17 ms·
Continuing our work to improve recommendations on YouTube
- elektor 8y agoLong overdue. Maybe in a few months I can watch a Joe Rogan podcast video without tainting my YouTube recommendations for the next year with Ben Shapiro-style clickbait.
- sametmax 8y agoOn the other hand, I wouldn't know who Ben Shapiro is without having watched Rogan videos. It's an important info to have, because it tells you what people are interested in, and what they believe in. You can't communicate efficiently without knowing that.
- Elitroness 8y agoI don't know who Ben Shapiro is so I'm just using him as an example and maybe he is noteworthy, but if the system tells everyone to watch Ben Shapiro videos of course everyone is gonna know who he is. Maybe he wouldn't be 'required knowledge' if youtube didn't force it and reinforce it on everyone. The current system doesn't tell you what people are interested in, it tells you what the system made the people pay interest to.
- sametmax 8y agoWell, I assume it recommends what other people that watched similar videos watched as well. I doubt Ben Shapiro is 'required knowledge', nor that he became popular only through youtube. Those people usually have an IRL crowd. They have IRL impacts. But I see your point.
- jobigoud 8y ago> Well, I assume it recommends what other people that watched similar videos watched as well. The problem is it creates a feedback loop and amplifies whatever is slightly over represented. I also noticed that on LinkedIn profiles, on many high profiles ones the related section contains pretty girls profiles with unrelated positions, just because statistically they get more clicks I guess.
- toasterlovin 8y agoTo take the position that people only believe stuff because it is fed to them is incredibly patronizing. Sure, the fundamental dynamic of social media (that immediate and direct feedback about what captures user attention is used to determine what users see) makes things more polarized, but people are polarized to begin with. Conservatives are conservatives because they have a fundamentally different outlook about the world, not because they just happened to fall down a specific click hole on the internet.
- Elitroness 8y agoI have not taken that position. To misrepresent the views of others to make your argument easier is very patronizing. My post was about notoriety not belief. Many things, trends and personalities are created by the media, whether you believe what they say or not. Flat earth conspiracies would never have been repeated by NBA players if not because of Youtube's recommendation algorithm.
- sametmax 8y agoWay before internet, I remember people were talking about how Marilyn Manson had surgery to be able to suck himself I also remember when I watched in disbelieve people saying the sun was going around the earth. Internet is just the reflect of human nature. Flat earth theory would have existed without it.
- fhbdukfrh 8y agoMaybe so, but it now enables global reach at the speed of light. You can't argue that the danger from a stick of dynamite is the same as the danger from a nuclear bomb. You might not care about the difference if you're standing next to it, but they are bit the same thing
- fhbdukfrh 8y agoYou're basically saying that well done propaganda doesn't work then, which is patently false. Watching polarizing YouTube videos isn't going to flip a bit, but constant exposure to a single perspective constantly reinforced is certainly going to influence your formation of beliefs. That's exactly what YouTube does with their recommendation system
- Consultant32452 8y ago>The current system doesn't tell you what people are interested in, it tells you what the system made the people pay interest to. I agree with you 100% here. But this problem can't be fixed. All that's about to happen is Google is going to decide that people will be interested in something Google finds more palatable. I don't know how to fix/escape this problem.
- FiveSquared 8y agoHowever, who determines what is a conspaircy? The government might be deciding that Iraq has WMDs and any evidence to the contrary is a conspiracy. While some measures are needed to be taken, who decides what is? No one is truly impartial. The censorship (while required due to how much crap is in YouTube) might devolve to 1984 without comple transparency, which we all know google isn’t providing.
- sametmax 8y agoNSA mass surveillance was considered conspiracy before PRISM. Worse, people that said it was a conspiracy are now calling other things conspiracy, without any consideration for their past errors.
- itchyjunk 8y agoThere seems to be people around who still think NSA mass surveillance is a conspiracy. Heck, don't the flat earther think round earth is a conspiracy? One mans theory is another mans conspiracy.
- rjf72 8y agoThere's some fun even around the origin of the term. In late 1963 JFK was assassinated. According to a sourced referenced on Wiki [1] the first mainstream reference to "conspiracy theory" was the New York Times who, in 1964, posted some 5 articles using the phrase. In 1967 the CIA had a psychological operation manual on discrediting conspiracy theories. [2] The reason I mention JFK there is because the conspiracy theory tactics created by the CIA were specifically relating to the Warren Commission [3]. Ultimately I've always found the term silly. People can believe idiotic things for sure, yet on the other hand I think there is an equilibrium where on one end you have people who believe no 'conspiracy theory' could ever be real, and on the other hand you have people who indulge every 'conspiracy theory' as probable. Both opposite extremes are equally naive. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conspiracy_theory#Etymology_and_definition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conspiracy_theory#Etymology_an... [2] - https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-02-23/1967-he-cia-created-phrase-conspiracy-theorists-and-ways-attack-anyone-who-challenge https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-02-23/1967-he-cia-create... [3] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_Commission
- spamizbad 8y agoYoutube OBLITERATES elektor's recommendations with Logic & Reason!
- vbuwivbiu 8y agosame! I touched a Rogan podcast & ever since I've been getting recommendations for a certain JP
- imhelpingu 8y agoYeah, and maybe some day I'll be able to do anything on the site whatsoever without it shoving CNN videos in my face.
- bengale 8y agoIt does seem to be getting better, for a long while I had to make sure to clear my history of any conservative leaning videos or I'd end up down a rabbit hole. Too many and all of a sudden its bloody flat earth videos and other insane conspiracies. Made it very difficult to try and watch a balanced set of videos.
