7 ms·
Why do US colleges over-admit like this? In the UK you apply to do a computer science course, and they have 50 places or whatever for that course, and so they a
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Why do US colleges over-admit like this? In the UK you apply to do a computer science course, and they have 50 places or whatever for that course, and so they admit 50 people. You can't get into the college and then be told that actually it's full. If they do accidentally over-admit it's their problem to solve, not yours.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoAnd you would have had to have done related courses A levels for the last two years. You cant just rock up at a university and say id like to study X with out any previous education - this is what the Raspberry Pi was made for originally.
- alexgmcm 8y agoI think in CS that isn't such a concern. I mean they will want good grades in maths (and decision maths covers some parts of the CS curriculum) but little else, perhaps Physics - but other than that just good grades. The thing is that the Computing A Level wasn't widely available and the quality differed between qualifications and exam boards as well - whereas Maths is pretty consistent and is run at every school. I was fortunate enough to be able to study Further Maths as well, which honestly I would consider a better preparation.
- coroxout 8y agoI sadly concur, as someone who did fine at Computing A-Level with no work, found Further Maths difficult and was lucky to get a B with extra tuition and some juggling of module results to maximise my two final grades, and dropped out of a CS degree. I liked coding for fun but really had almost no idea what CS was when I applied. So maybe the US system would have been better for me in that I could have dipped into a bunch of 101 courses and changed my major. In the UK system, most people don't go to other subjects' lectures and if you don't like what you're doing, you have to apply from scratch. There's usually no way to change course at the same university or even get any kind of help or advice about finding an alternative elsewhere. One of these years I'll work out what I should have studied and do that instead... actually, I probably won't, now it costs £30k+. I'm glad there are MOOCs so I can satisfy my urge to sign up for random things, watch one week's worth of lessons, and then never go back again, all for free.
- alexgmcm 8y agoI had some idea of what CS was as my dad was a programmer. I chose Physics though in the end - I think the subject that really gets let down is Engineering, I had no idea what that meant. The UK (and the rest of the world) really needs much better access to education - there is no reason it should cost 30k when huge parts can be delivered MOOC-style and the remaining exams and labs done in person. Even the Open University costs a fortune these days! I hope Corbyn's National Education Service idea might fix it - if he gets elected and Brexit doesn't wreck everything...
- C1sc0cat 8y agoAh so its been taken over by the maths department :-) Back in the day I tried to switch from a HNC stream mech eng to a Maths Stats and Computing but it was 99% pure maths (no CS maths) and the computing element was nugatory and ancient.
- RugnirViking 8y agoTo be fair, you can certainly give it a go. There's no requirements to be able to submit an application, and university grade requirements are rarely total, only recommended. You might not be able to get into a top flight oxbridge university, but show a history of interesting projects and maybe attending hackathons, competitions etc many universities will fight to have you Worked for me.
- sys_64738 8y agoIn the UK they oversubscribe most 101 courses, including Psych and Comp Sci. The real watershed is Junior Honours classes which are fixed places. Even 201 is very large.
- chrisseaton 8y agoOversubscribe in what sense? In that they're a bit crowded maybe - but it's not the case that they admit you to the university and then won't let you take the course, which is what this article is about. Did you go to Edinburgh? They have a US system unlike the rest of the UK.
- sys_64738 8y agoOversubscribe in that they fill the auditorium and overflow with high numbers (psych 101 was 500+ and CompSci was 250+). Many will dropout or won't make the level 2 cut. No I didn't go to Edinburgh.
- ptah 8y agothe other alternative is to let in 300 and weed them out in first quarter with extra hard coursework and tests
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gaius 8y agoMy undergrad did that... there were 80 of us on day 1 of term 1 with people sitting on the steps and standing at the back during lectures. On day 1 of term 2 there were 40 and we fit comfortably.
- magicbuzz 8y agoWhy do US airlines overbook flights? Is it the same sort of thinking?
