7 ms·
At this point I think I'm too afraid to ever go to China. You can't get justice there, and you can be swept up into some stupid diplomatic spat. Don't they re
by CydeWeys 8y ago
At this point I think I'm too afraid to ever go to China. You can't get justice there, and you can be swept up into some stupid diplomatic spat.
Don't they realize how short-sighted this is? This is incredibly harmful to tourism.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 8y agoHe was already a convicted drug trafficker. I don’t see any indication that his original 15-year sentence was improper. It is possible that he was falsely convicted, of course, but I don’t know that this is more likely in China than elsewhere. Suddenly changing his sentence to death is rather suspicious, but at least for me it doesn’t make a huge difference compared to a 15-year sentence. Random anecdote: I just got back to the US from several weeks in China. By far the most uncomfortable and worrying law-enforcement interaction of the trip was going through US immigration control on the way back.
- fermienrico 8y agoI’ve always had a pleasant experience returning home. I travel 200 days in a year and never have I had a bad experience during US Immigration. In fact, I look forward to “Welcome home” from an officer although now it’s more expedited with the automated passport control and they hardly take more than 20 seconds to let you go. I am curious of your bad experience, can you tell us more? Edit: I do not look like a typical US Citizen. Edit: Tangentially, I have also had great experience with American police. I’ve been pulled over a few times and the officers always have a calm demeanor with utmost level of professionalism. The narrative of US authorities mishaving happens in headline cases, not to vast number of people.
- Insanity 8y agoMaybe it is different when you don't _look_ like you're a US citizen.
- fermienrico 8y agoI look very close to an Arab person than I look like a typical US Citizen. My friends joke if I should get rid of my facial hair for the expediency of immigration. I’ve always been treated well and this goes for vast number of Americans and Foreigners that enter US.
- magduf 8y agoArab people look very close to "white" people, and even more so these days since almost all American men have decided to wear giant, fuzzy beards.
- maccio92 8y agoHow does a US citizen _look_? Last I checked we were an incredibly diverse nation.
- Insanity 8y agoWell, I meant what they think a US citizen would look like. For example, if you look Asian, you might still be a US citizen but more likely they'd treat you differently. I'm saying this as someone who is married to a Mexican and crosses the US border by car. In general the experiences have been good by the way - just not all the time. I'm just saying that it could be influenced by the way you look.
- askmike 8y ago(not big in American ethnicity but) I think his point is that "looking like a US citizen" is basically either being European, native American or African American. Which I guess is kind of like everyone except for people who look like Asian, South American or from the Middle East.
- mikeash 8y agoWeird. I have never had a pleasant experience with US customs. They are usually not unpleasant either, but they’re never friendly or even more than vaguely polite. (I say “usually” because my wife was once told off quite rudely when she went through the visitors line as a permanent resident, because she wanted to help and translate for visiting family members she was with.) The worst part of the experience is knowing they will not hesitate to fuck me over if they decide they want to, and I have little recourse. They can’t keep me out of the country, but they can screw me up for hours or days if they want. They can keep my wife out of the country arbitrarily, and the only fix there would be a lengthy and expensive legal process with no guarantee of success. It’s minor compared to the hypothetical example of being imprisoned or executed on false drug charges, but my point isn’t that US immigration isn’t equivalently bad, but that I felt and experienced no menace whatsoever from Chinese law enforcement.
- foldr 8y agoI've been through many times as white British person (both as a visitor and on various visas) and have never had a bad experience. I'm not denying that people do have bad experiences. But I find it kind of hard to believe that as a US citizen, you've never once had an experience of re-entering the country that didn't involve the customs agent asking you a couple of simple questions and then sending you on your way.
- mikeash 8y agoThat is exactly what the experience is most of the time. It’s unpleasant because they’re not nice and they have way too much power, but it’s not a big deal. Again, my point is not that it’s completely awful, but rather that this minor unpleasantness still manages to be the worst thing on these trips.
- foldr 8y agoI guess I don't understand what level of "niceness" you're expecting. Most of the time they've been friendly and polite (to me). Given that they're humans doing a basically crappy job, I don't expect any more than that.
- desireco42 8y agoYou are uniquely lucky person and probably by other responses you can see how rare is experience like yours. While I never had huge problems on the border, it is always unpleasant experience and what they can do to you is so overproportional to things you can be seen at fault. My mother in law sneaked an orange in our suitcase, for the kids. I was charged $150 or $300(not sure anymore) for it and put on some list. The best. experience is when you can pass without any interaction. Rarely I see it as welcome home, even though I am eager go and happy to be, home. God help you if you are from Syria, Iran or any other country like that. Even Israelis because they 'look arab' often have issues.
