19 ms·
Some young people are buying houses with friends
- triplewipeass 8y agoThis isn’t the future for my family or for any family with children. I grew up in a communal apartment in Russia, and let me tell you how suffocating it was to exist day in and day out in the company of strangers and their quirks. And what of those who have no friends? I struggle to name one person in this world who would qualify as a friend, let alone someone with whom I’d like to enter in a long term financial commitment.
- RankingMember 8y agoI agree mostly with your former statement, though keep in mind these people would be friends, not strangers. Even with friends it's all fun and games in the planning stages until you're locked into a mortgage with someone who clips their nails all over the house, leaves dirty dishes everywhere, and lets their kids spit on the floor. I love my friends, but seeing them 24/7 would drive me nuts. > I struggle to name one person in this world who would qualify as a friend I find that hard to believe, even if you have to lower your friendship bar to "guy who says 'hi' and asks how you're doing at the hardware store". Barring that, I'll be your friend old bean.
- logfromblammo 8y ago~Great! Now go buy a house with... green account... from peri-soviet Russia... named "triplewipeass"!~ ~No? Some friend you are.~ Stable, low-movement societies are more amenable to deep friendships, as one of the primate-brain requirements is mere proximity. We have to see, speak with, and touch the people who become our friends. Long-distance relationships are weaker and require far more effort--generally only worth it for courting and upkeep of pre-existing friendships. Military brats whose parents are frequently relocated often have trouble forming lifelong friendships, for instance. College might be their one opportunity to get to know someone well enough to stay friends after graduation, if they can afford to go. And that's just within a handful of closely-related cultures in the same country. Is it so hard to believe for someone with multiple xeno factors? Not speaking mother tongue, possibly with an accent. Not in the culture in which they were raised. Possibly different religion. No mutual acquaintances.
- alistairSH 8y agoI doubt it's the future, at least not for the long-term. Co-buying really only works well for younger professionals - not enough cash to buy solo, but still enough cash to get out and move on (hopefully). A better solution would be cutting the larger homes into condos (owner-occupied flats). Or, if the house isn't conducive to that, tear-down and rebuild as condos.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoIt doesn't really work for them either; a mortgage is a 30 year commitment. Do you really want to have such a commitment for 30 years with the people you now consider to be your friends? This seems to heavily bet on both people's incomes increasing and the housing prices to increase, which seems to work out alright in the current economic climate (just not in the UK, ironically enough), but it's not a guarantee and not something you want to bet your future on.
- elicash 8y agoA mortgage doesn't need to be a 30 year commitment. When I run rent vs buy calculators, it usually becomes a good decision around 10 years -- of course this varies dramatically from city to city. Note: This is for comparing rent vs buy of properties of equal value. But I'm just trying to make a point about the commitment of a mortgage.
- logfromblammo 8y agoThe important thing is that the rent-vs-buy inflection point is N years in the future. If N is 10, you have to believe that your current situation will be stable for the next 10 years, which is at least partially independent of the number of years it has already been stable. I have lived in the same place for about 10 years, so had I bought when I first moved, it would have been a good decision (only in retrospect). But 10 years ago, I had no idea how long I was going to be here. The job that got me to move only lasted 2 years. At no point during that 10 years did I ever believe I would still be here--and, more importantly, earning equal or greater income--10 years later. I still don't. The risk I face in loss of all mortgage-paying income is greater when I can't consider quick relocation to a hotter city for jobs, which is what happens when you buy an immobile, illiquid asset. It has never been a good decision for me to buy a home. Both times I actually did buy, I had to move earlier than the inflection point, for job-seeking reasons, and take a big loss compared to renting for that same period. The job market and housing market are inextricably intertwined. People need to live near the place that they work. If they don't have firm, stable career prospects for the next five years, at minimum, and they buy on a mortgage anyway, they will on average lose more of their money to bankers and real estate agents than they would have to rental landlords. Home-ownership is a trailing indicator for the health of local careers, not the other way around. If you don't have good job security, reasonable expectation of finding new mortgage-paying jobs quickly, or enough saved to buy your home in cash and still have some left over for expenses, you should never buy. The middlemen all earn the most when the churn rate falls into the realm of bad financial planning. If you have to sell your house and plow the proceeds into a new one frequently, the transfer middlemen earn more. If you refinance a new 30-year mortgage every 0 to 5 years, the bankers earn more. But fewer people can really expect to have same-job-same-house for the next 10 years, and they are still buying, on bad advice issued by those who will benefit most, not realizing that they are choosing poorly.