- chrisseaton 8y agoNo that metaphor doesn't work. US colleges' approach to admissions is more like selling aeroplane tickets but not asking people where they want to go, then be surprised when they all get to the airport and try to cram on the one plane going to the same place. In other places you buy a ticket for a destination. Yeah some flights might be a bit overcrowded in some cases, but it's not as bad as not knowing how many people want to go to each destination at all.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThey aren’t surprised. Rather, they simply can’t make all planes go to the same place. That happens over time, but then you have recessions where that plane becomes extremely unpopular, which messes up that growth.
- dsiegel2275 8y agoThere is certainly an aspect of overbooking present in university admittance/enrollment: Universities regularly "admit" more students than they can actually allow to "enroll". If a university can physically support a freshman class of, say, 1000 students, they will "admit" a number higher than that, say 1300, knowing that only a percentage of the students that they admit will actually end up enrolling (because very simply some of them choose to enroll at a another university that they were also accepted into). Here at the university I work at they refer to this "admittance/enrollment" ratio as "yield" or "yield rate". The yield is tracked from year to year and the number of acceptance letters sent out is based on this historical data. Sometimes, though, the University is surprised (like this past year here) and gets a much higher yield rate and ends up with more students than dorm rooms...
- AlphaWeaver 8y agoAt my university, in this situation, there _were_ more students than dorm rooms, and we have a freshman live-on requirement, so the university actually had to pay to rent out several entire floors of commercial apartments near campus.
- tyteen4a03 8y agoMy (UK) uni admits about 350 people to the Bachelors programme (I think about 250 survive the first two years) and about 100 more into the Masters programme. This year we had over 300 people take the AI module and it has absolutely resulted in a decrease of teaching quality, and I'm not sure if some of the students are qualified to be there (namely, Chinese students who can't even read the coursework specification correctly). International students are moneymakers (they got £75k off me) so I'm pretty sure they also over-admit.
- chrisseaton 8y agoBut everyone who was admitted can take the class, right? This article is talking about people being admitted, but then not being able to take the class at all.
- Wiretrip 8y agoI think this is a problem across the board in UK univeristies these days. When I did my CS degree (1993), I was one of two people in the year who got 1st class, now I think it's something like 25% awarded 1sts and the rest get 2:1s
- chrisseaton 8y agoI'm not convinced people aren't just legitimately working a lot harder. When I went to university graduating in 2007, so just before the crash but not really very long ago, everyone was pretty chilled out about their courses. Nobody did internships. As long as people weren't failing they were relaxed and enjoyed themselves. Getting a 2:2 was a bit of banter rather than a serious threat to your ability to ever get a good job. Now when I see students they are laser focused on absolutely doing the best they can in order to survive in a much more competitive world. I'd be working harder now as well.
- gdfasfklshg4 8y agoIt was already fairly clear by then that major employers require a 2:1.
- taneq 8y agoBecause they're getting tens of thousands of dollars per student, whether or not those students are actually getting anything of value out of it?
- writeslowly 8y agoThe article is using an elective course as an example, for some reason. Usually what you do (based on my experience at UT Austin) is try to register for all your classes in the system, with priority based on major and year. Then if there's something you really need to get into that's already full, you go to an adviser and tell them why you have to get into that class that semester and they can override the system and get you in.
- jefftk 8y agoThe US, especially liberal arts colleges, is pretty wary of premature specialization. A common thing here is that you apply to a university, take classes in a range of departments, and then by the end of sophomore year (two of four) you decide on a major. I went to Swarthmore (referenced in the article) before CS enrollment surged (www.swarthmore.edu/computer-science/alumni) and there were some people in my CS classes who decided to start on a CS major their junior (year 3 of 4) fall.
- ataturk 8y agoAnd lots of people took 5-6 years to graduate, don't forget that part.
- Aeolun 8y agoI don’t get this. In the Netherlands I’ve studied for 4 years on hard computer science. Somehow someone from the US has done maybe 1.5 years of that and gotten the same degree?
- jefftk 8y agoHow many computer science classes are needed for your degree? I believe when I was in college it was 9 classes (each one being one semester, about half a year). I took more than that, because I liked it, but many CS students just took the minimum. (This doesn't count requirements outside the CS department, like math, or other graduation requirements like "some total number of classes, at least three humanities classes, at least three social science classes" etc.)
