19 ms·
Costco opening a $440M chicken farm to escape America's chicken monopoly
- ivankolev 8y agoIf it is going to use the same factory farming processes, what's the point?
- eweise 8y agoI read somewhere they want smaller chickens that the farms produce.
- traek 8y agoNPR has more info about motivations: > Building a system to stock its own stores is a way for the company to better manage supply and costs, especially because poultry companies are trending away from raising chickens to be sold whole. > According to Will Sawyer, a meat industry economist for the Denver-based farm lender CoBank, chicken producers are growing bigger chickens to sell in parts. "The vast majority are processed into chicken breasts or leg quarters or thighs, or they're further processed into strips or nuggets," Sawyer said. "That's where the industry has gone over 50 years now." https://www.npr.org/2018/10/22/659561091/costco-builds-nebraska-supply-chain-for-its-5-rotisserie-chickens https://www.npr.org/2018/10/22/659561091/costco-builds-nebra...
- kevindong 8y agoI think there's two reasons: 1. They're partially insulating themselves from price changes in the chicken market. By raising the chickens themselves, they can guarantee that they'll only pay a certain price for the chicken they raise. 2. Fewer intermediaries = lower prices since there's fewer companies that each need to make some money = higher profit
- dguaraglia 8y agoPlanet Money had a really good episode on the kind of shit the "chicken cartel" pulls off: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/05/09/609890025/episode-840-fixing-chicken https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/05/09/609890025/epis...
- zhobbs 8y agoI think it's just classic vertical integration, nothing to do with how animals are treated: https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/012715/when-does-it-makes-sense-company-pursue-vertical-integration.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/012715/when-does-it...
- MrTonyD 8y agoI suspect that this is about quality of product. Chicken has had a lot of problems with poisoning people here in the US (since our standards for the environment where chickens are kept isn't designed to reduce disease - rather, it encourages disease.) People have gotten sick from Costco chickens - and Costco's better smaller suppliers have been taken over by the large producers - and of course people start dying again. As long as the profits stay high chicken producers are able to get laws passed to avoid any real regulation. Corrupt government is the real problem we should all be trying to solve as software developers.
- danieljohnson 8y agoDo you have any ideas on how software developers can solve the problem of corrupt government? Not being facetious, curious to hear what your views are.
- Centigonal 8y agoOpenSecrets[1] and Sunlight Foundation[2] are great places to start. That said, IMO the greatest change is achieved by canvassing, working in public policy, or running for office oneself. Senator Jacky Rosen (D - NV), a former Software Developer, is a great example. [1] https://www.opensecrets.org/ https://www.opensecrets.org/ [2] https://sunlightfoundation.com/ https://sunlightfoundation.com/
- MrTonyD 8y agoWell, who is making decisions and how are they being made. What metrics matter? How can we judge them better? How can we improve them in people? Or, to go even further, have you ever seen Star Trek where they use the holodeck for Training? They have many real-world scenarios so that they can build experience. Couldn't the same be done in many other domains.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kbenson 8y ago> Corrupt government is the real problem we should all be trying to solve as software developers. While I agree it's a problem we should all be trying to solve, I'm not sure what being software developers has to do with it. To me, that statement sounds just as odd as if you had said "corrupt government is the real problem we should all be trying to solve as retail employees." Software and networks might have some role in a solution, but I think any worthwhile solution will start with people and policy, and possibly use software and networks to help (just as it may use resources from other professional industries, economists, such as legal professionals, etc). I think any solution that comes out of trying to shove computer science theory and practice at the problem is most likely doomed to fail. Actually, if I had to choose one discipline to that had the most to offer to this problem, it would definitely be economics.
- JSeymourATL 8y agoThe rotisserie chicken is a well-documented loss-leader for Costco. At $4.99 for a three-pound bird, it’s an amazing solution for quick weeknight dinners.> https://www.thekitchn.com/costco-chicken-loss-leader-strategy-260017 https://www.thekitchn.com/costco-chicken-loss-leader-strateg...
- larrik 8y agoCostco's rotisseries chickens are MUCH better than the grocery stores', as well.
- maerF0x0 8y agoAnd yet, so far below getting a quality bird and roasting yourself... I've noticed that many of the rotisserie birds have really odd texture, I think because they're grossly overcooked
- WaxProlix 8y agoIf you don't get a fresh one there's a chance it's sat in the warming area for a few hours, which could definitely do something bad to the texture.
