16 ms·
Firefox Experiments I Would Have Liked to Try
- thepangolino 8y agoI think those kind of experiments should be the future of web browsers. We the people, need to take back control from online services.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- faitswulff 8y agoSticky reader sounds like a feature users would want and publishers would hate. TL;DR - pages from certain sites are always displayed in reader mode. Of course, this would cause havoc with any advertising. That said, I'm all for it!
- MBCook 8y agoSafari has had that exact feature for a few years at least. If advertisers don’t want me to use it they shouldn’t be so obnoxious I NEED to.
- cstuder 8y agoiOS has this feature already built into Safari, but it's well hidden: Long-press the reader icon.
- dgellow 8y agoFirefox on iOS also has this feature. Just touch the little paper sheet in the URL bar.
- _Microft 8y agoIf the paper sheet icon is not there, prepend about:reader?url= to the url to activate it manually. It even works most of the time even while Firefox thinks it can't be used on this page.
- jamesgeck0 8y agoThat only displays the reader; it's not persistently applied to every page on the site.
- severine 8y agoI mostly use Open in Reader View(1), but there's also Automatic Reader View(2), which fits your description better. (1) https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/reader-view/ https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/reader-view/ (2) https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/automatic-reader-view/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/automatic-rea...
- JoshTriplett 8y agoI'd love to have Sticky Reader Mode for a site, except that Reader Mode also eliminates site navigation sometimes. So, on some sites that display stories chapter-by-chapter, you lose the "next" button, and have to turn off reader mode, hit "next", and turn reader mode back on.
- dgellow 8y agoTry Safari then. The feature is nicely integrated and works well
- userSumo 8y agoOne thing i was thinking would be also cool is improving the image view (when you open .png url for example).it would be nice if it had proper smooth zoom using mouse wheel, and some preset zoom buttons for fit to screen, 1 to 1 pixel, etc. Maybe it could also open image links in just some simple popup window. Other than that i would really like updated bookmark and history manager.
- arc-the-lad 8y agoYes! The image zoom levels always bothered me, particularly the fact that it snaps to the size of the view vertically but not horizontally, making it hard to comfortably read vertically heavy images or use portrait-orientation displays.
- throwaway66666 8y agoSo much this. Also the ability to change the background from black to white (with a slider or an easy to reach color picker that doesn't involve opening the console). It's so hard to notice when an image starts and ends when it has black at the sides, or to be able to distinguish transparent pixels easily.
- _Microft 8y agoA way to rotate images without having to resort to the inspector and transform:rotate(...) would be nice as well there.
- catbird 8y agoYes! I used to have an extension that allowed you to resize any image (even in the middle of a page) by holding a button and scrolling. It was fantastic, but was never migrated to the new extension format unfortunately.
- pragmatick 8y agohttps://addons.mozilla.org/de/firefox/addon/better-image-viewer/ https://addons.mozilla.org/de/firefox/addon/better-image-vie... works reasonably well but doesn't have all the features you mentioned.
- popmatrix 8y agoIt would be great to signify a browser window as my main window where new tabs are opened rather than using the last focused. Alternatively, I would take a way of blacklisting a window from letting new tabs be opened. As more and more apps become web-apps, I like having the apps open in multiple windows on one monitor and use another monitor for web _browsing_. Having new tabs open, hiding my email, jira, docs, etc... is a small annoyance but one that would be great to have remedied.
- rolleiflex 8y agoI just want to have my tabs stop talking to other tabs and their resources / cookies / caches / spyware / tentacles. Every tab should be a VM. I am willing to pay a significant performance penalty to achieve that. I have a password manager, and I'm 100% OK with having to sign-in for every tab as well. I'm surprised no browser vendor actually ever tried that.
- sebazzz 8y agoTab or website as part of a tab? The latter is the only way cookies will never be shared.
- jMyles 8y agoHear hear. Can somebody speak to the challenges of such a scheme? I also really like this idea. Even for cases where I'm cool with tabs sharing state, I want to opt-in to that and be reminded with some kind of color-coding or something.
- swozey 8y agoThis is how Firefox container tabs work. I have several color coded tabs like Work, Personal, Gmail2, etc. It lets me use my personal Gmail in its own orange tabs then the blue tabs are my work gmail. It's made dealing with gcloud/aws and different logins for the same portals way better than my previous Chrome workflow of having different profiles I had to switch between. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account-containers/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account...
- __jonas 8y agoI tried to do this but I can't figure out a fast workflow to achieve this. I hate having to do the extra steps long-pressing the new tab button every single time and then selecting the container type (same scenario of two gmail accounts so I can't "open in container by default"), I wish there was just an url prefix or something to open in a specific container so I could just create a bookmark for each gmail. I'm curious what your workflow is like, do you just always keep both tabs open?
