12 ms·
Why We Dominate the Earth
- devmunchies 8y agoI saw an interesting, related theory in an ecology book I read recently. Most native peoples were very in tune withe the earth (Pagan Europe, Native American tribes, Hindu India, Tribal Africa, Aboriginal Australia, etc). The rise of Abrahamic religion, with man as the most important creature on the planet and everything on earth created for man, is a factor for why we "dominate" the earth.
- bpizzi 8y agoOr maybe the starting point is that sapiens' DNA really is shaped for ruling. That sapiens mostly preferred 'Abrahamic religion' to others is then a consequence to this starting point.
- krapp 8y ago>That sapiens mostly preferred 'Abrahamic religion' to others is then a consequence to this starting point. Sapiens didn't mostly prefer Abrahamic religion. Judaism didn't proselytize as far as I'm aware, and Christianity and Islam converted many cultures and people by force (although not exclusively.) And you're not considering the widespread preference for Buddhist and animist religions, which over time likely equal if not surpass the Abrahamic faiths... although to be fair those also sometimes were spread by force as well.
- bpizzi 8y ago> And you're not considering the widespread preference for Buddhist and animist religion [...] Actually I'm not considering anything, I was just pointing that the theory in the parent's book could be reversed.
- mtts 8y agoThe Chinese don't follow an Abrahamic religion and yet they've built huge urban empires. It's unlikely this is a factor.
- devmunchies 8y agoIt could be a factor everywhere else I mentioned, though. This is a logical fallacy.
- simplify 8y agoWhich fallacy? I don't understand.
- devmunchies 8y agoPerson A got cancer from smoking, but person B got cancer from exposure to chemicals so smoking likely doesn't cause cancer. Its the same argument.
- mtts 8y agoI think I meant it more in the sense of "smoking causes cancer and so does exposure to chemicals so it's not the smoking or the chemicals that we need to look at but something they both have in common." I may not have made that clear enough, however.
- yukonbound 8y agoAbrahamic Religions arrived perhaps too recently. The records we have of ancient civilizations show that they successfully dominated their environments already, and certainly accomplished amazing things.
- pnongrata 8y agoAlso, the Incas, Mayas and Aztecs.
- mikeash 8y agoI’d say the Earth was fairly well dominated by the time Abrahamic religion started to become mainstream around 300AD.
- Symmetry 8y agoAxial[1] religion might have something to do with which societies succeeded later, but that isn't the same thing as Abrahamic and is all about a later phenomenon. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axial_Age https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axial_Age
- mikeash 8y agoThis sort of thing really makes me wish we had high-fidelity simulations of human societies we could do experiments with. And then comes the fear that we’re in one.
- krapp 8y ago>Most native peoples were very in tune withe the earth (Pagan Europe, Native American tribes, Hindu India, Tribal Africa, Aboriginal Australia, etc). The reason there were so many bison in the US when the settlers arrived is that the native Americans had already hunted the rest of the megafauna to extinction. While I think there is a kernel of truth to your comment, I also think the premise that primitive people's were more "in tune" with nature than their Western counterparts in some deep cultural or spiritual sense is a revisionist myth predicated on the "noble savage" archetype. The truth is more likely that being "in tune" with nature was simply a matter of survival for such people. Obviously, if your culture survives primarily on deer, you don't kill all of the deer. But primitive people were quite capable of destroying or harming their environment, as long as they could survive it, just not as capable as more advanced societies.
- nikofeyn 8y ago> The reason there were so many bison in the US when the settlers arrived is that the native Americans had already hunted the rest of the megafauna to extinction. do you have a good source that details the evidence of this? and what megafauna were killed off? i tried searching and from what i found, it isn't anywhere as close to clear cut as you state it. i even saw an article debunking the "overkill hypothesis" which claimed some scientists did some dating studies and showed that in a region of north america the large animals died off before native americans arrived. of course that could be false, but it just doesn't seem so clear as you state it.