- sametmax 8y agoPersonnally I find those kind of meta informations useful. It's midly annoying to not have better suggestions, but on the other end, it gives you a perspective on what kind of people are fed with what kind of info. Kinda like the old email chains my mother used to send me. It allowed me to understand what were her fears, hopes, and lack in understanding about things I never had the chance to talked about with her before.
- Regolitch 8y agoYep. I like to watch some videos of varying view points and political leanings to avoid falling into an echo chamber. But more than. One or two conservative videos, especially about European current events, and you are sucked in to the Nazi Propaganda hole. Another inescapable pit of content is electronic music production. I was doing a bit of research on the teenage engineering pocket operators as a possible gift for my younger brother. Now Im almost exclusively recommend music production videos.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jsheard 8y agoThe way the algorithm pushes steadily more radical content is really concerning. Try making a completely fresh browser profile and deliberately browsing around right-leaning or "anti-SJW" channels and see how long it takes before YouTube starts pushing videos about white genocide and the impending destruction of western civilization by the muslim hordes (not very long in my experience). edit: I just tried this again and not much has changed. Started by viewing Joe Rogan's interview with Elon Musk on a fresh profile. The first suggestion from there is a Jordan Peterson anti-feminist video, from there we get a Jordan Peterson anti-islam video, then "The Suicide of Europe" by PragerU, and from there the floodgates are opened to fear-mongering about "rapefugees". That's less than a dozen clicks on highly related videos to get from Elon Musk smoking weed to videos with an overtly racist agenda, on a profile that's never sought out that kind of content previously.
- bdz 8y agoWe have always been at war with Eastasia
- ghostbrainalpha 8y agoDid you accidentally comment on the wrong story? Or is this a joke that I'm not getting?
- pseudolus 8y agoOrwell's 1984. "The world of Nineteen Eighty-Four exists in a state of perpetual war among the three major powers. Two of the three states are aligned against the third: Oceania and Eurasia against Eastasia or Eurasia and Eastasia against Oceania. However, as Goldstein's book points out, each superstate is so powerful that even an alliance of the other two cannot destroy it, which results in a continuing stalemate. From time to time, one of the states betrays its ally and sides with its former enemy. In Oceania, when that occurs, the Ministry of Truth rewrites history to make it appear that the current state of affairs is the way it has always been, and documents with contradictory information are destroyed in the memory hole." [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nations_of_Nineteen_Eighty-Four https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nations_of_Nineteen_Eighty-Fou...
- RodgerTheGreat 8y agoThey're making a reference to the novel 1984, in which governments routinely recast history such that the current status quo "has always been this way".
- tivert 8y ago> They're making a reference to the novel 1984, in which governments routinely recast history such that the current status quo "has always been this way". Though the reference they're making is so irrelevant to this story that it verges on a non sequitur. This action is more akin to developing a spam filter for your email service than a government totally rewriting history for political reasons. If you're going to reference a work as well-known as 1984, make sure it's a very apt reference.
- AnaniasAnanas 8y agoIt would be great if Youtube actually stopped recommending irrelevant videos that I do not care about (the recommended for you videos) and instead only showed videos in the sidebar that are relevant to what I am watching at that very moment. If I am watching a conspiracy video then I would prefer it if I got another conspiracy video as a suggestion rather than a random cooking video - and it actually goes the other way too! Every time that I go to watch a gaming or a programming video at least one of the suggestions is some lame political or conspiracy-related video.
- imoverclocked 8y agoI knew it!
- buboard 8y agoThey should introduce some features that allow better search or a hierarchical directory for ppl who like to pick and choose. Perhaps allow a more descriptive presentation of the creators themselves. Not everything needs to be a flat feed.
- petermcneeley 8y agoIf they could simply make the "Not interested" feature work that would be great.
- throwaway2048 8y agoyep, feels like they completely ignore it, right up to the point they just re-recommend the same videos.
- petermcneeley 8y agoYou should make a video detailing why you have this theory and post it on youtube.
- sam1r 8y agoI pledge to rebuttal with a counter theory, if you make this video detailing yours
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- amdanil 8y agoSeems to work fine for me. You just have to click "not interested" on every video of the topic that you don't like and after 5 times or so it stops recommending that topic. Let's say you watched a video called "Top 10 most amazing things you never knew until today" and now the youtube algo recommends you a bunch of clickbait. Just hit "not interested" on every single clickbait video you see and eventually it stops showing you those videos unless you watch more of them.
- colejohnson66 8y agoOr delete the video from your watch history. Your watch history is built based on your history
- PatentlyDC123 8y ago
- quotemstr 8y agoBut who gets to decide what counts as a "conspiracy"? It's very easy to suppress true and inconvenient information by attaching some vague and undesirable label to it, e.g., the Soviets abusing mental health diagnoses to silence dissidents. I'd rather have conspiracy videos in my feed than give the YouTube content moderation people the power to decide what counts as conspiracy.
- falcor84 8y agoI know what you mean, not I can't think of any other way I would fully trust. What committee would l trust? I suppose the only thing we can do is to require more transparency.
- mishurov 8y agoPeople in the Ministry of Truth were engaged in a similar activity. Can hardly wait when they start to hand out free soma to silence us off.
- narrator 8y agoWhat about the endless "Anonymous Sources say..." Trump/Russia collusion stories that appear regularly in the Buzzfeed, NY Times, CNN and Washington Post that never lead anywhere? Are these classified as conspiracy theories?