- adrianN 8y agoHousing cooperatives have a long tradition.
- taysix 8y agoMy friends and I have all thought about doing this. We still think about doing this a lot but we're afraid of a dispute coming up and ruining our friendship. We want to do it but we don't want to risk our group friendship.
- stephen_g 8y agoYeah, I wouldn’t ever do it. Living with friends was fun for a while, but at the end of the day I was very happy to be able to just move out after about two and a half years and just sign my spot on the lease off to somebody else.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI lived with my best friend whom I’ve known forever and it drove us apart. Weirdly, we still kee in touch and are on friendlier terms now than we were when living together. Doing it for 30 years sounds like my personal nightmare.
- dwater 8y agoI have done this twice, once ages 24-31 and once 31-34. Both ended up being financially advantageous, especially the first time around when few of my peers were buying houses. Both times it ended up being complicated. It didn't ruin friendships or result in bad feelings between us, but it wasn't easy. The first time though I wanted to move out before the other owner wanted to sell, so he stayed another 2 or 3 years and I was just a silent landlord, which was okay but made it impossible for me to get another mortgage or even a new credit card. In the end he got married and wanted to sell. This was in the DC area where the market was pretty much always hot, so selling the property was easy. Anywhere else it could have been more complicated. The second time my friendship deteriorated over the course of the time I lived there because of external circumstances, in the end the other owner agreed to refinance and buy me out, and there was a little tension during the process but I think we both walked away satisfied with the outcome. One of the reasons our friendship deteriorated was because as we grew into adulthood, my friend chose a career in the service industry, and I chose a career as a teacher, and it sucked living with someone who had the opposite schedule. Over time as we settled into our lives, our social schedules diverged as well, which was definitely detrimental to our relationship. I would actually recommend it either to people who are young and early in their adulthood, so that they have lots of flexibility and don't mind the challenges and inconveniences that it entails, or to people who are well settled in adulthood who already have similar lifestyles, employment situations, work schedules, etc. to minimize friction.
- RubenSandwich 8y agoThis does seem very financially risky to me. Yes, they did draw up a deed of trust and they mention that is okay if one of them wants to back out later. But that doesn't solve the monthly mortgage cost. Is that person who is "out" still obligated to pay that cost according to their arrangement? Because I can imagine finding another person to sign up to this arrangement could be difficult. I'm leaning more towards stacked micro-houses, aka micro condos, as the "future of housing" in urban centers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Cthulhu_ 8y ago> I'm leaning more towards stacked micro-houses, aka micro condos, as the "future of housing" in urban centers. This is already a thing, it's called coffin cubicles or cage homes: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/gallery/2017/jun/07/boxed-life-inside-hong-kong-coffin-cubicles-cage-homes-in-pictures https://www.theguardian.com/cities/gallery/2017/jun/07/boxed... What I'm trying to say is: No, you should not lean towards this. You should lean towards jobs and opportunities spreading out over the country. To appeal to the HN population, instead of thinking in the binary thought of "SF (or some other tech hub) or fully remote!", consider another option: opening up smaller offices. Bring work where housing is affordable.
- zhdc1 8y agoWhy not? I don't see any reason why young individuals looking to experience inner city life wouldn't be happy to exchange loving space for easy commuting and urban culture (which is what they already do).
- EpicEng 8y ago>Why not? Because your equity is now at the mercy of other people who you cannot control. No one wants to default on a mortgage.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- have_faith 8y agoIs the BBC writing more clickbait headlines than ever? continue reading to find out more! Ignoring the headline. This seems to be mostly beneficial to the lenders more than anyone else. The risk of a non-payments and financial issues is much higher and repossessions will be higher. > Even if four people's names are on a mortgage, if one or more stop paying, the mortgage lender has the right to demand full repayments from whoever they can reach, he explains. You only have to consider divorce rates to see the maligned incentives. Can someone more knowledgeable than me on the subject of mortgages explain if repossession is more valuable to the lender than someone paying off their debt? Intuitively it feels like repossession is worth more on a long enough time scale but would be interested in insights from someone else.
