7 ms·
Facebook's '10 Year Challenge' Is Just a Harmless Meme–Right?
- somethingle234 8y agoThe media really has it out for Facebook after Facebook decided to reduce page reach. It seemed like Facebook can't do anything right. The '10 year challenge' is a good feature. Some people enjoyed it. It created joy for those people. And, like other comments, the data isn't really useful.
- chollida1 8y agohttps://globalnews.ca/news/4855500/facebook-10-year-challenge-facial-recognition/ https://globalnews.ca/news/4855500/facebook-10-year-challeng... https://twitter.com/facebook/status/1085675097766031360?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1085675097766031360&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fglobalnews.ca%2Fnews%2F4855500%2Ffacebook-10-year-challenge-facial-recognition%2F https://twitter.com/facebook/status/1085675097766031360?ref_... and rebuttal. I know that Facebook's actions mean that it no longer deserves the benefit of the doubt but this seems like a non story that someone really wants to be a story. Thinking about it lest say 10,000 people respond, is that even enough data to move the needle? Which photo do you use for the old vs recent? There is alot of cleanup that manually needs to be done for this to be a decent data set. Basic common sense says this is a non story. I did my post undergrad research in 2000 in neural nets and the data sets were our biggest limiting factor, second was computation time. 10,000 data points was a huge set back then and still wasn't enough for most tasks.
- opless 8y ago10,000 ? It's probably many many more times that about three times the magnitude. It might be a bit of a noisy dataset now that it's a meme.
- matte_black 8y agoCleanup is standard work for any dataset. With enough money and a pile of Indians working for cheap hourly rates you can clean through A LOT of data. 10,000? Try a million!
- halfdan 8y agoMy guess is you can just use EXIF metadata and/or picture resolution/sharpness to easily sort old Vs. new. Cameras have come a long way in ten years..
- corobo 8y agoAs has internet privacy. Any social site keeping EXIF intact will pay big in their bug bounty to hear about it because that's a GDPR nightmare
- scrollaway 8y agoFacebook most certainly keeps exif intact. Just because they don't publish it doesn't mean they don't retain it as metadata. I dont know what you think gdpr is but it's not a magic wand which prevents companies from gathering data.
- corobo 8y agoMy response was in the context of a third party using the data
- anoncoward111 8y agoWhy do they need to be Indian? Sure the data would reflect that a plurality of global low wage workers are from India, but there are also plenty of low wage workers who are not ethnically Indian or geographically based in India (such as all of the Americans working on r/beermoney).
- matte_black 8y agoBy using Indian workers you are helping to provide a living wage for people who really need it, not just for “beer money”.
- anoncoward111 8y ago
- rzzzt 8y agoCan you think of other challenges from the past that might be good for training neural networks? Also, is it hard to figure out the origins of a meme? Lots of them are categorized and researched pretty well already.
- ngcc_hk 8y agoHow about you have 1.3+ billion subject?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- flocial 8y agoFacebook already has access to a larger repository of photos going back over a decade and all the years inbetween along with decent face recognition to create a much bigger dataset than resorting to a hashtag challenge. But I guess that wouldn't be newsworthy.
- JaleDarvis 8y agoAccess to what?
- berbec 8y agoa larger repository of photos going back over a decade
- corobo 8y agoThat is assuming it's Facebook training the algorithm
- reaperducer 8y agoFacebook denies involvement. But Facebook is no longer worthy of blind trust.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThis is a circular argument.
- acct1771 8y agoJust say what you're saying. It's Feds. And they're the biggest social influencers around.
- macintux 8y agoAs has been pointed out, people identifying themselves makes it easier to figure out which 10-year-old and current photos are actually: * themselves * 10 years old
- thatguyagain 8y agoThis is just stupid. Even if Facebook wanted to do something like this, they have the data. Millions and millions of photos are already time stamped.
- colordrops 8y agoA funny trend I've been seeing is posts from /r/conspiracy being mined by journalists for their stories. This exact idea was posted a few days ago to Reddit, and is not this tech writer's idea.
- rhizome 8y agoReporters combing Reddit for story ideas has been going on for years and years. Heck, it might be worth an experiment to see how quickly someone can start from scratch and put together a portfolio of clips this way. The pitches practically come prewritten.
- tw1010 8y agoI don't believe that for a second, it totally sounds like a conspiracy.
- praneshp 8y agoIf you were going for a joke, nice one! If serious, I can confirm that I saw this on reddit a few days ago too.
- burk96 8y agoI saw it as well, honestly I think journalists (the kind that are closer to glorified bloggers) have been doing this for quite awhile though. I can't remember what site it was for sure, maybe cracked, but I remember looking at the recent articles and it looked like a tl;dr of some of the top reddit posts of the week.
- colordrops 8y agoI've definitely noticed that with Cracked.
