19 ms·
Tim Berners-Lee: 'Stop web's downward plunge to dysfunctional future'
- wormy425 8y agoI have not been always been endeared to what TBL thinks the web should be. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/07/amid-unprecedented-controversy-w3c-greenlights-drm-web https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/07/amid-unprecedented-con...
- nicpottier 8y agoTim's letter: https://webfoundation.org/2019/03/web-birthday-30/ https://webfoundation.org/2019/03/web-birthday-30/ I actually thought it was pretty carefully worded and not super alarmist (despite the BBC headline). I personally think it is worse than he presents it. Perhaps it is just nostalgia, but today's web / internet seems to have given up on open standards and cooperation. Instead most of the money and effort is going into figuring out how to capture people in a walled garden such as Facebook etc.. so you can mine their data and advertise to them. For all its downsides, Bitcoin is the last exciting open standard I can remember that has done well and maybe has a future. We seem to have failed as a community to solve chat with an open standard (that has broken out enough to win), which is a serious shame. That's a hugely important medium today and we have essentially handed that to WhatsApp / Facebook / whoever. Imagine if we had done the same with email or the web itself. I wonder if it is just a cultural difference somehow. The Stalman's of the world seem farther and farther apart, or perhaps just the internet has become so monetized that the best talent just can't refuse the $$$s from a FANG job that focuses on crushing the competition and owning everything. I don't know, but it makes me sad.
- pmoriarty 8y ago"today's web / internet seems to have given up on open standards and cooperation. Instead most of the money and effort is going into figuring out how to capture people in a walled garden such as Facebook etc.. so you can mine their data and advertise to them." How are open standards and cooperation supposed to stop tracking and advertising? Tracking and unsolicited advertising should be tackled head on: by banning them.
- bhl 8y agoIdeally, open standards would mean that the network effects, which today keep people trapped in walled gardens like Facebook, would create a more distributed / federated community instead of a winner-takes-all model. I think this is largely true, since if you could still communicate with your friends and family on Facebook but be on a different paid platform which doesn't track or advertise products to you, most people would go for it.
- nicpottier 8y agoRight, exactly. You can choose a different email provider if you hate the ads or what your current one is doing with your data. You can't pick a different Facebook and still communicate with your friends there.
- pmoriarty 8y agoYou can pick a different one, but if they're all spying on you, tracking you, and advertising to you, it's not really going to make a difference. Also, splitting up Facebook alone isn't going to stop data sharing between its various parts, nor is it going to address tracking or advertising at all.
- nilskidoo 8y agoBut we can count the moments til a sacrificial lamb pops up, as with Bernie Madoff, or the epipen guy for pharma. Token examples without stopping the potential for their crimes to be repeated by everyone else in practice in the slightest. We need to uninvent the wheel.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThat will be a problem as you can't unring a bell - it is far easier to unscramble an egg.
- bhl 8y ago
- sn41 8y agoWalled gardens are partly due to the emergence of huge corporations who harvest and aggregate personal data to build profiles ostensibly to aid advertising. I find this baffling - traditional shopkeepers never used to ask for the personal details of the customers. That's why the phrase "it's just business" makes sense. Elizabeth Warren seems to have spoken of breaking up some of Facebook and Google. This might be the only way to combat the data hawkishness of corporate leaders like Eric Schmidt.
- zdragnar 8y ago> traditional shopkeepers never used to ask for the personal details of the customers Based on that statement, it sounds like you never lived in a small town, or you lived in a twilight zone version of one.
- 908087 8y agoI've never been to a small town where the shopkeeper asks for my address book and to briefly scan my personal communications for keywords "to improve our services and deliver a more relevant shopping experience".
- JohnFen 8y agoI don't know, I've lived in a few real-world small towns and have never had a shopkeeper ask for personal details as part of a transaction.
- onion2k 8y agoWalled gardens are partly due to the emergence of huge corporations who harvest and aggregate personal data to build profiles ostensibly to aid advertising. The FAANG companies built surveillance networks to target adverts at the beginning, but I think things have changed so much that advertising is just one of many uses of the surveillance data now. Take Android's location tracking as an example; Google doesn't need minute-by-minute location information of where everyone is to sell more adverts. They gather that data, and use it in Maps for live traffic tracking which is ostensibly useful, but it's not for advertising. These companies are at the point now where they soak up whatever data they can get just in case they can think of a use for it in the future. Advertising is the excuse, not the reason.
- mikekchar 8y agoEvery once in a while I feel the same way. It's hard to reply to this sentiment, though, because I think there is also a lot of wishful thinking mixed in. Years ago, standards processes were as much about screwing your competition as it was about cooperation. Take the telephone protocol standards. They are open, but the idea was always to rush an implementation that was different from your competition, push through that implementation in the standards committee and then force your competition to rewrite their code. The early days of web "standards" went that way as well (as I'm sure many people will remember). However, the other thing to keep in mind is that proprietary solutions designed to force customers into vendor lock-in has always been the dominant situation. In fact, things are dramatically better than they were ages ago. Things like TCP/IP were not the solutions that the big vendors wanted. They wanted their walled gardens (and worked hard to produce them). Even HTTP and the web only became popular because of NCSA Mosaic, which was proprietary software. It's also interesting to see the list of original licencees [1] The only company that currently exists is Fujitsu. Netscape Navigator was written by many of the same authors as Mosaic and they only decided to open source it in 1998 -- a move that literally shocked the development world. This eventually led to Mozilla. Back in the day, people "in the know" knew about free software, the FSF, Emacs, Vi/Vim, Posix, etc, etc. The average programmer knew nothing about it, except for being forced to learn vi in university perhaps. These days, you can't swing a cat without hitting someone who is passionate about at least open source, even if they don't necessarily quite understand software freedom. I don't think we are in a worse position than we used to be. Granted, there are more and more users (billions now) that don't know anything about free and open systems. 30 or 40 years ago, those people were similarly ignorant, but weren't using computers. So when your aunt Martha is hooked up to Facebook, it seems like we've lost (or at least are loosing). But these open platforms and protocols have always been niche and our niche is much bigger than it was before. While you may never be able to chat with your aunt Martha with a free and open system run by people who are more interested in providing a service than somehow extracting money from you, you can chat with a lot more people than you ever could before. I think the key thing to remember is that you've never been able to chat with your aunt Martha using that free and open system. I think it is perfectly acceptable (and probably even preferable) to turn inward and mostly ignore what's happening in the proprietary world. I think it's probably a good idea, at least for now, to ignore fashion and popularity and instead concentrate on building free and open applications that work the way you want. There are more than enough people around with the same ideals to make it work. If you build it, they might not come, but if you don't build it, they definitely will not come. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosaic_(web_browser) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosaic_(web_browser)
- ilovecaching 8y agoThere are still Stallmans, it's just much harder for a single person to have as great an impact as the various computing verticals have gained inertia. Not to downplay the importance of early pioneers, but a lot of success comes down to timing, being in the greenfield where your ideas can be fully realized without any prior art getting in the way, or needing to reach feature parity with the status quo. The trade off is that those pioneers had to work with very little, while we have very nice computing environments, but there are a ridiculous number of us, a lot of who are brilliant, and a lot of the great ideas are already taken.
