18 ms·
Spotify adds 1M unique listeners in India in less than a week
- GuillaumeBrdet 8y agoThat's some pretty amazing numbers for one week! I wonder how it affected Apple Music with cancellations. It is interesting that Spotify is $1.68 in India.
- KorematsuFred 8y agoApple users in India are negligible. There are just 10M iphones in India compared to 300M android users. Of course that number is just 1/3rd of Canada's 30M iphone users.
- anoncake 8y agoApple Music is available on Android.
- Gigacore 8y agoI had a bad experience with their app on Android. The collection is not great either.
- skrebbel 8y ago30M iPhone users on a 36M population? I strongly doubt that.
- anoncake 8y agoMaybe 30M Iphone sales in Canada?
- bpye 8y agoI have no idea how reliable statista [1] is, but they seem to agree. It seems kinda insane though so I'm hesistant to believe it... [1] - https://www.statista.com/statistics/274772/forecast-of-mobile-phone-users-in-canada/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/274772/forecast-of-mobil...
- KorematsuFred 8y agoActually It is something like 25M total mobile phone users. But 30M is a reasonably good upper bound.
- sn41 8y agoI use Apple Music on Android, in India. (The list of Indian titles available in Apple Music has been impressive, so I am inferring from that there's enough demand to keep the catalogue updated.)
- shubhamjain 8y agoThis includes both free and paid tiers. I am not sure if there's a strong reason to celebrate. I would speculate that most of these users are in the free tier. Spotify's catalogue for India is severely limited with the feud they are having with WMG, which makes it—despite being the best music streaming app—quite an unattractive option.
- ing33k 8y agoActually it's not too bad. I was able to find most of my favorite Kannada and Telugu Songs.
- ing33k 8y agoI was more than happy to cancel my Apple Music Account as soon as I was able to install Spotify in India. I primariy use an Android Device and use an iPhone as a bakup device. Apple mucic app on Android sucks.
- sanketskasar 8y agoI am on an iPhone and an Apple Music user. Got Spotify premium the very first day hoping to find good curated playlists. To my shock, I couldn't find a lot of mainstream Indian and International tracks, very limited playlists, and ever more limited regional and classical music curation. Cancelled my subscription just yesterday and got the refund. Apple Music still remains the go-to music platform in India despite so many competitors.
- yash1th 8y agoI’ve used for a few months before jumping to AM. The reason I moved was due to lack of indian songs library on Spotify. Although, initially AM sucked with their collection, at least it have some of the regional indian songs I wanted. I’m so glad I stuck with it, because lots and lots of indian albums have been added and continues to do so.
- r_singh 8y agoYou'd be more interested in knowing that Apple Music's family offering (for 6 users) is for $2.54/mo in India. Yes that's correct, $2.54 for 6 users!!!
- OJFord 8y agoIt's not shocking without comparing spending powers though. What's the price of roughly equivalent street foods in Mumbai vs. New York, for example. I'd wager the multiple's not far off that between 6 user Spotify in the two countries.
- r_singh 8y agoYup, I agree, and that's a smart move by these international cos. The average Indian street food in Mumbai for 1 person is half a dollar.
- alayek 8y agoIn India, Spotify Premium is 119 INR / month, while Apple Music is 120 INR / month. Spotify also have few other options, like annual membership, and student plans. While recommendation is off the charts, the collection simply isn't there. Mostly due to licensing issues, I assume. For instance, really loved the tracks from Suits, and got my own playlist on YouTube too, consisting off some nice tracks compiled from tunefinder. But the Spotify track list is only a subset, and not all those tracks are available. Am on iOS, so no Google Pay Music on phone, and for me Apple Music is no worse than Spotify, except when it comes to search.
- krtkush 8y ago> Am on iOS, so no Google Pay Music on phone What does that mean? Google Play Music works fine on iOS.
- josteink 8y agoAnd so does YouTube music.
- procinct 8y agoWhy can’t you use Google Play Music? It’s available on iOS.
- sanketskasar 8y agoIn my experience Apple Music is really good. I have found almost all songs I have searched for. Everything including very old regional songs to international indie artists and Japanese anime openings. PS. Suits soundtrack was one of the very first things I searched for and found many playlists with most tracks on it. And tunefind actually provides direct links to Apple Music so that you can immediately add it to your library.
