8 ms·
Earth’s Atmosphere Stretches Out to the Moon and Beyond
- mLuby 8y agoBussard ramscoop here we come!
- devmunchies 8y agoKind of like how there is a atmosphere of stench around rotting food.
- haberman 8y agoI'm surprised this would need to be verified experimentally. Why couldn't a density gradient like this be derived from fundamental laws?
- mLuby 8y agoAs I recall you can't even do this for Earth's atmosphere below the Karman line—it's experimentally derived. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Standard_Atmosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Standard_Atmosph...
- ummonk 8y agoYou could just assume constant temperature (using e.g. blackbody temperature based on solar radiation) and get a first order approximation of the behavior of the atmosphere. Won't be as good as the standard atmosphere model which uses empirical temperature gradients, but it will provide a ballpark model of the atmosphere.
- macawfish 8y agoThis is such a good question. Thinking about it reminds me of a quantum mechanics prof who once explained the way a physicist would model a person skiing through the forest. The person would be either a sphere or a box, depending on what's most convenient. The trees in the forest would be cylinders or boxes. The person skiing would then be something like a sphere bouncing around through all these cylinders. And then another time my statistical mechanics prof informed me that "physics is just drawing cartoons of reality with math." That came as a huge existential relief by the way. Popular science holds that physics is the study of "fundamental laws", but really it's just a special practice of articulating these very stable, ubiquitous patterns. When you look at things holistically, you will notice that they are often irreducably dynamic, complex and full of potential surprises, along with fully actualized surprises. So I'd imagine that all these relationships of atmospheric gases with things like the earth's magnetic field, weather patterns, chemical reactions in the atmosphere, interactions with extraterrestrial particles, the dynamics of other magnetic fields, etc. would all make this very difficult to model accurately. First principles apply very well to our nice toy models, but the sheer vastness of existence usually out-scales our toy models very quickly.
- Rychard 8y ago> physics is just drawing cartoons of reality with math https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spherical_cow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spherical_cow
- ithkuil 8y agoOne thing that physics does well is to place upper and lower bounds around what that unpredictable thing that the actual reality can be or do
- bookmacpro 8y ago> Thinking about it reminds me of a quantum mechanics prof who once explained the way a physicist would model a person skiing through the forest. The person would be either a sphere or a box, depending on what's most convenient. The trees in the forest would be cylinders or boxes. The person skiing would then be something like a sphere bouncing around through all these cylinders. This way of thinking is a bit flawed. Convenience is an important aspect, but it's not the entire reason. A physicist who wants to study how skiers might cause avalanches by modeling/simulation doesn't care about the details of the people they model because that's just not important. For what they want to study, it doesn't matter if they model the human as a sphere or as a real-life model with limbs and so on. It won't affect the grand picture. On the other hands, a physicist who wants to study how an avalanche would crush a person? Then yes, modeling the limbs and the person's physical properties become much more important. In modeling, you choose the model that best fits and represents what you aim to study. You start off with a complex system of equations and then you slowly go through and remove the parts that would be irrelevant. You don't need to account for turbulence if you know that you will never reach the high Reynolds numbers that require it. You don't need to model cellular biology if you're just trying to modeling how a piece of tissue stretches.
- macawfish 8y agoAll great points. But yeah it was a joke! And basically I remember his joke having a tangential quip about choosing the shape based on the coordinate system you wanted to stay in. And the point I got from it was that in modeling we often use crass approximations that are oversimplified in order to get a rough picture of what's going on with respect to certain dynamics, and that one shouldn't assume that the model resembles the full complexities of real life. By the way, he was a cosmologist, if that helps you understand a little better why he was so flippant with the shapes.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI guess it's because of the interactions between gravity of Earth, Moon and other bodies in the Solar System, solar radiation pressure, and magnetic fields. It's hard to account for all the possible influences, and verifying things experimentally lets you both check your theoretical work, and possibly discover sources of influence you've missed.
- abtinf 8y agoImagine how exciting it would be if you built a model, with every factor you could think of, and then it turned out to be even just a little bit wrong.