- Pristina 8y agoAll the open standards are still out there. Just because now there are 2 billions slaved to walled gardens doesn't mean all the good stuff disappeared. It just seems like everything is walled garden because the wall-to-unwalled ratio has decreased. IRC still exists, email still exists, just because whatsapp also exists and because a lot of people use it doesn't mean the web has gone down. all your film cameras don't stop working when digital came out.
- paulmd 8y agoEmail doesn't really work anymore. Have you tried to send to Gmail addresses via your own SMTP server any time recently? Good luck not getting spam-filtered. An analogy to HTTP might be if browsers stop accepting HTTP and only acknowledge HTTPS to exist (mandatory web-wide encryption on anything except localhost/designated intranet IP blocks). At that point you are forced into one walled garden or another - there may be good actors like Lets Encrypt but you are still forced into either their garden or someone else's. The days of running the web server in your basement with no say-so from anyone else would come to an end. And I think maybe in the next 10 or 20 years we start moving towards that. The film cameras didn't stop working when digital came out, but nobody will develop your Kodachrome anymore. You can also run your SMTP server and send packets into the void as much as you want.
- icebraining 8y ago> Have you tried to send to Gmail addresses via your own SMTP server any time recently? I do it all the time (from a VPS), it requires crossing all the Ts (SPF, DKM, etc), but never had any issues with Gmail, only with other self-hosted systems. > The days of running the web server in your basement with no say-so from anyone else would come to an end. That was never true, you had to have permission from your ISP, and many forbade it (and some outright blocked those ports).
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoI've never knowingly had an UK ISP that restricted services I provide from my home computer. I've not been particularly careful in choosing either -- is that castrating of users a USA thing? Gmail from a VPS has been a problem for me though, Microsoft mail has been worse (yes I look after the jots and tittles).
- profalseidol 8y ago> Bitcoin is the last exciting open standard I can remember that has done well and maybe has a future. And that future we call Ethereum.
- cf498 8y agoI think its more then just the lack of wide usage of open standards. Centralization was what sunk the ship. And it did so for a reason. Mailinglists became twitter, Forums became subreddits and dont even get me started on youtube and facebook. I dont think we have a viable concept anymore how to finance independent infrastructure, or maybe we never had one to begin with. Sadly the end of year push to collect enough to cover the server costs was always a common occurrence. I dont see how something like video streaming in a watchable resolution can be crowed founded.
- duckMuppet 8y agoof course it's cultural. People would now rather watch twitch, cat videos, or Instagram than Waste it on what ppl used to spend it on.. People now would rather pay for some proprietary SaaS or pay with their data than take some piece of software, learn it, make it better, then host it for other users for little to no compensation. There are fewer people to create truecrypt, fewer Stallmans in the world now because the culture isn't conducive to the libertarian ideas that a Stallman of that time period might have... Let's have a looksee: -The internet is shit now because the government hasn't regulated it. -The internet is again shit because greedy corporations force me to use their walled gardens, how the hell else would I communicate with anyone if I didn't allow them to siphon my data as payment to these fascist overlords. -The internet is a shitshow because not everyone has accepted that both https and JavaScript should be mandatory.. It must be the children of anti-vaxxers, somehow refusing to believe the science, a clear byproduct of not having the first point and an easy solution. -the internet is again a shitshow because the government hasn't told these fascist hardware manufacturers that I can't be bothered to read the quick start guides which clearly say change my router and IP cam password from 123456 to pa$$word.. Who the hell has time to do that with both pewdiepie and GoT having so much new content.. If the govt just had those clowns hard code pa$$word in the first place I'd be fine. Better yet, just let me get it as a service, they can just update it for me, then I can add nigahiga to my watch list. -The internet is finally a massive shitshow because, all these companies making money from me being the product have no right to, especially if I'm not getting a piece of the action. Time to break up these corporate capitalists and redistribute the wealth to the people where it belongs. I can keep going, but I'm certain it's scorched earth now. The truth is, a society that prefers the government give them things or provide their safety net, the Stallmans are going to be harder to find, because the ideas that go with such are very threatening. Pretty soon, it'll lead to making decisions for yourself AND taking blame for the outcome, good or bad, with or without a physical profit.
- krapp 8y ago>People would now rather watch twitch, cat videos, or Instagram than Waste it on what ppl used to spend it on.. What's wrong with that? I've seen a lot of complaints about social media, mainstream web culture, "cat videos and memes," etc. The web was meant for everyone, and most people want to use it for entertainment and talking to their friends. There's nothing wrong with using the web for mundane and trivial things. You want people to embrace an open web? Stop talking to them about freedom and censorship resistance and how the fascist capitalist overlords have turned them into sheep and make it easy for them to share their cat pictures.
- Illniyar 8y agoYou mean giving up on standards like IE6 and below, adobe/macromedia flash, RealPlayer, Quiktime and ActiveX ? You mean the open web of ICQ, Skype, AOL's walled garden? The web of 5, 10 and 15 years ago was much less standardized then we have today. Even though chrome is basically the only major browser left, almost all content you browse today is written in to an open standard. Walled gardens existed in the past just as much. We just didn't really consider them walled gardens because there was really no real alternative. The only difference now then in the past is scale. It seems that a closed and non-standard platform is ok if it is small, but the things that forgiven for a site with a few hundred thousands users is not for a site with billions. Which is as it should be, I think. We should have different moral standards for different sizes of market domination (the same way we have for monopolies), but let's not paint it as if the web was more open in the past.
