21 ms·
Fundamental rule of traffic: building new roads makes people drive more (2015)
- StillBored 8y agoSuch a blanket statement. Its about _where_ you build the roads. If you build big roads leading out of the city, then of course people move out and drive more. There are other choices.
- paulsutter 8y agoIt's called "elastic demand" and it just means that roads are useful. The Boring Company has a twofold solution (a) charge for usage, and (b) build to 30 levels or more to meet demand
- fabioborellini 8y agoIn the Old World we have public mass transit. One vehicle can transport a thousand commuters, and it does not need to be stored in the most desired area of the city for the duration of a working day. Sometimes it looks like the Silicon Valley is trying to solve transit problems either against the laws of physics and economics or, alternatively, ignoring solutions that were there already in the 1800s.
- fgheorghe 8y agoIn the “old world” cities like London, Paris, Berlin and others are facing the eact same problems, with or without those overcrowded, overpriced buses you mentioned.
- lmm 8y agoI live in London. Many people don't own cars. Many who moved here with a car give up their cars. Working public transport systems leave everyone better off.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoPublic transport in London is incredibly good, I'm always amazed. But then it's NOT run by 5 competing companies that couldn't care less about linked up journeys.
- twblalock 8y agoOn the other hand, transit in Tokyo and Osaka is run by a number of public and private companies, some of which compete with each other, and linked-up journeys are no problem at all. It's totally doable.
- lmm 8y agoJapanese companies do not have much of a reputation for red-in-tooth-and-claw competition (e.g. the "gentleman's agreement" about advertised car horsepower).
- icelancer 8y agoYour cities are built for mass transit. Ours are not, owing to the enormous landmass we utilize in the ways that we do. This is not a simple problem to solve by just adding more trains and bus units.
- fridek 8y agoI live in London and commute 10 miles each way daily. It takes me ~45 minutes in rush hour. Driving the same distance is, in the middle of the night, 30-40 min (in rush hour you can be stuck simply until it's over). Total cost is also lower at 2000 pounds a year for round trips on my route (which would cover only insurance and gas at best). Also, I haven't taken a bus to work, ever. Tube serves 5 million passengers a day and whilst sometimes crowded, seems to be scaling pretty well.
- awakeasleep 8y agoMusk is trying to solve the transit problem of people making over 200k a year- Maintain the standard of absolute luxury and privacy provided by the car, while reducing the concentration required to drive and the time it takes to be stuck in traffic.
- erik_seaberg 8y agoSometimes I wonder how buses with private compartments would be received, compared to today's cattle cars.
- twblalock 8y ago> Sometimes it looks like the Silicon Valley is trying to solve transit problems either against the laws of physics and economics or, alternatively, ignoring solutions that were there already in the 1800s. The problem is that many American cities, including those in Silicon Valley, would need to be torn down and rebuilt for European- or Japanese-style transit to make sense. Everything is very spread out. Most people in London or Paris or Tokyo live within a short walking distance of a train station. In cities like LA, many people could walk over a mile from their house and only see other houses. Because everything is so spread out, we would require many stations in suburban residential neighborhoods or nobody would have a station within walking distance of their home. However, those stations would only be useful to the small number of people who live in those neighborhoods because nobody else would have a reason to go there. It's hard to imagine those stations would get enough ridership to make economic sense. So we are stuck with transit restricted to downtown areas, and if you want to go downtown or leave downtown you need a car. The Boring Company is attempting to recognize that reality and solve the "last mile problem" by turning cars themselves into public transit. It will be pretty cool if it works.
- reaperducer 8y agoIn the Old World we have public mass transit. One vehicle can transport a thousand commuters, and it does not need to be stored in the most desired area of the city for the duration of a working day. If you include London in "the Old World," it has the same horrible freeway congestion problems every other city does. Being European doesn't change the laws of physics.
