5 ms·
Once upon a time, I had an employer who was looking for a machine learning expert. I mean, we had a brilliant mathematician who was breaking serious ground in
by klyrs 8y ago
Once upon a time, I had an employer who was looking for a machine learning expert. I mean, we had a brilliant mathematician who was breaking serious ground in the field, but we needed an expert, apparently. We were having trouble drawing experts out of Silicon Valley, and our resident genius said "Hey, I satisfy all of the requirements for this job you've posted, and I'm already doing the work. Can you promote me from this crap software-dev role you stuck me in?" and the company's response was "No, it clearly states in the posting that you'd need a PhD in machine learning." We promptly lost our genius. If only TPTB knew that it was a meritocracy!
In short: article's claims sound fishy; your lived experience may vary.
- josephg 8y agoI wonder how normal stories like this are. Was this just one bad manager in one company, which you remember because of how surprising it was? If so, maybe the core claim that software is a meritocracy holds. Or are stories like this common and everywhere?
- HarryHirsch 8y agoOr are stories like this common and everywhere? Very much so. Bad management is afraid of competence, because good performance cannot be argued away. I've seen this.
- ivanhoe 8y agoThey simply play safe. If you hire someone with PhD it's very unlikely that anyone will ever blame you for not taking that other random smart dude instead. The other way around you might get into a trouble for your choice. It's just how bureaucracy works, protecting your butt first, and everything else comes 2nd.
- el_dev_hell 8y agoI find the key factor the be company size. When I worked for a Fortune 500, credentials mattered. Possibly more than competence. I'm working for a much smaller company now and it's significantly closer to a meritocracy (or a "who will generate the most obvious value - even if it means working 90 hours per week" ocracy).
- koolba 8y agoThis is the HR version of “Nobody ever got fired for bringing in IBM”. It’s true till it’s not.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoIn a previous workplace we had a very capable part-time instructor. This fellow was never converted to a full-time position (eventually they got fed up and left); instead management kept recruiting externally for the full-time instructor position. They went through 3 or 4 people in as many years because the new recruits were glaringly incompetent. They were, however, innocuous and unthreatening. So far, no consequences for the departmental chair.
- Datenstrom 8y agoNot a genius but had something similar happen. Was literally doing the work already and successfully. My coworkers and boss all vouched for me but the company had a policy. There are probably other companies where a similar policy that effects single person that works there.
- gaius 8y agoHR: no sorry, it’s policy Worker: but you set the policy, it can be whatever you want it to HR: ... Saying “policy” must be a cover for a real reason that the company wants kept secret
- sct202 8y agoSo many times policy goes out the door if a Director or VP wants a specific person for whatever reason.
- minimaxir 8y agoRecruiters/managers are very picky about the Masters/PhD requirements, even if the corresponding day-to-day work does not necessarily warrant it.
- quantumhobbit 8y agoSuper common. More common than the opposite. In fact a version of the above story has happened in the last two companies I worked for.
- josephg 8y agoRight but, are most hiring decisions like this? If most hiring / firing decisions are based on ability (which is the case everywhere I've ever worked) then its a meritocracy with flaws. That is to say, if these stories surprise and disappoint you then the overall philosophy is that its a meritocracy and you're disappointed that its flawed for not being meritocratic enough. As far as I can tell, even obsessing over credentials happens because its a proxy for merit[1], and we care about merit. Its often a lousy proxy, but our industry as a whole didn't care about merit, why would anyone care to look at a candidate's credentials? [1] "Nobody gets fired for choosing IBM" -> "No recruiter gets fired for hiring a PhD"
- modriano 8y agoSeriously, yes. This happens all the time. I recently finished a Masters in CS with a focus on data science and machine learning from DePaul University, and I built predictive models that saved my previous employer hundreds of thousands of dollars every month. They had multiple machine learning positions open, but they told me they wanted Ph.D.s from University of Chicago level schools. Now I lead a team of analysts and junior data scientists at the University of Chicago. That company is still making money hand over fist. By the way, the point of the concept of meritocracy is that it depends on performance, not on some proxy variable.
- arethuza 8y agoWorth noting that the person who coined the term "meritocracy" did it to criticize the use of just those proxy values, particularly education, rather than actual performance: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment
- 8y ago
- nl 8y agoIt's not uncommon. But there is sometimes more going on than meets the eye. If it's an A.I/M.L startup, the number of PhDs is a significant factor in fund raising. Being able to say "we have 6 PhDs on staff" will open doors.
- AstralStorm 8y agoJust ignore the fact they're not in the field of CS or mathematics. ;)
- sidlls 8y agoIt's normal in my experience. It's not necessarily that these managers are stupid: they're just working in what they perceive to be their own best interests.
- nradov 8y agoIn the general case it's impossible to objectively evaluate the merit of knowledge workers because so much of what they do can't be quantified. But a good manager can make reasonably accurate subjective rankings.
- 75dvtwin 8y agoIt is often the case, and very unfortunate. Also besides a 'written job description' -- there are always unspoken 'tokens' for candidate's gender or, even, race, perhaps other attributes. Studies on this type of subject are a taboo these days. Promotions to different organizational levels in larger corps (with 20k employees or more, I would say) -- is like breaking through glass ceiling. You can see the other side, you can do the job on the other side -- but you cannot get through there... Scott Adams, Dilbert author, had a personal experience about a promotion he was sharing. [1] To me, it resonated, because it was closely matching my own at some point in my career. [1] https://youtu.be/ddBRiUsL_5I?t=2041 https://youtu.be/ddBRiUsL_5I?t=2041
- dalbasal 8y agoMeritocracy is a big word. Chess is a meritocracy. So is tennis and sales. Anyone can play. The best player wins. Chess coaching is not. Better coaches might win more or get better gigs, but stuff other than coaching "merit" can play a big role. But rather than getting stuck in a semantic argument... What the article means is that it's a relatively accessible field, on the way that software engineering is. The formal pathways are not as locked in. A motivated and talented individual can bootstrap a career without formal education, qualification or approval. All this is relative to, for example, civil engineering, law, medicine... There you'll need qualifications earned via established formal channels, gatekeepers and such.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- amelius 8y ago> Chess is a meritocracy. So is tennis and sales. Anyone can play. The best player wins. I'm not sure you are having the correct definition of meritocracy in mind. A meritocracy is a system where the actors who provide the most benefit to the society, benefit the most. However, in chess, tennis, etc., there is no real benefit.
- notahacker 8y agoThe term "meritocracy" can be defined in various ways. Originally it was coined as a satirical characterisation of a hypothetical stratified future society so obsessed with test performances in early years that all power became concentrated in the hands of adults who had demonstrated youthful aptitude and were thus assumed to not need to prove themselves any further thereafter since competition could only demoralise lesser minds; the author took the view that the "merit" of passing test thresholds would often be dependent on access to sufficiently expensive early years education and would resemble and often simply be a justification for upholding traditional social class divisions As for tennis, I think it's fair to say that tennis fans consider Federer et al to provide them with considerable enjoyment, and far more so than less talented players whose games they don't watch, or indeed most people working in non-entertainment jobs who can only help a few people at once and/or find it difficult to prove how much better they are than other people in the same role