- pokeymcsnatch 8y agoThe theory of natives wiping out American megafauna is well-disputed. It was probably a combination of factors (possibly including hunting). The idea of primitive people being more in tune with the earth doesn't have to go hand-in-hand with the "noble savage" romanticization. There's evidence that North America was essentially a well-managed game reserve. For people that didn't have much in the ways of truly domesticated livestock, it makes sense that they worked towards food security in a different way than societies that had cattle and pigs. By necessity, they would have had to develop practical and efficient methods for managing their food source. So sure, they were probably much more in tune with nature their contemporary Europeans or modern Americans, if "in tune" means having the know-how to bend and shape the natural world for their benefit.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI think this is a little simplified but I honestly believe that if the bible didn't contain the phrase "Let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness; and let them rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky and over the cattle and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth" the world may be a better place.
- lordnacho 8y ago> Surprisingly, it’s not our shared language or even our ability to dominate other species that defines us but rather, our shared fictions. I read his book where he talks about this. It makes some sense: you can operate at varied scales if you have shared fictions. When you meet a complete stranger, you're both members of the human race, sharing a desire for a better future. Meet a fellow countryman, and there are songs and stories that bind you together. Work for the same company and there's internal culture as well as the glorious leader you both work for. Support the same football team and you both remember that night in Istanbul. You were sitting at home in Liverpool, he was in Malaysia. Hard to tell as with anything historical whether this is the most convincing explanation though. I'm sure there's other things that separate us from the animals? But a compelling enough story and he tells it well.
- hammock 8y agoThat night in Istanbul was a fiction? Isn't that just a shared story?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mostlysimilar 8y ago"Football" being anything other than a bunch of humans running around on some grass kicking the ball is the "fiction" in this context, where "fiction" means "shared belief" and things like game rules, organized competition, etc. are mutually agreed upon and able to be talked about.
- lordnacho 8y agoThe fiction is that you have something to do with those guys who kick the ball around.
- learc83 8y agoThere was an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation that explored a similar concept. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darmok https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darmok
- dustinmoris 8y agoSapiens is a must read for anyone who wants to better understand the fabrics of humanity. It's one of my most favourite books and reading it definitely has opened up my eyes to the world. An example: Humans are the "creators of the world", the most dominant species on the planet and at the top of the food chain by a long distance and yet we are the most jumpy/scary species of all. If a tiny spider would crawl up the leg of a lion they wouldn't give a bit of a shit. A lion would remain calm, knowing that the spider cannot do anything and it wouldn't even bother to entertain the spider for a split second. However if the same tiny spider would crawl up the leg of a human there's a real chance that this person would start jumping up and down, perhaps trying to kill the spider or maybe even rush out of the room until the spider is gone. This is completely irrational for someone like us - the species who literally dominates everything on this planet - and yet so common. Why is that? Because lions had millions of years to climb the ladder to the top of the food chain and therefore had the time to develop a nature which reflects their strength, whereas humans have jumped to the top so quickly that we still have the fears and behaviour of someone who is extremely weak and vulnerable. It's actually quite scary and also explains why humans often respond to tiny issues with violence, bombings and other out of proportion threats when things could just be ignored.
- devmunchies 8y agoI don't agree. I lived in the Caribbean for a while and the longer i was there the less i cared about spiders or flies crawling on my face. If you see other peoples freak out from spiders, you think thats the correct reaction and so you do it.
- gnulinux 8y ago>If a tiny spider would crawl up the leg of a lion they wouldn't give a bit of a shit. A lion would remain calm, knowing that the spider cannot do anything and it wouldn't even bother to entertain the spider for a split second. > However if the same tiny spider would crawl up the leg of a human there's a real chance that this person would start jumping up and down, perhaps trying to kill the spider or maybe even rush out of the room until the spider is gone. I think there is a chance this might be a bad comparison. Do non-human primates not fear spiders? Some interesting read: https://www.psychologicalscience.org/journals/cd/12_1/Ohman.cfm https://www.psychologicalscience.org/journals/cd/12_1/Ohman.... https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2001-07628-001 https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2001-07628-001 https://psycnet.apa.org/record/1985-05872-001 https://psycnet.apa.org/record/1985-05872-001
- est31 8y agoWe are great at coordinated actions on varying scales, but I wonder whether we can also do coordinated actions at global scales that outspan an individual's lifespan. Like in preventing climate change. Or in making sure that we don't nuke each other. The nuking experiment has been running for a few decades only. Can we avoid rocking the boat so hard that it keels over?