- belenos46 8y agoLikely the latter, and for that we can largely thank large motorist groups in the US. Michelin comes to mind, as they created their "Michelin star" metric to give people a reason to drive places, and then lobbied like hell to create town/city layouts that mandated driving. A hundred years later, driving is a massive part of US culture, and we have trouble seeing the problem because that's "just how things are".
- twblalock 8y agoThis scheme would not have succeeded if people preferred public transit to driving. Honestly it's not hard to see why it succeeded. Back in the early postwar period, driving was cheap and easy, parking was plentiful, traffic was light, and the new interstate highway system made long-distance car travel practical. Even if the motorist groups had not lobbied for it, cars would have taken over anyway because people liked them so much.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lazyjones 8y ago> Sometimes it looks like the Silicon Valley is trying to solve transit problems either against the laws of physics and economics or, alternatively, ignoring solutions that were there already in the 1800s. That, or the Old World is simply stuck with cities where no more roads can be built without tearing down many inhabited buildings, so people are forced to use smelly, uncomfortable public transport. I'd appreciate more honesty and less ideology in such debates.
- chadcmulligan 8y ago> I'd appreciate more honesty and less ideology in such debates and yet > forced to use smelly, uncomfortable public transport There is no need to public transport to be smelly and uncomfortable if enough money is spent on maintenance.
- lazyjones 8y ago> There is no need to public transport to be smelly and uncomfortable if enough money is spent on maintenance. I live in Vienna, which has arguably some of the best maintained and expensive public transport. It's still smelly, because people. They forbid food (initially only smelly food, but signs - pictograms in the subway - show any/all types of food) recently because people complained and during last summer the administration handed out free deodorants to passengers. Sorry, public transport IS uncomfortable and smelly, like most places with many people.
- chadcmulligan 8y agoI'm in Australia and the public transport is clean here. No food is allowed, and its enforced. There is the occasional smelly person, particularly in summer, unavoidable. In general though it works well.
- lazyjones 8y agoI'd like to see some pictures of the inside of a subway train in the center of Melbourne on 6am on a Saturday... ;-) It's a mentality issue - Singapore and Japan are also famous for clean public transport, but in most countries it's simply not possible.
- imtringued 8y agoThis appears to be a classic case of a visible problem where the effects of the solution are not visible immediately. Building wider roads is a success if they move more people compared to a more narrow road. It doesn't matter if they stay congested even as you widen them. The goal of a wider road isn't to reduce congestion the goal is to move more people. This same type of reasoning is used against constructing more housing because building more housing doesn't have an impact on rent prices while ignoring that every new apartment provides housing for a new person. The goal of more housing isn't to reduce rent prices, it's housing more people!
- pbhjpbhj 8y ago>The goal of more housing isn't to reduce rent prices // A goal of house building is certainly to provide affordable housing. Unfortunately that goal isn't shared by the people with the money/land whose goal is usually just "make as much profit as possible". Those already profiting from rent are usually strictly opposed to the goal of affordable housing too. But that doesn't mean that a substantial portion of society doesn't support it; the power to achieve it just doesn't lie with them.
- closeparen 8y agoOf course the power lies with them. Their activism is the primary impediment to actually-feasible projects getting built. All they have to do to yield a healthier supply/demand balance is stand down.
- paulcole 8y agoCurrently, traffic jams only prevent you from moving forward. In the future they’ll keep you from going down, too. Progress!
- mklingen 8y agoThe Boring Company's "solution" is a [sad joke](https://slate.com/business/2018/12/elon-musks-los-angeles-tunnel-has-so-little-promise-its-a-miracle-he-built-it-at-all.html https://slate.com/business/2018/12/elon-musks-los-angeles-tu...) that belies Musk's utter disconnect with reality. The fact that the man openly mocks public transportation while crying about LA traffic only makes the matter worse.
