18 ms·
F-35's Towed Decoys
- maxxxxx 8y agoAfter a lot of bad news about the F35 it seems the PR effort has started to make it look better. Lots of positive articles about it all of a sudden.
- nerdponx 8y agoFrom a purely technological perspective, it's always been pretty damn cool.
- UweSchmidt 8y agoHN is a small, but not unimportant battlefield in the global information war.
- duxup 8y agoI was recently in western China and it's nothing like people say it is. It is very peaceful and I don't have to wear my backpack facing forward and worry about thieves like I do when I'm in Ameri ---- oops wrong story. In all seriousness, this article is pretty interesting and kinda stands on its own.
- ArtDev 8y agoYou should also visit Tibet. There are roadblocks and military everywhere. It is bizarre. Once I saw drunken Chinese soldiers spinning circles in the middle of a small town with a stolen tractor. Super weird scene. The locals were not happy about it. I had the sense that mainland China IS pretty safe from petty theft because all the police. However, what is up with all the open prostitution when is it supposed to be illegal? What were we talking about?
- DangitBobby 8y agoIt's just as likely that there were negative opinions created for your impression, and way people actually feel is coming to light. Disinformation cuts both ways.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoSystems get better with refinement. The F35 is getting into the "mature technology" part of the progress curve now so it's naturally going to look better. It took a lot of money to get there but we're starting to see more positive results. People are more likely to submit what they're reading if a similar post has already proven to be popular. Overall JSF program aside, this is a fairly interesting and in depth (at least for this audience, this is probably just a high level overview to someone who works on electronic warfare technology) article on a particular subsystem so why wouldn't it be popular here?
- eatonphil 8y agoMy impression is that there are two things at play: 1) Once you've noticed something, you tend to notice it more often. 2) Novel (or uncommon) articles on HN that get to the front page tend to attract other articles on the same topic. I can imagine this along the lines of: Human 1: Hey apparently there's an audience on HN for topic X that I enjoy! I wonder if HN is also interested in this related article on topic X. Or Human 2: Hey here's this interesting related article I discovered while looking at front-page article Y on topic X. The summary of all of this is to say that my guess is that like attracts like and uncommon topics die down fairly quickly in time. I imagine that it is less of a concerted effort by stakeholders to push and direct topic X than just the effects of a curious and diverse group.
- locklock 8y agoOn the other hand, this is the second positive article on this plane to hit the top of hacker news in 3 days [1]. A trillion dollar plane that is notorious for costing way too much probably has a pretty decent marketing budget behind it, and it's not very difficult to assume that these articles are part of that somehow. For an article that came out before this recent press rollout began, try this one: "The F-35 Is a $1.4T National Disaster" article: https://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/the-f-35-14-trillion-dollar-national-disaster-19985 https://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/the-f-35-14-trill... HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16869679 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16869679 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19506763 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19506763
- drstewart 8y ago>"The F-35 Is a $1.4T National Disaster" A trillion dollar plane that's cutting edge probably has a pretty decent opposition market budget behind it from adversarial nations, and it's not very difficult to assume that these articles are part of that somehow.
- rhizome 8y agono, it really is that ridiculous.
- thunderbird120 8y agoIt's actually been getting lots of good press for quite a while now if you follow defense news, mostly due to very good performance in wargames exercises and serious problems being resolved. That said, it's somewhat bizarre seeing a bunch of articles related to it on HN. This is really not the kind of community which usually follows that kind of thing closely. /r/CredibleDefense over on reddit is much more suited to discussions about this kind of thing.
- jjoonathan 8y agoThis has happened to me a few times before following a single boredom-induced chumbox click. Advanced military toys are always good for nerd sniping, recommender algorithms know this, and they will eagerly amplify a small amount of demonstrated interest into a deluge of recommendations. I'm pretty sure that's what's happening here. So yes, it's certainly a bought and paid for PR effort, but I wouldn't conclude that it's localized in time, just that HN recently wandered into it. Now, if you'll excuse me, I'll take my leave to go read about the fabulous toys my tax dollars are paying for.
- codeisawesome 8y agoYour comment made me feel like HN needs a “give gold” system. Proceeds could go to funding startups =)
- peteretep 8y ago> Advanced military toys are always good for nerd sniping That and active measures. Eroding public support for your enemy's shiny new military hardware is a cheap way to destroy morale and increase the chances it'll get cancelled.
- themodelplumber 8y agoThe "positive" articles are at least talking about the F-35's attributes as they relate to its primary mission of SEAD. To me this is a recovery of some signal against all the previous noise, wherein we wondered if the F-35 was the all-around best fighter ever, and if not why not, etc.
- aurailious 8y agoIt wouldn't surprise me if things changed and its actually good now.