- almost_usual 8y agoThis feels like a small number considering 1.3+ billion people live in India.
- swimfar 8y agoAlmost 0.1% of an entire country's population in a week is a small number?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- almost_usual 8y agoRounding up from 0.075% to 0.1% feels a little generous
- a-ve 8y agoMostly because people who listen to local songs are already using gaana/saavn/youtube, which arguably have a better catalogue when it comes to indie artists and songs in local languages. And people using Jio already have access to JioMusic/Saavn.
- onion2k 8y agoThe entire population of a country is rarely the target market.
- AJRF 8y agoSure 1m out of 1.3 as a percentage is small. Out of those 1.3bn, how many are children below 13 or seniors above 65? I wouldn't count those as targets of Spotify. Further still how many of the remaining pie is connected to the internet? Remember India has vast swathes of the country that are extremely poor. So take those out of the pool. Now of the remaining pool how many are eligible to pay for a service like this? Okay and what subset of that started using spotify in the past 7 days? The number is for sure smaller than 1.3bn and when accounting for the tiny time frame its enormously impressive. I actually find it impressive that you don't think that is a fantastic conversion in the space of a week, I wonder how many products in the history of mankind have achieved something like that?
- kumarharsh 8y agoThat's one way to stop piracy: go to the market. (:
- nolok 8y agoStill doesn't solve Spotify's core long term issue : if they make lots of money, right holders know exactly how hard they can negotiate for better fees. Netflix fights that with their own content now, but Spotify doesn't seem to be interested to go that way (and I'm not sure they could anyway). So they're pretty much trapped into being a barely profitable company that's also milking money to the content owner.
- rdiddly 8y agoThat's an interesting idea though, like basically "Spotify as a record label." They could sign & develop talent, maybe develop a distinctive in-house style, have a whole Brill Building type thing going on.
- xxpor 8y agoBen Thompson's been talking about this a lot recently. The tldr is this is a big reason why Spotifys been making a big push into podcasts, because its hard to impossible for them to make money because of how the value chain works I music.
- AndrewUnmuted 8y agoIt won't be too long, I'm sure, before Spotify gets into the market of licensing music for podcast productions, allowing them to double-dip - once during production, and again upon release.
- draugadrotten 8y agoBen Thompson on Spotify: https://stratechery.com/2018/lessons-from-spotify/ https://stratechery.com/2018/lessons-from-spotify/ He does list as one possiblity that Spotify will one day cut out the labels from the value chain. I personally think it is inevitable; the labels used to source, market and distribute music, and there is nothing (except the "admission cost") that I can see will prevent a distributor such as Spotify to become a label. Spotify has a strong brand name which can be leveraged as a strong asset for "great music" if they do it right, whatever that means. Can't see them put other labels out of business though. Their blue ocean can be to completely ignore physical and go fully virtual, perhaps even as far as offering immersive 3D concerts online, with artists that never appear in person - or perhaps in the future with virtual artists that never even existed irl. There is also nothing inherently wrong in just being a distributor. Sometimes harvesting a stable profit over decades is better than growing like cancer and then crashing because you're yesterday's news. However the record labels are a threat against the stability and hence it is most likely that Spotify will push to become independent, just like Netflix.
- meethkr 8y agoEntire Pantera discography, Pearl Jam discography and many older songs are missing. It's good for recommendations but the collection isn't great. I'll stick with the much cheaper prime, 15 USD Per year gives you video, faster delivery and music.
- 7171u 8y agoMay be because of this: https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/26/18241345/spotify-india-launch-warner-music-legal-battle https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/26/18241345/spotify-india-la...
- josteink 8y agoThat’s clearly 1 million which was waiting for this. Let’s see how the numbers change from now on. That will be a lot more interesting.
- r_singh 8y agoI have Spotify India on my phone, so I guess I'm a part of the 1 million that was waiting for this. I was about to pay for it even thought it's offered as a free service as well. However, once I gave it a go, I realised the collection available in India is quite disappointing and this is clearly not what the 1 million were waiting for. PS - I'm not really using Spotify, even though I'm counted as a user.