- shard972 8y ago> You mean the open web of ICQ, Skype, AOL's walled garden? I get your general point but i would point out that in regards to something as simple as messaging, ICQ/AOL/MSN/GChat/Facebook. It wasn't that many years ago that I could have all those clients loaded up in one chat client. Noways i think ICQ is about all that's left that allows you to connect to their chat services outside of proprietary software.
- pferde 8y agoNot anymore. Sometimes in late December, ICQ users received following message: "We are discontinuing support of older ICQ versions and other unofficial clients. To continue chatting, you need: 1. Link a phone number to your account here https://icq.com/<redacted>/verifyphone?sc=<redacted> https://icq.com/<redacted>/verifyphone?sc=<redacted> 2. Log in using the official ICQ client which can be downloaded at https://icq.com" https://icq.com" I can still log in with an alternative client, see my contacts' status and receive text messages, but any message I send is either lost, or delayed by several days.
- omnimus 8y agoAlso lets not forget that time when you could send messages between almost all of those prividers including Gchat and Facebook messenger because it was all federated XMPP.
- rimliu 8y agoThe main problem I see with the web is that we forgot about users. Dev's got so obsessed with means that they started to completely ignore the ends. I don't remember where I saw this phrase but I like it a lot: "make harder for databases, easier for the users". Alas, seems like desire to use the coolest tech or the only tech devs know trumps everything. The main question now is should we use Redux or MobX. Not "should we user React at all here? Does this project warrant to be a SPA?". And who needs accessibility anyway?
- rjf72 8y agoI think it's about something much more insidious: FOMO. Today it's easier than ever to create e.g. a decentralized or independent means of doing pretty much anything that could easily let people escape those walled gardens, if they wanted. The problem is people don't want to: FOMO. If they leave the walled garden, they have the Fear Of Missing Out on what's happening inside the walled garden. You can even see this phenomena in real life. You have a dozen people at a table or whatever. Unless you have some good sample bias, a good chunk of them will be constantly glancing at their phones if not having their noses glued to them. You have significant things that could be happening in your immediate vicinity, supplanted out of concern for missing what are invariably trivialities in a mostly fake world. This is a people problem - not a business or technology problem. And the worst part is that it's so incredibly insidious that people don't realize the harm involved. A person addicted to gambling will trend towards the same thing as a person addicted to drugs - losing everything they have. And so it's quite easy to see the consequences. A person who's mind is increasingly fogged and attention driven entirely to the pale glow of that screen and the little dopamine bumps it provides, by contrast, will see no immediately visible negative effects. And the addiction is so ubiquitous that even as consequences do begin to emerge, they're not really noted because it's 'normal.'
- hevi_jos 8y agoI believe you miss the main issue: Most people don't know or don't want to do computer systems administration. People don't need to know mechanics to drive a car, or architect to live in a house and Facebook, Google... are doing the same with computers. You don't need to know anything about how computers work in order to use them. There is no FOVO when you can convince your friends or family members to use a different and better alternative. The problem is that there is no alternative. There is no alternative. There is not some kind of box I can buy for 30 dollars, connect to my network and instantly being able to connect with my friends, family or workers with another box automatically and without work on my and their side like you can do with a physical telephone. There are lots of tinkering boxes for geeks. But they are too complex.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago
- tastroder 8y ago>For all its downsides, Bitcoin is the last exciting open standard I can remember that has done well and maybe has a future. If you don't mind elaborating, this point comes up rather frequently nowadays about bitcoin/other blockchain tech. So far the only thing that fell into the "exciting" category for me was ipfs and even that didn't really convince me that it's a viable thing. I get that blockchain tech is an industry nowadays but from my outside perspective 99% of it and the applications they promote seem rather, for the lack of a better word, self serving. Either that or it's some niche that I don't see will get any mass adoption anytime soon. Lots of these technologies seem to be technical solutions to problems that are social in nature and thus, again - from my outside perspective, prone to failure. Proof of X tech often looks like stuff that's solved as soon as parties agree on using it in the first place. edit: formatting
- m-i-l 8y ago> > For all its downsides, Bitcoin is the last exciting open standard I can remember > I get that blockchain tech is an industry nowadays but from my outside perspective 99% of it and the applications they promote seem rather, for the lack of a better word, self serving Blockchain might have been as exciting as the internet at the start, but it has turned bad (i.e. been exploited for profit by big corporations at the user's expense) much more quickly. In my view it is because blockchain puts money before technology rather than the other way around, i.e. during the dot-com era it was often "let's just build something useful and worry about monetisation later" whereas with blockchain it is more "we've got the monetisation in place and we'll worry about actual use cases for the technology and mass user adoption later".
- type0 8y agoIn other words it's a solution in search of a problem
- m-i-l 8y agoI think its a bit more subtle than that. Imagine on one hand if a printing press was invented that outputs the printed material to anyone in the world for free. At first there could be lots of great materials printed with it, but then the question would be asked - can we start charging money for some of it? Imagine on the other hand if a silver church collection tray was invented that could collect money from anyone of that particular religious persuasion anywhere in the world. At first it could collect great amounts of money, but then the question would be asked - can we do anything else with this silver church collection tray besides collecting money?
- DennisP 8y agoThat link gets a 404 now. You seem to have the right url, the link from the article is broken too.
- type0 8y agoIndeed, "a public square" and "a doctor’s office" - all one in the same and who cares right, remember there was once a thing called privacy; our grandchildren will read about it in the history books (or probably not, since maybe there won't be such things as books).
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoWe missed our opportunity with chat about a decade or so ago. When all the disparate chat protocols (MSN, Yahoo, AOL, etc) were battling it out, we should have decided on a protocol then. Sure, we'd see some growing pains now with how to deal with encryption, but at least we'd have a ubiquitous chat protocol. Chat is now worth billions of dollars apparently, so that proverbial cat is nowhere near the bag. I would love to be able to sign up with, say, Fastmail for chat and be able to chat with whomever I wish and it just work. As it is, I have be signed up with 4 different services and they don't talk to each other. Sigh.
- 908087 8y ago> Imagine if we had done the same with email or the web itself. Give it time, we've certainly been trying. See: chrome, amp, gmail, etc.