- mikeash 8y agoRight, they’re usually not outright bad, but they’re certainly not welcoming. To put it in perspective, I’d much rather go to the DMV than go through American immigration controls, and the DMV workers are way nicer.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI would rather go through American immigration controls than to wait for anything at ICBC (a state owned bank in China). There goes an entire afternoon of pure misery.
- abbe_k 8y agoYou don't think there is a big difference between 15 years in prison and the death penalty? You still have a lot of time left in life after 15 years so it is major difference.
- mikeash 8y agoNot really. In terms of “this has completely ruined my life,” 15 years in a Chinese prison would rate about 9.8 out of 10 for me, while death is 10 out of 10. In terms of balancing the benefits of travel versus the risk of law enforcement misconduct, that additional 0.2 out of 10 makes no noticeable difference.
- Erlich_Bachman 8y agoThat is a very uncommon opinion.
- mikeash 8y agoIs it really? It seems pretty widely accepted that the death penalty doesn’t deter crime, for example, which indicates that people (well, potential criminals, anyway) don’t see it as substantially worse than a lengthy prison term.
- adventured 8y agoIt's a fascinating point that the pro death penalty crowd universally ignores. US violent crime has plunged over the last 40 years, and the murder rate has been chopped in half since 1980, all the while death sentences have declined to ~45-50 year lows (there has been roughly a 90% reduction in new death sentences since 1999). The dramatic plunge in new death sentences over two decades hasn't coincided with any uptick in the murder rate or violent crime.
- magduf 8y agoThe people who commit heinous crimes usually have psychological problems that cause them to have very low impulse control. They don't think their actions through very well, which is why they're in their position instead of some better and more legal lifestyle/career. So harsher punishments really don't deter them; they don't expect to get caught and aren't thinking about that when they commit the crime. There's a theory that violent crime has plunged over the last 40 years because of leaded gasoline being phased out: the lead was in the air and environment and giving everyone low-level lead poisoning.
- gpm 8y agoHe was a convicted drug dealer, that's little comfort when other people like the random teacher [0] and entrepreneur [1] they arrested were not. [0] https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/china-sarah-mciver-detained-1.4953711 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/china-sarah-mciver-detained... [1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadian-officials-meet-with-detainee-michael-spavor-in-china-1.4969817 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadian-officials-meet-wit...
- mikeash 8y agoThat random teacher had some visa problem and was quickly deported. That’s totally normal in most countries. The entrepreneur is a high profile person playing a very political game with business in North Korea. It does sound like his arrest was unjust, but it doesn’t indicate anything for regular folks like me. His story just reinforces my policy of “stay the fuck away from North Korea.”
- yorwba 8y agoAccording to your link, the teacher was employed illegally. It's common for students and other people without work permits to be offered positions as English teachers where the only requirement is being born in North America. The employers usually gloss over the illegality or claim that the laws are not enforced. That's been true in the past, but as that teacher had to learn, it can change anytime. So my generalized advice is to comply with the law instead of relying on lack of enforcement. They can still get you for "national security" reasons, but it's much less likely if you aren't a big fish.
- learc83 8y ago>So my generalized advice is to comply with the law In a country where millions of people are held in reeducation camps for practicing the wrong religion, the "law" as written is a joke. From friends living their, it's impossible to actually strictly follow what's on the books, particularly for foreigners. You have to know the current expectations, what's being enforced by the local government etc... What matters isn't what's written, it's what is currently being practiced.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 3pt14159 8y agoEither China is doing this so they can have something to retreat on that seems gracious and careful (i.e., it's a complete ploy) or they're completely misreading Canadian sentiment. Canadians tend to give and give and bend and bend, but it really comes to it they snap in a way that I don't think the Chinese understand. We have way more leverage over China than they have over us. We sell them commodities. They sell us electronics. You know what's the one good thing about commodity sales? Fungibility. If we start banning Chinese phones we'll buy American ones come in instead. If they ban Canadian grain it will be less efficient, but the world will shift around and that grain will be sold to someone. If they ban our wood, it will be less efficient, but we can make our own furniture or sell wood to Europe to replace the wood China is buying from elsewhere. And if push every really came to shove there is a lot of Chinese owned property in Canada. Foreign ownership taxes can go way, way up. It's a complete misread of the situation by them. We have extradition treaties with the USA. Our society runs via a rule of law. They're going to turn the entire Canadian business and political community against them if they keep this up. Take it up with the Americans for fucks sake. Even Maxime Bernier has walked back his pledge for a Chinese-Canadian trade agreement.