- partiallypro 8y agoI always found the F-35 "bad" news to be agenda driven, possibly by a foreign actor. The people I know in the Air Force are fans of the F-35, but the media never has been. I think there are certainly cost overruns, etc that deserve coverage...but I am always struck by the negative opinion even the most common person has of the fighter just from headlines, that in some cases are misleading. I just can't shake the feeling that some of it is manufactured. I could be wrong, but it has certainly felt that way to me. So, it wouldn't surprise me if the DoD is doing a bit of a PR push to restore public faith in the project.
- ken 8y agoIt's $100,000,000 per aircraft, and US military spending is bigger than the next 7 countries combined. The news stories I've read about America in the past year are about how our water pipes are still full of lead, people are dying of gun violence, and government workers who live paycheck-to-paycheck got hurt by the shutdown. I don't need a foreign actor to explain why people in America today are unsympathetic to a new technologically advanced fighter jet. Even the foreign threats of today aren't the type where air superiority would help at all.
- sgc 8y agoAir superiority is the defining aspect of modern war. Whoever owns the skies wins. Whatever one's opinion on the FXX planes, the goal of maintaining air superiority into the future is completely obvious and necessary.
- WJW 8y agoWell, only if you can keep fighting a defined enemy who is at all vulnerable to a traditional conflict. An enemy who is globally distributed and just targets vulnerable energy and water infrastructure over the internet is much less targetable with air power.
- bordercases 8y agoBut if you don't keep up at least a modicum of pretense for building air superiority, you will have two problems. In the case of domestic extremism the theatre gets pushed to surveillance + communication monitoring.
- Symmetry 8y agoEvery new fighter the US has added since 1970 has followed the same pattern so it's not surprising. At least the F-35 hasn't killed a bunch of pilots like the F-14 did before they worked the kinks out.
- shin_lao 8y agoThe aircraft is likely to be very capable and since it embeds so much new technology delays and problems are not something surprising. Most of the negative coverage is more around that such very expensive aircraft (and program) may not be that useful, for example, to fight terrorism or low-tech nations (and like another person mentioned in this thread, there may be more pressing matters in the US). In the longer term however, it can be argued that maintaining that kind of advanced aerial capability may be paramount to keep balance vs countries like China. And if you think the F-35 is too expensive, check out the F-22 which was purely air superiority!
- Kadin 8y agoSorta makes sense -- it was subject to a lot of bad publicity for a long time, because all anybody knew of it was that it cost a lot, and didn't work well. That's kinda true of any product when it's in its final stage of development: there's a lot of money sunk into it at that point, and if you brought a user (or investor) in, they might question what the hell is going on if they don't have the right level of expectations set in advance (which by and large the public doesn't). Now that the thing is actually flying, and we're starting to hear from pilots and people have gotten to see it at airshows, etc., naturally it's getting better press. This is the payoff, it's what the thing is designed to do. So it better damn well fly well and look good doing it. There's still an open question and a debate to be had about whether the aircraft is WORTH the insane cost, and WHY the damn thing cost so much to begin with, though. I suspect it's like most things American at the moment -- we pay far too much, and get far too little for our money, compared to literally anyone else on the planet who might choose to build the same thing. (See also: healthcare, education, public transportation, physical infrastructure... we pay more and get less. Military equipment is no exception.) But yeah, I'd expect to see better press now than when the thing was all but vaporware and a big bill.
- adventured 8y ago> There's still an open question and a debate to be had about whether the aircraft is WORTH the insane cost, and WHY the damn thing cost so much to begin with There's no question about why it costs so much. The cost is including ~3,000 planes and covers up to 2070 in maintenance costs. That's a ridiculous number of planes to be maintained for decades. We'll never come close to building 3,000 however, the program will end long before that. Russia's new Su-57 planes are at least $50 million each. Their GDP per capita is 1/6th that of the US. Imagine paying for that if you're them. Equivalent to $300 million in the US economy, except Russia is a very poor nation and can't rationally afford anything close to spending even $50m per plane. Let's go with Russia's $50m number however. 3,000 planes at $50m = $150 billion just to get them built. Russia would probably spend another $600 billion maintaining those planes over four decades. The F35 unit cost is around $80 to $110 million depending on the version. The US is getting a stellar deal in scope to its economy compared to what the Russians are spending on their latest planes. The MiG-35 will cost at least double what the last MiG-29 variation did, or around $40 million. $240 million when adjusted to US per capita output figures. For Russia it's even worse if we look at the absolute scale of their economy (from which the cost of those planes must come out of), a mere $1.6 trillion, or nearly 1/13th the size of the US economy. If you adjust the cost on that basis, it's like the US spending $650 million per F35. Nobody would think that's a deal. Russia isn't even remotely close to matching the US in adjusted terms on its new jet costs, their wild spending is on another planet entirely. The Chengdu J-20 looks to cost $50 million per unit or more. That's in China, where they should be able to do everything radically cheaper than the US, and where they also have a GDP per capita 1/6th that of the US. $50 million is an astronomical sum for them to be spending per plane based on their economy. Or if we adjust based on the absolute size of their economy (the US economy is roughly 47-50% larger), it still pushes that unit cost up near the cheapest F35 variant. The Eurofighter Typhoon, an older plane, costs as much per unit as the F35. I'm not seeing any evidence that the F35 is expensive compared to other jets in the latest generation when you adjust for the US economic output level.