- seren 8y agoEmpires or religions are great unifying forces that span centuries and continents, so yes it is possible to have a narrative that goes beyond a simple human life. Regarding the global scale, even if we don't realize it, we mostly already have a global common culture. Everyone is organizing its time in year of 365 days, split in 24 hours, counting in base 10, have mostly the same economical policies. Even ISIS has seized and used dollars from banks in their occupied territory, so they also believe in the dollar [0]. All of the these things were not true 10,000 years ago, we have probably already lost thousands of different human cultures since the start of agriculture. Sure we still have regional preferences on sport, food, festival, etc, but mostly all humans are running the same basic OS, so to speak. So are we going to coordinates on the global scale, only time will tell, but this is much more likely today that it was 1,000 years ago. [0] IIRC this is an example taken from Sapiens in the chapter about money.
- rimliu 8y agoIs it not just autoplasticity vs. alloplasticity?
- jpadkins 8y agoI've wondered if mathematics is a 'shared fiction'. Obviously money and laws are shared fictions, but I wondered if other species can't grasp math concepts (beyond counting) because there is a fictional or conceptual element that their brains can't process.
- mjlee 8y agoThere is a fair amount of discussion about this in the most recent episode of the BBC show This Infinite Monkey Cage: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m00024ph https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m00024ph Should be downloadable as a podcast for the next couple of weeks from most sources. It's a fairly light take on science with some comedy and teasing, but the scientific element is respectable.
- akvadrako 8y agoOf course not, at least in any practical sense. Even plants use the mathematical properties of fractals to make effective structures. If we encountered aliens that are as alien as possible, they would agree on the ratio of the radius to the circumference of a circle on a flat plane.
- jpadkins 8y agoI'm not debating whether math exists or governs our reality. My question was can other species understand math concepts? Or is this a unique sapien genetic mutation. AFAIK, plants don't communicate or use math concepts (even if they grow using them).
- pnongrata 8y agoAs the author puts it, it's not about genetic mutations. Sapiens have the ability to share fictions, stories, in which we can all agree in order to live in a functioning society. So, in this sense, mathematics, laws and private companies are all 'fictions'. It only works if people believe in it.
- fmihaila 8y ago
- sh4rk 8y agoSorry but isn't it just because we innovate? We innovate without evolution. Does any other species innovate without evolution? Something feels wrong to me here. It almost like it's the exact opposite: shared fiction is what hold us back (though it's probably good from a survival stand point), and innovation is what makes us unique, and it specially happens when there is no fiction but a real search for the truth.
- cobbzilla 8y ago> Does any other species innovate without evolution? Technically yes, but for all practical purposes no. Different clans of primates (chimpanzees iirc) have "innovated" distinct and novel ways to get food, specific to their clan. These are not innate, they are taught within the clan and passed down from generation to generation. With this, they share a common cultural knowledge and can preserve it into the future. From a practical point of view, the speed of this "innovation" is glacial, but not all that different from the pace of human progress for most of our history. So what makes us different? I'd argue that the evolution of speech/language provided the most important initial boost. With language, all cultural knowledge, including innovations, becomes so much easier to retain across generations.
- dan00 8y ago> It almost like it's the exact opposite: shared fiction is what hold us back ... Shared fiction is nothing else than just shared knowledge. Without collecting and keeping your knowledge you can't go further, there's no basis for innovating further.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAs 'dan00 points out, without the ability to retain the results of the innovation process over generations, innovating pretty much goes to waste. What makes us special is a combination of ability to innovate, to pass it to others, to pass it to next generations, to build new innovations upon the old ones, and the ability to build stable societies that let us extend the scope of innovation to things beyond capability of single individual. As much as shared stories are crucial for building and maintain societies, it's an important element of what makes us special. WRT. the social part, I'm reminded of something 'lisper keeps saying - that the minimum viable reproductive unit for homo sapiens is a tribe or a village.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoI think this is all nice and well and but we raised to the top of the food chain because we had pointier sticks, abstract thinking came later. Much later. > About 70,000 or so years ago [...] the cognitive revolution https://www2.palomar.edu/anthro/homo/homo_4.htm https://www2.palomar.edu/anthro/homo/homo_4.htm > about 2.5 million years ago [...] Oldowan tools
- spurgu 8y agoGive a bunch of chimpanzees an unlimited supply of chainsaws and fuel, I doubt that'll take them to the top of the food chain.
