11 ms·
The Social Credit System in China [video]
- walrus01 8y agoEvery year the US State Department publishes a report on human rights in China: https://www.state.gov/documents/organization/277317.pdf https://www.state.gov/documents/organization/277317.pdf and every year the Chinese government publishes a report on how terrible the United States is in regards to human rights: http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2018-04/24/c_137133826.htm http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2018-04/24/c_137133826.htm It's interesting to see the very different perspective of both agencies. Both countries have significant problems.
- danbolt 8y agoWhat’s your take of China’s reports on the US, compared to vice versa?
- hkon 8y agoEvil
- InitialLastName 8y agoBe careful not to cut yourself on that edge.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoI'm probably the only person I know who believes that privacy is unsustainable and overrated, and that a social credit system is unavoidable and massively underrated. I have never understood people's obsession with privacy, Orwell's 1984, etc. It always seemed motivated by selfishness and irrational fear. For the longest time, I've been wondering what was wrong with me. Why don't other people share my preference for transparency and efficiency? Why is everyone trying to make things more difficult for people around them? Then I discovered China. It seemed like WeChat and Sesame Credit were what I had been looking for all these years. How come don't we have these things in the west? Why are we so conservative and technophobe? I quickly realized that WeChat and Sesame Credit were poor (centralized, authoritarian) implementations of great visions. It is now overwhelmingly clear to me that we need a decentralized version of WeChat and Sesame Credit. This would be the greatest innovation since the invention of the Internet. Yet, I can't seem to find anyone willing or capable to appreciate these ideas. What am I missing?
- scarejunba 8y agoI know at least two other people in my immediate circle who believe in the inevitability of ubiquitous tracking. For my part, I want to make sure it gets built right. I've also lived in very corrupt societies etc. This can be done right. I'm sure of it. I guess we'll see in the next ten years or so.
- akira2501 8y ago> What am I missing? First hand experience with corruption?
- ordinaryradical 8y agoHuman nature and its propensity to misuse great ideas. See also: communism, nuclear physics, and cryptography.
- valesco 8y agoThe experience of nazism, an industrialized killing system made possible by huge databases.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoAnd a compliant populace.
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoDatabases provided by IBM[1] 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_during_World_War_II#Critics_of_IBM's_actions_during_World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_during_World_War_II#Critic...
- walrus01 8y ago> How come don't we have these things in the west? Why are we so conservative and technophobe? Because of basic concepts like fundamental human rights, privacy, and other things guaranteed by documents like the US constitution, bill of rights, various constitutional amendments, and other documents such as Canada's charter of rights and freedoms. If your comment is not entirely satire, I'm appalled that I even needed to type this reply.
- smdyc1 8y agoThis can only be a means for the Chinese Communist Party to exert more authoritarian control over it's population. Depending on the actual implementation, I'd compare this to East Germany except in this case, the social credit system replaces the Stasi and their network of informers. If there is no way to opt out of such a system then freedom of thought and action are potentially gone. My question is, how do they justify such a system when the only apparent threat is to the Chinese Communist Party's waning influence and control in this information age.
- ep103 8y agoI asked a Chinese national friend of mine. He said that the system sounded good, because it would decrease the rate of crime. When I brought up privacy concerns, social concerns, etc, he looked at me like I was talking Swahili. I tried bringing up the Stasi, and he didn't know what I was talking about. 1984, had never read it. Secret police... they apparently only go after bad people. The sorts of things you're talking about are genuinely not on the radar of the average person over there. It would require education they specifically and intentionally don't have. (And, if I were to guess, are encouraged never to learn)
- walrus01 8y agoThe average mainland Chinese person who attended their public school system will simply not be aware of a great many historical events, such as: The Stasi Romanians lynching Ceaușescu Tiennamen Square (they'll know it exists as an innocent landmark in the capital, not the history of what happened there) 1984 and the whole genre of dystopian police-state literature
- yourbandsucks 8y agoIt's to be expected that they'll know less about european history and correspondingly more about chinese history. And everyone knows what happened in Tiananmen square. It's living memory. We could flip it around and talk about how ignorant westerners are of Chinese history..