- ses1984 8y agoI feel like the time scales don't matter as much as the aggregate repossessions. If the aggregate is high, it's worse for lenders. Reposessing a home is not good for the lender if they can't sell it on the open market for a price close to the previous price. If repossessions go up, demand drops, and the market collapses.
- have_faith 8y agoGood point. Is this percentage a known number or is there a name for the threshold in the lingo? Like a number they would actually want repossessions to be maintained at as it maintains gaining property while the market is effected as little as possible?
- pmorici 8y agoDon't they only need to sell it for the amount of outstanding debt? That is in part why standard loans require 20% down
- isostatic 8y agoPlus the costs of selling it (typically reposessed houses have all sorts of issues, from damage to eviction costs to disgruntled ex-tennents) They'll likely sell at an auction for cash too. With two houses otherwise identical, one being sold normally, one as a reposession, you'd go for the normal one. How much less would you pay for a repossession which runs a risk of the previous owners coming back to haunt you?
- Pigo 8y agoMaybe the future is kids figuring out that they don't need to live in the city. It's the city's fault if they want to push potential employees out.
- zhdc1 8y agoEverything old becomes new again. I expect that we'll eventually see a resurgence in the attractiveness of suburban and rural housing. There's something about having free space and a general level of independence that you can't really get in an urban area, even if you're weathly enough to own your own property. Of course, it's going to take an uptick in well-paying suburban jobs, but I see no reason why large companies won't start investing again in cheap office space for satellite offices, in particular as a way to bridge remote and central office working environments.
- Pigo 8y agoI don't live in New York or LA, so to some people I might as well be a hill-jack. But I very much appreciate as much space as possible. I've also noticed a huge increase in full or partly remote positions in recent years. It's fun going into the office once in awhile, but once I'm there I'm working from the same machine and chatting online.
- yardie 8y agoWhere I'm at the suburbs never stopped being attractive. The city is still growing and attractive. And both fit a certain lifestyle. Apartments in the city are approaching half a million $. Small, older, technically starter houses, near the city are approaching half a million $. Large suburban homes far outside the city, still half a million $. Realtors were expecting a glut of suburban housing after the financial crisis. And while foreclosures did spike during the crisis it never really turned into an epidemic. The purchase time frame increased as buyers had to meet new qualifications but the demand didn't drop. But this is the case for the SE United States. Midwest and flyover states in small towns are having a much harder time. But they're impacted more by their location rather than if it is urban or suburban zones.
- rootusrootus 8y ago
- diminish 8y agoA network of friends is to insecure to finance a long term commitment. Banks exist for a purpose. But in Germany for example, Landesbanks and Sparkasses offer friendly terms to people.
- kaybe 8y agoIn Germany there is also a strong network to help: https://www.syndikat.org/en/ https://www.syndikat.org/en/ In the end you only own half of it for as long as you live in it, but anyone can walk away and be replaced without problems.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nukeop 8y agoThe future of housing is people paying ever more for ever smaller places to live, because bubbles just keep growing indefinitely and markets don't get disrupted. The tendency of employers to offer 100% home office work is a factor that can easily reverse this trend, for one.
- tsukurimashou 8y agoFrom my point of view, I'd say that friendships now are more superficial than before, so I don't see this happening on a large scale
- keiferski 8y agoAt some point, I really hope the trend of massive centralization reverses. There are hundreds, even thousands, of smaller towns in Europe and America where one can buy a house for a reasonable amount of money. Remote work might be the panacea...hopefully.
- zulln 8y agoIn addition to remote work, there is better/faster/cheaper transportation possibilities as well!
- gramstrong 8y agoRemote work might bring relief to the larger cities, but it also opens up smaller, often blue-collar industry towns up for gentrification, out-pricing the existing residents in a place where there wouldn't normally be "office jobs". Remote workers who previously worked in Seattle have done this to where I live now - which has only displaced their housing affordability crisis to a different location, and on to a different demographic.
- 0xffff2 8y agoWell, why are all of those remote workers moving to your town? If you live anywhere remotely desirable, I think it's only to be expected that housing prices are going to go up over time until we start to see an overall decline in population. Furthermore, why has the movement of people to your town created an affordability crisis in the first place? If the existing residents are opposing increased building, then it's not really the newcomers fault. If you're building to meet demand, why are prices going up?
