7 ms·
GreatFire is tracking Apple iOS applications for instances of censorship
- sproketboy 8y agoWhich Apple Censorship? This shit is going on all the time.
- musicale 8y agoIsn't this just "Apple complies with local laws in China (etc.) requiring them to remove VPN apps and hand over data belonging to political dissidents?" Greatfire is right: Apple could indeed take a stand for freedom - if the shareholders demanded it and and were willing to shut down Apple's iPhone sales and manufacturing business, which is responsible for the bulk of Apple's income and profits. Google famously left China, but Google is more of an advertising company than a hardware company.
- hesarenu 8y agoPixel would be manufactured in China, though the sales might be very low. As I assume other google hardware.
- fluffycat 8y agoStill I find it comical that people thinks Apple keeps the moral high ground. I personally find Apples position disgusting and super hypocritical. Sure, they are the white knight that keeps you safe from other monsters, only if you avert your gaze from China. At least Google so far sticked to its decision, and hopefully keeps it that way.
- st3fan 8y agoThis is not entirely accurate. It will also show apps missing in China that the author has decided not to publish in that region.
- bigmonads 8y agoReminds me of Apple's censorship of US assassinations: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/538kan/apple-just-banned-the-app-that-tracks-us-drone-strikes-again https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/538kan/apple-just... There's a reason why centrally curated platforms are dangerous, and why Free Software Principals reject them. What's with the downvotes? More censorship?
- rootusrootus 8y agoThat app shows up in the app store. What changed?
- bigmonads 8y agoIt mentions it in the article. Supporters keep putting it back up and Apple continuously takes it down (under pressure of the US gov). For context, the app was created to track human rights abuses during the disclosure of the US's covert surveillance and assassination program in the Middle East. This was a scandal for the United States because it was disclosed that they were killing innocent people with knowledge and through reclassification, even killing children (internally using the terminology "fun sized terrorists"). The pressure to remove the app was brought to Apple during a sweep to control the scandal and public perception of the program. (Given the public conversation has moves far past the scandal, and the Trump administration continues the indiscriminate assassinations, that censorship program does seem to have succeeded)
- rootusrootus 8y agoJust speculation, but I wonder if Apple kicks it out simply because it is controversial and very political, and they just don't want to deal with it. It's also a fairly low-value proposition for a native app, in my opinion. It's really the kind of content worthy of a web page, that's about it. Not sure that contributes to Apple's vendetta against it, however.
- bigmonads 8y agoIf you read the reporting on the subject, you'll learn it is from government pressure. I agree with you, and think its endemic of the app ecosystem.
- feross 8y agoMore context: https://mailchi.mp/greatfire/applecensorship https://mailchi.mp/greatfire/applecensorship
- sneak 8y agoGreat site. Additionally, this doesn't show the endless number of apps that Apple censored from all countries' iOS app stores because they contained or might contain images of human bodies. It's not something the site can do, but it's important to remember that this is just the tip of the iceberg: at least in China they are required by law to block e.g. VPN apps; no such equivalent law requires them to ban apps that contain nipples in the United States; that censorship is entirely voluntary.
- oneplane 8y agoIn the US a lot of questionable filtering is done because of religious or common concepts that are not very sensible but do influence the amount of money a company can make. For example, a christian religious group might take offence to software containing other religions, and if that group is big enough, they might consider not buying anything from a company until a change is made. This basically goes for any subject and any group, but in the case of the USA, a lot of normal things are considered taboo by many groups of people (i.e. sex ed / sex health / pictures of bodies / alcohol / everything that is not american). Because some of those groups can be very large and very influential, 'normal' things get banned or ignored by those groups and as a result less money is to be made.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> ban apps that contain nipples in the United States; that censorship is entirely voluntary Is that true? Because that would cut out the Tumblr, Imgur, Reddit, Flickr, Twitter, etc. apps. And those are just the ones I can think of off the top of my head.
- sneak 8y agoI urge you to look into why the Reddit NSFW search looks and works the way it does, and why Tumblr alienated their userbase this quarter. In both cases you will find the root cause to be Apple app store policies. Steve Jobs once famously cited iOS as having “freedom from porn”, and went on to say that people would care more about it being blocked “when you have kids”. For being a California peacemonger, he missed out on big swaths of being a hippie.
- CharlesW 8y agoI don't understand how to use the site, but here's another good resource: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_Apple https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_Apple
- scarface74 8y agoI don’t get the purpose of “VPN apps” as opposed to just signing up for a VPN service and setting it up in iOS settings.
- dmix 8y agoThat's silly. That's like wondering why people use awful streaming sites to watch movies and not download high quality torrents instead. Ease of use, easy of discovery, learning curves, etc.
- lucb1e 8y agoThat one probably also has something to do with getting letters from MAFIAA if you torrent but not if you use streaming sites.
- Elidrake24 8y agoYou have no problems with the RIAA once you move to Private Trackers, but that does take a considerable time sink and a bit of dedication to breach. So point still stands.
- scarface74 8y agoWhat’s hard about going into settings and then General -> VPN -> add configuration and entering - Server - remote ID - Username - Password This is less setup than adding an email account.
- celeritascelery 8y agoYou have obviously never Worked tech support.
