16 ms·
Hurray! This is stupendous! I wish other CC brands follow the lead here in slaying this nefarious anti-pattern. There are so many services which require _you_
by mc32 8y ago
Hurray! This is stupendous! I wish other CC brands follow the lead here in slaying this nefarious anti-pattern. There are so many services which require _you_ to actively go and cancel when all you wanted was to trial something, but they required you to commit a CC knowing there'd be a large percentage of people who forget to cancel.
Thank you MC for raising the bar for other CC brands.
- petilon 8y agoA good example is SiriusXM. They give you a lowball initial offer, and the fine print says that at the end of the offer period the subscription will automatically renew at "then current" rates. To cancel you have to call their 800 number (which of course will put you on hold long enough to make you give up.) MasterCard is making an awesome first step here. The next step is to insist that companies must let you cancel subscriptions online, just like this California law: https://www.cnet.com/news/companies-must-let-customers-cancel-subscriptions-online-california-law-says/ https://www.cnet.com/news/companies-must-let-customers-cance...
- hackits 8y agoReason why I just using a 3rd party between the business and my credit card. Have no problem with a 3rd party taking a cut but standardizing the whole process through a single interface to cancel subscriptions services without needing to go through all the crap.
- ekanes 8y agoSounds pretty cool - what service do you use?
- jacob019 8y agoprivacy.com works well for this sort of thing
- ekianjo 8y agoAnything for non-US residents?
- petilon 8y agoCitibank, BofA and others let you create virtual credit card numbers off of your actual credit card. These numbers can only be used by one merchant, and you can specify the max amount they are able to charge, as well as how many months the number is valid. You can delete your virtual number any time. What does privacy.com have that is better? https://www.cardbenefits.citi.com/Products/Virtual-Account-Numbers https://www.cardbenefits.citi.com/Products/Virtual-Account-N... https://www.bankofamerica.com/privacy/accounts-cards/shopsafe.go https://www.bankofamerica.com/privacy/accounts-cards/shopsaf...
- jacob019 8y agosounds the same, works with any bank account
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoI’ve started stopping charges from my card rather than dealing with that kind of “customer service” ever again. When the company finds they literally can’t charge you, suddenly they have the time to call you. If you’ve tried to cancel a service, stopped using it, and stop payment... well, the rest is their problem.
- ekianjo 8y agoHow do you stop individual payments? Is that something that you get as a service? Because in my (limited) experience in different countries I don't think I can do that.
- gizmo686 8y agoMy bank (Bank of America) lets you create temporary credit card numbers. They are linked directly to your actual card, but can be revoked individually.
- codetrotter 8y agoI wish my bank offered that as well but another option offered in some countries including mine is to buy a prepaid MasterCard gift card. Now such gift cards aren’t perfect — you have to pay a bit extra, but for the purpose of signing up for a trial period with any company that automatically turns your trial into a subscription and which is known to make it difficult to cancel the trial it might be a good idea. However, before even signing up for a trial with a prepaid gift card one needs to be sure that one is not entering into an agreement that legally binds you to a subscription. I recently bought a prepaid gift card that I intend to use for a 7-day trial with a company that is known to make it difficult to cancel. But I will only sign up for the trial if the automatic subscription is not legally binding.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y ago> However, before even signing up for a trial with a prepaid gift card one needs to be sure that one is not entering into an agreement that legally binds you to a subscription. This gets to the heart of the matter: it shouldn’t be possible to sign up for a legally binding automatic subscription for a pure service. Customers should have the liberty to leave at any time without incurring a fee. If I can sign up in under a minute I ought to be able to leave in under a minute.
- ekianjo 8y ago> must let you cancel subscriptions online When I had a Xbox I remember that it was SUPER easy to register for Xbox Live Gold (online, done in a few mins, right from the console itself!), but then when you wanted to cancel... there was no menu anywhere. You had to go to the website, find an obscure page with a phone number you had to call, and spend 10 mins on the line with a representative to cancel your subscription. Needless to say, that was the last time ever Microsoft got my money with the Xbox.