- somberi 8y agoJio, the largest cell phone service in India, with about 280 million subscribers, recently acquired another streaming service called Saavn, and it is available for free for Jio customers (along with their Tivo-like TV streaming service and their movies). P.S - I work for Jio. P.S2 - Apple music also costs the same as spotify in India. To reply to Zuron's comments: Even assuming Spotify experience is better, it is a question of pricing. Jio currently offers unlimited calls, text and 1.5GB of data per day (which includes all you can stream) for about the same price (USD 2.10 per month for the whole thing whereas Spotify charges USD 1.70 just for music streaming). I am trying to making a humble point that there are some incredible values to be obtained at this price point in India today. @Ing33K - Yes that is me.
- zuron7 8y agoBut, let's be honest, the experience that Spotify provides is way better than what Saavn does. I can change music remotely on any device, get much better recommendations, and listen to podcasts conveniently.
- sreekar545 8y agoThe only recommendation system I really liked was of Pandora. Spotify's is a joke, playlists and radio got a lot better compared to 2-3 years ago but I can't just put the radio ON and forget like I can, with Pandora.
- zuron7 8y agoAh yes, Pandora is better (tried it over a VPN once), but I live in India, so was speaking from that perspective. Spotify comes second for me personally. I've tried them all.
- ing33k 8y agooff-topic: Hey, I remember you from your username. you were hiring for some fintech company. Were you hiring for JioMoney ?
- Gigacore 8y ago
- Gigacore 8y agoThat's not a bad number to start with! I have used Apple Music, Amazon Prime Music, Google Music, Saavn and Gaana etc. They all differ from one another in terms of collection. Now I am using Spotify in India -- though at this point in time it lacks a collection of regional music and playlists, it still has the better interface and options to use it across different devices compared to others. I guess once Spotify curates better regional music, it will have an edge over other services.
- hnzix 8y agoI would love some good Bhangra sources. Spotify is good for "Hottest 100" lists but digging deeper seems hard from within the app, I rely on external blog playlists like Dummy. I've yet to see a music app nail discovery.
- sanketskasar 8y agoFor punjabi songs, I feel Apple Music and Saavn are the best. Both have really good collection and atleast Apple Music has a good curation of playlists as well. Have been using it for almost a year now.
- zuron7 8y agoI wonder how many of those listeners were already using spotify through cracked APK's.
- Gigacore 8y agoEven with cracked APK, there was no option to set the region to India. With that, the stats for US must have gone down a bit after users switched their region to India.
- sidkhanooja 8y agoPersonal anecdote, but it's nice to see the growing maturity of the Indian audience - no one in my circle of friends and family is complaining that big names such as Linkin Park, Ed Sheeran, Coldplay et al. and rock/metal biggies (Slipknot/Dream Theater/Pantera et al.) are missing. Growing tastes, perhaps? And it's amazing to see Spotify grow so quickly. Almost all of the people I know (I'm guilty of the same) used a US free-tier account, and sideloaded modded applications to listen to Spotify. I used to think that was piracy as usual, but now all of us are on 1-year subscriptions. The price sensitivity ($9.99/month in US vs $1.68/month in India) does obviously make a difference.
- Nition 8y agoSo Spotify in India is missing a lot of the big-name artists? That's a little sad as I always felt one of the the big benefits of Spotify is they seem to have EVERYTHING. Video streaming services like Netflix are a joke in comparison.
- r3bl 8y agoThere are three major music publishers (UMG, Sony, Warner). As long as you have contracts with them, you'll have nearly everything. Spotify's not the only competing service that has almost everything. Tidal, Google Play Music, Apple Music, they've all managed to get a deal with those publishers. Smaller players like Deezer even manage to offer the same service to 180+ countries (compared to Spotify's 20). Netflix and others would also have nearly everything if the majority of the movies was produced by three publishers.
- caractacus 8y ago> There are three major music publishers (UMG, Sony, Warner). As long as you have contracts with them, you'll have nearly everything. If (i) you have mainstream taste and (ii) you're not in a market with a substantial domestic recorded music market like, oh I don't know, India, where the majors hold a minority of what people like to listen to.
- kristianc 8y ago
- coldtea 8y agoAnd the news is? In a country with 1.4+ billion people, you just put up ads for the new service, make sign up and basic functionality free, and even a "urinate on your carpet" service could get 1M uniques on a few days...