- casual_slacker 8y agoHere is the paper the article attempted to cite [1] (article link is 404ing right now) [1] https://repository.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1087&context=real-estate_papers https://repository.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=108... I believe the article mentions this, but the paper only studies urban-area VKT, the paper mentions that the same effects do not apply to interstate highway system or a number of other categories.
- JimboOmega 8y agoIs this even a problem? People are given an opportunity to do something and then they do it. That's way better than new roads going unused, isn't it? I like congestion charging alright, which the article advocates at the very end, but it has a habit of being regressive - it's easy for me, as a software engineer, to show up at work at 11AM, but that might not be the case for those who can less afford to pay those charges. I think it's a net positive, but it can have consequences - especially in places like the Bay Area where there is no vaguely affordable housing anywhere near where the jobs are. Why not think about locating things people want to go to - especially their jobs - near where they live? Why do we need sprawling suburban "campuses" and a million tech busses to shuttle people from the cities to them? Throwing up huge office buildings and tech HQs in SF - but refusing to build housing the same way - is only a little tiny bit better. Both just force people to the exurbs, creates more super commuters and more demand on the roads.
- msbarnett 8y ago> Is this even a problem? It’s a problem if your assumption was that demand was closer to fixed and building more roads would “spread drivers out”, reducing congestion. This was for decades, and still to some extent is, a very wide-spread assumption in local politics, leading to incredibly questionable urban planning decisions.
- erik_seaberg 8y agoIf we paved every square inch, traffic wouldn't go to infinity. It's pretty rare to go driving for no reason. Country roads don't have rush hour. It seems reasonable to assume that latent demand per capita is fixed, but at a level too high for a city to accommodate without destroying its density advantages.
- village-idiot 8y agoPeople will also adjust their housing and working decisions based on road availability, although the lag here is a little long.
- nck4222 8y agoWhich is also why building bigger roads, generally doesn't improve traffic issues. Given the options available, people will generally choose the most hassle-free route. If public transit improves, more people will take it, which will improve road traffic. If bigger roads are built, less people will take public transit, because roads can handle more cars before the traffic factor forces people to use alternatives. This breaks down a bit outside cities where the only option is to drive (no buses, too far to bike or walk), but remote areas don't usually have traffic problems even with low capacity roads. Edit, more info for the curious: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand
- komali2 8y agoI'm visiting my hometown of Houston after now having lived in SF for just under 3 years, and my partner and mine most common debate thread as we sit in Houston traffic is - what did Houston do differently, to get these uniquely Houston traffic problems? Is it "Houston's" fault, or the fact that it has an extra 2 million people? Does it actually have 2 million more people, or did it just octopus across the entire region to a ridiculous point and thus inflate its population numbers (really, does Clear Lake count as "Houston?" parts are nearly 20 miles away, and can take an hour or even two to get to on a straight shot freeway). Here's some questions we argue: 1. Where's the money coming from? We see massive Houston mega-projects, huge new freeways built on top of massive existent ones. Yet there's no gas tax, no state income tax, and I don't remember there even being a city income tax (that was several years ago that I worked here though). So who's paying for the new freeways? 2. Why do cars clump at exits? Why do Houstonians sometimes spend 15+minutes at a total standstill waiting to exit? Is it because of line cutters (culture of driving)? Is it because of people reacting violently to line cutters (culture of driving)? Is it because of poor design? Is it as the Houston Chronicle has argued and due to feeder roads, a feature that doesn't exist outside of Houston/Dallas (and thus is a strong contender)? Is it simply because the population is massive and driving is the only viable option to get around, and thus the roads are always clogged? Is it actually an issue in San Francisco, and we simply don't notice because we drive motorcycles (unlikely, but I will pay extra attention when we return)? 3. Why the fuck did i-45, in the middle of a 50 year construction project, suddenly swap out freeway-going-under-bridge design in the Clear Lake area for freeway-is-a-bridge design? Now it's terrifying to drive the speed limit over those bridges because you might smash at 65mph into a half-mile exit-clump line.