- dave_sid 8y agoCurrent status of the web? HTTP 417
- apostacy 8y agoI think it is worse than we admit. IMAP will soon be dead, and the only way we can check our emails will be on the terms of Google or whoever. And because of how websites work now, ad blocking is an uphill battle that will only get harder, as server side rendering becomes more common. So, welcome to a future where you can't check your email unless it is on a multicore computing device with out least 2G of RAM, running an OS that is less than two years old. And you have to submit to email tracking beacons. (But don't worry, they will be proxies through Google so marketers will only know you opened them, but not your IP). Google will make concessions for accessibility of course, but it will be strictly on their terms, and the screen reader will still need absurd system requirements and have to execute javascript quickly, to be able to read static text. This WILL happen, and soon. And tech journalists will celebrate this, and say that IMAP was obsolete and "needed to die". They will praise the responsive and fashionable UX (the only interface allowed), and there won't be any serious pushback. Maybe Google will require that you run an app or use some browser extension to fully utilize features that you used to get for free. And the OSS community will obediently scramble to implement these regressive requirements, because if Firefox and Ubuntu don't play ball with the latest DRM/restriction garbage, then they wouldn't be cool or something. Federated email will slowly get squeezed out and die with a whimper. OK, maybe an exaggeration, but is it really far fetched? And this is just a microcosm of where technology is going. The reason I am pessimistic is that the developer culture that I knew is dying out. Younger developers just accept that the centralized corporate internet is the internet. And people I think are far more obedient with technology than they used to be. But what's so frustrating is that they are accepting and obedient I think partially for very shallow and superficial reasons, and wanting to be cool and accepted. As if people think that Apple is too shiny to and cool to betray us. "So what if it's horribly intrusive DRM, It's Apple, come on. Nobody wants that second best obsolete crap. It is obsolete because that cool guy said so. And Google is 'the best' so we have to implement it their way. Please don't laugh at me." I have said it many times before, but I just wish that people were as skeptical of Google and Apple as slashdotters of old were about "Micro$oft" or Oracle.
- tareqak 8y agoDidn't Tim Berners-Lee have a hand in approving Web DRM and abandoning consensus? He did [0][1][2]. For all his accomplishments in creating the Web as we know it today, his considerably more recent involvement shows that even he has given up on open standards, cooperation, and consensus. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14720591 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14720591 [1] https://boingboing.net/2017/07/07/eschatology-watch.html https://boingboing.net/2017/07/07/eschatology-watch.html [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15278883 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15278883
- JohnFen 8y ago> perhaps just the internet has become so monetized I think this is really the core issue.
- rando_cal 8y ago> For all its downsides, Bitcoin is the last exciting open standard I can remember that has done well and maybe has a future. I'd argue, though less exciting, that the addition of emojis into Unicode is another such silo-busting standard. Nowadays, if you built a chat client from scratch, you would benefit from the network effects of those standardized emoticons.
- qwerty456127 8y ago> But initiatives like this would require all of society to contribute - from members of the public to business and political leaders. This means almost nobody is going to contribute. Sad but true - we can't change the world by asking everybody to change. We have to invent a replacement framework that will be both so great everybody (both customers and businesses) will love it and at the same time by-design almost impossible to use a wrong way. Sir Tim has already invented a framework everybody wanted but failed the second part. Now he is inventing a new kind of web addressing the second part but seemingly fails the first part :-(
- seandoe 8y agoI don't agree with the idea that the internet needs more regulation. Yes, it does have it's problems. But I think many solutions are in the making, we just have to be patient. My idea of what made the web great is its freedom and lack of regulation. I'm willing to endure some drawbacks in order to maintain a high level of freedom.
- thekyle 8y agoI agree. The only thing regulation is going to do is entrench existing internet companies and raise the barrier to entry for new startups to compete.
- potta_coffee 8y agoRegulation always benefits the rent-seekers. They have the best means of influencing that regulation in the first place.
- pmoriarty 8y agoI have clean air and water where I live, largely due to regulation. If "rent seekers" are benefiting from such regulations, they're certainly far from the only ones who benefit.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- keerthiko 8y agoThis is the actual problem, not regulation itself. Regulation should be designed to scale with the size and age of the participating operator (of business or service). Regulations should be about controlling the outsize influence of any individual player/entity in any direction, in addition to restriction malicious activity. If these were equally important in regulation design, they would be far less harmful for new small players and better manage incumbents.
- hirundo 8y agoThe https://contractfortheweb.org/ https://contractfortheweb.org/ is so bland as to be impotent. The principles are vague enough to be a Rorschach test. Presumably it has had all sharp edged filed down to gain consensus. As an engineer Sir Berners-Lee wants to bring a solution along with the problems he's found, and this is presumably his best shot. Given his capability that's depressing confirmation that these are hard problems.
- jchook 8y agoLaws stopped crime so no question they'll also fix the Web.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoThis has been on my mind a lot recently and I really think the biggest failure was not making the internet easy to use. Facebook et al won by finally organizing all of the people/companies/organizations you care about in one place, and being a 0-friction publishing platform to interact with them. Pre-Facebook "Grandma" either had to remember 1stbaptistchurchSTL.org, grandsontimmysawesomeblog.net, granddaughtersara42931.wordpress.com, nissanusa.com and countless other baffling URLs; or go to Google, which as good as it was for a while was a crazy bandaid. Now all of these things can be in one place and she can talk to them effortlessly. The closest that "the community" ever came to solving this problem was what, bookmarks and guestbooks? The privacy implications are unfortunate side effects, but have nothing to do with out these companies got so dominant to begin with. They solved real usability issues for the majority of users.
- Frondo 8y ago"The community" has had such a hostility to a broadly-accepted user experience ever since there was a web to browse. (I used to be one of them, back when <center> was a netscape-only tag. Follow the standards! Write for content! People don't need that visual jazz!) There's still a non-negligible contingent on here that insists that the web should be browseable without javascript; that ship sailed well over a decade ago. The users decided, rich interfaces are the way to go. We did fail the world, and this is what we get.
- fxfan 8y agoWeb is no longer web- it's increasingly becoming a number of sinks.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- iliketosleep 8y agoWe don't need new regulations. We need the web to be taken out of the hands of gov. and big corps. It's interesting how the web started off feeling so very utopian. A naive and benevolent world that was built upon trust - and therefore easily taken over when big corps and gov. moved in. We are now galloping towards some kind of dystopia, where one day we'll be nostalgically watching Black Mirror repeats! Then you have the Darknet, built on distrust and perceived as somewhat malevolent. It may seems dystopian at first, but as the community becomes broader it may actually evolve into the utopia we hoped the web would be - simply because large entities cannot wrest control of it.