- kalesh 8y agoYeah, I also hope for the same. It's hard though. Major jobs are around the big cities so a lot of people migrate from smaller towns.
- astura 8y agoThis can certainly work out but it's much riskier than a solo or married couple purchase. When it works out it's an amazing arrangement. So high risk high reward, I guess. Architecture seems important too. Every couple I know who successfully lived with another couple or singleton, each person/couple had their own floor to retreat to.
- notahacker 8y agoIs it really riskier than a married couple purchase, assuming the friends have lived together for a reasonable period before? There's 39 divorces for every 100 marriages in the UK, and needless to say it's a lot easier to draw up "what happens if you want to move or can't make mortgage payments" contracts between friends...
- astura 8y agoIt is, because there is an entire legal framework around marriage and asset ownership whereas there's no legal framework around BFFs. A married couple has the "benefit" of going through divorce proceedings where a judge divides up assets equitably and it's legally enforced with a divorce decree. If you're buying a house with a friend you're going to want to draft up an contract to avoid "no man's land." Then there's the "mixing business and friendship" issue. Civil marriage is already a type of business partnership, whereas friendship is not, so you're adding a new business partnership. If your buying with friends you're risking your friendship. I know someone who owns a house with her brother and it's a shit show. You're also tripling your exposure (3 people rather than 1)
- tomatocracy 8y agoThe tax system is kinder to married couples who split up than cohabiting people in this scenario. Stamp duty on a transfer to the remaining party can accrue the 3% "second home" charge if you're not careful whereas there's an exemption for married couples transferring properties between themselves. Married couples can also transfer assets between themselves without being liable to capital gains tax. This matters if someone moves out before a sale or buyout of their share.
- 8y ago
- m-i-l 8y agoThere was a startup that aimed to "help people buy property together"[0], although it looks like it was dissolved in May 2018[1] (despite the web site still being up). (Side note: I wish companies that were no longer operating would shut down their websites - there used to be a mirror shop near where I live that still has a website listing its address and phone number, and is still near top results for a search for mirrors in my area, despite the shop having been shut and the building demolished nearly a decade ago.) [0] http://neatsplit.com/ http://neatsplit.com/ [1] https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/09581451 https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/09581451
- rb808 8y agoI lived with room mates for nearly 20 years. I would have made a lot of money if I bought with them instead of renting, so I can see the benefits of this.
- m-i-l 8y agoOr instead of buying with them, you could have bought yourself and rented to them. This is what I did for the first approx 10 years of property ownership. My first place was even just a 1 bed flat, but had a separate kitchen, so I was able to rent the living room as a second bedroom. At the time, the rental income was enough to pay the mortgage, and tax free under the "Rent A Room" scheme[0]. From some quick calculations, I think this is still a viable approach, although the rental income is unlikely to pay the full mortgage now, and some of the income is likely to be above the tax free threshold. [0] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/income-tax-rent-a-room-relief/income-tax-rent-a-room-relief https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/income-tax-rent-a...
- gnulinux 8y agoDid you live with the exact same set of roommates for 20 years though? And there was no risk of this arrangement changing 20 years prior to this?
- miker64 8y agoI grew up in a big suburban house because my parents bought a house with a friend. She and her son took the downstairs bedrooms, we had the upstairs rooms. It was more house and in a nicer area than either could have afforded, and meant all the kids went to nicer schools. Built in shared parenting support, communal (but not hippy-ish) dinners. We moved in in the mid 80s, and in the early 2000s after all the kids had moved out my parents sold their half to the co-owner. Everyone's still friends.
- simonbyrne 8y agoInteresting: I've heard anecdotes about similar experiences in southern California, where the "good" school districts often don't allow apartments or smaller subdivided buildings (duplexes/triplexes) to be built.
- cptaj 8y agoWhy is the future of housing always having less?
- WhompingWindows 8y agoBecause those in housing already want the rest of us to pay more for less.
- mrec 8y agoIt's not just about having less, it's also about paying more for less. Constant property ramping by the BBC back in the early 'oughts was the main reason I cut the cord and never looked back. They're about the only big player in UK media with no commercial interest in doing it (no ads from the property sector), but even so, they just couldn't control themselves.
- entity345 8y agoBecause we're on track to be 10 billion soon.
- fixvzbdjzis 8y agoThat’s the global pop, not the UK’s. The UKs pop should dropping, if not for immigration which the UK can control if they wanted too (being an island surrounded by rough seas and rich neighbors).