- thorsday 8y agoFundamental laws are "just" models, and models are only as good as we can validate them. My day-to-day involves running simulations of physical systems and while things like the Navier-Stokes equations are well known and understood (to the best we can), the difficult part comes in the constants we use in the models to describe specific aspects. The Navier-Stokes equations themselves can describe and tell us how fluids behave, but we still need constitutive models to describe the fluid. We get those models by proposing ideas and testing them.
- jules 8y agoThis is a typical exercise in thermodynamics courses, but simple models may not be very accurate.
- erbium 8y agoThe magnetosphere and solar wind
- BorRagnarok 8y agoI'm surprised you're surprised. Why wouldn't you want to verify your theory? Look at all the missions to comets we did, they all returned totally unexpected results. Results we wouldn't have if we had never gone out there to verify our theories.
- tomrod 8y agoWhy doesn't the gravity of the moon cause atmosphere to collect around it?
- sandworm101 8y agoBecause the radiation from the sun pushes it away faster than the moon can hold onto it. The moon has no, or a lot less of a, magnetuc field to shield itself. This happens on earth too, but only for the light gasses like hydrogen and helium. That's why there is no helium layer at the top of our atmosphere. It gets pushed out into space by the sun. The process on earth is called called thermal escape. On the moon it just happens much more quickly and to heavier gasses.
- tomrod 8y agoNeat! Thanks for taking the time to explain! So if no heliosphere (but warm?) a moon theoretically could strip atmosphere?
- kijin 8y agoDo you mean: could the moon strip away our atmosphere with its gravity in the absence of solar radiation? Well, Earth has gravity, too. It's much stronger than the moon's gravity. In fact, Earth's gravity is the only thing that's holding the moon where it is! The moon might manage to steal a little gas from Earth and hold onto it, but the transfer of mass will be nowhere near what I would call "stripping".
- sitkack 8y agoShouldn't the dark side of the moon have a small atmosphere then?
- taneq 8y agoThe what now?
- firmgently 8y ago
- maskedinvader 8y ago"... The denser dayside region of hydrogen is still rather sparse, with just 70 atoms per cubic centimeter at 60 000 kilometers above Earth’s surface, and about 0.2 atoms at the Moon’s distance..." tldr: Well that's hardly anything, nothing to see here
- sohkamyung 8y agoNot quite true. It might affect astronomical observations from the moon: On the down side, the Earth’s geocorona could interfere with future astronomical observations performed in the vicinity of the Moon. “Space telescopes observing the sky in ultraviolet wavelengths to study the chemical composition of stars and galaxies would need to take this into account,” adds Jean-Loup.
- maskedinvader 8y agoimagine a gradiant of uv scattering atoms going from a density of 70 atoms to 0.2 attoms ... it should not be quite a interference, for the average astronomer out there, this is not an issue, simply dealing with the lower atmosphere is problematic enough. edit for missing not
- erbium 8y agoOne cc is pretty small.
- ta1234567890 8y agoSuper interesting. The article says the SWAN instrument measured/detected hydrogen atoms, is it possible there's other gases/elements there too?
- erbium 8y agoMostly ionized oxygen, sulfur, iron, various random metals and light elements.
- inamberclad 8y agoSure, it's kinda there... It'll count for free radical oxidation of spacecraft surfaces and cause minute amounts of drag at those altitudes, but it's worth reminding people that this is in the range of dozens of atoms per cubic meter. Water boils at body temperature at the Armstrong line, which is only 19.2 km above sea level.
- DoctorOetker 8y agoaccording to this article: > The denser dayside region of hydrogen is still rather sparse, with just 70 atoms per cubic centimeter at 60 000 kilometers above Earth’s surface, and about 0.2 atoms at the Moon’s distance. At the distance of the moon: 200000 per cubic meter so I think it's a bit higher than you think... of course you don't explicitly mention a height for the spacecraft surfaces...