- JaRail 8y agoOn the questions of funding, in the US, interstates are federally funded while local roads are state/city-funded. That's why the interstate system has been so successful compared to highway systems that are more locally-funded, eg Canada.
- kodablah 8y ago> interstates are federally funded while local roads are state/city-funded This is not completely true. In some cases interstates are 80/20 federal/state funded, in others its 50/50. Not sure of any states where it is 100% federal funding of interstates.
- TuringNYC 8y agoThe more intelligent approach to building roads is one i've seen in Washington DC. While the metro system isnt perfect, they allocated a portion of the highway to rail (middle track between both directions on the highway.) This way, the community expanded outwards via longer and longer highways and there was an obvious way to eventually simultaneously also expand the metro system outwards. They did this with the Orange Line westwards inbetween Route 66. They then did this with the Silver Line North-westwards in-between Route the Dulles tollway. I imagine the increased traffic due to increased highway capacity is partly because exurbs dont have mass transit support back to the center city...yet people reach further outwards to exurbs seeking more affordable housing. The Washington DC approach solves parts of that problem quite well.
- jandrese 8y agoThe problem with this is the last mile problem. Cars are their own solution to the last mile problem and highway placement reflects that. Trying to fit a light rail system on the same footprint immediately runs into the question of how you're going to solve the last mile problem. If you don't, you'll have underutilized train stations sitting in the middle of a road nowhere near where people want to be.
- barney54 8y agoDC has increasing traffic congestion, but decreasing Metro ridership. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/local/trafficandcommuting/metro-says-it-doesnt-know-what-to-do-about-its-falling-ridership-an-internal-report-lays-out-exactly-what-to-do/2018/10/03/d8771d2e-c721-11e8-b2b5-79270f9cce17_story.html https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/...
- jandrese 8y agoThese statistics are no doubt skewed by the Metro's deferred maintenance roosters coming home to roost and forcing the system to degrade service to accommodate repairs. It remains to be seen if the ridership numbers bounce back now that we are nearing the end of the extended closures.
- 8y ago
- netcan 8y agoIn practical terms, we can consume as much transport as we get. If it was cheap and fast I could have ramen lunch in Tokyo. Pick up the kids from crèche in Portugal on my way home to New Zealand. So, unless we get teleport watches... congestion is the "price," the thing that limits consumption. Economists would prefer the price to be price, being economists. One thing this article leaves out is what the value of all this transport is. Maybe more roads don't solve congestion but they do produce more "goods," more Kms travelled. Presumably this has value.
- reaperducer 8y agoMaybe more roads don't solve congestion but they do produce more "goods," more Kms travelled. Presumably this has value. It does, which is one reason why (in the United States, anyway), highways are paid for by the governments — to spur commerce. In contrast, railroads (at least in the United States) still mostly have to pay for their infrastructure, which is one reason why passenger rail is in the shape it's in.
- bobthepanda 8y agoIt kind of does. But only to a certain point; in some cases you're just shuffling growth around the region rather than stimulating new regional growth. A lot of road capacity is needed, but a lot of it is also purely wasteful and entirely caused by social choice. E.g., the parking lot for the store needs to hold the Black Friday parking demand -> the store is now too far from the street to walk home with bags -> everyone drives to the store and there is congestion -> the street must be widened to accommodate the congestion --> the street is now too wide to cross or walk along safely --> everybody drives, etc. The suburbs are now vastly overbuilt as a result. Nassau County is one of the wealthiest counties in the country yet has been fiscally monitored by New York State since 2000 because it cannot afford the lifecycle cost of infrastructure or services for such a low-density, sprawly environment. And this is despite very high property taxes, to the point where the population is starting to decline.
- Spooky23 8y ago
- imhelpingu 8y agoI'm so tired of pretentious people claiming to be "civil engineers" pontificating to me on the internet about how local governments should sit on their ass because demand elasticity is binary. This kind of shit is why I hate the online press.