- simonh 8y agoThis almost certainly has nothing to do with changing Canadian behavior, it's about domestic politics. Canada/USA kicked one of ours, so we're going to kick 20 of theirs. They need to be seen to be doing it. The fact that it won't work and is counterproductive doesn't matter.
- ardy42 8y ago> This almost certainly has nothing to do with changing Canadian behavior, it's about domestic politics. Canada/USA kicked one of ours, so we're going to kick 20 of theirs. They need to be seen to be doing it. The fact that it won't work and is counterproductive doesn't matter. Is CCTV or other state-run outlets making a big deal about this death sentence and the other Canadian arrests? Is it portraying them as retaliation?
- 8y ago
- jopsen 8y ago> Random anecdote: I just got back to the US from several weeks in China. I'm sure most people will be fine visiting China, but personally I like rule-of-law :) No justice system is perfect. Coming from Denmark, I'm not impressed by the US justice system. But if you hire a lawyer your odds of a fair trial is decent. But in China there is no assumption of regularity, or assumption of good faith. If someone powerful doesn't like you or wants to send a message -- then I guess you can take solace in the fact that your organs might not go to waste.
- mikeash 8y agoI totally see where you’re coming from and I have no problem with such a decision. It’s not the decision I make, but I wouldn’t try to argue that you’re wrong. My main point isn’t that everyone should go to China worry-free, but rather that a years-old drug conviction being bumped up from a long prison sentence to a death sentence isn’t going to make much difference to the decision. People like you probably wouldn’t go either way, and people like me aren’t going to change their minds because of it.
- j1vms 8y ago> ... at least for me it doesn’t make a huge difference compared to a 15-year sentence. There isn't a huge difference between a death sentence versus 15 years in prison? You're kidding right? Whether the person is in fact guilty or innocent, there is a significant difference between the two sentences, literally the difference between life or death. One irrevocably extinguishes the person's life - there is no going back. The other is a very long incarceration, cutting them off from society for that time, and offering at best a chance for correction.
- mikeash 8y agoThe context of this statement is in deciding whether or not to travel to China. I am having a very hard time coming up with a scenario where the possibility of a 15-year prison sentence has me deciding to go, but the possibility of execution makes me decide to stay home.
- echevil 8y agoThere are precedents that drug trafficker got death sentences, so there’s nothing surprising at all. I guess he got 15 years sentence originally probably because the government didn’t want to hurt their relationship with Canada at their time. Many Chinese find that sentence improper. Chinese laws and the laws in many Asian country regarding drugs are much stricter than those in US
- aiisjustanif 8y ago>Suddenly changing his sentence to death is rather suspicious, but at least for me it doesn’t make a huge difference compared to a 15-year sentence. There's a huge difference, from a human rights stand point for non-violent crimes there is a very noticeable difference.
- mikeash 8y agoOf course. But we’re talking about the potential impact on tourism here.
- advertising 8y agoThis is something that has really irked me the past couple years. I feel safer entering other countries than I do coming back to the U.S. It feels like you’re entering a prison camp going through immigration. Everyone is screened by security before getting on a plane yet passport control officers are wearing swat team bullet proof vests and open-carry guns while checking your passport.
- pupppet 8y ago>Suddenly changing his sentence to death is rather suspicious, but at least for me it doesn’t make a huge difference compared to a 15-year sentence. I'm guessing going from 15 years to death sentence is probably a big difference to him.
- vzq 8y agoThis is only harmful to tourism if you understand "smuggling ecstasy" as "tourism".
- ubercow13 8y agoMultiple popular tourist destination countries execute people for drug offences and it doesn't seem to be that big of an issue.
- roboys 8y agoMost asian countries execute because colonizers were drug dealers. All the famous people we love like Thomas Jefferson's family, the Roosevelt clan, and extensions of the British Royal Family.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoNot white westerners though its like how poor "workers" from other Muslim countries get treated badly compared to western expats on a full ride ticket.