- rednerrus 8y agoThere's a sticker on each box telling you what time it went out.
- gotorazor 8y agoThey are not undercooked. They inject the raw chicken with brine at the factory. That's why it has that funny texture.
- maerF0x0 8y agoI think you had a typo, ftr i said "overcooked"
- AceJohnny2 8y ago> American chicken monopoly run by the likes of Tyson, Pilgrim's Pride and Perdue. That's not what "monopoly" means.
- nickpsecurity 8y agoYup. That's an oligopoly. If a monopoly, the pricing and service would've been so bad that they'd have tried this sooner.
- philip1209 8y agoIs "cartel" the word they are looking for?
- SaltyBackendGuy 8y agoCartel is probably much closer than monopoly.
- dragontamer 8y agoCartel implies a degree of collusion. Oligopoly seems like the most accurate word choice.
- nerdponx 8y agoI would be surprised if there wasn't collusion.
- yuy910616 8y agocartels are inherently unstable and very hard to maintain, plus it's outlawed. I'd be surprised if there is one.
- danieltillett 8y agoThey are not so hard to maintain when everyone acts rationally. You don't need overt collusion as long as everyone acts in a consistent manner and doesn't try to compete.
- abc03 8y agoWatching several documentation and seeing chicken farms, I Never buy USD 5 chickens anymore. I buy only organic (more time to grow) and if available from my preferred supplier from the farmer’s market (she only slaughters 5 times a year and grows different breeds). My nephew from the US came over and was shocked at the taste (I didn’t tell him about the price as he would probably not eat it). Food prices are not a concern for me and I prefer to increase quality instead of quantity. I should anyway eat less.
- yegle 8y agoWhy would you say organic chicken takes more time to grow? Organic has nothing to do with how long it takes to grow the chicken right?
- msrpotus 8y agoThe antibiotics fed to non-organic animals cause them to grow faster.
- balls187 8y agoAre you sure about that?
- brilee 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibiotic_use_in_livestock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibiotic_use_in_livestock
- cloverich 8y agoSurprisingly, growth promotion is the original reason they were popularized: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/riots-rage-and-resistance-a-brief-history-of-how-antibiotics-arrived-on-the-farm/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/riots-rage-a...
- mlindner 8y agoAntibiotics don't cause animals to grow faster.... Please stop stating fake information as fact.
- dawhizkid 8y agoI hope Costco survives Amazon
- rthomas6 8y agoIt sells a lot of large things in its warehouses that are expensive to ship. I'm sure you can buy a 50 pound bag of dog food or a giant pack of paper towels online, but will you beat Costco's price? Doubtful.
- maerF0x0 8y agomostly because we value our own time below the market price to have someone else do it for us. If shipping cost ever plummets then this upend warehouse style stores.
- Qwertystop 8y agoNot just that - if you can get an entire shopping trip worth of stuff in one trip to a big warehouse-store, toss it all in your trunk, you don't need to fit it all in standardized boxes with bubble-plastic padding, and the distance from warehouse to your house will be covered in the most direct route. Even if you valued your own time at market rates, it would probably take less of your time than it would of someone else's, because shipping has more intermediate steps.
- jhall1468 8y agoI buy a great deal of stuff at Amazon, but Costco still represents the largest proportion of our shopping budget. I don't really think they are comparable and I don't envision a world where Amazon really competes enough with Costco to end the company.
- smsm42 8y agoI don't see why not. I am a consumer of both and I think there's space for both. I know Amazon owns Whole Foods now, but Costco and Whole foods are in different market niches, and I think Costco has a great business which so far is not seriously threatened by Whole Foods.
- elektor 8y agoGiven Costco's size and influence in the food market, I'd like to see them lend more credence to the plant-based meat market which would be even better for them financial and environmentally.
- Djvacto 8y agoI love finding new plant-based products at our costco, but sadly they rotate in and out and so sometimes we lose a product that I would have loved to keep buying. Hopefully I see some of my favorites back in soon. I understand Costco rotates products around sometimes, even if they did well.
- ianai 8y agoI don’t know why I can’t at least buy lentils from Costco. They’ve got the huge bags of pintos and rice already. They could definitely apply their business model to plant based options. Instead their shelves are prime examples of foods that could otherwise be great vegan but just have animal products needlessly included.