- tw1010 8y agoImagine the irony if that wasnt't the intent, but articles like this have now placed the idea in the heads of facebook engineers.
- crsmithdev 8y ago"My flippant tweet began to pick up traction. My intent wasn't to claim that the meme is inherently dangerous." He spun an offhand comment into full-on opinion manipulation, because we're now reading his article on the topic that not only has a clickbait headline, it seems to imply there's something more to the story, when in fact there isn't. So now we've got all this digital ink spilled on the (entirely hypothetical) topic, and plenty of eyeballs buying it with their attention. But all of it is vapor, even at the admission of the authors.
- avree 8y agoYou are replying to an article written by someone named "Kate O'Neill", in which they include a photograph of themselves via Twitter, and you are referring to them as "he"?
- crsmithdev 8y agoRight, so there's a letter missing from a pronoun. Noted. Any thoughts on the commentary itself? No?
- warp_factor 8y agoThe issue with internet nowadays to be honest. As soon as you got a bit of traction with a tweet or with a blog post people try to milk it in order to market themselves or other narcissistic interests.
- porpoisely 8y agoIt's not the internet. It's media in general. They need to create an artificial story to make a profit. Now that the internet is a profit making center, the media and its tactic has found a welcome home in the internet. Hence the "arctic blast" about to "ravage the east coast". Or as someone who has lived in the northeast, just winter. Or any other superlative clickbait. Everything is a crisis, everything is a disaster.
- tsumnia 8y agoThis research has been in existence for over a decade[1]. Clearly this would be a valuable dataset, but as others have mentioned, Facebook has probably the most valuable dataset. Realistically, the biggest hurdle in modelling aging is in children. The bones/muscles/everything are so elastic that it makes it difficult to accurately predict how they will look. The primary use for this tech has been for catching high-valued individuals that have gone in hiding or children kidnapped into human trafficking (hence the focus on modeling child face growth). This entire thing sounds more like someone made a joke about "Big Brother always watching" and people without a real understanding of what's possible freaked out when they realized it is. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/can-your-face-reveal-how-long-youll-live-new-technology-may-provide-the-answer/2014/07/02/640bacb4-f748-11e3-a606-946fd632f9f1_story.html?utm_term=.1b3abfe183cd https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/can-y...
- kerng 8y agoWhat I like about this tweet is that society starts changing and realizing what possible things could be done with information that is shared. Good to see more critical thinking evolve when it comes to social media.
- jamespetercook 8y agoThis seems more likely to be a marketing move to me than a covert request for AI training data. They’re struggling with engagement, so they seeded the 10 Year Challenge causing users to invoke the powerful emotion of nostalgia, made easy thanks to Facebook keeping all of your photos safe ;)
- justapassenger 8y agoAmount of non-stories about Facebook is getting boring.
- ozgurozkan 8y agoPeople above 18 don’t have very different face biometrics between 18 and 118 years old.
- baxtr 8y agoThis is saying a lot about what people think of Facebook these days. I don’t believe that FB wants to gather data here. This is probably an idea coming from their marketing department. But hey, why would you not think they’re evil after everything they’ve done?
- 40acres 8y agoFacebook and Google's facial recognition software is so advanced that they have no real use for photos of people explicitly tagged 10 years apart. Google Photos has been able to track my goddaughter from literally her first photo (when she looked like an alien) to now (5 years later), with about 2 photos per year. The subtle point here is that people have became so suspicious of these platforms that everything they do is observed with a sharper eye on privacy, speaking of which... I wonder how Portal is doing?
- oth001 8y agoExactly what I thought when I first saw this. Glad to see somebody wrote about it.
- aaron695 8y agoThis is a perfect story for the Russians to put out. Loved by conspiracy theorists. Known to be stupid by anyone who thinks logically. Great for division. Weakens the legitimate anti Facebook side. Funny how the media has the same purpose as Russian propaganda. Side note, dumbs things has to believe - "Last year police in New Delhi reported tracking down nearly 3,000 missing kids in just four days using facial recognition technology." 3000 of 45,000 kids in homes could be found using facial recognition... Because they were actually missing and should not be in a home. We are supposed to believe 6.6% of kids in a home are actually recorded as missing A parent could go through all the photos in a day, but didn't. What's the false positives on this? Can't these kids talk? Parents walked to the cop shop with a photo but not the local orphanage? All these kids fell asleep in a train?
- itchyjunk 8y agoMaybe it's not the data in the meme but studying how memes spread and how well you can predict it?
- feelix 8y agoThis is idle speculation from somebody who has no idea what they're talking about. Because it was published on Wired it has gone viral. It's just technical enough that most people who don't have a clue think that it might be right so they spread it. Anyone who knows about data processing, programming, or AI knows that it's a very stupid idea due to easy-to-implement fault tolerance (such as random dropout) in machine learning models.
- Sam_Harris 8y agoWow Hacker News just loves paywalls.