- camochameleon 8y agoSmall nitpick, but it's estimated that global population will peak at approx. 8.7 billion before starting to decrease. See: https://www.cnbc.com/id/101018722 https://www.cnbc.com/id/101018722
- entity345 8y agoThat's very optimistic. "The median estimate for future growth sees the world population reaching 8.6 billion in 2030, 9.8 billion in 2050 and 11.2 billion by 2100" (2017) Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projections_of_population_growth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projections_of_population_grow...
- b0bby_tabl3s 8y agoNO. The very notion is for slackers.
- ape4 8y agoLiving in a space with a suite for each person / couple and shared common space might be ok.
- sigzero 8y agoI hope not. Friends can quickly turn.
- logfromblammo 8y agoFaster than old milk poured on older fish. If your business relationship requires friendship to begin, that friendship will be exhausted by the time it fails. If you enter in to such an arrangement, you need to forget that your partners are your friends, and instead imagine that they are all either evil goblins trying to screw you and take your share, or evil faeries that will disappear on a whim to a land that you cannot reach. A business relationship that still works between mortal enemies can certainly hold up when the partners have a relationship more cordial than constantly trying to kill each other.
- speeq 8y agoI think housing should be a basic human right. Just get Elon Musk to build affordable underground tunnel homes with his Boring company. He wants to build a city on Mars, so why not test the technology (and social aspects) here on Earth where it's much easier. Housing is a political problem, not a technological one.
- normal_man 8y agoI agree that it's a political problem, but your solution is baffling to me. Instead of addressing the inequalities above ground, like millions of homes going unused while millions of people are homeless, you want to let a private company put poor people in mole-man colonies underground??
- magduf 8y agoWell there is some sense to it: with the extreme weather we have to look forward to thanks to climate change, it'll make a lot of sense to burrow underground and live there. Underground colonies would be mostly immune to hurricanes, for instance, and probably a lot easier to keep warm when polar vortexes result in -50C temperatures outside in the winter, and easier to keep cool when it's 60C+ in the summer.
- normal_man 8y agoYou got me there. Somehow I doubt Elon Musk would be moving into the rabbit hole next to mine, however.
- smallgovt 8y agoMaybe it'll be like the history of lobsters, where it starts as housing for the poor but eventually becomes housing for the rich.
- speeq 8y agoI guess the preferable option would be to create high-speed affordable transport so that location won't be an issue to people. I'm not sure which one is more feasible.
- jrockway 8y agoI feel like this is the past of housing as well. Most people you see that live in a relatively nice housing unit in a nice neighborhood have a roommate -- the person they married. I remember when I was younger I would always ask myself why it seemed everyone other than me had twice as much money with which to buy a house... then I realized.
- black-tea 8y agoNo, that's a quite recent development too. Not too long ago it was normal for each household to have one earner. Now, thanks to women joining the workforce, we all work more for the same thing.
- standerman 8y agoNot that recent. We left the gold standard in 1971. All that inflating monetary supply has to get stored somewhere. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MSPUS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MSPUS
- moorhosj 8y agoCAGR from 1961 (beginning of data) to 1971 (gold standard) - 4.2% CAGR from 1971 to 2018 - 5.5%
- Frondo 8y agoIt isn't women's fault that the capital-holding class has turned the screws on the rest of us. It is, however, to the capital-holding class's advantage that we blame women for being paid less.
- quacked 8y agohttps://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/
- 8y ago
- shehryarrr 8y agoThis seems more like an issue of not being able to afford housing anymore in areas where there's enough demand for work. Feels dystopian to see the future as having less.
- faramarz 8y agoMy friends in Toronto co-bought a giant home in a great neighbourhood. Vice media covered their story: https://free.vice.com/en_ca/article/59xp9z/how-six-friends-pooled-their-money-to-buy-a-dollar13-million-house-in-toronto?utm_source=vicecanadafbca&utm_campaign=global https://free.vice.com/en_ca/article/59xp9z/how-six-friends-p...
- h3ckr 8y agoThere’s nothing new about this. It’s like having a co-founder in a relatively low risk small business. The fact that we need a co-founder to aford a shelter says a lot about where our society is heading and the simple presence of such articles should worry us.