- ModernMech 8y ago> We need the web to be taken out of the hands of gov. and big corps. Interesting use of the passive voice there. Who exactly is going to take the web out of the hands of gov. and big corps? Technologists?
- pmoriarty 8y agoTechnologists have been not only exceptionally ineffective at preventing this dystopia, they've been instrumental in creating it.
- iliketosleep 8y agoIf a critical mass of individuals migrate to a network which replicates the key functionality of the web but is designed with privacy and decentralization at the core, I believe it would be safe to say that it's not in the hands of gov, big corps, or any individual.
- jeremyboom8 8y agoLike Holo.host?
- profalseidol 8y agoLikely those who use GPL and other copy-left licenses.
- peterwwillis 8y agoLast year, 27 people were murdered in India due to shared WhatsApp messages. https://www.wired.com/story/how-whatsapp-fuels-fake-news-and-violence-in-india/ https://www.wired.com/story/how-whatsapp-fuels-fake-news-and... https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/07/18/technology/whatsapp-india-killings.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/07/18/technology/wh... Facebook is used as a platform to attack Rohingya muslims in Myanmar and Sri Lanka. Over 600,000 have been forced to flee the country. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/27/world/asia/myanmar-government-facebook-rohingya.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/27/world/asia/myanmar-govern... Politicians have hired companies to mine Facebook data of millions of people for use in their campaigns. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Analytica_data_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Ana... Foreign governments use social media accounts to spread disinformation and destabilize elections. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_2016_United_States_elections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_20... .....But this whole "regulation" thing is clearly overblown. It's not like there are serious consequences to having multiple Big Brothers that not even the state controls. Right?
- NavyNuke 8y agoForeign government's use of social media is the most alarming thing in my opinion... Revealed: Israeli Military Monitors Social Media, Blogs and Forums in Search of 'Security Leaks': https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-revealed-israeli-military-monitors-social-media-blogs-and-forums-1.6531061 https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-revealed-israel... Jewish Internet Defense Force: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_Internet_Defense_Force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_Internet_Defense_Force
- lupire 8y agoRwandan genocide via radio https://www.concordia.ca/research/migs/resources/rwanda-radio-transcripts.html https://www.concordia.ca/research/migs/resources/rwanda-radi... Remember the Maine! via newspapers http://www.ushistory.org/us/44c.asp http://www.ushistory.org/us/44c.asp
- crummy 8y agoHow does encryption work for group chats on WhatsApp? Could Facebook have moderated these messages to prevent the attacks or is the content still hidden to them?
- bb01100100 8y agoI've been thinking about the walled garden thing recently. Several of my friends who are /long/-time users of FB - thanks to its ability to gather scatterlings from across the world - have started talking about creating (logically) local and durable (not lost in the ad-injected update feed) content, memories and information. As someone who long since gave up trying to provide that type of thing (because corps did it better/faster with no learning curve, excellent reach, etc), I find this shift interesting. It speaks of non-technical people wanting to have real control of their own content; not some token effort that ultimately enables monetization. To me, there is still value in the ideas behind older unix services and protocols; things like gopher, old-school blogs (pre mega-corp platforms), irc chat, usenet, etc. I see ActivityPub and IPFS as interesting developments; I'd love to know what other tools we could string together to help create other (presumably connected but distributed / federated?) spaces that aren't backed by a monetization engine. It would be neat to see a "distro" that stood up a node with long and short-form content, chat, news and "groups" capabilities. Something a keen but inexperienced individual could spin up on AWS / GCP / DO / Azure, etc. Am I crazy? PS: Wasn't chat solved by Jabber (now xmpp)? IIRC, Yahoo and Google at the time didn't support it (other than by using brittle bridges).
- toomim 8y agoGoogle supported Jabber in Google Talk, and then deprecated it, and then removed it in Google Hangouts: https://www.disruptivetelephony.com/2015/02/google-finally-kills-off-googletalk-and-xmpp-jabber-integration.html https://www.disruptivetelephony.com/2015/02/google-finally-k...
- lupire 8y agoThe rationale at the time was that Facebook had walled-garden chat, Google had to create a walled garden compete. "Copy Facebook at all costs" was Google's survival strategy during the G+ era.
- YUMad 8y agoYeah google switched hard from promoting interconnectedness to walled garden approach cca 2010. This was in response to Facebook's success and possibility of Facebook overthrowing google as the ad king. In those days, even Facebook ran an xmpp gateway for their chat.
- techntoke 8y agoI think part of the problem is aside from IPFS, little work has been put into decentralization and standardization of content. Dynamic content is based around JavaScript which has and will continue to become a spy tool for marketers. I don't see the Internet improving until there is other options for standardizing dynamic content other than JavaScript, and making it easy to host your content without needing to rely on a centralized cloud platform.
- gbhn 8y agoI have some direct experience with this. It is summed up as "open standards people are extraordinarily hard to work with, uncompromising, and subject to infinite fine splitting of the space. Meanwhile, 5 billion users do not care and want things to be easy, fast, work well, and be well integrated." The result of these two forces is that it ends up being extremely difficult to work on open standards for any kind of data that people care about. (Users can't see HTTP, so it is fine to standardize. They can see blog titles, so... no dice.)
- thwarted 8y ago"…Meanwhile, 5 billion users do not care and want things to be easy, fast, work well, and be well integrated." They can see blog titles, so... no dice.) Hard to place all of the blame on the open standards people if the other side doesn't want to do anything other than wall people in by not cooperating, with open standards or each other.
- Swizec 8y agoAs an enginner I really love and support open standards. As a user I’m on Apple everything because shit just works and gets out of my way.
- Moru 8y agoIt's funny how I always hear this about apple but every time I try to use the company issued iPhone I get stuck trying to do something that just can't be done. Can't even plug in a standard sd card or an audio plug...
- Swizec 8y agoWhat kind of mad man uses SD cards with their phone? That’s what the 256gb of internal storage is for. Modern Androids don’t have audio plugs anymore either by the way. But really it sounds liek your problem is that only the company phone is Apple. The argument really only works when all your devices are apple. Preferably including your whole family. If you prefer Android, then all your devices should be that and you’re gonna hvae a great time. That’s kinda the joke here. Nobody cares about open standards as long as everything they do belongs to a single “stack” because interoperability sucks. Like really sucks. Probably on purpose. Look no further than trying to repeat a Spotify song on Alexa. “Sorry repeating songs is not supported on Spotify”. My ass it isnt you just don’t want to.