- mrspeaker 8y agoI don't think youtube has much control over what is printed there.
- Elitroness 8y agoNot as long as people keep confessing and being convicted.
- alacombe 8y agoWith a big enough wrench, you can beat confession out of anybody...
- ilaksh 8y agoUnfortunately things are converging on the Chinese model. Young people in the US have been so brainwashed against anything really critical of the government that they are literally earnestly requesting political censorship.
- driverdan 8y agoI downvoted you because YouTube made no indication they're censoring anything at the behest of the government. They're also not removing content, just adjust what's recommended.
- Tehnix 8y agoI sorta view actively suppressing information, while not completely removed, as censoring...which YouTube very much does. There’s plenty examples of things that should have been on trending by every possible metric, but never gets there. And I don’t think I’ve ever seen PewDiePie appear in my recommended section, even though he’s the only creator I consume regularly. I have to find him in my notification list, on the site, buried.
- alacombe 8y agoReplace "government" with "Silicon Valley groupthink" and the same argument applies. Meanwhile, Google is happily doing business in China & other oppressive country when I'm absolutely certain they do censor based of government standards.
- apacheCamel 8y agoHow so? They are changing how recommendations work, they aren't removing videos based on agenda. I am also wondering how the brainwashing comment comes into play here, just because people do not believe in a conspiracy theory doesn't mean they are brainwashed. I also do not remember ever asking to be censored.
- ilaksh 8y agoThe recommendations determine what people see. People in this thread are asking youtube remove content from their feed that does not tailor to their worldview. The problem is that the worldview many young people have is highly dictated by the government and any serious accusations toward the government are labeled as conspiracy. Conspiracy is auotomatically associated with insanity. The reason I use an extreme word like brainwashing is because many people have been given such a strong bias that it is impossible for them to accept the possibility of serious criminal immoral activities by their government.
- Causality1 8y agoYouTube suggestions are worthless now. Used to be if you were watching "Jack cooks a 4 course meal part 2" the recommended videos would be "Jack cooks a 4 course meal part 3", Part 1, and some other videos by the same user. Now it's a host of other unrelated bullshit.
- rchaud 8y agoI remember that! That system was so sensible, it was great when I was following the lessons on ExcelIsFun/VBAisFun. The next video in the series would play seamlessly. Now, thanks to the all powerful algorithm, I can watch a video about a rescued pitbull living with his new family, and have it followed up by "10 times Ben Shapiro owned the libs".
- alkibiades 8y agoit changed from being “users who watched this video watched X next” to “You would like Y videos based on your watch history” (somewhat biasing the first 2 or 3 to be related to current video)
- AltruisticGap 8y agoI like that it seems heavily based on the watch history because it gives me some control. In general I find the selction on the homepage to be useful, however it does take some work as I regularly remove a lot of random things. I also open random videos in a private window to keep my watch history more focused. So it works fairly well for me, bringing up videos from channels I like that I haven't seen before... but it takes effort to get it to work for me. So it is arguably not very good for a typical user.
- endofcapital 8y agoA few weeks back I got a weird fan biopic of Himmler created by some account with the SS logo in their picture recommended to me after watching a video on some obscure DNS features. I reported it but it's still there. Google is beyond broken. Chasing those engagement numbers on a forever treadmill, just hoping they inch up a little more at any cost.
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoI know this is about Youtube suggestions, but let me share another google property with suggestions: Google Mail. https://twitter.com/300_lines/status/1088288289042415617 https://twitter.com/300_lines/status/1088288289042415617 ------------------------ Tweet: "Ugh. G-mail's suggested responses to an update from my aunt about my uncle's fight with cancer. Google Mail suggests: Will do! So cute! Love it!" ------------------------ If this is the quality of AI and their suggestions machine learning, then I have serious doubts. I'd figure the word "cancer" would be enough for basic sentiment calculators to go 'give somber sad answer', not "Love it!"
- Retra 8y agoDon't have google write your reply emails then? Sometimes you get a crappy solution because the problem being solved is just not worth the effort.
- atonse 8y agoWe currently don't allow our son to watch anything on youtube, simply because it's a cesspool of horrible videos for children. You're always almost one click away from some violent video where cartoon characters are getting their limbs chopped off, etc. And it's sickening that Google's done nothing about it. Secondly, I can't watch any video without it taking over my recommendations. Alex Jones for example. I still haven't watched an Alex Jones video (I was curious about what rubbish he spews), without worrying that I'll get a bunch of delusional hyper-conservative drivel taking over my recommendations. There should be a way to watch a video once and not have it take over your recommendations. On the one hand, we find that we're making great strides in certain areas with ML. On the other hand, recommendation systems are still just so, so, so naive and bad.
- alttab 8y ago>> There should be a way to watch a video once and not have it take over your recommendations. Log out.
- nwellnhof 8y agoYou can't log out of the YouTube Android app anymore. There's only an incognito mode.
- alttab 8y agoDon't use the app
- propogandist 8y agoNewpipe
- zcid 8y agoOr if you want the official experience: https://vanced.app https://vanced.app
- atonse 8y ago
- minimaxir 8y agoIt's worth noting that this blog post appeared less than 24 hours after BuzzFeed News posted an article explicitly highlighting the conspiracy theories in the recommended section: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/down-youtubes-recommendation-rabbithole https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/down-y... I helped contribute to that article, feel free to ask any questions!