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoChange Scout is actually one of the basic reasons to deploy Huggin... so you can monitor pages for changes and get emails.
- behyo 8y agoTest Pilot is closing? Does that mean that the Mozilla Corporation no longer has a backdoor in Firefox through which they can install plugins in the same way they installed the Mr. Robot advertisement plugin some time ago? https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/16/16784628/mozilla-mr-robot-arg-plugin-firefox-looking-glass https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/16/16784628/mozilla-mr-robo...
- blaze33 8y agoI usually keep lot of tabs opened and I known I'm not the only one to use Firefox (or any other browser) like that. I'm still waiting for a better UX on this use case. Bookmarks are hidden behind menus and require some work to organize and sort them: it's easier to leave an open tab in plain sight that reminds me to eventually read it and decide whether to close it or save it as a useful resource. Last actual improvement I noticed was when Firefox stopped fully reloading every tab in session restoration. Any actual research on user-friendly UX to manage and organize lots of potentially useful urls ?
- nicoburns 8y agoI use the Simple Tab Groups plugin for this: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/simple-tab-groups/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/simple-tab-gr... It allows you to move tabs into named groups. Only tabs from the active group are shown in the tab bar, and you can switch between groups using an icon in the toolbar.
- saidajigumi 8y agoAs a pre-Quantum Tab Groups user, I find that Simple Tab Groups is considerably more stable and has a slightly better UX than the old support. So A+ for that. I still feel like there's some missing "secret sauce" here, but I haven't had the time to really delve into the problem to suss out what that might be. I do love that tab groups are malleable to the user's concept of organization, not some artificial notion such as grouping by website.
- albru123 8y agoUnfortunately Simple Tab Groups (or maybe some internal feature it uses, probably hidden tabs) somehow leak resources and end up eating all the RAM for me. The end of Panorama (or Tab Groups as known nowdays) was a disaster for me, as I don't hesitate having over 3k tabs open.
- nevster 8y ago
- clairity 8y agoit was interesting to read about the "line of death": https://textslashplain.com/2017/01/14/the-line-of-death/ https://textslashplain.com/2017/01/14/the-line-of-death/ the chrome doing weird things in the viewport will make users trust unsafe actions by bad actors, so don't do that.
- Fice 8y agoIt was discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13400291 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13400291 Thinking about it I came to realize that there is a much deeper cultural problem: it became the norm for users to run lots of opaque untrusted code on their computers. Every application is a threat, as it represents interests of the vendor rather than the user, and this can not be solved just by isolating UIs (the line of death) and code (sandboxing), we must reconsider the models of software distribution that we use. Maybe the Web should not at all be used as an application platform and instead focus on content and give more control of its representation to user agents. And there actually is a software distribution model that gives grounds to trust — the one used by GNU/Linux distributions where software is not pushed to the users by vendors directly, but reviewed, built from source and packaged by distribution maintainers who represent the interests of their users. And of course, for the maintainers to be trusted, their work must be maximally transparent and verifiable. Some distributions, like GNU Guix, managed to advance this model really well, while others are unfortunately now going in the opposite direction by adopting things like Flatpak and Snap.
- clairity 8y agoyes, thanks for adding a more probing analysis. the web is still great, so i wouldn't like to see it thrown out yet, but maybe something better (built on gnu/linux?) can supercede it eventually. open source hardware like arduino and raspberry pi is now near the point of being powerful, cheap, energy-efficient, connected, small and plentiful enough that maybe it begins to undergird trustable computing devices for wider consumption. google is completely untrustworthy and while apple is better, it's not without its trustworthiness compromises. with mobile, there's really no 3rd choice unfortunately (waiting to see how the purism device turns out).
- chalst 8y agoWrt the "My Homepage" idea: one of the ideas driving IPFS is just this [1]. A barrier to IPFS is that they (necessarily) reject HTTP in favour of something in some ways like Bittorent. Les Orchard wonders if some sort of profit system could bootstrap the system. The IPFS folk have proposed an interesting cryptocurrency, Filecoin [2], allowing people who want their content hosted can pay people who offer hosting services; the core idea is that proof-of-work can be replaced by proof-of-replication, which I think is a nice idea. [1]: https://ipfs.io/#why https://ipfs.io/#why [2]: https://filecoin.io/ https://filecoin.io/
- KoenDG 8y agoI thought this was going to be about stuff like Ubiquity: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Labs/Ubiquity https://wiki.mozilla.org/Labs/Ubiquity Loved that back when they tried it. Here's an old screenshot: https://imgur.com/O8rN9fK https://imgur.com/O8rN9fK Since there doesn't appear to be any on the site. It was great. Just directly interact with all kinds of apis from a commandline-like environment, within your browser.