- smcl 8y agoI don't think that tourism is as much of a big deal to China as you think, and additionally I've got a feeling that most potential tourists wouldn't be aware of this news item or could dismiss it as "those people probably did something stupid, it won't apply to me"
- est31 8y agoWhen the protests were in egypt, tourists stopped visiting the country. This had a major impact on the economy. So this kind of stuff can definitely have an impact. The situation in China is different though. Egypts economy is very dependent on tourism, while China's isn't. On the other hand, country wide protests with anarchy are a different thing from a government killing one individual in some shitty trade war.
- Blaiz0r 8y agoMost tourism in China probably comes from within China.
- Double_a_92 8y ago> "those people probably did something stupid, it won't apply to me" To be fair, he did attempt to smuggle "methamphetamines to Australia in pellets stuffed inside tires". It's not like they picked some random foreigner and accused him of something.
- yumraj 8y agoBut this doesn't apply to just tourists, this applies to all foreign visitors including the business people who drive Chinese economy. If the business people start avoiding China, there impact on it's already slowing economy would be devastating.
- learc83 8y agoFrom what I've heard, in the last few years, China has become much more hostile towards foreigners living in China, and the government has significantly turned up the anti-foreigner rhetoric.
- roboys 8y agoIf you don't take drugs there you have nothing to worry about. Reminds me of all the people complaining about Singapore's tough laws when they punish American vandals and execute druggies. Don't break the law, drugs are not a joke in Asia (especially true since western governments proved they were/are not above using drugs as an economic attack vector).
- alimbada 8y agoFor a bit of perspective: on the other hand, as a brown Muslim man I won't be going to the US any time soon. Also won't be going to China either due to their current genocide of the Uyghurs.
- bauhw 8y ago99% of the tourism in China is domestic. Foreigner shouldn't have white cards on the law because of tourism, that's arrogant and unhealthy. I was afraid of China because of these random news. But when I finally went there in September, I was surprised as all the internet fear mongering was wrong. When you read your local newspaper and see a murder, are you afraid to go out ? No because it's an outlier, as is the case above. I went alone for 1 month in China and felt much safer than in France. But if you plan to go to China to play the game of law for money, then except to lose big. That's why the country feel safe, the risks are huge, that means dissuasion. Avoid political talk and don't be arrogant = 0 issues there.
- curiouserrr 8y agoIt’s interesting how new accounts get created to defend China every time a negative piece about China shows up.
- jimclegg 8y agoTrue. I signed up because US audiences though intelligent don't always have a good grasp on international historical context. A lot of wars can be avoided when this education gap is filled.
- dpratt 8y agoYour account is three minutes old and this is your first (and only) comment. Additionally, your grammar indicates that you’re not a native English speaker. I’m not typically a tinfoil hat type of person, but I, at least, have a heavy amount of skepticism towards your comment. Bluntly, it reads like it was taken directly from some pre-approved list of PRC propaganda.
- yukonbound 8y agoI don’t know. His english mistakes are very plausible just typical French grammar mistakes and his viewpoint is not incorrect and in fact most likely true for the overwhelming majority of visitors. Perhaps the tin foil is sitting a bit tightly...
- ngokevin 8y agoAs long as you're not an organized drug trafficker. Also our media is susceptible to surfacing up anti-China pieces so it'll skew perceptions. I think it could be healthy to visit to get a different perspective other than "that evil brainwashed country on the other side" that I feel is very pervasive. It's an interesting place to visit if you feel like you want to go to a different planet. Though the fact people are now getting scared to even visit makes it feel like the Third Red Scare.
- CydeWeys 8y agoYou don't need to be a drug smuggler to be held as a political hostage there. Look at the other links in this thread of other people being snatched as hostages for far less. In a country without rule of law it's trivial to fabricate some excuse to grab someone if you want to. Your only recourse is to not go there at all, as whether you get snatched if you are there is outside your control. "Don't smuggle drugs" isn't sufficient.
- sverige 8y agoEspecially in a country that is currently holding hundreds of thousands or maybe millions of its own citizens as political hostages. You don't have to be a foreigner to be subject to capricious arrest and imprisonment in China.
- korvighua 8y agoRelated links: Thirteen Canadians have been detained in China since Huawei executive’s arrest, says Ottawa https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-thirteen-canadians-detained-in-china-since-huawei-executives-arrest/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-thirteen-ca... China says detained Canadian Michael Kovrig doesn't have diplomatic immunity https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/china-says-detained-canadian-michael-kovrig-doesn-t-have-diplomatic-immunity-1.4976894 https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/china-says-detained-canadian-m... You shouldn't be going to a country where they don't even respect diplomatic immunity
- AnaniasAnanas 8y agoI don't really understand how diplomatic immunity is relevant here. It's not like it is going to protect you if you are not a diplomat. Plus, if I am not mistaken Michael Kovrig is not a diplomat so saying that china does not respect diplomatic immunity seems baseless.