- lvs 8y agoAnd it's all from the same URL, showing up on successive days on HN.
- Haga 8y agoTime to write one about the enormous waste of funds for PR on this project.
- CodeSheikh 8y agoOne thing that has often puzzled me is the effectiveness of an expensive fighter jet against inexpensive adversaries in a face to face dogfight. For example F-35 costs in upwards of $90 Million per unit. Chinese J-10 or JF-17 are $20 or $25 Million per unit. That's 3 fighters for one F-35. So is one expensive F-35 capable enough of taking on 3 cheaper (yet sophisticated enough jets read up on JF-17 recent achievements)? Granted pilots and ground crew on both sides are equal match in skills.
- e1ven 8y agoIt's not just about raw effectiveness per dollar. Lost lives hurt morale quite a bit, and play badly on domestic news.
- mcny 8y ago>> Lost lives hurt morale quite a bit, and play badly on domestic news. I don't follow military news but even I know that US military lagged YEARS behind private contractors in adding ground transport for troops that were safer against road-side bombs during the first few years of the Iraq War starting in 2003.
- saiya-jin 8y agoPlus they used to say it takes cca 1 million $ to train a fighter pilot from scratch properly, and god knows how long. this was quite some time ago, so I expect both cost and duration of training must be higher/longer now
- duxup 8y agoI wonder the same. Also the price means you have fewer jets. If there is a tech flaw and handful get shot down... you're really low on jets. I can't imagine we 100% know how effective all this tech is. We've seen how much ground warfare changed where the Humvee was found to be severely lacking, the US found that lots of high explosive bombs were less desirable now and very low explosive accurate bombs were needed. I almost wonder if a two tiered system would be better. Top of the line, then high volume lower line where tech trickles down over time. This would especially be handy in situations where you have air superiority and ... now still have a lot of work in the air to do, don't need expensive planes to do it, and really just want high volume coverage.
- ptero 8y agoSorry, but this reads like a cheap infomercial to me. Nothing wrong with extra advertising I guess (other than the fact that it is likely in the end charged to the taxpayer), but I just cannot help translating things like "The fusion of information ... degrades a stealthy aircraft's ability to remain undetected" to "this was cutting edge stealth when conceived, but as aircraft has been in the works for so long (work started 1992, first flight 2006) its stealth is kind of useless now. We have to depend on towed decoys :(
- ben7799 8y agoThis is a really interesting article. Having been interested in aviation for a long time I was not aware of these. Fascinating stuff. A much fancier version of chaff & flares. Reminiscent of submarine warfare.
- themark 8y agoSeems like something the military would want to keep close to their chest. I am amazed that things like this are allowed to be in the public domain.
- dajohnson89 8y agoyeah, i tend to agree. i get that it's good pr, but is it worth it to declassify these capabilities?
- dba7dba 8y agoMy gut reaction is they would like to, but they realize enough of the information is already out due to carelessness, spying, etc. So they just decide to release some information, with some FUD mixed in.
- openasocket 8y agoThere's a couple things to keep in mind here. First is that the basic concept here isn't new. We've had towed decoys of some sort or another in use since the 1990s. Second is that there's very little here in the way of details, and you'd need to know a lot of specifics to be able to counter this sort of technology. Finally, there are actual advantages to letting information like this get out, as it can act as a deterrent. With technology like this, there's some calculus you have to do about the risks and rewards, taking into account the odds of an adversary copying or countering it, the value of it as a deterrent, the expense/difficulty of keeping it secret, etc.
- swasheck 8y agoEver since the SR-71 piece a few days ago (in which there are some disparaging F-35 comments), there have been a few submissions on the F-35 that appear to attempt to bolster its reputation.
- diminoten 8y agoI think it might just be on people's minds, is all.
- adolph 8y agoPersonally I have no opinion on the F-35 and its reputation other than time will tell and people other than me seem very invested in it one way or another. I think the article as an overview of towed decoys in general is interesting and a not very well covered topic.
- stcredzero 8y agoThe US has "little buddies." Australia is looking to build "Loyal Wingmen." (Autonomous drones) https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/26/australia/australia-artificial-intelligence-boeing-drone/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/26/australia/australia-artificia...
