/what-finally-killed-airpower/ https://ifixit.org/blog/14883/what-finally-killed-airpower/
- samstave 8y agoHow would you compare AirPower with Cue::cat?
- paul7986 8y agoThey canceled it because the iPhone is going to become a wireless charging pad for your AirPods, watch and even another iPhone. Samsung just released Wireless PowerShare as a feature in the S10 that allows you to share a charge and reports note this will be coming to the iPhone. Incidentally and FML ... I was filmed pitching this idea to Intel and Mark Burnett (reality tv mega-producer) for the reality tv show, America's Greatest Makers. They reached out to me as they really needed fledging inventors. Overall we pitched sharing battery power between two phone cases https://ryanspahn.com/GetLeech https://ryanspahn.com/GetLeech . I haven't looked but if Intel has patents that are from Sept 2015 and on then really FML. Otherwise what I thought was potentially a completely unique idea wasn't.