- ehaughee 8y agoWith how popular command palettes have become (in things like text editors), I'm a little surprised this hasn't stuck for browsers. I really enjoyed the various implementations of this kind of thing for browsers but often found them lacking in ways that I think a native implementation would be more effective.
- pfraze 8y agoIn a dev branch of beaker, I've been playing around with something similar the "Modal Page Actions" idea with a "context bar." It has actions based on what the browser recognizes about the site (stuff like "follow this site" or "view profile" or "10 comments"). I'd like to have a whole contextual sideview as well, because I'd like to render trusted interfaces for the given page, but it's a little tricky to decide when to take real-estate in the shell. Some people liked it in a demo, and some felt like it's an intrusion. The trick is, if you make it a toggle then you can't rely on the interface being there so it's hard to use for critical functions, which makes me think it shouldn't be a priority yet. We'll see about the context bar. The "My Homepage" concept will be in the next release. Seems like a good idea.
- ww520 8y agoThat's a fantastic list of ideas for Firefox. I hope some of them got implemented as feature in the browser or add-ons. BTW for Popup Tab Switcher, I had a similar thought and built an add-on for it, showing tab thumbnails instead of tab list. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tip-tab/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tip-tab/
- ww520 8y agoThe sticky reader idea is something I myself would use. I hope you don't mind I steal the idea to build an addon with it. I'm already doing restoring saved reader mode tabs in my other add-on Session Boss. It's just an extra step to transfer that functionality to make sticky reader mode work.
- JoshTriplett 8y agoThe "Personal Historical Archive" notion suggests one specific improvement I'd love to have: full-text search of my history.
- detaro 8y agoI haven't tried it myself, but there was this Show HN a while back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17743352 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17743352
- ceiphr 8y agoThe "My Homepage" experiment sounds like a decentralized social platform right?
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoThe statement "So using RSS would be very reasonable discovery mechanism, but an “RSS reader” doesn’t seem like a good direction on the current web." strikes me as needing elaboration.
- ianbicking 8y ago(Author here.) The RSS feeds of major news sites gives a list of articles and titles, but a large portion don't give anything more, and the remainder give excerpts. So the RSS feeds are more like a headline ticker. It's a good way to get an up-to-date list of news posts, but not news content.
- ttepasse 8y agoA front page of different news sources is in effect a headline ticker. And you still have the links to the articles which give you detailed information via Open Graph / Schema.org / h-entry markup. As a heavy user of feeds I always wanted a feedreader in my browser, but more with the list in the sidebar and a content main, like in a traditional feedreader. Firefox' Live Bookmarks did that for a while, but of course Mozilla killed it. Safari's Twitter integration hat the same model for a while. Also Opera. But UI-wise all solutions weren't as great; hindered by integration into bookmarks of general non-nativeness. Like the current top comment I find it frustrating that browser makers stopped caring for the power user demographic and effectively stopped competing with UI features. My ideal browser would be a mixture of the feedreading capabilities of NetNewsWire 3.2 (Subscribe to a shell script!), the storage modell of Evernote and such, the tab management of TreeStyleTabs but with the taste and elegance of OmniWeb 5, the native integration and resourcefulness of Safari and the configurability of old Opera.
- ianbicking 8y agoTo be clear, I'm not disagreeing – it's just from a technical point of view RSS is limited. The next step I'd want to take is to use that list of updated URLs to fetch content, get Open Graph metadata, maybe try text summarization, etc. Traditional RSS readers were basically ways to browse the content of a bunch of RSS feeds, and we need a little more these days to build a good product.
- vanderZwan 8y ago> It would monitor the page inside the browser, so it would have access to personalized and authenticated content. A key task would be finding ways to present changes in an interesting and compact way. In another experiment I tried some very simple change detection tools, and mostly end up frustrated (small changes look very large to naive algorithms). I'm somewhat surprised by this - I would have expected a modern diffing algorithm on the HTML (after the page has finished rendering) to work quite ok. I wonder what would be the reason it doesn't?
- ianbicking 8y ago(Author here.) Perhaps it was harder because in the other experiment I was focusing on applications like gmail. These applications would tend to rerender large portions of the UI on seemingly small changes. Also I was trying to find a region that changed, like a rectangle or a portion of the tree, so that I could show the "interesting" part of a page. These applications didn't easily split their changes into regions. The approach where you show the entire page, and show the changes as green/red or <ins>/<del>, would probably work. But that doesn't lend itself to summarization, which is where my head was at.
