5 ms·
A short summary of what’s going on here: The land in question involves an aboriginal reserve that has a border going through it. Canada used to have its borde
by Scoundreller 8y ago
A short summary of what’s going on here:
The land in question involves an aboriginal reserve that has a border going through it.
Canada used to have its border post at the physical border. But felt that this allowed too much smuggling with the reserve all around it.
So the feds move the border post inland: at the border of the reserve and the rest of Canada.
As a result, the “correct” procedure to enter the Canadian side of the reserve is to:
1) exit USA
2) drive past your intended destination to the border post (I suppose they could create the world’s largest duty free or free trade zone)
3) drive back to wherever you were going.
- snambi 8y agoShould Canada leave the aboriginal reserve, because it makes more sense?
- mynegation 8y agoNo, US should do it. But seriously though, the territory spans both US and Canada. Why is Canada different from the US in that regard?
- vkou 8y agoThe thing that would make the most sense would be to allow the First Nations tribe in question to vote on which country it should belong to, and, regardless of the outcome of the vote, to grant all residents of it dual citizenship (Due to existing ties that members of the tribe have to persons living outside of the reserve.) Everything else either: 1. Compromises the border. (If you don't care about the border, then this point is, of course, negotiable.) 2. Draws an arbitrary geopolitical line, that benefits[1] two super-powers[2], at the expense of the rights and freedoms of a nation, that has been there long before the existence of Canada and the United States, and will likely remain long after. [1] Actually, it's not even clear if there are any benefits to the current state of affairs. [2] Think Germany, being split in half by the East/West border - or the Berlin wall. It sure as hell wasn't built for the benefit of the Germans.
- amelius 8y agoHow about a temporary change of the border? I.e., an agreement where one party gives up the region until they decide to have it back.
- vkou 8y agoIf you do that, the problem will shift to bouncing people around between two incompatible social and economic systems. "You are now subjects of Canada, until at some indeterminate point in the future, half of you will become Americans. Again." The land these people live on is not of vital importance to either country. As such, we should be doing right by the people who live on it.
- azernik 8y agoThat kind of "temporary" solution that lasts forever in practice is a good way to get around national sovereignty sensitivities, though.
- vkou 8y agoThis may make Washington and Ottawa feel good (Because it lets both sides save face), but is going to be pretty shitty for the people living in said territory, if it ever goes back to being split. If it will never be re-split, then it's a de-facto annexation. In which case, I'd prefer that the residents vote on it.
- bhickey 8y agoA condominium arrangement[0] seems like a pretty reasonable to resolve this. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condominium_(international_law) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condominium_(international_law...
- labster 8y agoThe obvious solution is for the United States to negotiate an open border with Canada. Policy changes might be needed on both sides, but the economic benefits of open borders between allies with similar economies is undeniable.
- goodcanadian 8y agoCanada used to have its border post at the physical border. But felt that this allowed too much smuggling with the reserve all around it. My understanding is that moving the border post had more to do with poor community relations. It became too much of a hassle to maintain it on Akwesasne land: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akwesasne https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akwesasne