- chrisseaton 8y ago> How many computer science classes are needed for your degree? Most non-US universities don't work like this. You get a programme that you follow, sometimes with alternatives that you can pick from. You don't have a target number of classes or credits or hours to complete. Everyone takes the same classes (except for the alternatives) at the same time in one big cohort all the way through the degree. There's not much flexibility for a minimum or maximum - there's just the one set path.
- SiVal 8y agoThe classes aren't usually limited to people majoring in CS. Lots of non-majors take these classes, and the popularity of a class among all students is not controlled by limits on how many can major in CS. In some schools they give CS majors first priority, but there are still all sorts of issues such as scheduling conflicts causing a major to need to sign up for a class late, after it has been opened to non-majors. American universities are not trade schools, and most require their students to take several classes--which students choose for themselves--that are entirely outside their majors. Waves of popularity then rise and fall.
- gumby 8y agoThe US university system is quite unusual (I believe Canada also has a similar system): at the undergraduate level you typically don't apply to a specific program; all students are expected to take a variety of classes (confusingly called "courses"), only some of which apply to a specific course of study. Domain-specialized classes become an increasing proportion of your overall classes after the first or second year (when you choose a major) though never 100%. So while the school can get some idea of demand based on what people put on their application form, typically what you put on that form has little to no impact on whether you are admitted and doesn't actually bind you to a particular program. I actually think this is a pretty good system, and was glad my own kid chose a US university (which luckily we could afford) rather than the free university education he could have chosen in either of his mother's or my countries. The theory is that you can get a broad foundational education to prepare you for a variety of possible futures, and also that there is more to education than simply work skills. Of course the reality isn't quite as utopian. It also means professions like law and medicine require whole additional degrees.
- gww 8y agoWhen I was an undergrad (Finished in 2007) it was different. You were definitely assigned to a program which had required courses with a 1-2 half courses a yearyou could use for other courses. They didn't generally limit what classes you could take and I filled out my schedule with computer science courses. This changed in my last year where they switched to a specialization / major / minor system where you could combine courses to more or less create your own degree. I ended up leaving with a specialization in biochemistry and microbiology and a major in computer science.
- hoaw 8y agoI don't know about other countries, but for non-professional degrees in Sweden a program is essentially only a guarantee to be able to take certain classes. Otherwise you can take whatever courses you want, at whatever school you want, as long as you in the end fulfill the degree requirements. Which usually means half your bachelors are credits in the same subject.
- deleted 8y ago
- alistairSH 8y agoSibling comments mostly cover it. Outside of truly specialized professional programs (engineering, nursing, architecture), US colleges delay specialization until year 2 or 3. The other notable difference is an undergraduate degree in the US is typically a 4 year program. Many in the UK are 3 year programs.
- arethuza 8y agoThe system is completely different in Scotland from the rest of the UK - undergraduate degrees are usually 4 years here rather than 3 years in rest of the UK. This is largely based on the fact that admittance is done mainly done on what people do in 5th year of high school rather than 6th year A-levels.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoFollow the money. The cost per credit hour is the same regardless of what classes you take. That 500 person freshman CS (or engineering, or bio, or whatever) class is a big money maker for the school compared to that 40 person capstone class. Schools want to make money so they pull out all the stops to freshman enrollment. The school doesn't care if students drop out because they already got their $$. The school doesn't care if students who can't hack CS switch majors because then they take more money making 100 level classes in their new major.
- nwbrown 8y agoThe short answer is that because there is a huge variety in quality of high schools in the US, that would result in a lack of diversity.
- volkl48 8y agoThis is very much a college by college thing. Where I did my CS degree, any student in the major was always going to be able to get their core courses on a proper schedule that allowed for on-time graduation. Sometimes that meant the college would add entire extra courses if there were more people needing something than expected. Did I get every elective (not all electives were taught every semester, some were only taught once every year or two, there was a large rotating selection - You had to take a few from different areas) that I was interested in? No, but I got most of them. ------- However, if you were a non-major looking to take some CS classes (beyond an intro one specifically intended for non-majors), you would have a tough time getting in. You were only allowed to register for those after all the students majoring in CS registered.