- 40acres 8y agoWhy are roads an elastic demand but it seems that other transportation methods, like light rail, aren't? I've seen cases of quite a few expensive lines and rail-stops that have lower than expected utilization, but it seems like new highway roads and lanes get immediate use. Is it down to the fact that there is simply more "freedom" with regards to roads over rail?
- pkulak 8y agoPeople prefer to drive, so they do that first. Public transportation functions the exact same way, so long as there is no more road capacity. There are countless examples of new light rail stations spurring new development in the area.
- baddox 8y agoI think it’s because in the US cars effectively “won.” Even if mid and long distance passenger rail were more of a thing, you’ll have to rent a car at your destination anyway. In other words, with just a car you can get anywhere you want in the continental US in 2-3 days. With just passenger rail (or commercial air travel, etc.), you can get to passenger terminals in a lot of places, but that’s about it.
- mklingen 8y agoIn areas where cities are dense enough for public transportaiton to make sense, adding a new line does indeed lead to induced demand. For cities that are spread out and unwalkable (read: almost all US cities), public transit isn't efficient enough to move enough people from point A to B, due to A and B being very far away -- never mind the fact that once you get to B, you can't even walk to many destinations due to the city being designed in such a sprawly, pedestrian hostile way. For public transportation to work, we first need to make our cities denser. The best way of doing this is by outlawing use-based zoning and moving to form-based zoning. That means getting rid of the concept of a "single family zone" and a "commercial zone", etc. and just specifying stuff about the materials and shapes of buildings. It also means outlawing parking minimums. Many cities around the world (and even a few in the US, re: Philadelphia, NYC) have this kind of zoning which allows for much denser development.
- 8y ago
- whoisnnamdi 8y agoThis is an important point that is commonly overlooked. Traffic is a sign of something. It’s a sign that the benefits of transportation outweighs the costs of transportation. Given this, high traffic often implies that there is pent up demand out there - more cars that would be on the road right now if only the roads could support it. When more roads are built, this unlocks some of the pent up demand, as the cost of transportation has effectively declined due to more available roads. However, this reduction in cost / hassle etc and the previously pent up demand may be so large that in encourages much more driving, such that in equilibrium the traffic could be nearly as bad as before.
- ip26 8y agoIt’s a sign that the benefits of transportation outweighs the costs of transportation Which, given the way roads are funded, is something of a broken equation. The costs of transportation are not fully borne by the user proportionally to consumption. You pay fuel taxes & buy tires, yes, but they by no means cover the full per-mile cost of your trip.
- megablast 8y agoNot sure why you are downvoted, drivers are subsidised to a huge amount, and that doesn't even include pollution, deaths, destruction of wildlife, etc...
- Johnny555 8y agoEven people that claim not to believe this believe it without admitting it. I tried to explain the concept to an acquaintance who claimed it wasn't true - bigger roads just ease congestion so all we need to do is keep expanding roads until congestion stops. Then, after a freeway expansion was completed, he moved 10 miles to the far side of the expansion to buy a bigger house. And now he complains about the traffic since his dream commute for the first couple years is now worse than ever.
- avar 8y agoFrom the article: > [...]perhaps you could create a system that also takes a person's income into account, which would let you make a progressive form of congestion pricing. It's oddly inconsistent to hold that opinion about road use and not say real estate use. Very few people are of the opinion that someone making minimum wage needs to be living in downtown Manhattan. Why shouldn't use of the scarce road resources of Manhattan be treated similarly when it comes to pricing?
- Hermel 8y agoSame applies to Internet bandwidth. The more you provide, the more it will be used. And that’s good.