- luvjournalists 8y agoI noticed that you started the article by transferring guilt from an crude, anonymous Youtube comment about illegal immigrants, to a video posted by a think tank which was designated as a "hate group" by a private organization based on vague criteria, to a fickle recommendation algorithm which picked a valid (related content, just from a different angle) video, to Youtube and Google the company. I also noticed that every one of the "bad recommendations" you picked out in your article falls on one side of the political spectrum. My question is: when you cause a $1T monopoly with unprecedented control over the world's information to enhance its censorship algorithms with a news article, what motivates you? Is it just the feeling of power? Do you recognize that you have a particular viewpoint or philosophy that you're trying to protect? Or do you believe that you're only seeking the truth, that you're right, and everyone else is wrong? edit: forgot another possible motivation: getting paid to do it, raised whole life to do it, don't care any further than that. (I'm not just trying to impugn, I literally have no idea what goes through journalists heads when they write articles like this)
- webwanderings 8y agoHave you investigated their rabbit hole for children? YT for Kids simply needs to die. They are evil.
- claudiulodro 8y agoAgreed! What I have found is that most legitimate popular YT kids content (Blippi, Pinkfong, etc.) is also available repackaged and included in Amazon Prime. I've been using that for most kids content instead, as it's not just sponsored toy unboxing crap and I don't need to worry about weird auto-playing recommendations or commercials.
- wlesieutre 8y agoWhat really bugs me is when a video literally has "Episode 18" in the name, but somehow the recommendation list on the right side fails to find the one with "Episode 19". But if I want to go watch Episode 5 again or jump ahead to Episode 26, it's happy to help. Awesome.
- taude 8y agoYou've summed up my frustrations, well.
- corobo 8y agoWhat would be even better is if they had somewhere that you could just specify what episode it is in a series rather than it try to guess based on titles
- scribu 8y agoYoutube creators already have the ability to create series inside playlists. Example: The Slow Mo Guys channel has a "Planet Slow Mo" series: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbIZ6k-SE9Shmj0UvxtrvzHD2tfZDZ1PA https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbIZ6k-SE9Shmj0Uvxtrv...
- corobo 8y agoThis is not available to... well, almost anyone. Seriously try searching for it. Every permutation of your search terms will bring you back to one of three results that all heavily imply or say that it's available to a select handful of channels It's not even subscriber gated or verified channel gated, it's someone at youtube for some reason flicked the switch on for this channel gated
- blihp 8y agoThe problem is when you first find a video that's interesting you don't necessarily find the playlist that it belongs to. (or worse, you find it in someone else's playlist which includes the video along with other seemingly random videos that the playlist creator was interested in)
- bodski 8y agoJust please, for the love of god stop trying to show me Jordan Peterson videos!
- taude 8y agoI wish YouTube kept better tabs on what I've watched and not re-recommend them. I especially wish they wouldn't automatically add to the automatic play list videos I've already seen.
- throw7 8y agoFor a short time, you could actually hide a video in your subscriptions by just clicking one button (an "X" overlayed in top-right). Best feature ever. Now it takes two clicks and mouse movement to hide.
- thrusong 8y agoWhy do they recommend the same five videos of a series (like Barefoot Contessa) over-and-over when I've watched them already? I don't want to say "not interested" because I don't know what that means... I want a feature where it's like "more like this, but not this one in particular." It's surprising they've been under Google's control for a very long time and yet their main recommendation algorithm still leaves a lot to be desired.
- NoodleIncident 8y agoIf I remember correctly, the "not interested" UI has an option for "I've already seen the video"
- thrusong 8y agoThat just makes it seem like their algorithm is powered by bad code or bad management, or both. They know what I've watched. They should know if a video is likely to be watched repeatedly (ie. classifying songs/music videos differently from other content).
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoOk, but why? If there is one thing the algorithm should know it's which videos you've already watched!
- v_lisivka 8y agoI banned thousands of channels in Russian language, but Youtube never stop attempts to convince me to watch an another video about Putin or mighty Russia. How to ban all videos per country of origin or/and per language? edit: Moreover, how to bless my native language in Youtube and Google?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- IggleSniggle 8y agoFor some insane reason, no matter what video I watch, I almost always get recommendations for Penn & Teller. Doesn’t matter that I don’t care about that even a little bit, and haven’t watched one of their bits for years. Doesn’t matter that I was just watching a technical tutorial. Doesn’t matter that I was just listening to a music video. Doesn’t matter if I just played a Thomas and Friends video for my kid. I mean, wtf? I want a “why am I seeing this recommendation” button at this point, because my curiosity has gotten the better of me and I want to see how this magic trick is done. Oh, hey, wait a minute...
- munificent 8y agoI too watched a couple of "Fool Us" videos and now YouTube believes I am training full-time to be a professional magician.
- shdh 8y agoLet me block channels from appearing in my recommendations. Obviously I don't like that channels content, so I don't want to see it.
- ddebernardy 8y agoShould be "block this channel and very similar ones" IMHO.
- amdanil 8y agoI would love to see youtube add more videos to the recommended section. Right now I believe the limit is 18. When you load the homepage it shows you 12 tiles and you can click "show more" to display 6 more for a total of 18.
- falcor84 8y agoYeah, this is the most annoying thing for me too. They have an endless stream of recommendations if you go to www.youtube.com/feed/recommended , so why not put it in the main page? I can only assume that it's an intentional marketing thing to get people to watch other things.