- dmortin 8y ago> The approach where you show the entire page, and show the changes as green/red I don't know if you know Distill. That does this, though that shows the changes only within the part of the page you selected. It's a change detection tool which works in the browser. https://distill.io/ https://distill.io/
- vanderZwan 8y agoAh, that makes sense! I was stuck in an "article" mindset - what if it was only used for reader mode? That might simplify the implementation and still be beneficial for what I expect to be the most common non-developer case: seeing if and how an article was changed since publication.
- air7 8y agoShameless plug: I made a FireFox extension called Check4Change which, well, you can probably guess...
- mcbutterbunz 8y agoI wish I could get adjustable windows in Firefox. I spend a lot of time in a browser and I have a very large monitor. With one OS window to alt-tab through but multiple pages open at the same time, that would be killer.
- alanbernstein 8y agoAdjustable how?
- ChrisGranger 8y agoThis used to be possible with the Tile Tabs add-on, but the updated Tile Tabs WE is somewhat neutered, unfortunately. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tile-tabs-we/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tile-tabs-we/
- ww520 8y agoThe add-on Tip Tab [1] has a view to show all tabs of all windows, and let you use the TAB key to cycle through all of them, with the RETURN key to activate the current tab. So you can have multiple windows open with different sizes at different locations of the screen, and still be able to cycle through them. Not sure whether that would help. [1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tip-tab/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tip-tab/. (shameless plug for my add-on)
- curioussavage 8y agoWhat I really want is a keyboard centric power user browser. I don’t think any of the big browsers could even turn into something like that at this point. Power user feature like keyboard shortcuts are an after thought. I want really good tab management built in through some kind of workspace. I want something more than just profiles a workspace should be kind of like an editor workspace and provide different tools to help you be productive. A minimal UI and user configurable keyboard shortcuts would be great too. I wish I had written down more of my thoughts but I think to sum it up - all browsers are trying to compete for the average customer. I would pay money for a power user/developer focused browser. For now I’m trying to customize qutebrowser to get closer to what I want.
- ekianjo 8y agoHave you tried this? https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/vimium-ff/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/vimium-ff/
- fernandotakai 8y agoi tried all vim-like addons for firefox and none come close to what the old pentadactly did :( i ended up with vim-vixen, but it's still missing a lot of functionality.
- jcelerier 8y ago> What I really want is a keyboard centric power user browser. I don’t think any of the big browsers could even turn into something like that at this point. Power user feature like keyboard shortcuts are an after thought. https://www.qutebrowser.org/ https://www.qutebrowser.org/
- jakecopp 8y agoTridactyl gives you Vim bindings in Firefox (Quantum)! https://github.com/cmcaine/tridactyl https://github.com/cmcaine/tridactyl
- bovine3dom 8y ago
- euske 8y agoHere's what I want: a complete browsing history with all the keystrokes and whatnot, or a replayable browser. Sometimes I want to know how I discovered a certain page that is in my history or bookmarks but quite don't remember. It would be cool if I could trace back what I was thinking during browsing.
- epage 8y agoHistory is pretty broken. Some other problems to address - You can either search or browse by time, but not search within a time frame (as far as I know) - Pages are listed by when you opened a tab, not when you closed it. I might have a tab open for several days (or ahem years). I look things up by what I was recently doing, not when I started doing it.
- cryptokernel 8y agoJust leaving this here. Earn cryptos while accomplishing tasks. Join CoinCircle now: https://coincircle.com/l/50VVxbObg3 https://coincircle.com/l/50VVxbObg3
- bckmn 8y agoIt's fun to map each idea into a separate product. Reminds me of Craigslist's re-bundling [0]. From the post: > Personal Podcast: > [...] When on an article, you can generate an audio version that will be added to the feed > [...] just send/text the link to add it to your preferred podcast app That's exactly what we've built at https://www.narro.co https://www.narro.co - with Firefox support via good ol' vanilla bookmarklet. -- [0]: http://acrowdedspace.com/post/166470695392/the-rebundling-of-craigslist http://acrowdedspace.com/post/166470695392/the-rebundling-of...
- reaperducer 8y agoWhen on an article, you can generate an audio version that will be added to the feed I believe this is possible natively in macOS. Select some text. Control-click on it and select Services > Add to iTunes as Spoken Track.
- zcwbz 8y agoTest Pilot is closing? Does that mean that the Mozilla Corporation no longer has a backdoor in Firefox through which they can install plugins in the same way they installed the Mr. Robot advertisement plugin some time ago? https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/16/16784628/mozilla-mr-robot-arg-plugin-firefox-looking-glass https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/16/16784628/mozilla-mr-robo...