- caravaggi0 8y agoand building trains makes people ride trains. The fundamental rule is path of least resistance, literally and figuratively. It also matters who has the powerful interest. Seen this? Taken for a Ride - The U.S. History of the Assault on Public Transport in the Last Century https://youtu.be/p-I8GDklsN4 https://youtu.be/p-I8GDklsN4
- marcosdumay 8y ago> and building trains makes people ride trains. Only if the trains carry people to a place they want to go.
- throwawaysea 8y agoTLDR there is a service/good that is useful (point-to-point personal transport) and in high-demand. This whole notion of "induced demand" seems like a suspicious artificial label used to position roads as a negative. The reality is that roads provide something people want - the ability to get around quickly, on one's own terms, without dealing with waiting times or trip planning, and without some of the unsavory experiences that can sour public transit (e.g. https://www.sfgate.com/crime/article/BART-takeover-robbery-50-to-60-teens-swarm-11094745.php https://www.sfgate.com/crime/article/BART-takeover-robbery-5...). Building roads doesn't "induce" demand. Rather, it _fulfills_ it. There is a limit to that demand - it's not like supplying infinitely more of something would infinitely scale the associated behavior. There are only so many humans and only so many trips they are willing to make in a day. And an area that is 100% roads obviously would not have any destinations worth traveling to (leaving aside edge cases like race tracks). So as far as I can tell, this is just regular supply-demand: people want something, and supplying it satisfies that need. Why is this noteworthy except that it lends dubious credence to a narrative Vox likes to push?
- yason 8y agoFor any practical purposes road traffic can be considered a gaseous element that quickly fills as much space as is allocated for road space, with heavy emphasis on segments that lead to several destinations. Conversely, when roads are put on a diet and lanes are removed it generally turns out that the traffic does not pack into queues twices as long, as is often expected or feared, but generally disappears. To control congestion is to control the space available where congestion can happen. Build a two lane road and you will have two lanes of congestion. Build an eight lane road and you will have eight lanes of congestion.
- waiseristy 8y agoIn that case then, we should rid ourselves of all roads and live in small self sufficient communes.
- yason 8y agoThat's very true if the goal is to get rid of automotive congestion completely. The practical solution is to find a trade-off where we allow enough congestion to allow the necessary and important things to move but not too much that allows convenience traffic that makes the city unwalkable and car-dependent.
- honkycat 8y agoIf you are sitting there thinking: "So what", I highly recommend you educate yourself on how building roads actually affects US infrastructure. We have a CRUMBLING infrastructure in the US, and people are constantly complaining about potholes in major metropolitan areas. And the solution is build more roads? We cannot even maintain the ones we have! Recommended reading: - https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme - https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/1/16/why-walkable-streets-are-more-economically-productive-3bzg5 https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/1/16/why-walkable-s...
- vbezhenar 8y agoI don't understand how is it possible that you can't maintain roads. Use car taxes to maintain roads. Increase them if necessary. Introduce paid roads where applicable. If taxes were too high, some people would prefer cheaper public transportation, so market will find a balance automatically.
- claar 8y agoSimple -- tax money earmarked for roads is spent elsewhere, leaving insufficient money for road maintenance.
- vbezhenar 8y agoThe problem is not with roads, then, but with tax distribution.
- ip26 8y agoIncrease them if necessary. Good luck. Introduce paid roads where applicable. Oh my god do the voters scream about this. They are entitled to free roads. We struggle to maintain roads because the voting public wants $1.00 worth of services for $0.90
- mikeash 8y agoIncreased taxes are extremely unpopular. Gas taxes, which are supposed to fund road maintenance, are almost always a fixed per-gallon amount, so they gradually erode due to inflation. They also effectively shrink due to increasing fuel efficiency. Just keeping gas taxes actually steady looks like an increase, and voting for that is a good way for politicians to lose elections.