- neom 8y agoVice did a pretty interesting mini-doc about it a couple of weeks ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dkw15LkZ_Kw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dkw15LkZ_Kw
- miketery 8y agoThat's chilling - especially the support by the guy who got dinged for it. If he didn't support it how would he be able to say so? This is very much like building a Panopticon.
- ZumaBeach 8y agoWow Chinese people are so fucked....between this, crushing taxes on private enterprises, and the impending crash of their economy from the tariff hike next march.....
- dayaz36 8y agoThis is very one sided. Only shows the opinions of people that support the system even though vast majority do not. Seems like Vice is doing propaganda for China's Orwellian/Black Mirroresque system
- chillacy 8y agoA rejection by comparison to dystopian fiction is like saying "welfare is turning us into Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged" or "capitalism is ending up like Rapture in Bioshock". A lotta slippery slopes and ideology.
- chillee 8y agoI'd say the vast majority of people in China do support the system.
- ConfusedDog 8y agoThe "driving point system" is very ubiquitous in China. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Point_system_(driving) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Point_system_(driving) It is also very common in the states and other countries. Funny thing is, in China, offenders can "buy" points from other people so that they still can drive. I wonder if that would work for this "social credit system" as well at some point...
- walrus01 8y agoFor comparison, Finland apparently scales driving penalty fines proportionally according to your income: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland-home-of-the-103000-speeding-ticket/387484/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland...
- sampo 8y agoCan confirm. Typical fine for 21-29 kph speeding is 20% of your monthly income, and for 30-60 kph speeding, 40% of your monthly income.
- troels 8y agoSame in Denmark, at least for DUI. You'll get roughly 10 x BAC x monthly salary (post tax). A local footballer famously got hit hard by this, with a fine of DKK 842K (~ USD 130K).
- org3432 8y agoThe Chinese are formalizing it and adding the system to places that haven't been too political in the past, but the west has its own unwritten social credit system and if you don't figure it out and kowtow to it then you're secretly penalized. e.g. Cross an insecure manager or exec in your company by saying something that's true and better for the company, you'll get dingined without knowing it. Focus solely on learning at school and not enough on figuring out the game too, there again you're going against the system.
- lsd5you 8y agoReally? This doesn't stand up as a comparison. In so far as there are shitty unwarranted consequences for unwanted actions in the west it is similar, but that is human nature (and possibly even wider than that). The difference is that china is implementing a centralised, state controlled system. Which will elevate the minor tyranny of some obnoxious policy in some organisation to an unchecked and magnified universal tyranny. This is precisely why we need checks, balances and distribution of power, because the elite minority cannot be trusted.
- org3432 8y agoOn the good end of the policy they're trying to correct "human nature", so the western approach is basically c'est la vie humans are terrible. I don't agree with the Chinese system either, but I don't see a good look in the mirror being a bad thing here either as that there are very real world consequences in the west penalizing doing the right thing.
- ribs 8y agoYou’re comparing a) word of mouth that might spread across parts of a company, maybe a little further, impacting you when you apply for a job, to b) a nationwide, government-run system that will be involved in a wide variety of life situations. A) and b) are of wildly different scope, formality, import.
- zandl 8y agoIf you’re black for example, you’re treated like you have a low score, yet you can’t do anything about it.
- rblion 8y agoJust like in 'Black Mirror'.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoAs much as I like the idea of a social credit score, their implementation is absurdly naive. Not to mention centralized and authoritarian. Do they really think they can manually craft a fair and balanced system, when they arbitrarily decide that jaywalking costs a person 10 points? They use the same unidimensional score affected by jaywalking to assess a person's ability to pay debt? What could possibly go wrong. They should keep collecting data about people, but they should rethink the way they attribute scores. Ideally, a person's score should be calculated based on the values and preferences of the perceiver. The score of Donald Trump, for example, could differ significantly depending on who you ask.