- guelo 8y agoTim Berners-Lee is partly to blame, his W3C squandered all of its authority, partly through incompetence and partly through bureaucracy and corruption, and now it has little leverage to affect change.
- buzzert 8y agoWhat would they do even if they had authority? What does “authority” even mean in this context?
- _bxg1 8y agoHaving the respect of those who implement the spec. To my understanding, WHATWG has basically usurped all of the W3C's influence and just let it stick around as a figurehead. But it has no real power anymore to incite change.
- einr 8y agoI don't think that altering the technical details regarding the implementation of HTML, CSS et al would do much of anything to stop the proliferation of walled gardens and spyware.
- klez 8y agoYou're right, it wouldn't. But the fact is that once the arguably most important thing the w3c did got out of their hands, they lost importance as a whole. So they now have little political power to push back on other things.
- _bxg1 8y agoHere is a prime example: https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/8/15942238/web-drm-standard-eme-approved-controversy https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/8/15942238/web-drm-standard-...
- leowoo91 8y agoI disagree with arguments on web becoming centralized. Unless you are acting unethical, there is little control over what you put online. I understand issue starts with the giants but they are brought under regulations inevitably to bring the balance back at some point. I think this thread is contributing to the same cause in natural manner.
- kqr 8y ago> I undertand issue starts with the giants but they inevitably go under regulations to bring the balance back at some point. Inevitably? As by some law of nature? Or inevitably under the condition that people like Tim Berners-Lee speak out and rally people for the cause?
- leowoo91 8y agoAnti-trust laws? Without people rallying, of course it wouldn't be possible.
- Nasrudith 8y agoDefine "acting unethical" - since on a technical level you control what you render and what you send. Now if you routinely start hacking into everything to erase IP traces that is unethical but literally nobody does that.
- pessimizer 8y ago> Define "acting unethical" Criticism of his royal majesty, disrespect of the judiciary, or denial of the inherent evil of the Armenians.
- leowoo91 8y agoI didn't mean his majesty, but anything takes a hit on basic human rights is simply unethical, with level of which %99 people could tell the difference. If you guys mean "giants crushing competitions", it takes longer for people to recognize, no doubt about it.
- pdonis 8y agoDoes anyone else find it odd that contractfortheweb.org pops up a warning that they're using cookies?
- m463 8y agothat's part of the problem. News media has to report on how crazy it has become, but... "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it" -- Upton Sinclair
- cobbzilla 8y agoI’m a huge fan of TBL but the solution will not come from governments and corporations, they have nearly every incentive in the opposite direction. Slowly, slowly people are waking up to the realization that we the people must solve this ourselves, with a solution that cannot be controlled by any one party. We did this with strong encryption but that was much simpler. The set of memes and values people need to understand will be similar but larger in scope. It will probably take 10+ years to get there, but we’ll get there faster the more we stop looking up to hierarchical authorities for solutions, and looking around at their fellow netizens.
- falcrist 8y agoYou're talking about a distributed solution that will never happen. A centralized system will tend to behave more efficiently than a distributed system, and the owners of that centralized system will undercut the distributed system at every stage. Corporatism will block any such movement via pricing, ease of use, marketing, FUD, and legislation. If you don't include corporations and governments in the model, that model will fail.
- einr 8y agoA centralized system will tend to behave more efficiently than a distributed system If that was always true, we literally would not even have the Internet. Centralized, corporate networks like TYMNET died like flies once the open, distributed Internet became widely available.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI'd say that Internet was a fluke. Some standards - both electrical and software - managed to spread worldwide and solidify against the opposition of the market. This was a time when being compatible with everyone else turned out to be more beneficial than trying to strike out on your own. It's important however to contemplate on the degree to which Internet is centralized - or getting centralized. As it is today, everything up to transport layer (TCP, UDP) can be considered baseline infrastructure. Very few market players are trying to mess with it, similarly to how most market doesn't mess with the voltage and frequency standards for electrical outlets in your home. But anything above TCP/UDP is up for grabs, and is becoming heavily centralized. This is the way of the market. You make money by building barriers, not bridges. And the players that make bridges only do so to tear down their competitors' barriers, so that they can replace them with their own barriers.
- sbmassey 8y agoNo mention of the Solid technology from Inrupt that TBL is meant to be touting.
- ajvs 8y agoRiot/Matrix is gaining some momentum due to having E2E encryption, federation and it's ability to bridge with other chat networks like IRC, Discord, Slack, etc. XMPP failed due to a Linux distro-like approach where each client supported different extensions, making cross-client compatibility poor. Riot/Matrix instead is more similar to using one of the various distros that are built on top of Ubuntu - so you know it "just works", there's a full feature set you can expect from using any client and all of them are compatible with each other.
- jasonzemos 8y agoRiot/Matrix is a chat standard, but it's not an open standard. I say this with melancholy as the developer of the only federating matrix server other than the reference server developed by the for-profit company (read: for-profit company) that controls the standard. I do it because this has the potential to be a great protocol and facilitate a great UX if the controlling party didn't alienate talent from its ecosystem. Matrix is a lot of gloss, a lot of hype and cheap talk, but under the hood it's deeply insecure and it's entirely controlled by a single person (again, read: a single person). And he is a fraud. He has lied about the userbase on numerous occasions; the company had its funding abruptly cut in 2017. It's now funded by scamcoin sales from a shell called status.im. Anyway, I think matrix has potential as a traditonal free software community project which can exercise some leverage against the controlling party, so that's why I still work on the Construct: https://github.com/matrix-construct/construct https://github.com/matrix-construct/construct
- feanaro 8y agoIf you were able to build a federating server implementation, in what way is it not an open standard? Also, deeply insecure how?
- jasonzemos 8y agoIf you go to matrix.org and look at the list of about a dozen or so servers: you will find that none of them actually work except the reference implementation, and maybe sometimes Construct. Even thus, the phrase "able to build" is questionable. I have spent months reverse-engineering their software and its interactions before, and after, it was at all documented in this so-called standard (by the way, it's just documentation of their software -- errata and all (and rather poor)). Construct server is the single survivor out of the ones listed and even more who have attempted and given up early which we don't know about. That being said, it is still incomplete.