- gboudrias 8y agoHoly crap, I don't remember hearing about this. Yeah I'd rather not have that. Reminds me of the Ubuntu hubris and their built-in ads. You just have to wonder what it is that makes big open-source companies so disconnected from their userbase. Still better than Google in practice, but Google's PR is much better.
- mrec 8y ago"Studying what Electron does for people ... What gives the app value over the web page?" I always assumed that the immediate benefit here wasn't to the user at all, it was to the developer who could be 100% sure what engine they were running in, and so didn't have to bother testing in multiple browsers and versions, or risk browser updates breaking their site.
- zitterbewegung 8y agoAlso, its much easier to find people that can design for the web instead of designing for the desktop.
- mrec 8y agoDifferent question, no? This is about Browser vs Electron, not Browser/Electron vs Native.
- damagednoob 8y agoThe author gives two examples in Slack and Spotify and it's pretty apparent why Electron is better than a browser. During screen sharing calls in Slack, it can capture the user's mouse and control a remote user's desktop. With Spotify, it can cache gigs of mp3s to save on bandwidth. I don't think either of these features are possible with a standard browser because of sandboxing, nor should they be allowed.
- TylerE 8y agoNitpick: Spotify is Vorbis, and has never been MP3
- notatoad 8y agoBut slack and spotify both have websites that offer all the functionality of their electron app, and people still install the electron apps. They devs aren't saving any effort by having an electron app if they still have to build the browser app.
- foxhop 8y ago* Right click and "remind me later" about this tab. * Right click and "make a task" out of this tab.
- owaislone 8y agoI was hoping to see them give Ubiquity one more shot as part of the experiments.
- accountwhatever 8y agoOne experiment they could try is fixing bookmarklets, which have been broken for over 6 years now: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=866522 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=866522 Even this 20 line PR to bring back the most basic functionality has been languishing for 7 months https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1478037 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1478037 Another experiment would be allowing the user to set the new tab page to a local html file without having to create two config files full of magic incantations.
- severine 8y agoI use Bookmarklets Context Menu in Firefox, it's not perfect but it works. Read about it here: https://github.com/mems/bookmarklets-context-menu https://github.com/mems/bookmarklets-context-menu
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SophosQ 8y agoOne satisfactory solution that had existed in the early days of Firefox was the use of group tabs that you could access at a click of a button. They were an excellent solution that I wish could be reimplemented.
- huxflux 8y agoAm I the only one who still keeping Opera installed because it can pop-out video into a new window?
- sanfur1745 8y agoGwgwgwgwf
- sanfur1745 8y agojbaharba123@gmail.com
- Ygg2 8y agoI could be the minority here, but I really enjoy the Pocket recommendation I find in my Mobile Firefox. I'd like for Desktop Firefox to show them as well, as well as sinking, so I get the same recommendations on both mobile and desktop.
- archiepeach 8y agoI have been working on the timed repetition one for the past couple of years. https://vocabifyapp.com https://vocabifyapp.com It's a Chrome extension & web app for highlighting bits you read online. Then it generates flashcards for you to review on a spaced repetition-type schedule. No Firefox extension yet, but shouldn't be hard to port over. Very interesting read, quite impressed with the other experiment proposals.
- iamaelephant 8y agoMaybe Firefox could "Experiment" with making trackpad pinch to zoom work like every other browser first.
- Joyfield 8y agoI would like for FF to remember the volume...
- GuillaumeBrdet 8y agoThis is really cool and well presented! Lots of interesting ideas as well.
- godDLL 8y agoWhat I'd like to see is a Fire-Pixie, a sort of a Rust/Go/Dart or whatever rewrite that is modular----sorry, has modular support for HTML5/beyond features that I could enable. Or install. As modules. With some sane common base of modules, that does not include <video> and <script> and such. An HTML1/5 base if you will. That is about fifth of what is in the spec, sorted by common usage among the more traffic-heavy sites on the Internet, crucially ommiting the annoying and colorful and tracking functionality altogether. Do I need to lay this out further? Because, oh boy, I so can do that. For like 16KB right off the top of my head.
- epitactic 8y agoThe cloud browser concept is intriguing, as a quick weekend project I whipped up this simple demo: https://gitlab.com/epitactic/cloudbrowser https://gitlab.com/epitactic/cloudbrowser - using Google Chrome instead of Firefox, but it runs headless on a VPS and lets you browse most websites. Comments/feedback welcome, I'm trying to get it posted as a Show HN soon. Here's a live demo on a VPS: https://cloudbrowser.website/ https://cloudbrowser.website/