- jalgos_eminator 8y agoSay what you want about YouTube recommended political videos, but I have found some absolutely great music because it showed up in my recommended. A small Canadian band showed up in my recommended and that first song captivated me. Then I listened to their other singles and two albums, and now I'm going to their show next month. Also, I just found an artist from Belarus that makes fantastic synthpop. The weird thing is that all his videos use cyrillic characters, so I don't know how google even matched it. I am thankful though.
- hateful 8y agoI agree. I've found a host of new artists this way. I've taken to subscribing to a few choice channels that have live performances (mostly local radio stations). There are a few that do a thing where they have a band on and the do one original and one cover - sometimes I end up finding two new bands.
- hateful 8y agoI also recommend going to https://www.youtube.com/feed/music https://www.youtube.com/feed/music . It's a landing page that used to be behind a "Music" button on the youtube homepage, but has since been removed. But luckily the page still exists. It gives you a bunch of different playlists, including "Recommended" and "Latest Videos". I like the Latest Videos because it allows me to see what's "current" at a glance, even if I choose not to view any of them, I can see what' going on in the mainstream.
- FiveSquared 8y agoAlso, I discovered awesome electro music and house music along with the Seven nation Army Remix by Glitch Mob. That’s song is now in my main playlist.
- timmaah 8y agoThe Dead South ? They seem to be oddly popular on youtube.
- 8y ago
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoYouTube recommendations are so terrible I consider any suggestion of a channel I don't already watch as a warning. "We see you watched an informative video on topic X, would you also like to watch DudeWhoHatesEverything rant incessantly about X, or BaityMcClickface's Top 10 Ys about X? Don't worry if you don't, we'll keep bringing them up every time you watch anything even tangentially related to X."
- FrozenVoid 8y agoIt would be much cheaper to use user feedback instead of "human evaluators" who represent a tiny segment of audience. Just try adding some sort of rating system for reccomendation like 10 is Perfect Reccomendation and 0 is Completely Irrelevant and adjust the algorithm accordingly. I think the current one use something like network analysis that feeds its own reccomendations back to itself.
- kajumix 8y ago"To that end, we’ll begin reducing recommendations of borderline content and content that could misinform users in harmful ways—such as videos promoting a phony miracle cure for a serious illness, claiming the earth is flat, or making blatantly false claims about historic events like 9/11." Why take moral positions on the content of the videos? Why be the arbiter of what people should watch? Why censor?
- nightski 8y agoI agree this is annoying. Personally I enjoyed watching the conspiracy theory 9/11 videos even if I didn't believe it for a second.
- AgentME 8y agoMaybe they should be there for people who seek them out, but YouTube shouldn't be recommending them onto people who didn't previously want them and who might not be approaching it skeptically.
- throwawaysea 8y agoWhy is it YouTube's business to judge truth and falsehoods and provide a manicured walled garden? That seems like an avenue for all sorts of manipulation, censorship, etc.
- AgentME 8y agoYouTube is already an avenue for all sorts of manipulation. They recommend harmful crazy conspiracy videos to unsuspecting people all the time right now. (9/11 conspiracy theory videos might just sound silly, but I'm also thinking of stuff like racially-charged holocaust conspiracy theories and baseless anti-vaccine stuff.) I think you're way too optimistic if you don't think those are likely converting many people at YouTube's scale. Just because this is the result of non-action by YouTube doesn't make it okay. YouTube becoming a moral arbiter isn't a perfect situation, but it can easily be better than the status quo.
- throwawaysea 8y agoIn this thread, in social media, and in recent articles that critique YouTube's recommendations, it seems like the anecdotal examples all try to support a claim that YouTube's recommendation algorithm radicalizes viewers towards the far right side of the US political spectrum. This to me seems like a naive, self-serving perspective channeled by those who are on the US political left. Somehow, the same algorithm might help channel viewers to content from say Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, but no complaints are made in that instance, since that content aligns with the views of those who are complaining. These algorithms are based on what people watch based on prior history. As outsiders, we can't know exactly how it works, but it seems like it would be some mix of the video you are currently watching and other videos in your watch/search history, which then feed into a model that considers all users' behaviors and produces probabilistic relationships between videos. This is a fairly standard way for how recommendations work, and it is reasonable. As others have pointed out, there are also many anecdotes of YouTube recommendations working great - for example with discovery of music. But we should keep in mind that the same recommendations engine supports those same positive anecdotes. For a lot of users, the recommendations some are labeling as incorrect, radicalizing, etcetera are actually the recommendations they want and enjoy. Why should other users or YouTube intervene if that's what user behavior supports? Clearly, the reason is that these other users want to constrain access to views they don't share - which is just another way of saying they support censorship when it applies to others. There is a dangerous concept creep in Google's blog post: > We’ll continue that work this year, including taking a closer look at how we can reduce the spread of content that comes close to—but doesn’t quite cross the line of—violating our Community Guidelines. This is really the first step in expanding their guidelines, and if they cave to either internal political activism or the complaints coming from the outside (a group with very uniform views aligning with the political left), it is a risk for public discourse. This is in part because there are very few alternatives to Google in general, and that applies to YouTube as well. As others have pointed out, BitChute was blackballed by payment processors. Any constraint on free exchange of information on YouTube is dangerous because so much of online discourse is under Google's control, on their platforms. I can't help but think that the BuzzFeed article and others are basically cherry-picked hitjobs to create a false narrative that something more nefarious is going on beyond YouTube simply respecting user behaviors. The impetus to say something is wrong here seems to be based entirely on personal political biases. For example, some people