- FakeComments 8y agoThere’s around 10^25 atoms per cubic meter of air at sea level, so talking about a 10^5 density, a 10^20 reduction in density, is pushing the definition of “there”. (This also makes it closer to space, at 1 particle per cubic meter, than Earth atmosphere, by a dozen orders of magnitude.) For reference, lead in drinking water is actionable at a 10^8 factor, but beyond that — say 10^12 — we largely talk about it not being there. There’s basically no case we refer to something attenuated by twenty orders of magnitude as qualitatively the same. Edit: For fun, I looked up what it meant as energy differences — twenty orders of magnitude is the difference between you jumping and the total energy from the sun that strikes the face of the Earth each day. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orders_of_magnitude_(energy) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orders_of_magnitude_(energy)
- EForEndeavour 8y agoYour comment is consistent with why the parent replied to the grandparent: 2e5 is orders of magnitude greater than "dozens." That's still closer to space than to sea-level atmosphere, but it's not nearly as close as the grandparent comment stated.
- ajuc 8y agoSo, when will the Moon fall on us?
- taneq 8y agoIt won't. This negligible smattering of gases would have less of an impact on the moon's orbit than the tidal forces pushing it further away.
- animal531 8y agoYeah, it's actually moving away from the Earth at something like 4cm per year.
- ufmace 8y agoIIRC, it's believed that the Moon would eventually leave the Earth's orbit, if not for the fact that both the Earth and Moon will be destroyed by the Sun going red giant long before that would happen.
- dotancohen 8y agoThis is a terrific question that should not have been downvoted. The article literally says "the moon flies through the Earth's atmosphere", which implies drag.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoA downvote without a (short, simple) statement of reason can be quite impolite and disrespectful. This is a perfect example. Not only is it discouraging (not everyone knows they've made an error...and so it punishes an innocent question ), it leaves the recipient without knowing what the problem is.
- SomeHacker44 8y agoThe moon is actually getting farther and farther away over time and increasing its orbital period as it does.
- zokula 8y agoFun fact! The Earth is inside the sun's atmosphere.
- em-bee 8y agoi have been wondering about just that...
- ValleyOfTheMtns 8y agoSo, in a way, the Moon has an adopted/hijacked atmosphere?
- mirekrusin 8y agoSo humans did not leave earth’s atmosphere after all.
- kerbalspacepro 8y agoIf we want to just play with words to make them meaningless: humans have never left the bonds of Earth's gravity.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoAnd literally never will.
- danjac 8y agoDoes this technically make the Earth a gas giant?
- buboard 8y agonow i need to find a very very very big balloon
- tempodox 8y agoWow. Apparently, those sensors generate so much data that even 20 years later one can still make discoveries by evaluating it.
- jonnycomputer 8y agoI would imagine therefore that Earth's micro-organims occasionally land on the surface of the moon. Not a particularly hospital place the moon. But if it were made of cheese, it'd probably be green by now. (:
- lazyjones 8y ago> I would imagine therefore that Earth's micro-organims occasionally land on the surface of the moon. Only on the moon? They might be hit by space debris and travel through space to other planet's atmospheres.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoTardigrades beat us there?
- kempbellt 8y agoTardigrades beat us here
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoNaturally. But I thought we had em beat in terms of rocket propulsion.
- sangnoir 8y agoI'd think that's highly unlikely as the geocorona is mostly sparse hydrogen atoms; I doubt even viruses can float in a hydrogen atmosphere, let alone micro-organisms.
- subbz 8y agoHilarious fact!
- api 8y agoWould any be theoretically viable? I imagine a cyst gets blown into space from time to time but wouldn't last long in a radiation filled vacuum. Solar UV radiation is intense without the atmosphere. It's why space suit visors look reflective and why spaceships tend to always be white or shiny. Bonus: myth: space is dark. You don't get the omnipresent lit sky effect since there is no atmosphere to scatter the light but if you are anywhere near a star it is blindingly bright... in the star's direction.
- jefurii 8y agoThe article notes that the study used twenty-year-old archival data from the ESA/NASA Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO). It's good to keep that stuff around, organized so that you can find and use it.