- akgerber 8y agoA mechanism to build apartment buildings cooperatively with friends, with ownership still subdivided among the tenants, in the style of the German baugruppe, is much more sustainable than multiple families sharing a single house: https://grist.org/cities/i-want-to-live-in-a-baugruppe/ https://grist.org/cities/i-want-to-live-in-a-baugruppe/
- GuillaumeBrdet 8y agoLots of different opinions here, but I do believe buying housing in groups/syndicates will become something we see more often. Most can't afford 100% of a great deal in the beginning, though, they could afford the 10%.
- radium3d 8y agoAs someone who co-signed on a loan in the past and had to short sell, I advise you to keep paying rent, save money and only purchase a home you can afford instead.
- rootusrootus 8y agoThat sounds unpleasant. All of the downsides of living with family and few upsides. Might as well just go back to multi-generational family housing. At least then grandma would be on site to help with my kids...
- newnewpdro 8y ago> All of the downsides of living with family and few upsides You choose your friends, not your family. So unless you're not discriminating who your friends are, I don't see how it's similar to family at all.
- rootusrootus 8y agoAt least with my family I have bonds that go above and beyond the house we live in. Getting into a mortgage with friends sounds perilous.
- aidenn0 8y agoIt really depends on your family. Plenty of people have friends that they trust far more than they trust family. I know plenty of people that have had their parents steal from and/or defraud them.
- newnewpdro 8y agoI think it comes down to working with what your resources afford you and weighing the risks vs. rewards. By involving friends it's entirely possible to avoid a mortgage altogether. Living mortgage and rent-free buys a lot of tolerance for others in my experience.
- nfriedly 8y agoHonestly, I kind of wish multi-generational family housing was more acceptable. Sure, it might not be for everyone, but I have seen it work out well before.
- throwaway-1283 8y agoAnecdotally, I only know of unmarried partners buying houses together, but not platonic friends.
- hanoz 8y agoNo, BBC, the future is not yet another generation of youngsters paying more for less and resorting to obviously impractical group mortgages in support of your relentless pro house price inflation agenda. The future is for them to have some semblance of security of tenure without having to "get on the housing ladder" and prop up the whole sordid ponzi scheme.
- eli_gottlieb 8y agoThe future is socially owned housing.
- merpnderp 8y agoDoesn’t the UK call those council houses? And people are usually trying to get out of them.
- stronglikedan 8y agoThat's the present, too, for those that need it, but it will never be the norm for those that don't.
- richmarr 8y agoIn the UK's case, I think the future is a massive house price crash triggered by the depression following Brexit.
- crushcrashcrush 8y agoMaybe I can buy a flat in London! Just a little pied a Terre from some disgraced Saudi...
- jasoncartwright 8y ago> relentless pro house price inflation agenda Strong accusation. Probably a reflection of a UK culture of house buying, rather than BBC bias.
- deleted 8y ago
- perfmode 8y agoWhat type of legal abstraction would provide the features needed to make it safe and sensible as a practice? Incorporation with shares?
- detcader 8y agoWhy would I want to buy a house at all, much less with other people? Some anecdata and heuristics incoming: I know someone who owns his house and he had a plumbing problem in his basement recently; huge pain and expense. Folks in their 20s are seeing these stories. Cultural criticism and call-out culture makes it clear to us that productive communication and friendships are actually hard to do, and that just because you're "supposed" to buy a house and have 2.1 kids plus dog doesn't mean you really have to to be a "successful person!" I think if people my age see the economic incentives like I am, they are going to move in to apartments, where they can just autopay rent and worry about degrees of magnitude less things that could go wrong, or just move out of the country where they can make more money?
- nfriedly 8y agoMy brother did that with some friends so that they could own a house in the Bay Area. I'm glad they're happy, but it seems a little crazy to me. (I lived in the bay area for a year, but then moved back to Ohio. Housing prices weren't the main reason, but they were a small part of why I moved.)