- josteink 8y agoMaybe Tim could have made this stand before approving WebDRM? Then at least it would have had some more credibility.
- Shivetya 8y agoRead the letter, the same angst that really has nothing to do with the web other than highlight it made it easier for the bad actors in society to affect more people faster. you are not going to fix his list of issues until you fix mankind. worse is that not everyone will agree on all the items listed, some may be absolutes but others are far more often a product of where you are in this world. so yeah, we have a problem, the web just puts it in the face of everyone at once
- zipzap324 8y ago>The Stalman's of the world seem farther and farther apart, or perhaps just the internet has become so monetized that the best talent just can't refuse the $$$s from a FANG job that focuses on crushing the competition and owning everything. This is so important. Seriously, how many MIT/Berkeley/CMU/Stanford/etc. grads are wasting their insane talent tweaking news feed, advertising and recommendation algorithms. It's truly sad.
- tannhaeuser 8y agoW3C is partly to blame for the situation. They don't bother to complete their spec work anymore - W3C HTML5.3 is officially at CR status, but hasn't be worked on since october, and SVG 2, which has been reduced basically to include SVG 1.2's vectorEffect=nonScalingStroke into SVG 1.1, and remove SVG 1.1 features that were never supported by browsers anyway, looks even less like it'll ever be completed. At the same time W3C's CSS WG churns out specs (subgrid, trigonometric functions, etc.), adding to the infeasability to code a browser from scratch ever again. If they want to contribute, they could do a lot of things: publish a reduced, rational profile of HTML (and in particular CSS) to give developers a usable target specification, rather than a bunch of isolated specs at various degrees of completion. They could also publish "real" specs with formal semantics and grammars, rather than the prose they publish now, which doesn't know if it wants to be an authoring or browser implementation guide. They could also create a browser from scratch in a formally verifiable language. They could do more lobbying. Or they could disband, to show the world that the public doesn't sit at the table when FAANG decides about the future of human communication. As it is, the web is becoming a net-negative, a medium for mass propaganda and censorship, an overly complicated turd leading into monopolies, and a place where creators don't get their share. W3C needs to demonstrate the actual value of the web to society, not naively appeal to idealists with their futile "save the web" campaigning. The web is a means to an end, and failing, not an end in itself.
- dmitriid 8y agoDon’t forget that W3C has been stealing WHATWG’s HTML specifications and republishing them with credits and attributions stripped: https://www.reddit.com/r/javascript/comments/5swe9b/comment/ddkwft4 https://www.reddit.com/r/javascript/comments/5swe9b/comment/...
- tannhaeuser 8y agoIdk, maybe W3C didn't do all they could to credit WHATWG, but I didn't interpret it that way. People actually reading HTML specs know WHATWG very well. I for one appreciated W3C's efforts to publish a versioned HTML spec which WHATWG never bothered to do. Rather, WHATWG created a self-serving, never-ending process around HTML (but mostly JavaScript APIs) that saw Opera and then MS drop out of creating browsers alltogether. What exactly is the HTML5 shield logo designed to shield against?
- arendtio 8y ago> malicious activity such as hacking and harassment I don't know, but somehow I see hacking much less of a problem than harassment. I mean even the bad guys out there, trying to get into our ssh ports even minute we speak, are just a reminder to secure our systems properly. Harassment on the other side is a social phenomenon not limited to the digital world which has no upside that would be proportional to its downsides. > problematic system design such as business models that reward clickbait This is a real problem. I mean, it's not just about the clickbait titles. It is about an advertisement. So what is advertising? In its essence, you present information to change the inner state of a human being towards a specific direction (e.g. my product is cool, buy it!). So what an advertiser does is to forge information sources. With books, it is not much different, but with the personalized advertisement, the effectiveness has increased dramatically. Nowadays, we have effective human manipulation machines which manipulate millions of humans every day or in other words, someone has managed to crack democracy... > unintended consequences, such as aggressive or polarised discussions Similar to harassment, I don't think the internet is the cause here, but merely the filter to bring those nasty elements of human nature out of the dark corners of our societies. After all, people quarrel/fight/kill offline too. We probably just have to learn as a species to not be afraid our own disadvantage but to embrace diversity and make the most of combined forces instead of trying to be just a bit better than our neighbor.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Similar to harassment, I don't think the internet is the cause here, but merely the filter to bring those nasty elements of human nature out of the dark corners of our societies. I'd go a step further. Those things to some extent are natural, and in their natural form manageable. But the advertising-driven business models on the Internet serve as amplifiers, and it is they that make "aggressive or polarized discussions" an actual problem.
- xtf 8y agothis - it goes viral
- ram148280 8y agohttps://www.compressware.in/2019/03/game-making-software.html https://www.compressware.in/2019/03/game-making-software.htm...
- ram148280 8y agounity pro 3d highly compressed download <a href="https://www.compressware.in/2019/03/game-making-software.html">unity https://www.compressware.in/2019/03/game-making-software.htm... 3d pro highly compressed</a>
- tempodox 8y agoIt's only dysfunctional for non-commercial users. The ones making making money from it are getting richer than ever.
- Nasrudith 8y agoOh it is dysfunctional for them too they just don't care
- xtf 8y agoEveryone is in the net. - malicious activity such as hacking and harassment - problematic system design such as business models that reward clickbait - unintended consequences, such as aggressive or polarised discussions These are problems of human evolvement. Education, education, education and not screaming at each other and discussing with the opposition till consensus.
- StreamBright 8y ago>>> dysfunctional future More like the dysfunctional present, the best invention that happened recently to the web is Pocket and reader view. I have stopped reading content on the web directly because an average web page is full of tracking and ads, some of them are known attack vectors.
- egberts1 8y agoFirst, you have to stop JavaScript.
