11 ms·
IPv6 xmas display uses 75 Internet's worth of addresses
- devereaux 8y agoIt is nice because it's a xmas display, but it's nothing magic. IPv6 lets you do many things very simply, and it can get very messy too (which is fun by itself!) They got a /48, and they got some inspiration. You too can get a /48 easily if you want to play! Even if you don't get a /48, you can do some messy play very easily. My personal experience being messy: when I had to handle multiple containers on one actual computer, I had enough IPv4 addresses (like A.B.C.D) to give one per container, but just a single regular W:X:Y:Z/64 (the suggested minimum default for IPv6, like with SLAAC, while a /56 is often better even for a home network) The provider wanted some insane amount of money for a decent IPv6 allocation while usually it's the opposite, and IPv4 is expansive but IPv6 is mostly free. I didn't want to use tunnelbroker to keep the latency low. So I simply assigned W:X:Y:Z:A:B:C:D to each container -- because, why not? Yes it's wasteful, but it's easy to figure out which is which! IPv6 make many creative things possible and simpler than what the equivalent IPv4 solution would be, simply because of space constraints. After reading https://blog.donatas.net/blog/2018/12/14/geodns-ipv6-failover/ https://blog.donatas.net/blog/2018/12/14/geodns-ipv6-failove..., among my new year resolutions is setting up a CDN using IPv6. It's mostly to play with BGP.
- qlk1123 8y ago> So I simply assigned W:X:Y:Z:A:B:C:D to each container -- because, why not? Yes it's wasteful, but it's easy to figure out which is which! It makes me curious. Did you apply any service-discovery mechanism in your IPv6-based container cluster? I wonder if IPv6 makes orchestration easier, tougher, or actually things just work transparently.
- devereaux 8y agoNo, I didn't do anything that fancy even if it's what I really wanted in the first place :-) Full story: initially I wanted to do SLAAC with different subnets for the different physical computers. To do that and use the MAC address of the containers in a "standard" way, I would have needed a larger subnet that what the provider even had for sale - but then everything would indeed have been much easier and automatic. In case it's not clear, imagine having W:X:Y::/48 like the xmas tree example, then using Z to identify which physical computer the container is on: then A:B:C:D are automatically derived from the hardware address of the (here virtual) interface. It's also very handy if you have multiple networks - say a wired and wireless setup: use a different value for each network on each site say Z=1 for your wired netword, Z=2 for your wireless, etc. Then you can automatically populate AAAA records like computername.connection.site.yourdomain.com. Why is it cool? Then if you need to check connectivity or push updates or whatever, you can ping6 ceolaptop.wifi.nycoffice.yourdomain.com- but don't worry, that IPv6 address will not be leaked if you are using the privacy additions (lft=0 aka deprecation): this laptop will use a "throwaway" IPv6 access so it can't be tracked (well, at least the mac address part, but good luck finding the needle in a haystack!) See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPv6_address#Stateless_address_autoconfiguration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPv6_address#Stateless_address... : A 64-bit interface identifier is most commonly derived from its 48-bit MAC address. A MAC address 00-0C-29-0C-47-D5 is turned into a 64-bit EUI-64 by inserting FF-FE in the middle: 00-0C-29-FF-FE-0C-47-D5. When this EUI-64 is used to form an IPv6 address it is modified:[1] the meaning of the Universal/Local bit (the 7th most significant bit of the EUI-64, starting from 1) is inverted, so that a 1 now means Universal. To create an IPv6 address with the network prefix 2001:db8:1:2::/64 it yields the address 2001:db8:1:2:020c:29ff:fe0c:47d5 (with the Universal/Local bit, the second-least-significant bit of the underlined quartet, inverted to 1 in this case because the MAC address is universally unique).
- dishwasher1999 8y agoI remember the original IP v6 xmas tree. The one you see when you visit the site but get redirected soon. It is truly something that got me involved and learning networking to say the least and what a fun way to put it accross. This one is like 10 times more dank.
- scarmig 8y agoA thought: you could address all the bits in a 1TB hard drive with 8e+12 IPv6 addresses. Meaning you could do this with up to 4.25e+25 1TB hard drives. Someone think of something cool to do with that.
- walrus01 8y agoSize comparison: https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/2qxgxw/self_just_how_big_is_ipv6/ https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/2qxgxw/self...
