6 ms·
Good for them -- it's their town after all! My grandmother's house (in Australia) was assigned a house number (in the 70s?) but she refused to use it, continui
by gumby 8y ago
Good for them -- it's their town after all!
My grandmother's house (in Australia) was assigned a house number (in the 70s?) but she refused to use it, continuing to give her address as the house name and insisting that we grandkids address letters to her by name. As far as I know they always arrived. There was no number on the house or letterbox. I went by a few months ago (somebody else lives there now) and there's a number on the letterbox.
My in-laws live in a village in Germany (a little south of the town in this article) with only two streets, referred to as "am Berge" and "im Dorf" (on the hill and in the village) and though the house numbers are not unified as in this article's case, there is no actual street sign -- but by "name" it's pretty obvious which is which.
- scotty79 8y agoGood for the 60% of the 69% of voters that showed up and voted against street names. Less good for 40% of 69% voters that showed up and voted for street names. And probably 'meh' for 31% of voters that didn't care enough to show up. Personally I really hope something like https://plus.codes/ https://plus.codes/ will catch up. People should be easily able to provide address without knowing or caring about local arrangements.
- bhaak 8y agoPlus codes work as long as your location doesn't change. Happens not so often. But it does happen that the coordinates of a building don't stay fixed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structure_relocation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structure_relocation
- scotty79 8y agoWhat if you move? Your address changes. Why would it be any other way? If you want something attached to your identity not your location, that's what names are for. Just don't be surprised people can't find where you are if you give them your name instead of location.
- laumars 8y agoI would imagine your classic postal address (ZIP / postal code) would also change if that happened since all western methods for addressing houses are based on location. I say "western methods" because there are some exceptions to this rule is countries with high numbers of nomadic tribes.
- jacobush 8y agoHm, in Sweden they are shifting Kiruna, a mining town.
- bhaak 8y agoYou don't have to resort to countries with nomadic tribes. House numbering logic wildly differs between countries. In Tokyo, houses are numbered in the order in which they are constructed. I would expect a moved house therefore to keep its number. London (or even the UK as a whole?) also has a rather random assignment of house numbers even though the natives will claim its completely logical.
- chrisseaton 8y agoWhat are you referring to for UK house numbers? They’re just sequential by location on the road in most cases.
- laumars 8y ago> House numbering logic wildly differs between countries. In Tokyo, houses are numbered in the order in which they are constructed. Isn't that the case for most countries? > I would expect a moved house therefore to keep its number. Do you have any reason for this expectation? I ask because your comment here sounds very speculative judging by the way it has been written. > London (or even the UK as a whole?) also has a rather random assignment of house numbers even though the natives will claim its completely logical. It's only random where houses haven't been built sequentially down the road. Much like the Tokyo example you gave. In any case, you're addressing the point about house numbers where as I was discussing postal codes. The two differ. House numbers are an exact designation for your property; be it a house, flat, or even mobile home on a plot of land. Post codes (zip codes, etc) are a region of land which would typically serve a cluster of homes. While you code move a property and decide to keep the same house name (though it would be massively confusing if you kept the same house number if you moved it to another street - so I suspect some authority or other would step in and say you cannot do that), you cannot keep the same post code. To use a comparison, it's a bit like moving your house out of London and into Tokyo but still putting London, England on your addresses and expecting post to get delivered to the right place. While you can move your house, you cannot move London nor England with it. And the same is true for postal / zip codes - in fact more so because you can in theory put garbage down as your address just so long as you get the house number/name and the post code right.
- Double_a_92 8y agoIf the location changes drastically, which I guess would only matter for a public building anyway, you could just update the adress. I don't see the problem.
- gumby 8y ago> Personally I really hope something like https://plus.codes/ https://plus.codes/ will catch up. Who needs some proprietary system (there’s also a so-called “three word” competing system). Just use lat/long which are universal. > People should be easily able to provide address without knowing or caring about local arrangements. What can be more “local” than an address and why should it be subject to outside specification? If you consider lat/long user-unfriendly then just stuff them into URIs of some sort — URLs would work — and keep this em in a sort of DNS. Then people could name their addresses whatever they want.
- pwm 8y ago> What can be more “local” than an address and why should it be subject to outside specification? This is a pretty strange statement. Ad address, in my interpretation, is an identifier that can be given to anyone without local contextual knowledge to find a place of interest. You can tell me in my hometown that the cafe is opposite of the hardware store and I'll find it precisely because I know where the hardware store is. In other towns/places, as an outsider, I would need an address to be able to find something.
- scotty79 8y agoI'd love to use lat/long. I would expect that on the phone with GPS I should be able to paste my current location (after reviewing it and possibly adjusting it on a map) anywhere .. mail, text, message in any app, any text field. And whoever views the message or document with such pasted location should be able to see where it is, navigate there. But regrettably that's not the case. So I'm hoping that SOMETHING will catch on eventually.
- hxsvui 8y agoYeah and guess how good it works offline. You don't even know which country a place is in if you only know coordinates and have no access to the smartphone. Do a typo and there's no redundancy or error correction. You'll end up in some ocean then.