- ptd 8y agoI’m not too familiar with this hypothesis, do you have any sources I can refer to? Thanks
- coldtea 8y agoSorry, I don't ascribe to the theory that people shouldn't use their observations of industry/society/media/etc and brains to make deductions unless there's a ready-made paper and some stats they can quote. I came with this hypothesis on my own, without referencing some media industry analyst...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Erlich_Bachman 8y agoI think the poster probably refers to the basic math of the number of subscriptions/size of the market.
- poizan42 8y agoHitting 0.07% of the market with a free service in a few days is not impressive, do you really need a source for that?
- sreekar545 8y agoHa ha. That's true. Also, the craze towards anything American in India is mind-boggling. People are going to install and use it for some time even if they don't like the service.
- superasn 8y agoAmazon prime music also has a very large collection of music + gaana.com offers yearly memberships for 99rs and Jio has saavn which is free for Jio users (at least currently) so they are up against some very tough competition since most of these services are ad free and free.
- manojlds 8y agoPeople are joining Spotify for the "cool" kid factor - they want to differentiate themselves. Much like buying iPhones in my mind.
- philliphaydon 8y agoI buy iPhone because it’s better than android.
- manojlds 8y agoI am not talking about the western market. iPhones are extremely costly here and generally sold unlocked. Buying it is for the status even when people have to do EMIs.
- philliphaydon 8y agoI'm not talking about the western market either. I'm saying "people buying spotify for the cool kid factor" is false.
- pragmaticlurker 8y agoI'd like to be also a user for 1.60$/Month instead of 9.99€
- ascii_only 8y agoMake Spotify family account and share it with friends or use VPN and make Premium Philippines account.
- pragmaticlurker 8y agodo you care about your password? I do
- dhruvrrp 8y agoSharing a family account doesn’t mean you give your password away. The way it works is one person pays and that person can add 5 other accounts to his ‘family’ to give them access to premium.
- pragmaticlurker 8y agoI didn't know about that kind of account
- grwthckrmstr 8y agoSpotify India user here. At midnight when I found out from my friends that they launched in India, I switched from my $9.99/mo shared account from some internet service to Spotify's $1.67/mo within minutes. Spotify had a pretty neat prepaid option too, where your subscription doesn't renew until you manually recharge. Was cool of them to add such an India-specific feature at launch.
- finchisko 8y agoIt really costs 1.67$ in India?
- dakshmiglani 8y agoyes it does, but for the time being a lot of artists are not available there. so worthless for some people.
- statictype 8y agoApple Music is almost the same cost and has almost everything I want to listen to.
- lvng 8y agotrue but apple music's ui and music discovery feature sucks. Ongoing feud between warner and spotify will be over in coming days as both companies are loosing out on revenue, so yeah spotify will get better with time in India. But for local music listeners Gaana is still a better choice imo.
- mesaframe 8y agoThats scaled according to cost of living in India.
- govg 8y agoI'm unsure if Spotify offers these plans elsewhere, but in India they have the following tiers : Rs. 119 per month (1.7$) Rs. 1189 per year (16.85$) And also, funnily, "top-up" plans: Rs. 13 for 1 day (18c) Rs. 39 for 1 week (54c) Rs. 389 for 3 months (5.5$) Rs. 719 for 6 months (10.2$) Also available are student plans, which give you a 50% discount on the monthly plans. So you could end up using Spotify for ~85c a month in India.
- sanketskasar 8y agoPretty sure a high percentage of these listeners are using free tier. And most of them using it just to brag that they are listening to music on Spotify. Their music collection is one of the worst among all services present in India. Lots of major international records are not available. Regional music collection is not good. Only the mainstream/popular content is available. Bought the premium subscription on very first day of launch. Tried using it for few days. Found major stuff missing. Cancelled and got the refund. Kudos to them for prompt service on this. But very bad in comparison to Apple Music and other Indian services. Apple Music costs similar for individual account and much cheaper with a family account, has much better International and Indian collection and really good playlists collections, at least in India.
- r_singh 8y agoKeeping in mind the current collection available through Spotify, the more appropriate way to state the first sentence would be: > Pretty sure a high percentage of these listeners have downloaded and tried the free tier. Because most of us aren't really using it, are we?