- bloopbloop 8y agoTravelling to a country in a private capacity, with a private passport does not grant diplomatic immunity.
- sharpneli 8y agohttp://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/conventions/9_1_1961.pdf http://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/convention... "A “diplomatic agent” is the head of the mission or a member of the diplomatic staff of the mission;" "1.A diplomatic agent shall enjoy immunity from the criminal jurisdiction of the receiving State. He shall also enjoy immunity from its civil and administrative jurisdiction, except in the case of:"... Michael Kovrig was not part of a diplomatic mission to China by Canada. Therefore he is not a diplomatic agent. This is a clear cut case. Ex-diplomats with private passports are not entitled to diplomatic immunity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- glasslion 8y agoGuess how many Canadians are detained in US right now? 90k
- mikejb 8y agoNews we get about China is heavily biased, and it taints our perspective. There's people who won't travel to the US because they hear daily news of someone getting shot there, and I think that's on a similar position on the reasonable/ridiculous scale.
- finnjohnsen2 8y agoA good point.
- perfmode 8y agoShit like this happens right here at home, when you’re a black man.
- factsaresacred 8y agoDeng Xiaoping, the Chinese leader who led China's market reform, had a saying along the lines of “hide your strength and bide your time”. Xi Jinping appears to believe China's time has come and you're seeing the results: they're behaving like the authoritarian and petulant bullies that they've always been. Personally I think this behaviour is gift. For too long we've been fed the narrative of China's 'peaceful rise' by people happy to make a quick buck from its gigantic market. Now we're seeing China's true colors. In the decades to come, making China a superpower will be looked upon as one of the most foolish things The West has ever done.
- jopsen 8y ago> In the decades to come, making China a superpower will be looked upon as one of the most foolish things The West has ever done. This assumes this is something the west did. Or that this is something the west should have prevented. By trading with China the west certainly accelerated growth. But let's be clear hundreds of millions of people have been pulled up from extreme poverty -- overall I think that's a good thing.
- factsaresacred 8y agoTrue, China's rise has been beneficial for hundreds of millions - it's pretty much a miracle and China deserves a lot of credit. I just believe that all those that called the USA a reckless superpower ain't seen nothing yet.
- mengxue0 8y agoRen Zhengfei’s first wife was Meng Jun (the mother of Meng wan Zhou), the daughter of the former Sichuan Provincial Vice Governor Meng Dongbo. Meng Dongpo served as deputy secretary general of the East China Military and Political Committee. Director of the Infrastructure Department of the Ministry of Metallurgy, Director of the Metallurgical Industry Department of Sichuan Province, Director of the Provincial Economic Commission, Secretary of the CPC Dukou Municipal Committee, deputy governor of Sichuan Province,etc
- Cypher 8y agoyou can't get justice in the west either that's why Snowden went to Russia..
- CydeWeys 8y agoBut don't kid yourself, on the whole, as far as justice is concerned, Russia is way worse than the west. They routinely lock up and assassinate people who criticize them, and they're currently conducting a war of hysteria against homosexuals within their own borders.
- chrisper 8y agoIt can happen in the US as well. All the cops have to do is put some drugs in your car while searching it.
- jopsen 8y agoThis very rarely happens at the direction of senior members of the government. No system is perfect, but in the US we can generally assume the government to be bound by law.
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agoIt's hard to travel anywhere these days. But the US "justice" system is not any better (just more hypocritical - at least China doesn't pretend to follow human rights). Pissing off the US is generally a bad idea due to all the extradition agreements in place. Take for example cyber crime: Guys like MalwareTech are being made an example of. A country that imprisons people just because being poor and runs it's prisons as capitalist corporations, not to mention champions black sites to torture others shouldn't have an extradition agreement with anyone. The US partners in Europe are as bad. I'm not suggesting the US is alone with this but us Westerners should be careful with pointing fingers at China, (or Russia) and claim that we have any right to lecture them on human rights issues or our superior legal system. Not in the age of Trump, Bannon, Farage, May, Kurz, Orban, Seehofer, and all other fascists in power today.