- leetcrew 8y agocan't you already do this with share intents on android? how many messaging apps do you know of that don't provide an endpoint for share location from google maps?
- krapp 8y ago>People should be easily able to provide address without knowing or caring about local arrangements. That's up to the locals. They have the right to insist you should care first about local arrangements before interacting with them.
- scotty79 8y agoWhat if I'm a local but I don't care about other locals and their arrangements and I just want to get my damn package delivered from people who care about local arrangements even less than I do?
- krapp 8y agoCampaign harder for the next referendum, I guess, put up with it, or move. I could understand it if the existing system were broken, but it doesn't seem to be. From what I can read, it seems to work, presumably people do get their mail and packages.
- scotty79 8y ago> Campaign harder for the next referendum, I guess, put up with it, or move. Or work around local arrangements using lat/long or plus codes or whatever naming scheme delivery companies will choose to use for your town... Democracy (or any form of government) wouldn't last long if you couldn't work around regulations.
- brownbat 8y ago> They have the right to insist... People have a right to share true information legitimately acquired without the constraints of governments or mobs in other jurisdictions. Locals can't prevent foreigners from giving directions to their library or the best restaurant. Those are just facts of the world. Visitors are welcome to go discover a town then leave and tell their friends about it. Then an addressing system is just a shorthand for that locational information. It's just a hash function or a lookup table. No one has a right to prevent others from using data structures to organize their thoughts. All rights granted to some impose negative obligations on others. Those implied negative obligations should not conflict with other rights. Rights should promote the healthy functioning of society. Also, rights should promote freedom more than restriction. A right to prevent others from discussing addresses without permission of locals conflicts with other rights, doesn't promote the healthy functioning of society, and creates far more restrictions than freedoms. I don't think it's a good right.
- Waterluvian 8y agoIt's adorable and precious and very "silicon valley startup" to reinvent the coordinate system and then proudly remind you that it's free!
- masklinn 8y ago> Personally I really hope something like https://plus.codes/ https://plus.codes/ will catch up. People should be easily able to provide address without knowing or caring about local arrangements. So… they've reinvented japanese block-based addressing except shittier all around, and proprietary?
- mavhc 8y agoPerhaps you could explain the Japanese system, and why it's better. Plus codes are open source though
- StreakyCobra 8y ago> Personally I really hope something like https://plus.codes/ https://plus.codes/ will catch up. People should be easily able to provide address without knowing or caring about local arrangements. It would already be a better solution indeed. But ultimately I would prefer to have a kind of unique identifier for my person that is not based on my location nor my name, like for instance A23C-B442-9F72. It could then be associated to a first name, last name, and geographical address in a database. Delivery services can then look-up the geographical address and your name at delivery time to find you or your mailbox. This would avoid so much troubles for stuff like: - Moving: I can change my address in one place and everything will be delivered to the new place, no needs for thousands of calls and letters to companies to update every subscription. - Changing name: Whenever someone is changing his name for any reason (weeding, gender change, etc.) it should only be modified in one place. - Disposable address: It should be possible to get disposable identifiers that can only be read by delivery services for hiding your real identifier/address from suspicious website Of course this system is not perfect and probably has drawbacks, but it would be already a step in the good direction for me. Implementation details are left open for discussion (Centralized vs distributed database(s), checksum for spelling mistakes, financial repercussions, etc.)
- leetcrew 8y agomaybe this is already obvious to you, but a disposable address only hides your location to a certain degree. an untrustworthy vendor probably couldn't figure out your exact address, but I bet they could narrow down your city/town by requesting shipping quotes from many different locations and triangulating via price differences.
- robrenaud 8y agoTo me, it seems like an utter failure of democracy. Why wouldn't the locals want street names?
- B-Con 8y ago> Good for them -- it's their town after all! Doesn't mean they're doing what's actually best for themselves. FTA: > There are some house numbers that are about 3 kilometers (1.8 miles) apart, Sounds like a pain to navigate.
- Grue3 8y agoThis is a textbook case of tyranny of the majority. The people who aren't inconvenienced by the current status quo vote to preserve status quo. The few people who are inconvenienced aren't numerous enough to change the status quo. In the end nothing is done to solve the problem.
- nolok 8y agoI'm not sure "a group of people has an inconvenience that doesn't apply to the a majority of people, we should change it for everyone" is much better. It happens and I support it when it's specific kind of issues that's worth protecting the minority even if costly (discrimination, fondamental freedoms,...) but for things like that... It's the same principle as when some want to filter the entire internet to protect a small minority from reaching content that could shock them (often porn). It feels less like tyranny of the majority and more like democracy. Being in the minority in a vote should not be confused with being abused by the majority like you do, because that dilutes the recognition for cases where it really happens.
- Tepix 8y agoIt's not like people will suffer when their house suddenly gets a proper address. On the other hand, people already suffer because they have problems with their deliveries, visitors etc.