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoDon't be too hard on them, they're the largest organic retailer in the US[1]. Which doesn't mean they couldn't do better (in lots of ways), but they do seem to be trying. 1: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/retail/costco-becomes-largest-organic-grocer-analysts-say/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/retail/costco-becomes-...
- _coveredInBees 8y agoI think it depends on the local market. I live in an area with a large Asian (Indian/Pakistani/Chinese/East Asian) population and my local Costco sells all sorts of lentils along with Naan, etc. They even have a few types of boxed pre-made lentil soups (dals). It probably just doesn't make sense for them to stock lentils in markets with low demand.
- savrajsingh 8y ago
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI think the bigger story here is whether or not Costco's chicken will improve with respect to the other players in the market. Consider that the 'big players' have all extracted the costs they felt they could, with the choices they made, and that is the 'standard' product most people are offered. Now we get CostCo which is making different choices and perhaps getting a different result (size, flavor, what have you). In the event that CostCo chicken becomes the market leader and perhaps people are even incentivized to join CostCo in order to have access to their chicken supply, CostCo would likely open a second and third farm so that all of their chicken needs could be met. And what would that do to the profitability of the others? To my reading, the article implies that these large farms conspire in their offering, otherwise CostCo could just move their business to the one that was willing to meet there terms. Sort of like McDonald's and their beating potato farmers over the head with demands for the specific variety and size pototato they needed for their fries. (which they could do because their purchases were a significant chunk of the market[1]) So without cooperation from the chicken cartel, or perhaps for other unmentioned reasons, CostCo decides to become an agricultural company too. I'm really wondering if there is some way to disrupt these large agricultural interests effectively. Imagine the Uber for Chicken Farming where an app connects people with extra chicken into a chicken acquisition and slaughtering pipeline for resale. [1] http://www.nbcnews.com/id/32983108/ns/business-us_business/t/mcdonalds-holy-grail-potato-farmers/ http://www.nbcnews.com/id/32983108/ns/business-us_business/t...
- droopyEyelids 8y agoForgive my tangent, but do you have any idea why you like to write it as "CostCo"? I notice it's a common practice on news.y to find (or invent) sub-words in names and capitalize them. Like I remember everyone writing "GroupOn" for the portmanteau of "group coupon" It's puzzling to me and I want to understand where you're coming from!
- hodder 8y agoIt is a variable naming convention known as "CapWords" or "upper CamelCase". This is the recommended naming convention for Python class's https://legacy.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0008/#naming-conventions https://legacy.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0008/#naming-conventi...
- mark-r 8y agoFor an article about chickens, there sure wasn't a lot of meat in it.
- dbg31415 8y agoLook, it's Costco. Not Walmart. Costco has higher standards than just about any other retailer I can think of. * Costco tightens standards for antibiotics use by meat producers | The Seattle Times || https://www.seattletimes.com/business/agriculture/costco-tightens-standards-for-antibiotics-use-by-meat-producers/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/agriculture/costco-tig... I suspect this move to own their own production is because they couldn't get the quality they expect, at prices they expect, at scale from the current suppliers. * Animal Welfare | Costco || https://www.costco.com/sustainability-animal-welfare.html https://www.costco.com/sustainability-animal-welfare.html
- setgree 8y agoThis is kind of a nitpick, but I wish articles like this specified somehow that Costco buys _dead_ chickens, and dismembered to boot. I know everybody reading it knows that, but I don't like euphemisms/language games that divorce consumers from the choice to eat an animal that was killed for you.
- smsm42 8y agoAnybody who knows what Costco is knows what these chickens are for - for eating. What else could they be for - recreating all Hollywood movies with all-chicken cast? I thing demanding that media would push anti-meat propaganda into every article mentioning animal-derived food is a bit too far. I mean, you have the right to your opinions and your consumer behavior, but nobody is obliged to share them and propagandize them for you.
- goda90 8y agoI'm not seeing any euphemisms or language games. In English, chicken both means the animal and the meat, so there is no game in calling dead chickens just chickens.
- loco5niner 8y agoNo language games. It's clear that the chickens will be killed and eaten. There is nothing wrong with killing and eating chickens as long as its done in a responsible manner.
- mx24 8y agoResponsible or sustainable animal agriculture is a pipe dream at this point. With 7+ billion people on a planet facing environmental destruction it’s irresponsible to advocate for the consumption of meat.