- anonymousab 8y agoIt does not need to be fair or balanced to accomplish their primary goal. They do not need to care about edge cases - a citizen unfairly falling through the cracks is just as unimportant as any other citizen, so the gestalt effect matters more.
- jchanimal 8y agoI gave a talk on multi dimensional subjective cryptocurrency modeled on the peer to peer web of trust. Might be of interest to you: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2ENERyV7xA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2ENERyV7xA
- anonymousab 8y agoThe fun part will be extending it to track and apply to foreigners, even outside of China. It's a very small thing to make people second-guess a critical blog post or Reddit comment about China in case they ever want to visit or do business with a company that has any Chinese presence.
- tivert 8y ago> The fun part will be extending it to track and apply to foreigners, even outside of China. > It's a very small thing to make people second-guess a critical blog post or Reddit comment about China in case they ever want to visit or do business with a company that has any Chinese presence. That would be difficult to extend to activity in non-cooperative regimes. China has been working to de-anonymize internet access by making phone numbers traceable to national ID numbers, network connections/IP addresses traceable to phone numbers [1], and forum posts traceable to IP addresses. I think it's unlikely that they'd be able to automatically trace a pseudonymous post on reddit made by an American in the US to a particular US passport number to factor reddit posts into a social credit score at a large scale. However, they might be able to do it for public posts on a real-name policy site like Facebook. With facial recognition and a real name, they could probably reliably match an account to a passport to sanction posts they dislike. They'd probably be fine with any false positives due to fake accounts, etc. [1] e.g. to connect to airport wifi, the landing page asks for your (local) cell number, and texts you a code for access.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoForeigners generally don’t appear at all in Chinese credit systems, to the point that we can’t get credit cards on our own even if we have a lots of money in the bank and a continuing direct deposit. I really shouldn’t be using my real name on HN, however.
- oldoverholt 8y agoIt's strange to me that the social credit system in China seems to rarely be discussed alongside credit scores in the United States, an already existing, massively opaque, punitive system that keeps people in cycles of debt and poverty.
- sambull 8y agoNot to mention that it interjects itself as a social ranking system for private employeers.
- brudgers 8y agoAnd access to health care is strongly linked with employment.
- mc32 8y agoAre they equitable? There is some resemblance, but it's different enough. Let's put it this way, despite the ills of the US Credit Bureaux, I would want the Chinese Social Credit system much less. Even with no credit, one can still get on a train, it does not affect what schools you can put your kids in, or penalize my spot in a gov't queue.
- oldoverholt 8y agoCredit score absolutely affects what neighborhoods you can buy or rent in (so public schools) and whether you can afford private school. It’s obviously not a 1:1 comparison or “this one is better than the other,” but when like Bill Kristol is floating the idea of regime change in China in response to news about the social credit system, I think it’s important to do some reflecting on our own oppressive systems.
- mc32 8y agoIt's not a direct comparison. I think it's a bit of a stretch. Of course, not having money means you can't afford housing in a good school district, but if you happen to be poor or have bad credit but live in a good district (or borrow a relatives address) you can still put that kid in the district school. Basically, it's not a direct result. The most obvious difference is my _knowing_ someone with a bad score does not lower my score by loose association. Kristol is a war hawk, like many of the other conservative in name Neo-Cons. Glad their influence is now on the wane. What China is doing is not good, in many cases, but it's their problem and they can sort them out like they did in '49 and '66-'67. Somewhat more comparable is the German Schufa system --but it's till not the same.
