7 ms·
How about the NSA and similar institutions in other countries don't hoard zerodays and instead actively work to improve security? Defending against hackers is a
by adrianN 8y ago
How about the NSA and similar institutions in other countries don't hoard zerodays and instead actively work to improve security? Defending against hackers is a lot easier than defending against nuclear missiles. We don't need an active deterrence if the defenses are good.
- zelon88 8y agoWhile I agree and I hate the NSA's practice of hoarding zero days, they do this to keep software vulnerable on purpose. They've invested millions in uncovering zero days SPECIFICALLY so they could then spend millions more to be the only ones exploiting these vulnerabilities. If they share the zero day, the vendor will write a patch and it's game-over for their multi-million dollar exploit. Don't get me wrong, it's entirely inappropriate for an American government agency to be subverting the security of American products made by American companies and used by the American public. We have a unique opportunity that no other country has to coordinate our secret intelligence work with the private sector to completely own the security industry, but we allow our government to take an adversarial approach to defense. It's insane and criminal, but that's how it is. Imagine how effective an intelligence campaign would be against, say, Iran, if the NSA went to Microsoft, disclosed a vuln, and then told them to patch the vuln ONLY in specific markets. Roll out the patch to American companies first, but leave select targets still vulnerable. No other country could get Microsoft to do that except the United States... And we waste that opportunity by trying to lone-wolf everything.
- AndrewGaspar 8y agoI'm sorry, but this seems a little naive. 1) It assumes that the NSA would only want to exploit a vulnerability exactly once, 2) this behavior would be fairly obvious since hackers examine patch payloads, and 3) this behavior on the part of American tech would undermine their credibility globally. Wouldn't you reasonably be very skeptical of Microsoft if you were a foreign government if you knew they were actively working with the American government to pwn you? The status quo of a semi-adversarial relationship between the NSA and tech companies for offensive cyber capabilities seems better to me for both parties. Of course it would be good if they were collaborating on defensive cyber security.
- magduf 8y ago> 3) this behavior on the part of American tech would undermine their credibility globally. Wouldn't you reasonably be very skeptical of Microsoft if you were a foreign government if you knew they were actively working with the American government to pwn you? The fact that foreign governments aren't more skeptical of Microsoft really baffles me. The American government isn't dumb enough to buy security products from Kapersky after all, or devices from Huawei.
- espeed 8y agoMaybe that was part of the motivation for Microsoft moving toward open-source. Showing their cards in a way that can be audited and verified to ease any potential foreign organization's concerns. Software is part of it, but hardware is the harder sell.
- chopin 8y agoAfaik that's only for cloud. There the software runs on an opaque virtualization layer. Windows is still closed source. Therefore there is a lot of speculation around the phone home capabilities.
- daenz 8y agoI read a fantastic article on Stuxnet. I can't find it now, but this should cover it, if you don't know the details https://www.csoonline.com/article/3218104/what-is-stuxnet-who-created-it-and-how-does-it-work.html https://www.csoonline.com/article/3218104/what-is-stuxnet-wh... To pull of what they did, they knew multiple zero-day vulernabilities in Windows. To any reasonable security-minded person, knowing that many vulnerabilities and having the ability to capitalize on them is likely only achievable a few different ways, one of those ways being having an arrangement with the company whose vulnerabilities you were exploiting.
- woodman 8y ago> I'm sorry, but this seems a little naive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSAKEY https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSAKEY. I thought everybody already knew that US corporations serve as an extension to the surveillance apparatus. Remember all the corporations fighting against the government's mandate at an artificially crippled maximum keysize of 40 bits, in order to allow continued surveillance in the 90s? Yeah, neither do I.
- srum 8y agoYou’re surely right about the incentives at play, and why no intelligence agency is going to spend millions doing x company’s validation work for them. But how in the world would selective patching work? How do you hide that?
- giancarlostoro 8y ago"We are testing beta features on different customers based on regions."
- bsamuels 8y ago>Roll out the patch to American companies first, but leave select targets still vulnerable. I would pay for tickets to the hacker news thread if that ever actually went down
- TimTheTinker 8y ago> Imagine how effective an intelligence campaign would be against, say, Iran, if the NSA went to Microsoft, disclosed a vuln, and then told them to patch the vuln ONLY in specific markets. While that approach might be effective, the long-term result could be increased distrust of American software companies by other countries, depending on how it's done. I think the primary problems are structural: that (a) a single agency has to act as both red and blue teams, (b) the red team lacks enough oversight to ensure it respects rule of law and civilian civil rights, and (c) the blue team isn't authorized to disclose all its known vulnerabilities to software vendors.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> the long-term result could be increased distrust of American software companies by other countries, depending on how it's done America isn't Australia. The NSA hoards bugs in software domestic and foreign alike. One amendment to their charter which might make sense would be installing a public ombudsman. This ombudsman reviews the NSA's vulnerability hoard, takes into account the software's usage in the United States and then makes arguments to senior leadership for selectively releasing them.
- ENOTTY 8y agoIt seems to me that the public ombudsman role you propose is already played by the other agencies and departments involved in the Vulnerabilities Equities Process https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/images/External%20-%20Unclassified%20VEP%20Charter%20FINAL.PDF https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/images... I would specifically call out Treasury (high dependence of financial sector on publicly available products), OMB (high dependence of government systems on publicly available products), and Commerce (most direct purview of publicly available products) in playing that role.
- geofft 8y ago> Imagine how effective an intelligence campaign would be against, say, Iran, if the NSA went to Microsoft, disclosed a vuln, and then told them to patch the vuln ONLY in specific markets. Not very. Do you think Iran doesn't have a Windows VM somewhere within the US and is also incapable of reverse-engineering patches?