- LoSboccacc 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vssqb-0i2-A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vssqb-0i2-A mhm
- scoot 8y agoUnrelated to the article, but the headline raised the question in my mind - is intelligent life an inevitability, and is that a good or bad thing? If the human race had not, would another species eventually rise to a similar position? And would it have caused the same destruction? On the flip side, what purpose would natural life serve if there was no species sufficiently cognizant to recognize it?
- Juliate 8y agoWhy would purpose be a thing to the accidental?
- malvosenior 8y ago> is intelligent life an inevitability, and is that a good or bad thing? Without intelligence, there is no good or bad. You can't begin to overlay a moral framework on the world if there are no sentient beings to create it.
- dota_fanatic 8y agoWithout intelligence, there is no red or blue. You can't begin to overlay a color framework on the world if there are no sentient beings to create it. Maybe universal morality does exist, we're just too simple minded to see it.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoWithout eyes, there's no red or blue. There are wavelengths of light, but no colors. Colors are the names we give to sensations. Similarly, morality is a property of mind. It's like color, not like wavelength. And unlike light, we didn't find any objective source in the outside world, nor do we know of a process that would tune our perception of morality with fundamental laws of physics. Personally, I currently believe the only somewhat-objective source of morality is path dependence: all humans share the same brain architecture. I think all the base shared moral instincts we have come from that.
- 8y ago
- Finnucane 8y agoWe don't dominate the earth. Ants do.
- WilliamEdward 8y agoI'm not sure what you think dominate means...
- eanzenberg 8y agoIt's kind of revisionist to consider the last 60 years (if we're generous) but more like 10 years as proof that intelligent beings got there through some massive amount of cooperation across borders and beyond close-knit groups >>Sapiens can cooperate in extremely flexible ways with countless numbers of strangers. Human intelligence has been around a lot longer than a few decades and for the vast vast majority of that time has not only still dominated the world but sects of people were uncooperative and competing with each other all the time, wiping out people here and there without a though otherwise. If the main thesis is that a common language lead to cooperation and therefore world dominance, that's false too. People have dominated the earth for a while, and with a language, and without much cooperation but through fighting and spilled blood.
- golergka 8y ago> sects of people were uncooperative and competing with each other all the time And those groups who cooperated with in-group better have repeatedly outcompeted groups that didn't cooperate as well.
- eanzenberg 8y agoUp to a point. Successful cooperation seems to be through family ties or common upbringing, such as the vikings or spartans.
- jpadkins 8y agomodern corporations outcompete family or upbringing based orgs.
- golergka 8y agoIf you look at history, cultures that have managed to form a wide group identity have wiped out cultures that relied on close, tribe-like cooperation. Here's a short clip from Sapolsky's lectures on behavioural evolution about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQKTnau5AEY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQKTnau5AEY I originally watched the whole lecture course, so I don't know how well the point gets across in this clip, but I highly recommend his lectures for this and other related subjects.
- Symmetry 8y agoSapiens was a pretty decent book but if you want take that's both deeper and more scientifically informed I'd go for The Secret of Our Success instead.
- chkaloon 8y agoReading the book right now. What's concerning to me is that we are currently seeing the dissolving of myths across the board, whether it be religion, faith in public institutions, or facades that we kept before social media existed. Is the breakdown of social cohesion a consequence? Letting go of myths seems like an inherent good, but can we survive it?