- xnyan 8y agoThe only way to get around this (in the united states) was to set your address to Chicago. I assume some local statute required this.
- briandear 8y agoCalifornia requires this now as well: if you sign up online, you have to be able to cancel online.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoYou could always cancel online Setting your address to Illinois allowed to turn off auto-renew, which was not possible to do online otherwise.
- Semaphor 8y agoIn Germany, everything has to have the option to cancel in the same way you signed up. So if you sign up online, you will be able to cancel online.
- peeters 8y agoThat's such a sane, common-sense law. If a company has the resource to allow online payment processing, they sure as hell have the resources to allow online cancelling. So the only reason they wouldn't have it is to make it hard for you to cancel.
- tyfon 8y agoI think this is common all over Europe. You also have the "right to regret" so within 14 days of buying stuff online you can cancel and refund it no questions asked by law. In fact, in my country there is also a requirement that the companies send you a information about this right and forms you can fill out to complete the request with the order confirmation.
- Silhouette 8y agoYou also have the "right to regret" so within 14 days of buying stuff online you can cancel and refund it no questions asked by law. Although this comes with some caveats. The consumer protection rules for distance selling are very strict in the EU, but if you're buying something like digital content, it's obviously not reasonable to say someone can pay today but can't then be provided with what they've just paid for for 14 days just in case they decide to cancel. The law does provide for giving up those cancellation rights and getting the content immediately, as long as it's clearly stated at the time of purchase that this is what you're doing.
- tyfon 8y agoYes, if you buy digital and download the content you can't refund, but that's about the only way you can "give up" the right i think?
- xfitm3 8y agoSiriusXM TOS says you are still liable for the charges in this case. It will be sent to collections.
- dawnerd 8y agoThey won’t send to collections, not worth their time or money. It’s just a scare tactic. I blocked payments on them, no collections. Although they do still spam me with come back offers.
- smsm42 8y agoI've been using SiruisXM for years, and they have been more than happy to continue their lower initial price - or one very close to it - indefinitely, provided you call them once a year and threaten to cancel right here, right now. Why on earth they insist on this game instead of just giving me the price they and I both are happy to agree on is anybody's guess, nevertheless this is the case. I guess a lot of people give up and pay the higher price? Never had a problem with their service reps though. Answer times were reasonable and as long as you make it clear you'll really cancel if you'd not get a reasonable price, it didn't take a lot of time overall.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Why on earth they insist on this game instead of just giving me the price they and I both are happy to agree on is anybody's guess, nevertheless this is the case. Because you're not an individual customer to them. They look at customers as if they were a liquid, so they don't bother with individual liquid molecules. If the customers want to flow up, but they want them to flow left, they'll insert some stupid block in the flow path. It doesn't matter the liquid will splash, and some individual molecules will get lost. As long as most of the customers flow in the direction they need, that's all they care about.
- moduspol 8y agoEveryone in my family has been doing this for years. I even tried just asking the first person if there are any promos available, to try and skip the song and dance. But they said no. "OK, then I need to cancel." And you're sent over to someone who can get you back down to your prior rate. I always tell them that $5/mo per radio is the most I can justify paying, and it always works. Then set a reminder to call them again in a few months. Often they'll tell you directly to call back before the promo expires so they can ensure you get back on one. My next reminder is for February 15.
- sgustard 8y agoTivo, a California company: "We currently don’t offer the ability to cancel service online." https://www.tivo.com/my-account/cancel https://www.tivo.com/my-account/cancel They deserve a public and vocal PR backlash over this.
- sl1ck731 8y agoThe worst is newspapers. 3rd parties bundle a bunch of them and you have to be sure you cancel all of them. You call and they will fight you about it and actively try their hardest to "lock you in for another 3 months at only x/mo."
- kop316 8y agoMy fiancée got a new car that included SiriusXM and she activated the free trial. Sirius called the car via onstar to give her a sale pitch and try and get he to activate XM radio. When it happened while I was in the car, she said that was the third time they did that.