- makewavesnotwar 8y agoEh... There was a toll lane added from just outside Boulder part way to Denver. This has not generated more traffic, but it has generally speed up the road (sometimes to an undesirable extent as faster moving vehicles make more noise). They didn't change the two lane in each direction structure, they just added another lane on each side which can only be entered/exited around exits. A couple things I've noticed, most mid-day traffic occurs in clumps. You can usually take one segment of toll road for $0.35 and exit back into a mostly empty highway. Also, the toll lane people usually move above the speed limit. This speeds up traffic in general because people seem to tend to move into the right lane when someone blasts past them. A few people do it and most slow drivers will get the idea. And it also discourages lane switching which is a significant contributor to traffic. Once you're in the toll lane, you're committed to it until the next exit. The problem with just arbitrarily adding more lanes is than lane switching is a major cause of traffic. Every time someone switches a lane because their lane is too slow, they usually cause the car behind them to have to slow down which causes a ripple effect. Add this to complexity of an 8 lane freeway and you may have created a nightmare for travelers. Granted in over populated areas like much of CA, congestion is somewhat unavoidable. (I grew up in the LA area)
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI don't understand why this is happening. The article attempts to come up with explanations, but I find them hard to believe. Although (most) roads are free to use, we pay for travel in gas, car upkeep, and—perhaps most importantly—time. All of which can be quite costly! I live in upper Manhattan and have an unlimited-ride metrocard. But I would much rather go shopping at the store that's a five minute walk away than one that requires 30 minutes on the subway, even though the latter offers many more options. I increasingly order products online instead of doing either. To where are people driving that makes these longer trips worth their while?
- fabianhjr 8y agoThis is a specific case of induced demand: https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Induced_demand https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Induced_demand
- 24gttghh 8y agoWell... a whopping 45% of Americans have no access to public transit[0], in any form. So I would hazard a guess that those with access to light rail/subways is significantly less than 45%. Light and commuter rail ridership makes up only 300M/quarter riders out of a total ridership of 2.5B/quarter for all forms of mass transit, if I'm reading this right.[1] [0]https://www.apta.com/mediacenter/ptbenefits/Pages/FactSheet.aspx https://www.apta.com/mediacenter/ptbenefits/Pages/FactSheet.... [1]https://www.apta.com/resources/statistics/Pages/ridershipreport.aspx https://www.apta.com/resources/statistics/Pages/ridershiprep...
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoYeah, I have cheaper and faster access to transit than most drivers can ever achieve—and I still don't use it all that much! Why are people driving such long distances—and putting up with traffic—in their expensive cars? Is a larger house really that valuable? I suppose the answer is "yes, it is that valuable", since we are where we are. But, like, what's wrong with people?
- apo 8y agoIt's interesting to apply these findings and conclusions to other areas. For example, Bitcoin is a lot like the interstate highway system in that it's prone to traffic jams. The Great Bitcoin Scaling Debate of 2016 and 2017 attempted to address this problem One camp argued strongly like the old-school urban planners in the linked article: more capacity = less congestion. Another group argued that variable-rate fees (a feature built into Bitcoin from the beginning) would take care of the problem. When transaction volume spikes, so do fees. This discourages use during spikes and incentivizes off-peak use. Bitcoin ended up adding a small increase to capacity in the form of segwit. The result followed the prediction in the article. After a massive spike in usage during the later part of 2017, fees spiked to $50 or more per transaction. This was followed by a marked decrease in on-chain transaction volume to the point that blocks aren't full today. Fees have likewise decreased by more than two orders of magnitude. Two other developments during 2018 may be relevant: 1. The BTC/USD exchange rate collapsed. 2. The Lightning Network (a way to route more transaction volume with fewer on-chain transactions) was deployed on mainnet.
- zone411 8y agoIt is actually possible for an additional road to increase the travel time for each driver, without any new cars added, and with everybody acting rationally! Braess's paradox (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess%27s_paradox). It has been observed in practice.