- buboard 8y ago> With the Law of Sea and the Outer Space Treaty, we have preserved new frontiers for the common good No we haven't. We have needlessly put limits to who can go to the stars and seas, as if the entire oceans and indeed the whole universe belongs to earth's heads of governments. The web is still the most open platform one can find, and like all undiscovered lands it is full of dangers and opportunity. We are hugely thankful to Sir Berners-Lee (my personal hero) for creating and generously giving us such an open world-wide network full of opportunity. But the ones who are destroying the web are russia's government, china's government, the NSA, Europes regulations etc, who not only want to restrict their subjects physically, but also want to own all their information. This is a bad proposition born out of fear and will only provide a temporary protection to corrupt governance. We should instead double down on free networks, create new channels and underlying infrastructure for information to flow freely, and perhaps also break up monopolies that funnel too great amounts of information. > If we don’t elect politicians who defend a free and open web, if we don’t do our part to foster constructive healthy conversations online, Just like universal human rights, we just can't rely on the electorates to protect freedoms, we need wide consensus
- pjc50 8y ago> russia's government, china's government, the NSA, Europes regulations etc, who not only want to restrict their subjects physically, but also want to own all their information. Those really do not belong in the same sentence, especially given that many of the European regulations are for the preservation of the individual's rights over their information, in a way that doesn't exist elsewhere. > we just can't rely on the electorates to protect freedoms, we need wide consensus Consensus among whom, if not the electorate?
- buboard 8y ago> Consensus among whom, if not the electorate? "the electorate" is usually 51% percent who are often regulationg against the other 49%. That is a bad way to decide about the future of humanity. wide consensuses also ensure a low level or regulation.
- lazyjones 8y agoPerspectives are fascinatingly different. For me, the biggest issues of the near-dysfunctional web are: 1. registration popups (newsletters, membership) and paywalls that appear when I click on promising links. 2. cookie banners, popups, interstitials that pointlessly require additional actions everywhere, like a stupid second door on a fridge. 3. stuff that is broken because obscure JS / new non-standard browser feature doesn't work, possibly because of ad/tracker blocking. 4. copyright scares and other legal obstacles and uncertainties for publishers (e.g. GDPR) that drive smaller, especially noncommercial publishers away from the web, so users become easy victims of multinational corporations with predatory business practices. This is a much bigger issue than hacking for small publishers. What do "polarised discussions" even have to do with the web? We have them in every pub. The fact that they're prevalent on the web is a sign that something works, not the opposite.
- Chico11Kidlet 8y agoWhat did you expect? Everything you open up to commercialism will eventually turn to poo. Look at television and what it was initially meant to be and where its ended up.
- austincheney 8y agoIs the web public or private? People want it both ways but you cannot have both at the same time. This distinction governs policy, security, and enforcement and as result are all less clear than they should be. While this is nebulous the problems spelled out in this letter will continue without serious resolution. Compare that to email, which is inherently private and as a result far more simple to provide laws and policy around. Email is not always secure, but the platform and concerning laws are very clear.
- macminus 8y agoDon’t break up big tech — regulate data access, says EU antitrust chief. tcrn.ch/2CgjHxw
- justanegg 8y agoa canvas only web is needed, maybe streaming.
- PointersAreFun 8y agoThanks in no part to JavaScript turning the web into a platform for adware and spyware.
- dentemple 8y agoIf Java applets had won, then you can be damn sure they would've turned them an adware platform as well. Don't blame the language, blame the corporations who are given free reign to abuse the public.
- lyxsus1 8y agoHey, why stop there? Dig deeper! Thanks to internet and computers turning the web into a platform for adware and spyware. No, actually, thank electricity. It's a stupid point of view, where people blame some tech for problems created by those very people. It's not javascript that makes web slightly slow, but incompetent developers driven by business. If it wasn't javascript, it would be something else that allows you to run some computations on client side. And it would be the same if not worse. There's a reason web was won by JS, not java or COM or flash. Hell, there just was a post no NY that demonstrated that fonts are potentially turing-complete. Our behaviour, economy, law, customs, complete lack of culture and education causes slow web, privacy problems and de-decentralisation of internet. Fundamentally, bug is outside of computer, it's just us.
- JohnFen 8y ago> If it wasn't javascript, it would be something else that allows you to run some computations on client side. I agree that blaming Javascript the language is incorrect. One of the major problems is that websites are able to run code client-side at all.
- lyxsus1 8y agoWell, we really need to do some client-side computations for really good reasons. And if we hadn't, it would be reinvented pretty quickly. What we need right now (IMHO): 1. Some easy-to-use on/off capping button for code size, memory consumed, cpu used, resources loaded per tab. Enabled by default, shipped in each major browser, including mobile 2. Cruelly penalise links that abuse client resources in search results of all major platforms 3. Give it a year and watch them raging, but slowly adjusting to new requirements 4. Repeat with lower caps until it's good enough That's all we realistically can and should do: impose some universal limits and require user conscious action to bypass per webapp. It must be job, which W3C should be doing already, probably with joint efforts of Google, Microsoft and Apple. If they managed to enforce CORS, they'll be able to that also.
- forinti 8y agoI was watching a documentary on animal intelligence and it seemed to me that once a species gets to a certain level, individuals start cheating and hiding things from each other. This happens with dolphins and chimps, for example. What humanity has achieved with the internet is the industrialisation of lying, cheating, and faking. An individual's ability to cheat was more or less limited by space (and he had to be convincing). Now a good liar can reach out to millions and he doesn't even have to show his face (and he can reach the credulous easily, so he doesn't even have to be as convincing as before).
- johnminter 8y agoThe content on the Internet ranges from "free" to "paid subscription": 1) We have volunteers that curate content and they have limited time. We need to be gracious, courteous, and thankful for their effort. 2) Businesses are providing content and generate revenue via subscription, advertisements, or data mining our input. Put another way, in the last two cases we are the product. In all cases the content will be biased because humans are biased. We deal with that by reading content from multiple points of view and apply critical thinking and reasoning skills. We also have to continually remind ourselves that there are people with disruptive agendas - both individuals and collectives funded by nation states that have an agenda. How many times have you been notified that your information has been compromised?... Jurisdictional issues make it hard for law enforcement agencies to track them down and shut them down. The situation reminds me of the caricature of the American West in the 1800s - a free-for-all. To be forewarned is to be forearmed. We need to take security seriously.
- rbanffy 8y agoSometimes I feel we invented the Krell Big Machine. The way social networking damaged our democracies is shocking.
- JohnFen 8y agoI agree with most of what TBL says here (even though I think that a few of the positions he's taken over the past few years have not helped). From my point of view, the web is clearly degenerating and the rate of degeneration is increasing. From my point of view, this is because of privacy and security issues, not so much what people are using the web to say. For years now, the web has been growing smaller and smaller for me as more and more websites (particularly newer ones) become effectively unusable. I realized last year that it's entirely possible that I may stop using the web entirely at some point in my lifetime.
- jedahan 8y agoThere are projects working to promote a better future for the web. Scuttlebutt and Dat to name two.