- nolok 8y agoPeople didn't suffer either with opt-out internet filters schemes that we saw in some anglo saxon countries, they can just opt-out ! On the other hand, people already suffer because they have kids getting access to porn, etc ... The problem is not always the direct change, but the infrastructure and public mindset change. Add a filter, and now adding things to it is much easier. Germany for better or worse is very much privacy minded, even more so that us neighbors (and compared to the US or asian countries we're very privacy minded). They basically have no google maps coverage because of it, for exemple. So a change in that direction will impact them.
- isostatic 8y agoAs the mailman had to visit every house, and did it every day, he'd soon learn the idiosyncrasies of selfish people who refuse to label their house. I used to deliver pizzas. If she'd ordered one, it wouldn't have arrived. "Joes Cottage, Long Lane", is a completely pointless address, it forces the person attempting to find it to investigate on average 50% of the houses on Long Lane. Given that only about 1 in 10 hours had a number visible at night from the car - especially in the rain - this would be pretty much impossible to do.
- dingaling 8y agoThe mailman problem I have relatives who live in Donegal, Ireland. They don't even have house names, just their personal name and a townland. When post sorting & delivery was run in the town, by generational postmen who grew up there, everything was fine. They knew that Patrick R Flaherty was in the white house and Paddy J Flaherty was in the stone one. Now the deliveries are by rotating agency workers driving a post van over from Donegal Town. It's chaos.
- CalRobert 8y agoWhile it's imperfect, Eircode should help with this. Having just purchased a house in rural Offaly where several houses have the exact same address (I guess the post person was supposed to know everyone's name?) Eircode is really helpful for disambiguation.
- isp 8y agoBingo: Eircodes were invented for exactly this problem. Eircodes are unique per delivery point, whereas 35% of addresses were (pre-Eircode) non-unique. This caused problems for, e.g.: (1) Delivery people, except the state postal provider (An Post). As you rightly said, An Post kept a note at the local post office (not centralised) of who lives where. For anyone else (e.g. FedEx) it would be literally impossible to tell where to deliver an item, if the address is non-unique. (2) Ambulances not able to find the correct house. (3) More complicated provisioning for, e.g., fibre broadband - how do you avoid incorrectly disconnecting a neighbour, if the neighbour has literally the same address as your customer? Now, an Eircode is sufficient in itself to uniquely identify the delivery point. To see this in action, go to Google Maps and put in an Eircode, e.g., "D02 AF30 Ireland". Or go to https://www.eircode.ie/ https://www.eircode.ie/ and put in an Eircode, and the rest of the address will be shown. But to go the other way (from address to Eircode) literally requires, for non-unique addresses, the person to click on the correct property on a map.
- Tepix 8y agoIt's silly. If every village gets to do its own scheme we'd have chaos. The standard street names + numbers scheme works well, it obviously works better than their "numbers only" scheme, it should be adopted.
- marcosdumay 8y agoStreet numbers + numbers is a joke, and doesn't work anywhere. People are only able to know where some street is if they happen to know the place very well, and you can never trust the ordering of numbers.
- mac01021 8y agogiven that knowledge of local streets is necessary to find a route there, what would be a better system?
- marcosdumay 8y agoThe city I live uses a sum of two numbers given by the house position in the two directions (one on the hundreds, other on the unities) into a coarse grid. There are plenty of cities that have numbered streets, in order. Some cities have named "mega-blocks" as a third grouping element beyond the street/number and finer grained than the usual neighborhood name, so you have to memorize less stuff. In short, there are plenty of schemes that give way better result. If you have to look up on a street-name database to find an address, there is little to gain compared with a house-number database.
- mac01021 8y agoOk, that makes sense. When your streets are lain out in a grid, everything is easier. But most municipal road systems are far less tractable. I can't imagine easily navigating my hometown, or any other town in New England based on grid coordinates.
- lb1lf 8y ago> My grandmother's house (in Australia) was assigned a house number (in the 70s?) but she refused to use it, continuing to give her address as the house name and insisting that we grandkids address letters to her by name. As far as I know they always arrived. -My parents once received a postcard addressed simply to their first names - period. No last name. No street. No town. No postcode. No nothing. It goes to show that: a) Norway is, as such things go, a pretty small country with at least one postal clerk bored enough at work to do a little bit of investigating, and: b) Having a central database in which every Norwegian is required by law to be registered with the address of his or her residence does have its benefits for the less privacy-conscious. (This was pre-internet everywhere, and they were not listed in online yellow pages or similar - so someone must have made a query to the folkeregisteret database along the lines of 'Is there a $male_name which lives with $female_name anywhere in the country?)
- joveian 8y agoThat is rather amazing. There was one case I remember reading about 15-20 years ago where someone in the UK dropped a letter into a mailbox with just a name, street number (IIRC), and street and it managed to get to the recipient in Pennsylvania, US. Someone from the post office guessed that a bunch of misreadings happened to get it close enough. I guess a creepy possibility is if they have a database of every letter sent they can search that to often figure out the likely recipient (at least in the case I am thinking about where they were in regular contact).
- Angostura 8y ago> Good for them -- it's their town after all! Of course, your grandmother was relying on the kindness of the postal service in this case. The postie could simply have decided it to return it as misaddressed.