- lazyjones 8y agoThat's a whole can of bogus science you opened there. The Wikipedia example is particularly funny, since it looks at a case where a new road is suddenly added and all drivers currently on the road switch to it momentarily because at one single moment in time it looks beneficial (but isn't). In reality, people don't change their routes based on new roads added during their trips and even if they did, they'd quickly learn a new overall more efficient route instead of what this bogus example suggests.
- JoeAltmaier 8y ago...lets people drive more. And in other news, more food makes people eat more. And more money lets people spend more.
- narrator 8y agoThis is known as Jevons paradox[1]. Any resource that is used more efficiently will be used more. The more efficiently drive time is used in terms of average speed, the more it will be used. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- scythe 8y agoAround the fifth time this was posted I tracked down the study, and the big asterisk here is that yes, more roads do mean more traffic, but part of that traffic is mediated by more jobs and more residents. The way some people tell it, it’s an unmitigated negative. Not quite.
- Chloro 8y agoIf roads were 20x wider I guarantee traffic would be reduced or damn near eliminated. They just want an excuse to charge people and/or enable the rich to get special transport privileges. Also where do they get off claiming these people are getting this for free? They bought it with their taxes, so to double charge them and exclude the poor is pretty messed up.
- k_sh 8y agoIf roads were 20x wider, 68% of LA County would be streets. Sure, turning two-thirds of a city into roads will cut down on traffic - but within realistic restraints on road construction, induced demand is real. (There are 140mi^2 of roads now[0], and 4,058mi^2 of land mass[1].) [0]: https://la.curbed.com/2015/11/30/9895842/how-much-parking-los-angeles https://la.curbed.com/2015/11/30/9895842/how-much-parking-lo... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles_County,_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles_County,_California
- ummonk 8y agoWell there is a hypothetical world in which you could stack roads. It's prohibitively expensive, but not physically impossible.
- BurningFrog 8y agoHere is the BIG elephant on the road. Why road consumption is different than all other consumptions: We don't pay for road usage!!! Anything useful that is handed out to consumers at the cost of $0.00 will be overused and develop a shortage. This is so ingrained that it can be hard to think about. Anyway, if we had to pay to access roads, depending on the traffic load, traffic could always flow at full speed, road investments could pay for themselves and a lot of things would be healthier in society. I know this argument doesn't convince a lot of people... I think we just have to wait for some society to implement it first and the the rest of us can wonder at the miracle and slowly copy it. Perhaps the Chinese? The seem keen on innovating, for better and for worse :)
- chillacy 8y agoSome cities have special lanes you have to pay for to use during rush hour, FastPass is one system. They charge by number of wheels.
- BurningFrog 8y agoYeah, it's very slowly coming along!
- johnwalkr 8y agoNot quite as comprehensive as your example but in Japan all highways are tolled and the toll is approximately the same as high speed train fare. In cities all parking is paid too, normally even at your apartment. Driving is often more expensive and slower than transit. The end result is much higher pressure for maintaining good transit, good infrastructure for walking the last mile (it’s rare to see a long stretch of uncrossable road or missing sidewalk). There’s a lot of pressure to keep shops and restaurants within walking distance of most neighborhoods, too.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThanks! I didn't know about this. I'm very impressed by Japanese infrastructure, and this is one more piece explaining how they do it.
- stmfreak 8y agoThis is such a frequently peddled lie it has become a cultural truth. The saying neglects to mention that same volume of drivers on expanded roads is always better for traffic—which is why we ask for more lanes and better roads. Since driving is the preferred mode of transport, the fact that a reduction in traffic encourages more driving (and congestion) should not surprise anyone. The question we should be asking is whether people are being better served stuck at home afraid of traffic or would they be better off getting out and going places.
- ummonk 8y agoYeah, let's not build enough housing for everyone who works here to live here, and let's also not build more freeway, to make sure they can't commute in either. Not only should we not make room for newcomers to the Bay Area (cause screw immigrants), but no need to make room for people who grew up here either; just have them live with their parents!