- Elidrake24 8y agoExcept an email account is something everyone has to use in the day to day, and getting to that point was a 15 year battle. Go down and work with the IT department sometime, it's incredible the blind spots you'll see. The calrity of your knowledge is far from universal
- intopieces 8y agoWill Apple allow their trademark to be used in this way? Or does it fall under the “____ sucks” provision of free speech?
- thaumasiotes 8y agoIt falls under the "nominative use" defense to an assertion of trademark infringement. Free speech has nothing to do with it. Trademarks are intended to provide consumers with the confidence that the products they're buying really come from the producer they claim to come from. As such, you're prohibited from assembling your own computer and branding it Apple; you've never been prohibited from referring to Apple.
- masonic 8y agoWhy do retail entities refer to the Super Bowl by pseudonyms (e.g "The Big Game") rather than its true name?
- peteretep 8y agoThis is a good question, and there's some more information about it here: https://www.broadcastlawblog.com/2013/01/articles/advertisers-beware-remember-that-super-bowl-is-a-protected-trademark-that-cant-be-used-in-a-commercial-without-permission/ https://www.broadcastlawblog.com/2013/01/articles/advertiser... In summary: "If “Super Bowl” is used by an individual or business to describe the event and not used for commercial intent, then individuals and businesses can use the term. For example, a grocery store can say “Make sure to stock up on chips for the Super Bowl” but the store cannot say they are the “Official Super Bowl Chip Stop.”" That said, you can just avoid infringing entirely by calling it The Big Game
- masonic 8y agoYes, I would think so as well, but every retail entity avoids saying "Super Bowl". Maybe everyone is afraid to be first into the breach, like so many avoided using "Happy Birthday to You" for decades in fear of the bogus, broad copyright claim
- amingilani 8y agoPlease note that while Apple itself may censor applications in regions, creators of the apps may choose to limit their distributions as well. For example: Bank of America's mobile banking app isn't available in Pakistan where I currently am, but this website wouldn't differentiate between that type of censorship or Apple's censorship. But, personally, I still think this is a great idea!
- Meckin 8y agoThis was the point I was about to make, some apps don't want users all over the world due to country limitations.
- r00fus 8y agoDoesn’t this tool focus on removals? Ie app was deployed but then not available.
- duskwuff 8y agoNo, it does not. As far as I can tell, it's simply comparing search results for the two countries -- apps which have never been distributed in China will still appear in red. Try searching for "Uber Eats", for example.
- duskwuff 8y agoI would hesitate to call that "censorship" at all. Some apps simply aren't relevant in a country because they're associated with a physical service which doesn't exist there. For example, a number of food delivery apps (like Uber Eats and Grubhub) don't operate in China, and as such have chosen to not make their app available there.
- lazyasciiart 8y agoAnd nobody ever leaves the country. Or if they do, they're totally willing to go through the entire giant hassle of switching their account for a few days.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RandallBrown 8y agoI'm not sure how this shows censorship. It just shows you if an app is available in China. Lots of apps aren't available in China or outside of where the developer is based.
- philwelch 8y agoIt's also a really, really, really hard line to draw. Lots of countries have laws and regulations that may require a company to withdraw apps from an app store. If you had a Wolfenstein game in your app store, you'd have to "censor" it in the German app store. China is especially censorious and authoritarian, but your only options are (a) don't do business at all in an especially censorious and authoritarian country, thereby censoring all of the apps, or (b) censor the apps the government wants you to censor, which is what you already have to do in lots of other countries anyway.
- judge2020 8y agoIn this case, it isn't Apple censorship. But even if Apple was the one to pull an app due to a country's local laws, we can't expect Apple to start refusing removal requests when it threatens the app store (or worse, Apple products) being banned in the entire country.
- gotocake 8y agoSome people and groups have quite the axe to grind, and the buzzword guaranteed to work in this crowd is “censorship” so that’s what they’re calling it. Never mind who is actually doing the censoring, or where censorship and curation part ways. It’s emotive language designed to inflame passions at the expense of reason.
- flaviojuvenal 8y agoThis site allows you to compare with other countries too. Search for VPN, Communism, Privacy. Try Brazil, Argentina, even Russia. Results are mostly similar to US.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mrmondo 8y agoIsn't it Chinese censorship - as reflected by Apple App store in China vs USA?
- etse 8y agoNo, the tool allows you to compare availability against a number of countries in addition to China.
- RickSanchez2600 8y agoInteresting I typed in Clash of Clans and found all of the Clash of Clans clone games like Clash of Kings, etc. Only the Chinese App store had Chinese letters in their name.
- emersonrsantos 8y agoIt's politics, but I choose to not have my app distributed in China due to bot hyperactivity ruining my metrics.
- mishurov 8y agoDoesn't matter, for only monkeys use Apple.
- larrysalibra 8y agoAs many have noted, you can't tell from this site whether apple decided to remove an app from the China app store or the developer decided never offer it in that coutnry. Because of that, it's not useful for calling out censorship. We do know, however, that Apple does certain certain apps and functionality on device for China. Censorship of the News app is one such example: https://www.larrysalibra.com/how-apple-censors-news-in-china https://www.larrysalibra.com/how-apple-censors-news-in-china
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hhanesand 8y agoChina commands such a massive market which makes it hard to rationalize neglecting it, purely from a revenue standpoint. Going to be interesting to see how Western companies respond to the continuing rise of authoritarian policies in China, and whether or not it influences their business practices outside of China.