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI'd be surprised if they bother, at that point I'd just fork Linux and go from there...
- mc32 8y agoHow would you hide these targeted updates from foes? I’m sure they can at least check the hashes of the updates, if not more. Presuming we’d be targeting their military industrial complexes who one might presume monitor for these kinds of things.
- cmurf 8y agoWhat stops non-USA companies from applying USA available patches?
- jokoon 8y agoDon't you think it's also dangerous? There were stories that US power plants could be made inoperable. Also how do you really monitor bad actors using those vulnerabilities to do other kinds of damages? To me it doesn't seem cyber weapons are that easy to use, they're volatile, secret, can be fired very quickly without sound, and are very difficult to control. So far one could say the security market was not big enough, and computers not widespread enough, so it was tolerable to let the 0day market open as long as the US has the upper hand, but as this market goes bigger, damages are going to show up more and more. Having the upper hand in term of cyber warfare is one thing, but I have a problem with what the cyber warfare terminology. I'd rather live in a world where weapon trafficking is neutered, instead of a world where bandits can cause damages (small, but still damage). I think the day is coming where higher security standards will be required by law, because the swiss cheese strategy won't work for long. Also, I have doubts that the NSA can really keep the upper hand because they have more brainpower. The cyber warfare is not only the sum of the weapons, because anybody can be taught computer security and learn how to build weapons.
- dontbenebby 8y ago>While I agree and I hate the NSA's practice of hoarding zero days, they do this to keep software vulnerable on purpose. They've invested millions in uncovering zero days SPECIFICALLY so they could then spend millions more to be the only ones exploiting these vulnerabilities. If they share the zero day, the vendor will write a patch and it's game-over for their multi-million dollar exploit. What happens when those zero days are leaked or stolen?[1] The government couldn't even protect nuclear secrets.[2] At least with nukes, it's difficult to obtain the fissile material. Even the poorest, smalled, most isolated countries can utilize stolen or leaked 0-days, and depending on how they're used they could kill more people than a nuclear bomb. (Eg: shut off the power to the Midwest during winter) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Shadow_Brokers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Shadow_Brokers [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_spies#Notable_spies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_spies#Notable_spies.
- chopin 8y agoImagine how effective an intelligence campaign would be if the NSA went to Microsoft and let them place backdoors for specific targets. Where would you draw the line?
- raxxorrax 8y agoMicrosoft would quickly lose any trust they might have left in foreign markets. Plus, I think elevating the scope of NSA is a bad idea, since they already misused their power as evidenced by multiple leaks. It would be an overall terrible idea. The cyber warfare scare is just a false reiteration to fortify arguments for further military and intelligence arming. > It's insane and criminal, but that's how it is. Just insane and criminal in my opinion because these institutions are not beyond reproach.
- woodman 8y agoThis is one of those situations that makes me wonder at how obvious the right way to go is, and how unlikely that is to happen. Offense/defense costs are not even close to being symmetrical, it is insane that the USG would advance the state of the art in electronic warfare - while not even pretending to try and match the effort in defense. This is why we abandoned our biological weapons program, we were effectively developing the technology for incredibly cheap weapons of mass destruction that any banana republic could mimic... not unlike the rootkit leaks.
- KorematsuFred 8y agoWhat NSA does to China is irrelevant. But they hurt their own American companies in the name of cyber security. I personally see this as British King using East India company to build colonies outside. This will have ugly consequences.
- Waterluvian 8y agoI suspect there's a very real fear that their surveillance capabilities will completely go dark and they'll have just no way of going the extra mile on intel gathering when it's sorely needed. I'm not a supporter of this but I do believe there is a genuine, good faith act here.
- ecocentrik 8y agoTheir primary mission isn't the discovery and publication of critical zero-days but it doesn't make them good faith actors if they occasionally do when it's both convenient and strategically advantageous.
- ufmace 8y agoI think I'd argue the opposite. I wouldn't compare hackers to nuclear missiles, but defending against hackers doesn't seem to be realistically possible. Consider the state of the security world now, how many piles of money already get thrown at security, and how vulnerable everything still is. With that in mind, I find it hard to believe that even in the fantasy world of all of the "good guy" nations, whoever you think those are, working with vendors to fix every flaw they find instead of holding them for later exploitation against selected targets, that the security landscape would be meaningfully different. Somebody would still find and hold zerodays and use them in attacks. Whoever that is would have a huge advantage against whoever didn't. I suppose in a perfect world, we'd all melt down all of our guns and turn them into wrenches or something instead and all live in harmony. But we don't live in that world. In the real world, if you melt down all of your guns, someone else will keep theirs, and use them to take your stuff, because you can't hurt them anymore. And similarly, if you disclose and patch all of your zerodays, someone else will still have their own, and will use them to hack your stuff and cause you damage, and you'll have no way to fight back, except to break out the guns and start a hot war with them. We're still learning how things work in the cyber-war realm, but I feel doubtful that it'll ever be possible to have defenses so good that you can rely on the fact that nobody can touch you.
- sdinsn 8y agoThe NSA is working to actively improve security- for the US government. The NSA should not give security secrets to our enemies abroad...
- ShorsHammer 8y agoThe problem with this sentiment is that every other country is technically the enemy. The NSA has no qualms about stealing corporate secrets or influencing governments of allies who send their kids to die on your battlefields.
- sdinsn 8y ago> is that every other country is technically the enemy No, they aren't. The NSA shares many secrets with allies.