- evdubs 8y agoAs a completely unverified anecdote perhaps related to the Social Credit System (and more so the amount of information being collected and distributed in China), my SO recently told me about her Dad's attempt to order pizza. It went something like: SO Dad: Hi, I'd like to get a large supreme pizza Pizza Op: Hello, SO Dad. I can help you with your order. Is the food being delivered to 123 Main St? SO Dad: Yes. Pizza Op: And can I call you at 123-4567 when the food is delivered? SO Dad: Yes. Pizza Op: Ok. I see that you are reported to have high cholesterol. Can I perhaps interest you in a vegetarian pizza? SO Dad: Okay. That's fine. Pizza Op: And I see that you have a family of 5 people. Should I add another pizza to the order? SO Dad: Sure. Pizza Op: Alright, that will be $30. Will you be using the payment information we have on file? SO Dad: Yes, please. Pizza Op: One moment ... Sir, the payment information we have is not working. SO Dad: I can't see why that is. I drive a nice car. Can you try again? Pizza Op: I tried again and it did not work. I see you are 100m away from our store. Can you just come down and pay in cash? SO Dad: Ok. I can do that. Pizza Op: Great! The pizza will be ready in 20 minutes. Please pick it up then. Good bye. Again, this is unverified and I don't know if she embellished parts of the story, but the idea that a pizza clerk can pull up your location, family information, and brief health record so easily is shocking. I suppose customers talking to clerks at restaurants they frequent will be able to glean some of this information over time, but the impression I got was that this was a "first time" order and the clerk was able to just look all of this up.
- david-gpu 8y agoCan anybody please offer any primary sources to back up these claims?
- mpfundstein 8y agoOP wrote clearly that this is anecdotal data.
- david-gpu 8y agoIf such a system was widespread, others would have reported about it. Alas, it was a hoax.
- jpatokal 8y agoA lot of the comments here seem to be based on speculation, not the actual content of the video. A few key points: * There is no one system (which is why the title is "The" Social Credit System, the scare quotes are there on purpose!), but ~70 local experiments, with the talk focusing on three of these (~19:45) * Alibaba's Sesame/Zhima system is not government-accredited (~26:00) and has a lot of shopping/loyalty card features (pay with Alipay, earn points!) * The current systems have many crippling flaws, like rich people being trivially able to buy their way to good scores to paper over their sins (~35:00) * Some type of nationwide system is likely to be rolled out nationally at some point, but the details are still very fuzzy (~49:00)
- Pulcinella 8y agoRich people buying their way to good scores is probably a feature, not a big.
- Pulcinella 8y agoNot saying that I approve of that...
- thetechlead 8y agoLiving in China and lived in the US. In general the credit systems in China aren't much different from those of the US. * There is no one system (which is why the title is "The" Social Credit System, the scare quotes are there on purpose!), but ~70 local experiments, with the talk focusing on three of these (~19:45) There isn't a central one. To be fair many credit systems exist for a while, for example financial credits from banks, traffic violation credit from DOT, airplane/train black-list, Dang'an system (rongcheng), etc. All of them aren't much different from their western counterparts, with one exception (Dang'an). * Alibaba's Sesame/Zhima system is not government-accredited (~26:00) and has a lot of shopping/loyalty card features (pay with Alipay, earn points!) Worked in Alibaba before and can confirm. Not government-accredited and not much different from a financial credit score, though much more commercial institutes are adapting it. For example, you don't need to pay deposit when opening a bike sharing account if you sesame score is above a threshold. * The current systems have many crippling flaws, like rich people being trivially able to buy their way to good scores to paper over their sins (~35:00) Not true for the majority but there's one exception. You can pay others to 'deduct' your traffic violation points. However it's not exactly buying way to good scores. Let me explain. In China violation is caught on traffic camera 99% of the time, while in the US most tickets are issued by a police officer. Thus the violation is issued on the vehicle since there's no way to identify who's the driver from camera footage. So people literally can claim someone else is driving the vehicle and points will be deducted from their account. Everyone has 12 points, refreshed every year. Most time that's enough to cover minor incidents. * Some type of nationwide system is likely to be rolled out nationally at some point, but the details are still very fuzzy (~49:00) There's proposal but I think it's both stupid and infeasible to design such a score. And various credit scores are already implemented and functioning, there's no need to get a new one.