here are bemoaning the fact that watching Joe Rogan's podcasts (which are less political) lead you to watch Jordan Peterson or Ben Shapiro. If that's the behavior other users who watch a Joe Rogan video are exhibiting, I don't see anything wrong with that recommendation. And if you dislike it, consider that this might be the exposure to different views that people often pay lip service to. Some of the other annoyances outlined by commenters are less related to specific content and more like general usability concerns. A summary: - It is no longer possible to see recommendations based on just the current video. I agree this is poor design. It seems at some point YouTube switched the recommendations feed from being centered on whatever content you are currently seeking (which the currently playing video would be an input for), to just showing recommendations based on everything you've ever done. I think there is a place for the current set of recommendations but it should not be the sole set. Having a "Based on this video" section of recommendations and a "More for you" section of recommendations would solve this problem. - User feedback saying you don't want to watch something is not immediately respected. Other users say that it is respected, if you provide the feedback multiple times. The latter may be appropriate, since a single dislike is likely best interpreted not as an absolute, but a signal that gets ingested into the algorithm and weighted appropriately. - People want to be able to watch a video and not have it feed into their recommendations. This is currently possible by pausing watch history or search history, but that's deep in the settings and much harder to find. I agree, YOuTube should make a privacy mode toggle that is available right next to the video. - Sometimes videos that were already watched are recommended. I'm split on this one - I've certainly seen times they recommend a previously-watched video where I don't think it would make sense to rewatch it. But that is likely based on user behavior as well. And if there are enough users watching some video repeatedly, it might be a fair and correct prediction to suggest it to me. When you click the 'Not Interested' link beneath a video, you can also click 'Tell Us Why' and select the option 'I already watched it' to give them that hint. But the interface is a bit cumbersome, certainly.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoMy expectations are very low, and I generally only browse my sub feed, but I have noticed that some recommendations are getting better. Specifically, I notice more of: * Subjects I haven't watched in a while, but went through a period of watching. This is especially useful if it's a recent update or revival of a particular topic. * Content from channels that are actually similar to what I often watch, and not just clickbait stuff. Occasionally there's actual valuable discovery in the recs. * Videos that I very much would normally watch from sub'd channels, but missed for whatever reason. The recs are actually helping remind me to watch things I want to watch. It's still the minority of recommendations, but I have to agree that the system is actually improving.
- AltruisticGap 8y agoManual selection doesn't bode well. I like to watch spiritual and metaphysical talks, Papaji, Eckhart Tolle, Conscious TV, Rupert Spira and the like. I don't want someone to tell me what's "true" or what's "real" by refering me to the so called "facts". Sounds like a slippery slope to me... There sure is a lot of drivel on YouTube.. much of it like content farms playing search engines, is driven by the ad revenue. I find this empty / mindless content far more distracting than "false claims".
- gotocake 8y agoI don't want someone to tell me what's "true" or what's "real" by refering me to the so called "facts". Sounds like a slippery slope to me... It sounds at a first reading as though you’d feel everything since the Enlightenment has been a slippery slope. To be fair to YouTube though, if you want an environment devoid of “what’s ‘true’ or ‘what’s real’ by referring [you] to the so-called ‘facts,’” then YouTube seems like it should be your paradise. I watch mostly technical, science, and history videos, but apparently YouTube interprets that as a preference for ranting conspiracists and people who make Joe Rogan look like a gentleman and a scholar. I can only imagine the trash it throws up if you actually seek it out! If you want to create a bubble of people saying things totally divorced from anything like reality, what more could you ask for than YouTube?
- AltruisticGap 8y agoGarbage content in my opinion is mindless, soulless content created by content farms. Which in a way is what YouTube encourages through their advertising business. Same issue with low quality results in search engines due to all the content farms. Any content that makes me question things is good in my opinion. I had a period when I was into UFOs and whatnot.. and it led to an interesting realization about what I actually know. So in my view everything has its place. For example a video about flat earth may very well engage the viewer to wonder WHY the earth wouldn't be flat? You can't force people to ask questions. Some people will get into the deep end and lose themselves. So be it. You can never force someone else to wake up out of their dreams. It's each individual's choice. At best it is only through the heart, and not rationality, that you can help someone see more clearly. Everyone believes n one thing or another, in order to feel safe. And yes you are right. YouTube is absolutely perfect right now in some funny ways. Through the limitation of their own business model, they allow everyone to express themselves. And this is better for everybody. I think they're going to stick to moderation politics and whatnot anyway, so who cares.
- odiroot 8y agoUntil they'll get PewDiePie's videos back on Trending I'll consider completely dishonest and unethical. They follow the same path Facebook paved before: closing people in bubbles.
- microcolonel 8y agoYouTube keeps showing me videos I have already seen, while not sending notifications for videos on channels I'm subscribed to (yes, with the bell!). In order to find videos from people I am subscribed to, I have to go to their Twitter/Discord/Minds so that I don't miss out on at least one video per day, it's nuts.
- drcode 8y ago...I hate that feeling when I browse youtube and want to watch a trashy video, but then have to stop myself because of the negative effects on the recommendation engine. (yes, if I'm in browser youtube I have the option to open an anonymous tab)
- izzydata 8y agoIn the last year the videos recommending on the right margin have always been the same videos regardless of what video I was on. Which are the same videos at the top of my home page recommended videos. What ever happened to video specific recommendations? That was what allowed me to discover new things related to what I was watching and not just some total aggregate of everything I've ever watched.