- 86carr 8y agoYou should check out RS Bakker or Peter Watts. https://rsbakker.wordpress.com/ https://rsbakker.wordpress.com/ https://www.rifters.com/ https://www.rifters.com/
- nyolfen 8y agobakker has some thoughts of his own on harari: https://rsbakker.wordpress.com/2016/10/20/visions-of-the-semantic-apocalypse-a-critical-review-of-yuval-noah-hararis-homo-deus/ https://rsbakker.wordpress.com/2016/10/20/visions-of-the-sem... https://rsbakker.wordpress.com/2018/08/11/were-fucked-so-now-what/ https://rsbakker.wordpress.com/2018/08/11/were-fucked-so-now... > The biological origins of narrative lie in shallow information cognitive ecologies, circumstances characterized by profound ignorance. What we cannot grasp we poke with sticks. Hitherto we’ve been able to exapt these capacities to great effect, raising a civilization that would make our story-telling ancestors weep, and for wonder far more than horror. But as with all heuristic systems, something must be taken for granted. Only so much can be changed before an ecology collapses altogether. And now we stand on the cusp of a communicative revolution even more profound than literacy, a proliferation, not simply of alternate narratives, but of alternate narrators. > If you sweep the workbench clean, cease looking at meaning as something somehow ‘anomalous’ or ‘transcendent,’ narrative becomes a matter of super-complicated systems, things that can be cut short by a heart attack or stroke. If you refuse to relinquish the meat (which is to say nature), then narratives, like any other biological system, require that particular background conditions obtain. Scranton’s error, in effect, is a more egregious version of the error Harari makes in Homo Deus, the default presumption that meaning somehow lies outside the circuit of ecology. Harari, recall, realizes that humanism, the ‘man-the-meaning-maker’ narrative of Western civilization, is doomed, but his low-dimensional characterization of the ‘intersubjective web of meaning’ as an ‘intermediate level of reality’ convinces him that some other collective narrative must evolve to take its place. He fails to see how the technologies he describes are actively replacing the ancestral social coordinating functions of narrative.
- devoply 8y agoWhy we dominate the earth is not an interesting question. An interesting question is should we and is it a net positive? I personally don't think so. We as a species is completely incapable of managing the earth... or we have not yet evolved systems to do so and until we do we should stop dominating the earth.
- m0skit0 8y agoDefine "dominate". IMHO bacteria dominate the Earth, but of course, they don't know. They don't even need to know to dominate.
- EpicEng 8y ago>dom·i·nate >verb >have a commanding influence on; exercise control over. >be the most important or conspicuous person or thing in. Bacteria have a huge effect on all life, but they don't "exercise control" as they are not self aware. Their influence is comprised solely of externalities. Humans by comparison exert far more control over the environment around them. We shape the world to our purpose. I think humanity wins here.
- evv 8y agoHumanity may win here, but you should be careful about how you define it. Individual humans don't control much more of our environment than animals do. Like animals in a zoo, we are often born into very constrained situations that wildly limit our actual control. We are usually caged by our economic situation. What I'm saying is, the "human" does not dominate the earth. The corporation does. We shouldn't be afraid of loosing control to an AI that will rule our world, because we have already let the companies do whatever they want. Some of us are lucky enough to participate in this world, by forming and working for world-changing corporations, but everybody else is closer to the bacteria side of the spectrum.
- EpicEng 8y agoTell that to the folks who invented agriculture. We were shaping the planet long before corporations existed. It's amazing how some people can turn any discussion into some version of a discussion on /r/LateStageCapitalism.
- evv 8y agoOf course individuals shaped the planet long before corporations existed, but once people could organize and compete, individual farmers lost control.. right? These days, farmers are beholden to governments, banks, and agro companies, who use economical pressure to force specific behavior and crops. How much control do modern farmers really have over their farm? I haven't spent much time on that subreddit, but it sounds like I would feel at home there! It is incredibly important that we have each-other's backs.. humanity may technically be thriving, but most people are just trying to make ends meet.
- wanted2 8y agoWe do not dominate Earth, we're just destroying it. Just as we think we are intelligent beings, we're actually incredibly stupid.
- Eire_Banshee 8y agoThis is such an easy, garbage take on the article.