- xhrpost 8y agoTwitch builds a TIFF image?
- iforgotpassword 8y agoA partition table and file system first, please.
- walrus01 8y agoFor fun, this is sort of a parody of ipv4 exhaustion counters: https://samsclass.info/ipv6/exhaustion.htm https://samsclass.info/ipv6/exhaustion.htm I have two /29 of ipv6 and at current consumption rates they should last until the end of human civilization. For reference of size, a /32 of ipv6 is what any ISP can get from Arin or ripe just for asking.
- MikusR 8y agohttps://samsclass.info/ipv6/exhaustion-2016.htm https://samsclass.info/ipv6/exhaustion-2016.htm
- devereaux 8y agoWho doesn't like fitting a power law!
- wolco 8y agoPart of me feels like this will not be enough if they continue to give huge blocks away. We will find trivial ways to use them. ipv8 or ipv16 or ipv1024 will come in our life times.
- xvilka 8y agoSadly at the same time in many countries IPv6 is next to non-existent[1]. I follow closely when China will adapt it, since was announced long time ago, but seems no progress since. [1] https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html
- jjpprrrr 8y agoThe three major ISPs in China just deployed IPv6 in most cities, though IPv6 based routing and DNS is still suboptimal. I don't know how Google generate the ipv6 statistics, but in the case of China it may not be very accurate. Most Google services are blocked there.
- xvilka 8y agoI live there and I don't see a change. Other, non-Google counters are also not very optimistic. EDIT: My bad, I just checked today and there are positive changes - all my connections are now IPv6, mobile and fixed line. The IPv6 speed as opposing IPv4 one is very low though...
- takeda 8y agoThe statistics are generated based on which protocol is used to access Google, so if Google is blocked it won't show up here.
- canofbars 8y agoThat chart seems very hopeful to me. Constant linear growth. I expect there will be a tipping point where enough people have it that some smaller sites go v6 only to cut costs and the rest of ISPs are forced to adopt it. My vps provider gives you a $2/month discount if you don't take a v4 address.
- em-bee 8y agohow about a new message protocol: IP over ping. 255 addresses, each ping sends one byte. bytes are ordered by the pings timestamp
- KMag 8y agoYou mean ICMP Echo.
- em-bee 8y agoright, "IP over ICMP Echo" will be the formal title for the RFC. "IP over ping" is the street name that everyone is going to call it, or IPing for short. also: TCPing and UDPing will replace TCP/IP and UDP/IP respectively.
- Intermernet 8y agoAlready exists https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICMP_tunnel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICMP_tunnel
- em-bee 8y agothat's different. that puts data into the ICMP Echo payload. IPing packets contain no data at all, but the data byte is encoded in the destination address
- Aeolun 8y agoIf we keep going in this direction we will quickly run out of adresses again.
- xnxn 8y agoYour concern is, um, addressed in the article.
- kortilla 8y agoIt says you get up to 10^27 of them. While that’s a lot, it’s right back in the ballpark of usable v4 space.
- rpearl 8y agoNo, it's not, it is many, many times larger than 'usable v4 space'. Like, if each of the hypothetical 10^27 displays was given a single IPv4 address we'd run out and still need to assign billions of billions of displays.
- hopler 8y agoV4 is 2^32 or 10^11. You could fit an entire IPv4 with an entire IPv4 nested inside each one, throw them all away and repeat every day for 300 years.
- KMag 8y agoScrew math. I'm still with the OP's darn rec'n'n, it's more truthy!
- stordoff 8y agoIt's _massively_ bigger - (10^27)/(2^32) = 2*10^17. 17 orders of magnitude is not in the same ballpark (you could give every IPv4 address an entire IPv4 address space, and it'd _still_ be bigger (54 million times bigger)).
- Aeolun 8y agoNo, it’s not. My concern isn’t this particular implementation, it’s that implementations will keep using up larger and larger chunks of adressable space. Thinking something is unlimited is the fastest way to find out that it is.
- nikanj 8y agoWhat would be grandma-proof equivalent of the implicit firewall provided by ipv4 NAT? The Right Way would be to make informed decisions per-port and per-protocol, but that's a nightmare to set up, and to maintain.