- mindcrime 8y agoMy biggest problem with YT recommendations is that they dramatically overweight recent videos when generating the recommendations. I mean, I can spend a week doing nothing but watching (well, listening) to videos of classical music performances, and my recommendations will be full of classical music, exactly as you'd expect. Then I watch one random one-off thing, like "15 funny pitbull fails" and suddenly ALL of my recommendations are animal videos. Then I have to go manually edit my feed history and remove "15 funny pitbull fails" to get my recommendations back to normal.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoIt's a combination of that and focusing on recommending videos in depth on whatever topic it thinks you're most interested in. I don't want to watch fifty videos about swords. Three is plenty for now. I want to watch a bunch of different videos and shallowly explore a lot of topics, and the YT recommendation system is extraordinarily incompetent at facilitating this exploration mode.
- eanzenberg 8y agoI tried FB video recently and was amazed by its predictions. It was pulling up compelling video from stuff I liked a decade ago that I was more than willing to view, it was kind of uncanny.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAll the AI stuff is really still incredibly dumb. Same for Amazon: Buy a mixer and suddenly you will be haunted everywhere by ads offering more mixers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- paulddraper 8y agoYou think that's dumb, but I bet the marketing data behind that says otherwise. You think "I already have a mixer, idiot!" but in reality the chance that you are interested in buying a mixer just went from 1% to 2%. (Because you want another one, because you want to gift one, because you returned yours, etc.)
- subliminalpanda 8y agoI wish they would provide to turn off recommendations on the home page when you're logged in. Far too many click-baity channels show up and it becomes cumbersome to wade through all of it to find the channels that I follow.
- highstep 8y agoUsing uBlock Origin to hide the youtube recommendations sidebar was a fantastic UX improvement. Now I don't have withstand youtube's persistent recommendations to watch Jordan Peterson.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sdfasdslk 8y agoNowhere to go but up, really.
- white-flame 8y agoI love watching crackpot conspiracy videos on YouTube, especially flat earth & moon landing denier stuff. Beyond just the curiosity to dissect their weird contrived explanations, there's tons of interesting scientific & historical context to be learned from the counterpoint experiments and such. I hope it will still be generally available & in the sidebar if you're already watching such content. Also, generally speaking, you really should block youtube cookies. The recommender doesn't seem to track your history then, and the entire experience is FAR better, simply recommending associations from that single video, instead of always trying to railroad you back into where you've historically spent more time.
- sayno3 8y agoHow about not allowing for using ad campaigns for targeting individuals or even groups of individuals by email or other personal information, you fucking retards (youtube employees responsible)? How does it feel to know that your "don't be evil" corporation is what allows for the radicalization of fringe/psychologically-vulnerable users? They have literally placed a greater importance on fine-grained targeted advertisement than one of the most subtle forms of malicious manipulation that has probably had a great deal of influence on the worst atrocities of our time.
- sayno3 8y agoWhat needs to be in recommended videos is niche stuff that falls into similar categories of things you have watched. That is what needs to be recommended, not a video with a million views already which compounds the winner-take-all tendency of the internet and memetic information spread. Something that is so hugely popular will be recommended through word-of-mouth or posts from other sites. They are making it harder to find lesser known pieces of information, essentially burying valuable stuff in a torrent of already popular videos.
- magicalhippo 8y ago> We now pull in recommendations from a wider set of topics—on any given day, more than 200 million videos are recommended on the homepage alone. What does the first part (wider set of topics) have to do with the second part (number of videos recommended)? Anyway, YouTube recommendations are generally quite poor I find, though sometimes a few gems come along. I also made the mistake of watching YouTube on my Android TV box. Holy cow, an ad _every single minute_. And the same 4 ads, rotating.
- TravisDick 8y agoJust guessing, but it could be that they are claiming that 200 million unique videos are recommended on a given day, with the number of unique videos being a proxy for how diverse they are. Perhaps before some of their recent changes, the number of unique videos was smaller. (Who can say for sure, though)
- porpoisely 8y agoImproving recommendations? All I'm seeing is a complete deterioration of youtube's recommends since the glory days of the early 2010s. How about stop spamming me CNN, SNL, Late Night Show ( kimmel, john oliver, etc )? I've yet to accidentally click on these links/channels in all my years using youtube and yet, I still see them every day? Why? I've pretty much given up on recommendations and just directly go to the channels I want to watch. There was a time ( early 2010s ) when youtube recommends was great and it was actually fun going down the youtube recommends rabbit hole. Now it's just corporate shilling. Just like google search and its incredible decline. You guys aren't going to improve anything because you don't have competition.
- icsllaf 8y agoI have always had the idea that there should be a law requiring any recommended item anywhere on the internet to be accompanied with a reason of why the item has been recommended. Youtube already does this with certain videos but I would much like it to be expanded completely.
- commandlinefan 8y agoHm - I was hoping to read a little bit about the algorithms behind YouTube's recommendation engine but instead got a few paragraphs informing me that YouTube was going to implement (even more) arbitrary censorship and claim it was in the spirit of "protecting" us.
- dilap 8y agohonestly, i'd like to be the judge of if a theory is crackpot or not. i'm not a kid, i don't need youtube to save me from "bad information". hopefully the change is mild. i've discovered a ton of great stuff through youtube recommendations (especially music! youtube blows everything else away for music discovery).