- angarg12 8y agoA few experiences here from people who did this and worked out nicely. I also know a good amount of stories of people who bought property with their partners and didn't turn out ok. Now take that risk and multiply it by the number of people involved. But my biggest issue with this approach is that it doesn't solve the underlying issue of housing affordability. Essentially it says "you need 4 incomes to buy a house now", which will enable prices to keep on rising. What will happen when prices keep on rising and 4 incomes are not enough? Where will the limit be. "Is buying with friends the future of housing?" I hope that if I do it it's because I want to, not because it's what I need to do to put a roof over my head.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mbostleman 8y agoI have a hard time understanding all the negative reactions to this. I think it would be helpful if people separated the emotionally driven ideas of "friends" and "living together" with the more business driven idea of partnerships that acquire assets. I wish I would have never rented. It would be a huge advantage for anyone to accelerate their entry in to buying property by combining capital early on. Yes, you and your partners have to be grown up and treat it like a business - not like frat bro room mates. Yes, there is a risk that someone will not hold up their end of the deal but that is true with any business partnership, hence the need to choose your partners wisely. The bottom line is, this is a great way for people to impact their balance sheet significantly over their lifetime by starting early.
- marssaxman 8y agoThe earlier you start, the less life experience you have, and therefore the less wisdom you can apply to the problem of choosing your partners.
- robear 8y agoAs an anecdote, my wife and I bought a place with friends because we couldn't afford on our own. People told us we were crazy. We basically bought the worst place in the city even with both families having good incomes (Vancouver). We had a five year plan to renovate the house and sell it. My wife and I didn't have a kitchen for a year. We cooked on a hot plate and washed dishes in the tub. Every time one of the houses around us was torn down, the mice would flee to our house until we plugged all the holes. Weekends and evenings were spent working on the house. We were lucky that the market continued to go up and that both couples were on the same page about everything. The house turned out quite nice. We have since gone our separate ways and each have our own place. I love where we are now but I could have continued to live in the situation we were in longer. It was like family. We did lots of things together socially and we supported each other. Financially, it was the best thing both couples have done in their lives (again lucky the market continued to go up). That's my sample size of one.
- pkulak 8y agoYou bought property in Vancouver 5 years ago. That's like saying you bought AAPL in 2004 with a bunch of friends and it worked out great. Well, it wasn't the friends part of the scheme that made it work out. ;D
- robear 8y agoI get the tongue in cheekness of the comment with the ";D" but I think I qualified how lucky I feel several times and that it is an anecdote/sample size of one. When we bought people thought it was the peak of the market and that is part of the people telling us it was crazy. We had no thoughts of the market continuing to go up when we bought. Our main focus was possibly making a bit on the renovations. Even if the the market had gone down or sideways, and we didn't sell, I would have been fine with it. If we had lived there for the rest of our lives, I would have been fine with it. I liked the location and with the renovations, it was a great house. It wasn't a get rich quick "scheme". Buying with friends was a way to buy a home. We were constantly being renovicted. We didn't have a place we felt was home. That house was home and buying with fiends was the only way it was possible.
- throwaway-1283 8y agoI see a few startups that are doing rent-to-own or get down payment help for equity in your home. Some people will scoff at sharing upside in your home, but IMO it makes more sense than this.
- tomatocracy 8y agoShared appreciation/whatever you want to call it is only really appropriate in my view where you have a strong view that your income is likely to grow more quickly over the next few years than house prices. This is because these schemes are usually limited in availability in such a way that you can't rely on them being there again when you decide to move up - so you need to be sure you can borrow a mortgage of the size of the amount of shared appreciation you are paying back to be able to move up (otherwise you'll get "trapped" - you can only afford to move to a cheaper house or stay where you are). If you don't think your income will rise that quickly, or you think house prices will rise even faster, you'd be better off buying a place you can afford without shared appreciation and taking the biggest traditional mortgage you can get. If you think prices are going to fall but want/need to buy now anyway then they are a fantastic deal.
- csomar 8y agoAh, the big cities are turning into a shit-hole for many people. It is interesting that both politicians and rentiers will ignore the signs until a full collapse. How hard will it be to move government jobs and private jobs (with special tax breaks) to a different nearby city? I mean: London, Paris, New York. Over-priced shit-holes. Check the apartments that the average guy/middle class family can get. The apartments in both London and Paris are real shit-holes. Amenities (like doors, toilets, kitchens) are from the 60s. The solution is actually not quite sophisticated: Move government jobs first. Most people will move when offered a new, clean, affordable city that they can live in. Brazil did this with Brasilia. The US has Las Vegas. Positive side effects: + The people from the country side where the project will be built will become instantly rich. They hold large lands that new developers will pay (relatively little) for. So wealth moves from the average guy to the poorer ones instead of the rich ones. + New, Modern transportation system are easier to build in an empty plot of land. + You'll probably have underground parking in your condominium. + You pay less for rent/mortgage but you get to live on a 21st century apartment or house.