- loco5niner 8y agoCostco is quite responsible. I think the fact that they are opening a giant chicken farm is a good indication that it is not a pipe dream.
- devonkim 8y agoCostco is on a supply chain shakedown it seems because they’re also making an eyewear factory for similar business reasons as with chicken. Being in Georgia I see some of these chicken trucks full of live and dead chickens and while they’re pretty dumb and dirty birds there’s no question that the birds in the system are suffering terribly. On top of that is the human suffering of the farmers that raise them in the kind of financial conditions they’re subjected to. I’m fine paying substantially more for better treated chicken but the issue is that I have few guarantees that this is happening when I choose some labels over another given how convoluted the US agriculture and FDA system is.
- debacle 8y agoThey likely just hit an inflection point where it started making sense to do their own fab.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chrischen 8y agoIt says monopoly byt then lists 3 other competitors. Are they all colluding?
- oblib 8y agoI am surrounded by chicken farms, and the farmers who own and operate them. Almost all of them are family owned farms who sell to Tyson. I can say with confidence that they work hard and are very diligent in maintaining a high standard of quality. It's a false sense of higher morality to claim "ethical reasons" for not buying those chicken. You aren't saving or improving the lives of any chickens when you do that. And those chickens don't have it all that bad. I also raise my own chickens and they have a great life for a chicken but it's not idyllic. Chickens have always been low on the food chain and here where I live there are a lot of chicken eaters that are not human. As for safe and organic feed, we all want that, even my neighbors who are chicken farmers. Right now that's still easier said than done. Costco's move may help lead/push us that direction and I commend them for leading on this issue.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> It's a false sense of higher morality to claim "ethical reasons" for not buying those chicken. You aren't saving or improving the lives of any chickens when you do that. Consumer pressure has made a variety of improvements in animal welfare, and is likely to continue to do so.
- hyperbovine 8y agoI don't understand why this comment is being downvoted. This is undeniably true. Heck, the industry itself freely admits this. E.g.: https://www.beefmagazine.com/beef-quality/consumers-not-science-are-driving-demand-antibiotic-free-meat https://www.beefmagazine.com/beef-quality/consumers-not-scie... https://www.unileverusa.com/news/press-releases/2017/hellmanns-mayonnaise-and-dressings-now-use-100-percent-cage-free-eggs.html https://www.unileverusa.com/news/press-releases/2017/hellman...
- specialist 8y ago"It's a false sense of higher morality to claim "ethical reasons" for not buying those chicken." Who are you (bunny ear) quoting? Costco's investment is to get better pricing.
- jMyles 8y ago
- aristophenes 8y agoThis is really confusing. When the top 5 companies control 2/3 the market, how is that a monopoly? The biggest company is less than 25%. Anyway, the fact that I can walk into a store (not just Costco, I do this elsewhere) and buy a fully prepared, seasoned, cooked, ready-to-eat, warm, entire chicken for 5 US dollars blows my mind. We don't understand how good we have it. Most of us here on HN can exchange the money we get for less than 10 minutes of work for the aforementioned culinary delight. We're not talking about a bowl of porridge here, this is protein-packed meat. I've been around the world. Everyone (who eats meat at all) loves chicken. We live in paradise. I can understand ethical and environmental concerns, but we have to be doing something right here.
- antisthenes 8y agoAgreed, rotisserie chicken is the 8th wonder of the world. Nice nickname, btw.
- bg0 8y agoJust moved to Montreal from the US. Was astounded that chicken price per pound is 5x the price it is back home.
- immichaelwang 8y agoDoes anyone have recommendations on good documentaries in this space?
- mistrial9 8y agoI recall seeing the "giant chicken vacuum" in a documentary once..that was a new low for me.. it is 10 or 12 feet high, but somewhat like a vacuum with a big bag for the birds, and a pole sweeps across a measured, enclosed area such that none of the birds escape.. what comes next is also in that movie.. mercifully I do not recall the name..
- sky_rw 8y agoNetflix documentary mini-series Rotten has a really great episode on this.
- tokyodude 8y agoYou can eat raw chicken at many if not most izakaya (Japanese tapas) in Japan. Tastes great!! No idea if that means Japanese chicken production is safer or if it's just their food culture is more risky like France's