- AgentME 8y ago>honestly, i'd like to be the judge of if a theory is crackpot or not. i'm not a kid, i don't need youtube to save me from "bad information". If your local library or city center decided to prohibit a local white supremacy group from putting up flyers on their billboards recommending Holocaust conspiracy theory materials, would you criticize them the same way? I'm curious about why people seem to have very different standards for public spaces and websites moderating themselves.
- dilap 8y agonot a perfect analogy, because (1) billboard space is limited (2) this is restricting thingd that otherwise specifically would be recommended for me. anyway, i, personally, would still give them (and every1) the space on the billboard. let every1 talk, even the crazy and the hateful. more generally, i dont think any institution should be privilged over the individual to decide which ideas they get to hear. just one possible philosophical position, one choice on a spectrum of tradeoffs.
- charliebrownau 8y agoHow to fix YT: * Stop censoring people that dont support GLOBAL FASCIST LEFT * Support Equal Opportunity + Merit for hiring staff * Stop shadowbanning people * Stop removing subs from people * Stop pulling channels without valid reason Basically be FUCKING HONEST and be held accountable for your shady shit
- charliebrownau 8y agoFree Speech exists for EVERYONE , even if you dont support GLOBAL SOCIALIST LEFT and "progressive" Intersectional cult
- aphextron 8y agoI don't want YouTube to reccomend anything for me. I don't want Facebook to show me the news stories they think I should see. I don't want Google to show me the ads they think are more relevant to me. None of this improves my life in any way whatsoever, and in fact is leading to the dumbing down of society. We have completely handed over individual taste, interest, and curiosity to algorithms that do nothing but optimize for engagement. I'm done. I want the old internet back. A place where you were presented with a variety of information, indexed by it's content, from which I am able to pick and choose, and then discuss with other human beings.
- AgentME 8y agoThe users of YouTube, Facebook, and Google generally like a feed of things recommended to them. I feel like if this were an article about too many people pissing in a pool, your comment is saying no one should want to swim. That's one way to not get urine on you, but plenty of people clearly want to swim and it doesn't help much to blame them.
- makosdv 8y agoThis is why I never look at the recommendations on YouTube. I just go straight to my Subscription feed; there is usually something worth watching there and if not, I find my entertainment elsewhere.
- jaredtn 8y agoRecommendation systems are often too specific, full of recency bias. I use YouTube for classical music while I'm working, so I play several hours of video every day. My feed is full of similar videos that are all the same! YouTube can step it up by offering a wider variety of potential interesting videos.
- contravariant 8y agoI'd be happy if they just stopped trying to recommend videos to me personally and just tried to keep the video suggestion remotely relevant to what I'm watching.
- aaron695 8y ago>To that end, we’ll begin reducing recommendations of borderline content and content that could misinform users in harmful ways—such as videos promoting a phony miracle cure for a serious illness, claiming the earth is flat, or making blatantly false claims about historic events like 9/11. So this will apply to Christian(etc) videos? Or is this really code for videos we consider alt-right? Cause we all know it is. aka Republicans.
- simula67 8y ago> To that end, we’ll begin reducing recommendations of borderline content and content that could misinform users in harmful ways—such as videos promoting a phony miracle cure for a serious illness, claiming the earth is flat, or making blatantly false claims about historic events like 9/11. Instead, why not just include videos that thoroughly debunks these ideas in the recommendation section of these videos ?
- curiousgal 8y agoI am only 24 years old and hearing 9/11 being referred to as a historic event makes me feel old.
- natch 8y agoMy YouTube suggestions list is filled with videos I just watched in the last few weeks or months. Along with the some new videos, but remarkably many already watched ones. They are not labeled as such. I suspect I blocked some cookie or changed some setting they didn't want me to change, and this behavior is deliberately calculated to be punitive. It's not very user friendly. Or, the YouTube developers are just not very smart. Either way, it doesn't look good for them. This would be so easy to fix. If they don't know how, they are welcome to reach out to me and I can give them some ideas. Yes it did occur to me that some users might like this. But they way they have it set up is very confusing and suboptimal for my needs as a user. I will admit though it may be serving some business need that they have, like saving their bandwidth by re-serving me old videos from my cache.
- nononotnot 8y agoUser control is completely lacking in youtube. It's a tradeoff between marginal quality content and tolerating the UI and search. Their creativity in thinking up new annoyances (e.g. undesired playing of videos if you merely hover the selection to a video) is infinite.
- alan_n 8y agoI think the problem is they're using machine learning on something where it's hard to know when to reward the AI. Do you reward it for max minutes the users watch, max clicks, etc? None of them imo really measure whether the users are satisfied with the recommendations which even if that means less watch time for them, it's good for youtube as a brand. I just ignore them completely now except for when browsing music. They often don't even help when watching serial things (e.g. part 1, 2, 3), I'll often make the effort to look up a playlist instead. I have also always ignored the front page, so can't say anything about it. I do wish youtube would let you pick areas of interest and whether you wanted to be recommended based on those areas. If a video fits in an excluded area, you would just get random recs, otherwise you would get recs from around that area. Preferably a mix of recent + old + really old videos that still have good ratings / watch time. Also they would have less to sort through, etc, if they allowed creators to "archive" a video (because its outdated and maybe some other newer one replaced it). This happens to me all the time. And as a user it would be nice if for example, when some video's audio was bad and then a newer fixed one uploaded, if I was prompted to go to the new one. Similar thing with serial content. It would be nice if creators could establish one video follows another or is related.
- lolc 8y agoToo late, I installed the "Distraction Free Youtube" extension. No more sidebar: No more clickbait. Youtube got so much more pleasant.