- LoSboccacc 8y ago> they required you to commit a CC it's not always that type of scam. services that feature some kind of content upload or distribution ask for cc also to have some sort of hard-verified identity, to prevent service abuse.
- Markoff 8y agoit's not CC brand though, that's like saying Toyota it's electric car brand I've had plenty of Visa and MasterCard cards and never had credit card
- odiroot 8y agoThis would literally kill a few businesses here in Germany that rely exactly on that dark pattern.
- Kliment 8y agoAnd may they rot in hell.
- pille 8y agoUnfortunately I think the German bad actors would continue with their business as usual. German companies like this prefer to treat recurring billing to a cancelled credit card as a delinquent account. They'll keep the service 'active' nominally, but refer payment to a collections agency ("Inkasso"), who will then send bills, threatening letters from lawyers, and bills for the threatening letters from lawyers. Worst of all, it seems like German law is a-ok with this practice.
- denzil_correa 8y agoThis is one thing which is quite ridiculous in Germany for all contracts - phone, Internet, electricity, gas etc. Once, I had a bike sharing company which charged me 3€ the next year after I forgot to cancel it the year previous. They sent me an e-mail saying "intimation is not needed". I told them, they sent me 100s of marketing e-mails which wasn't needed too. Couldn't they send one reminder before they continued the charge? They just didn't get it! Admittedly, 3€ was not a big amount but the business practice was purely unethical.
- Scea91 8y agoSame experience with German gym memberships. My 2 year contract will automatically renew in August if I do not cancel it 30 days in advance.
- tremon 8y agoYup. Same thing with Blendle: the advertised "free trial" actually costs 1 cent for two weeks, and by confirming that payment you automatically commit to a paid subscription following those first two weeks. Needless to say, I didn't pay for the free trial. It's a shame, because I think their business model is the right way forward. But I will not support such practices.
- reitanqild 8y agoHave Blendle changed business model? I thought with Blendle you paid for reads, not for days/weeks/months? Cannot recall having seen any charges for Blendle since last time I used it.
- sascha_sl 8y agoThe worst offenders cancel the trial period as soon as you take away payment. Looking at you, Pluralsight.
- mobilemidget 8y agoAnd the million of adult sites will change their billing schemes too
- Silhouette 8y agoI don't see why that is so offensive. Businesses aren't offering these trials out of charity, they're doing it to give you a chance to see if you want to become their customer, as a form of marketing. If you've clearly demonstrated that you have no intention of continuing to that point in the relationship, why should they have any obligation to continue giving you stuff for free anyway?
- m45t3r 8y agoI always cancel the subscription after entering in those trials, because if I don't like the service I will forget about this service and probably will be billed at the end of the next month, generating a nunnecessary headache. If I like the service and want to continue to use it after the trial period, I simply re-added my billing information. Cancelling the trial if I remove my billing information during it is unfair because it is just another mechanism to make consumers forget about the service and being billed by a service they don't even use.
- Silhouette 8y agoYou seem to be arguing that you've started a trial because you're genuinely interested, you're aware enough of the trial to remove your billing information, yet stopping the service when you do so is unfair because you might forget and then be billed for a service you're not using. If you're not using it, why is it a problem for you to have the service stopped when you remove the billing information?
- kevindong 8y agoThe worst company I've ever had to deal with regarding cancelling a trial is the Wall Street Journal and all of the sub brands it owns. In order to cancel, you HAVE TO call in and sit through an aggressive sales pitch.
- grok2 8y agoNot so fast! The press release is sort of ambiguous. It sort of seems like they only added an additional rule for the merchant to send an email or text with instructions on how to cancel before billing. To me it seems like the first of their statement announces what they've done and the 2nd part tells how they've done it -- with an email to cancel. It's not clear that the same email will require the user to click confirming the charge. "The rule change will require merchants to gain cardholder approval at the conclusion of the trial before they start billing. To help cardholders with that decision, merchants will be required to send the cardholder – either by email or text – the transaction amount, payment date, merchant name along with explicit instructions on how to cancel a trial."