- reneherse 8y agoExcept that it's not 1950.
- droithomme 8y agoBuying with friends is a good way to end up with a lot of problems. Are you absolutely sure that you really want to spend every day living with your college buddies for the 30 years of a mortgage, covering them when they are short, either living with their filth or cleaning up after them, as well as dealing with all the long term house guests and pets they bring in? The court cases resolving these sorts of breakups make bitter divorces look like a walk in the park. But they are not quite as bad as when two business partners who started a business without an ironclad contract have a break up. Having fun with someone once a week to watch sports on TV on weekends, playing beach sports, hiking and camping, hanging out in pubs, etc, doesn't mean you're compatible enough to have fun living with them every single day in a small space for several decades. Notable exception is long term unmarried best friends who are basically married to each other but it's platonic. These relationships are fairly rare. Pushing friend mortgages to the general public as a solution to unaffordable housing is a good strategy for mortgage brokers and real estate agents who work in those markets. They don't have to deal with the fall out of the break up so it's only upside from their point of view.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoI strongly recommend, if possible, to have a single homeowner and set everyone else up as renters. The only exception is married couples who already have shared finances. Want to share a house with friends for twenty years and share childcare responsibilities? Great, have them sign an intent-to-lease agreement and take that to the mortgage company to help with qualification. Not having this kind of agreement can lead to all sorts of issues. This should also extend to being jointly and severally liable for paying rent, not just mortgage. What happens when a tenant stops paying? If you've got joint and several liability, you basically have to pay the full amount while being unable to evict the deadbeat for nonpayment (since they're an owner or on the lease). It's slightly better in the case of the lease since you can negotiate a technical default and deadbeat-only eviction with your landlord, but it's still a mess that you should avoid if possible. That all said, living in a house with friends is an excellent choice IMO. I think humans are built to have some non-blood relatives at that level of closeness and cooperation, and it seems good to raise a child with more than two adults that they interact with in their typical household setting.
- silverlake 8y agoIn the US 2 single people who jointly own a home can EACH deduct the interest on up to $1m loan. So consider having a legal agreement for joint ownership instead. I’ve done this and deduct an extra $20k.
- jcoplan 8y agoWhat is the basis for saying that two single people can deduct the same interest paid? How could this possibly not be fraud? You are double claiming the interest.
- silverlake 8y agoNo. My home loan is well over $2m. If we were married we could only deduct $1m (half the interest). As 2 single people we can deduct the interest up to $2m. It’s a wrinkle in the tax code.
- 8y ago
- jgamman 8y agothis will take off if and when the market lets it ie, banks need to have mortgages that have >2 people, standardised contracts and housing _designed_ for co-living. it's a big difference between sharing a nuclear-family-designed house with friends and sharing something that has alone-space and communal-space. personally, i think co-housing will take off. It's pretty standard in Norway for instance IIRC.
- harrumph 8y agoAny fans of the fiction of Kim Stanley Robinson are nodding their heads at this news. Communal living is a big theme with his stuff.
- wharfjumper 8y agoIn New Zealand, the banks commonly require personal guarantees on this type of mortgage. As a result my friend declared himself bankrupt when 1. his co-owner stopped paying his share of the loan 2. the rent didn't cover the mortgage payments 3. the sale price was less than the purchase price. In other words read the loan documentation very carefully and think about the consequences in a worst-case scenario.
- damjanv1 8y agoI always thought that it would be interesting if houses could be bought through more flexible financial arrangements like other financial instruments. Say for example I wanted to buy a house but I would be the majority shareholder with a 51% stake in it and I would like to sell the other 49% to investors that want exposure to the property market (which they would already have but in the sense that they would want to take a more active view in this shareholding) . You as the majority shareholder would get to live in it while only putting up 51% of the capital. Of course as someone stated below there would be many difficulties in this not least the explosion in property prices as demand goes up.
- _archon_ 8y agoI don't see why you can't do this now. Draw up an ownership contract and shares etc. This should be workable as long as you don't need a mortgage, and you'll likely need to incorporate, so the deed will be owned by an LLC or some such.