- lwansbrough 8y agoI wonder what role AI/CV has in identifying and ignoring towed decoys in modern weapons systems (either allied or adversarial.)
- dba7dba 8y agoIf you'd like to read how the towed decoys are used in real life (F16 in this case), be sure to check out book "Viper Pilot: A Memoir of Air Combat" by Dan Hampton. The desc of the book includes: 151 combat missions, 21 hard kills on surface-to-air-missile sites, 4 Distinguished Flying Crosses with Valor, 1 Purple Heart. I've been into historical aspects of war/plane/ship/weapon so I've read lots of books and viewed many pics/videos related. However I had never heard of towed decoys off of a modern fighter jet like F16 until reading above book. The book is awesome to read if you are into that kind of stuff. I remember reading in the book where he talks about getting into a fight with the towed decoy deployed. When he was out of the fight and tried to tow in the decoy, it was gone. Meaning it had done its job and sacrificed itself and therefore saved the F16 itself. Btw, there's been lots of discussion of MCAS on Boeing 737 MAX and how some are uneasy that software HAS to be involved for 737 MAX to stay airborne at certain times. I believe F16 was first production fighter jet where computer has to be involved in controlling every moment it's airborne. If computers on it stopped working, F16 will supposedly stop being a flying object almost immediately.
- bdavis__ 8y agothus the nickname of the plane. the 'lawn dart'
- jaytaylor 8y agoTFA includes this image of an F-35 underbelly: https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/the-drive-cms-content-staging/message-editor/1553810000189-dadadac.jpg https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/the-drive-cms-content-sta... The exotic curves are visually exquisite, and I'm curious what the production and fabrication technique and processes are. Particularly for the jet engine housing. Is it comprised of a few large sheets, or many smaller pieces? Not sure how to get the curvature and bends consistently correct within tolerance limits for large sheets. It seems like it would be extremely challenging. It looks like it might be titanium? If you know about this or have ideas, please do tell! P.S. What a cool read! This is the type of article I come to hacker news hoping to find :)
- ghostly_s 8y agoAny reason they couldn't just stamp, then CNC route the final profile for high tolerance?
- Gravityloss 8y agoI don't know if it works the same way for titanium but aluminium has been shaped like this for aircraft. https://boingboing.net/2012/02/13/machines.html https://boingboing.net/2012/02/13/machines.html
- craftyguy 8y agoWho said it was made of titanium?
- Green_man 8y agoI had thought that fighter jets used more specific aluminum alloys than titanium, but I found this on the f-35 specifically (Bruce Tanner is Lockheed Martin's CFO): "Tanner says Lockheed uses more aluminum than steel on its aircraft projects, which in addition to the F-35, include the C-130 cargo plane, and F-16 fighter. And the F-35 uses more titanium than aluminum and steel, he said. " https://www.defenseone.com/business/2018/03/how-much-do-americas-arms-makers-depend-foreign-metal-no-one-seems-know/146579/ https://www.defenseone.com/business/2018/03/how-much-do-amer...
- dmitryminkovsky 8y agoLots of talk about the F-35 here lately and I've been meaning to ask if anyone caught the PBS NOVA "Battle of the X-Planes" about it back in 2003 [0][1]. It's a really interesting take on the program from that era. And it really shows you the complexity of building this aircraft. I saw it in high school and it made me want to major in aerospace engineering. That didn't happen, but I always think about this show and wonder if people have seen it when the F-35 is mentioned. [0]: https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/xplanes/about.html https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/xplanes/about.html [1]: https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1ft1qf https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1ft1qf
- zepearl 8y agoI guess that once total stealth has been maxed in the "reflective" research-area, the next effective defensive would be some wide-ground arrays pointing to at least 1 satellite (making satellite techno a must) => as soon as at least 1 of the emitting array does not reach the satellite (of course something more complicated to avoid man-in-the-middle-attack, interference, etc...) it would mean that something flew through it... .
- Zelizz 8y agoHow well would a towed decoy be able to fool a missile equipped with a camera and a neural net trained on pictures of fighter jets? Are the distances and speeds too extreme for a visible light camera? Is there some technology to "blind" a visible light camera?
- NullPrefix 8y ago>pictures of fighter jets You mean pictures of fighter jet backs?
- bdavis__ 8y agomissiles work with radar signature or heat signature, not the visible spectrum. and yes, there are countermeasures available to 'blind' an IR sensor (like those used on short range A/A missiles)
- Zelizz 8y agoRight, I know that you’d want to use radar for longer distances, but if the towed decoy is meant to appear as a juicy target, to take a hit for the fighter, couldn’t you just follow it until you’re in close range, and then switch to a better discriminating sensor (visible light camera in my example) to hit the jet instead?