- stephen_g 8y agoYou need basically the exact same stateful firewall you already need with IPv4 even with NAT, except that with IPv6 you need to allow ICMP as well otherwise path MTU can break. On the in chain - allow ICMP, allow established/related, block otherwise. Open up any additional ports as needed, just the same as you used to do with port forwarding before. All routers, even crappy consumer ones should have a basic stateful firewall on by default. Hopefully with sane default settings.
- growse 8y agoNAT is not an 'implicit firewall'. Firewalls do packet filtering, NAT mangles routing. These are different things. If you're trying to solve the problems of "How do we stop anyone on the internet sending packets to grandma's open ports?", then the answer is a packet filter. Thankfully, must sane consumer routers come with these.
- kortilla 8y agoNAT overloading private IPs onto a single IP (what 99% of consumer routers are doing) is an implicit firewall. Without additional protocols like UPNP or manual configuration of port forwarding, nothing behind this style NAT can receive unsolicited traffic. “Mangling routing” to a single source IP requires state tracking of outbound sessions to know where to send inbound traffic. No outbound traffic, no session, no inbound traffic.
- growse 8y agoIf NAT is an implicit firewall, then so is an unplugged network cable. I guess it's technically true, but isn't a particularly meaningful assertion - you might as well say that NAT is also 'not a donkey'. Again, technically true, but doesn't really help. Firewalls are packet filters. Confusing routing and packet filtering doesn't help anybody solve any problems. We're talking (I think) about how to mitigate threats from the public internet by dropping unwanted traffic with IPv6. The answer is a firewall (as it is with IPv4).
- jsjohnst 8y agoAnyone have details on how they did the networking part of this? I can think of several approaches (all using a single PC for all the IPv6 addresses), but curious which they chose.
- zamadatix 8y agoThis is a PDF presentation from how the original tree worked in 2016 http://mum.mikrotik.com/presentations/NL16/presentation_3994_1479721384.pdf http://mum.mikrotik.com/presentations/NL16/presentation_3994... I imagine it works the same way now just with the added x y coordinates.
- jsjohnst 8y agoYou sure that’s the right link? The presentation slides link on that page didn’t seem related. Edit: n/m, watching the video made more sense. That said, it wasn’t simply “adding the X Y coordinates”, the Christmas tree example didn’t use IPv6 or Ping, but I’m sure the process was likely similar. tl;dr They use a Microtik firewall which uses an rsyslog forwarder with an Arduino to control the Christmas lights.
- exabrial 8y agoIpv6: making it trivially easy for Facebook and Google to track individual devices! (I certainly understand the problems with ipv4, but ipv6 reveals far too much information in it's current state).
- lloeki 8y agoRFC4941 begs to differ. https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4941 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4941
- exabrial 8y agoThink a little broader. The IPv6 Privacy Extensions just shield your mac address unless I've missed something. Let's say I'm a transit provider [like Google]. Right now, I see TLS traffic from your public IPv4 address to another public IPv4 address. I have no idea how many devices are behind those public IP addresses. I can maybe combine a few assumptions with my browser-based tracking, but it's difficult to identify you in apps I don't have control over. Switch to IPv6, now I know exactly how many devices behind your firewall are talking and how many devices you're talking to. Even better, I can combine this with a browser-based tracker and I can see what you're doing in apps I don't control. I first identify you with the browser and what IPv6 address you're using. Then as you use other apps that I can't spy on, I just have to look for your IPv6 address in my transit traffic to figure out what you're doing.
- gtdawg 8y agoA solution could be a Firefox browser extension that allocates a huge number of v6 addresses to your computer dynamically from your LAN /64 or /56 and creates fake garbage google usage data, so that google can never build a profile on you based on v6 address (if you are this paranoid). Or... just stop using google and use uBlock Origin to block all Google domains.
- SwellJoe 8y agoSo...you think Facebook and Google don't already track individual devices, even with IPv4?
- brownbat 8y ago> Since the led wall was being flooded with inappropriate content we had to implement a whitelist system... That was probably inevitable. The last scrolling LED message I read was "Uncaught type error: Undefined is not a function." Is one of you out there trying to fuzz this poor tree? :)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TekMol 8y agoEverybody seems to make a big fuzz about ipv6. Yet for some reason, it seems to be of no importance to my life at all. I'm a fulltime native of the web and yet I don't even know if I have ipv6. I just typed 'do i have ipv6' into Google and the first page I landed on says "0/10 You appear to be able to browse the IPv4 Internet only.". I doubt I am missing out on anything. I'm sure I would have noticed. I also make a living from the web, yet I don't even know if my websites support ipv6. Let me type 'test website for ipv6' into Google and see what happens ... ...ok here we go: "No AAAA record. This website is not ready for IPv6." I get that for all my websites. Again, I would be very surprised if that has any impact. Somebody would surely have told me that my websites don't work for them. They are constantly in the press and on social media. Some users would surely mention it if they had problems accessing them.