- pqhwan 8y agoI think about how language, in a utilitarian sense, is a tool for individuals to program each other. I guess, in gaining the ability to tell convincing fictions, we've discovered more powerful primitives, and were able to spread consistent programming to wider groups of humans.
- socrates1998 8y agoMy unscientific guess is that the mutation allowed for greater group dependence and cohesion. This article and Harari's book sort of dance around this, but I think it's some type of emotional gene that we are emotionally hard wired to NEED to connect with people. Like a tiger stalks with your back turned to it, people emotionally need to be connected to other people in a deep, meaningful way. Humans are not only unique in their abilities like problems solving and language, but also in their 100% dedication to the tribe. I think it is this combination that allows for us to work together in such large groups and successfully. Harari calls it "fictions" that bind us together, but that doesn't quite seem to work for me. The question I ask is WHY do these "fictions" work so well? Why would a Nebraska farmer go half way across the world and climb French beaches with German guns shooting at him? Why are we so compelled to identify with a group? A comedian has a great joke about this. Essentially, the WORST thing you can do to a person is put them in solitary confinement. Even being surrounded by criminals and prison guards is infinity better than being forced to be alone in a room. We desperately need to connect with people. It seems hard wired genetically to me. I think culture helps serve this purpose of binding us together. Art, music, theatre, and even sports are all a part of the process of group cohesion. Group cohesion and dependency is so powerful that it's often the number one factor in determining which societies/countries/groups come out victorious with intergroup conflict. A great book called "War and Peace and War" by Peter Turchin is a fantastic book to read if this concept interests you. Another one, "Tribe" by Sebastion Junger also explores this topic.
- Phenomenit 8y ago"A comedian has a great joke about this. Essentially, the WORST thing you can do to a person is put them in solitary confinement. Even being surrounded by criminals and prison guards is infinity better than being forced to be alone in a room. We desperately need to connect with people. It seems hard wired genetically to me." My unscientific response to this is that it's more a personality dependency. Our personality or individuality is dependent on other individuals so when you your all alone your ego starts to disolve and all your skills and attributes that depend on ego start to fade. Most people would experience this as going insane. Cohesion in large groups are aided by strong personalities that create and sustain larger groups(hierarchies) and than in turn enables larger groups.
- iskander 8y agoThese evolutionary backsplanations feel like they're saying more about our current society, values, and biases than any group of past humans.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- _bxg1 8y agoI've previously thought about the idea that Humans are the first species with software, instead of just hardware. When a bug exists in a chip, you have to wait for the next generation to have it fixed. But a programmer can fix a bug or add functionality to the same physical machine; this is why software exists in the first place. The decision-making of other animals may develop generationally, but it has very limited capacity for change within a single organism's life. On the other hand, a human can endlessly rewrite her software on top of the same hardware. We can evolve without waiting for our DNA to change.
- rdiddly 8y ago"There is no parallel in other species for these quick, large-scale shifts. General behavior patterns in dogs or fish or ants change due to a change in environment, or to broad genetic evolution over a period of time." Aha! This passage made me realize why we can't seem to get a grip on, for example, climate change (but also that we soon, easily could). Humans can undergo a quick, large-scale shift in behavior having nothing to do with an environmental change; therefore it's also true that humans can staunchly and stubbornly adhere to the same behavior, despite an environmental change.
- bambax 8y agoThere are many problems with the thesis that sapiens is oh but so special (and of "special" being good). One is that our species is at least 100,000 years old, most probably 200,000 and possibly a million years old. Yet, culture, history and "world dominance" only happened very recently. Why did it take so long? Another is that there were many "sapiens" species and they went extinct, either because we exterminated them, or nature did, or we absorbed them by cross-breeding. Being cognitive is no guaranty of success and even, it turns out, no protection from extermination. Yet another is that other species have language (dolphins for instance, which are neither "dogs" or "fish" or "ants"). And finally, talking of our "success" is the most ironic way of putting it, since we're in the process of destroying all mammal life on earth (including us). Maybe ants "eat our garbage" but they are likely to survive us, unlike anyone who's reading this.