- sanketskasar 8y agoPretty much not. I installed the app. Bought premium. Cancelled it. Uninstalled the app. All in a matter of few days.
- adventured 8y agoWhat are the top local competitors in India? I'm unfamiliar with the streaming music market there.
- r_singh 8y agoJIOSaavn, Gaana, Amazon Prime Music, Apple Music (which is much cheaper as a family account), Hungama, Wynk. All the above currently have more songs (except Prime) on them than Spotify in India does.
- iamgopal 8y agoGlad to see this, I think all US based internet companies, ( not only the giant ones but small ones too ) should grab the Indian market which, because if Jio, growing at many folds. Couple of years back, It was not possible to watch movie online, and now, each individual in my family has 3 GB / Day data plan, so much to the point where we hardly turn on the tv. same can also be possible to infrastructure and industrial / corporate products. I can see in couple of years all major Enterprise software running in cloud for majority of Indian industry.
- ptr 8y agoWhy US based? Spotify is Swedish.
- blackoil 8y agoIndia has free song service from Jio(Saavn) and Airtel, 2 largest mobile service provider. Few independent players like Gaana which are half the price of Spotify and Amazon Prime music which is at same price as Spotify but comes bundled with Prime Video and Shopping benefits. So uphill battle for Spotify.
- dakshmiglani 8y agoHonestly, I'll rather pay $15/mo for the US version of spotify then get the Indian version. Most of the songs, I listen to are not available in Indian Version. songs from artists like green day, linkin park, coldplay, etc.
- tarasmatsyk 8y agoSounds good, as Youtube music is coming for the market. Go Spotify! PS. Still miss you in Ukraine
- r_singh 8y agoThis is just positive PR now that Spotify is publicly traded. It's not a serious indication of their success in this market. This truly just means that 1 million people in India "downloaded" the app: a good share who were waiting for it and wanted to pay and a great share that are using it since it's also offered here for free. Plus there's already strong competitors with cheaper services and a lot more songs (including Apple Music). If Spotify's only USP will be its song discovery, I doubt they'll get a lot of Indian users to switch just for that.
- Gpetrium 8y agoThe goal is likely to show that they are managing to penetrate the competitive Indian market, a valuable market to be in, in the long run. Whether they are able to remain competitive is another matter.
- openloop 8y agoI like the social in Spotify better than iTunes a lil
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- anildigital 8y agoMost of them talking about price and free tier. But I think good apps and good service is what can attract more listeners to Spotify. Their app is world class and a good competition to Apple Music. They have huge collection of curated playlists and new generation surely loves listening international albums and not just local music. I think they are going to grow faster and become a good competition to JioSaavn, Gaana, Wynk. There is a high chance some of them are going to shut down soon.
- mccoure 8y agoFor someone who listens to a lot of International rock/metal/post-rock etc I can say most of the names and even some obscure Norwegian/Australian bands are present. The ppl complaining probably are referring to local content(Bollywood/Marathi/Hindi/Tamil music). The recommendation engine is fabulous as always and the podcasts section has a pretty decent collection too
- r_singh 8y agoI couldn’t find latest hip hop albums from Atlanta on Spotify. They’re on Apple Music tho.
- actuator 8y agoNo, a lot of big names are missing. I will still use it as discovery is still miles ahead of any service. For example they are missing names like Led Zeppelin, Van Halen, Whitesnake, Fleetwood Mac etc.
- djhn 8y agoIn which region? I've had all of these all over my playlists for as long as I can remember... A decade?
- Chico11Kidlet 8y agoWhat's the reason for that?
- notadoc 8y agoSpotify is the best streaming music service, nothing else comes close to competing. Pandora is still decent for discovery.
- HHalvi 8y agoI used Spotify at first via VPN and then went for a premium account and it's been around 3 years since then. I know a lot of other folks that did the same (using it via VPN, not really the premium part) and most of them ended up switching the country tab from US to India the day Spotify quietly launched here. Don't have any evidence to back up my claim but I think a large majority of the first 1 million unique listeners are made up of these folks.And also they(myself included) have evangelized Spotify to their friends/family/twitter followers