- tinus_hn 8y agoWhy do I see all these pictures of hungry children in Africa? Don’t they understand they can just get food at the supermarket? That’s what I do.
- progval 8y agoIPv4 is not sustainable, we're already running out of IPv4 addresses. Unfortunately, some ISPs only provide IPv4 support, so (almost) all websites have to support IPv4. And as all websites support IPv4 there is no insentive for ISPs to add IPv6 support. Repeat ad infinitum.
- mac01021 8y agoI would pay an extra $X per month for a handful of public, statically allocated ip addresses for the boxes in my house. Ipv6 would make that easy for my isp, but they're still never going to do it.
- vegardx 8y agoYou can always get a tunnel from one of the many tunnel brokers. Some are even free. I've used he.net back in the days before my ISP had native IPv6 support.
- progval 8y ago/r/place with ICMP as user interface/API, I love it
- hoppelhase 8y agoIf this becomes more common, the IPv6 address space will be exhausted pretty quickly. There already was a proposal on encoding phone numbers in IPv6 addresses.
- xionon 8y agoThere are 2^128 available addresses in ipv6. Encoding phone numbers isn’t even remotely a problem.
- hoppelhase 8y agoWell, the proposal was controversial. There was an article about this recently on the German news site Heise: https://heise.de/-4196981 https://heise.de/-4196981 Translation: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=https%3A%2F%2Fheise.de%2F-4196981&edit-text=&act=url https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&pr...
- notjosh 8y agoThe article has a note on that saying: > If you think this use of addresses seems wasteful, you needn’t worry. There are around 3.4×1038 IPv6 addresses, enough for 10^27 such displays. So even an intentionally wasteful project has plenty of headroom for quite a while yet!
- hoppelhase 8y agoBy "this" I mean encoding information in the address in general, not this signage-thing. See my other reply in this thread.
- edoloughlin 8y agoMakes me wonder if this could be used as an obfuscated comms channel? (I'm sure there's a term covering it, steganography doesn't quite describe it). If you owned a bunch of ipv6 addresses on multiple ISPs, you could use the timing of pings from these addresses as a comms protocol. You could even rotate IP addresses and use the modulus of the address to add a layer of obfuscation.
- shawn 8y agoYes. Ping and DNS are some of the most effective ways to exfiltrate data since they are rarely blocked.
- blattimwind 8y agoQuiet hosts with an unpublished v6 address are AFAIK impossible to discover in a better-than-linear-scan fashion from other networks (e.g. The Internet).
- zamadatix 8y agoNo different than obfuscating in higher level abstractions on a single IP as has been done forever. In either case you are getting a block of identifiers which have guidelines on how they should be used but no enforcement by design of the protocols. As an example things like port knocking can be carelessly translated into IP knocking. Doesn't make it any sneakier though, just less header.
- Eliezer 8y agoAnd people say that Moore’s Law has broken down! Sure, processor speeds aren’t increasing as fast, but that’s more than made up for by the incredibly rapid increase in the number of Internet addresses per device.
- zamadatix 8y agoWhat does the density of transistors in a circuit have to do with switching to larger addressed v6 which was standardized and first implemented in the late 90s?
- Midnightas 8y agoI'm not very experienced when it comes to such low-level networking, but I'm curious as to how they claimed all those contiguous addresses. Is there some fundamental difference between IPv4 and IPv6 that let's you do this?
- Dagger2 8y agoNot as such, it's just that v4 is so small that most ISPs don't bother to give routed prefixes -- or rather they can't, since there aren't enough addresses available to do so. In v6 it's typical to get something like a /56 from your ISP, which is 2^(128-56) = 2^72 addresses. (v6 also has a protocol, DHCPv6-PD, to manage prefix delegations automatically, whereas v4 requires manual config or some custom mechanism.) You could argue that the difference between 2^32 and 2^128 is big enough to be considered a fundamental difference. (Also: "lets".)