16 ms·
Star Citizen: The Road to Release, Financials and New Partners
- swampthinker 8y ago$460M valuation and taking on money from a family office. Not too shabby. I still think CIG bit off far more than they could chew, and comprised the final product as a result. But I do hope they succeed.
- raesene9 8y agoI'm very impressed that they got that valuation. Looking at the UK CIG accounts for 2017 they had a balance sheet value of -£12,304 , so props to them for getting that much investment.
- Krasnol 8y agoI don't understand all the talk about marketing there. If there is something those products doesn't need more of, then it's marketing. They've made millions selling digital pictures. It was pretty much brilliant. However the product itself lacks...everything.
- danso 8y agoThey've promised an ongoing persistent universe with Star Citizen, with no subscription fees and ongoing updates/upgrades after its official release (whenever that is). How many backers does SC/SQ42 actually have? Isn't it around or less than 2 million? That's a pretty low figure for an AAA game (one that features top acting talent, like Henry Cavill, Mark Hamill, Gillian Anderson, Gary Oldman). When SQ42 finally launches in 2020, they'll probably want to expand the userbase, and marketing is an effective way to do that. Even Rockstar, which is a current industry legend with unbeatable name recognition and hype around GTA and RDR, still spends hundreds of millions in advertising.
- zrobotics 8y agoThey already have most of the market though. What will advertising really do for them, considering that anyone who will even remotely be interested in this game has already heard of it. The population of people who would be willing to play star citizen has to be smaller than the number of people interested in something like red dead or GTA, the original pitch focused on the fact that this game is niche enough to not attract AAA studios. Who will they advertise to, they've attracted enough attention that any potential players have already heard of this project?
- erikpukinskis 8y agoWell, there's the whole market of "people who want the game to exist before they buy it".... seems like a pretty big group.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI am definitely curious how they'll manage to keep post-release funding afloat for all of the server costs and content development. I would expect a game with Star Citizen's server demands to be a subscription title, and I doubt they'll be able to keep selling ships at the rate they have once you can reasonably earn them in-game. (You can now buy ships in-game, but it takes a lot more money than people tend to make right now, and everything gets reset regularly anyways at the moment.)
- iamdave 8y agoHowever the product itself lacks...everything. I don't know if I, a frequent Star Citizen player and Day 1 backer would say it lacks "everything", and am unsure if your hyperbole was just for dramatic effect but from the first executable to where we are now in Alpha version 3.4 (soon to be 3.5), we have an impressive amount of content-all things considered, especially via in-game locales and systems that have facilitated some incredible emergent gameplay among the player base. The "Jumptown Wars" have been an amazing thing to watch and participate in, and I encourage you to go look through the Star Citizen subreddit to see some of the in-game coordination players are engaging in just to secure a static trading depot on a dead moon (diving deeper into the anecdote rabbit hole: I participated in a 12 ship assault on said depot when a pilot in the player "Organization"-SC's guild system-I'm a member of was shot down by a rival group and requested evac). It's light years from lacking "everything". It's not complete, but it's also not near as empty of an experience as you seem to be suggesting.
- Ralfp 8y agoI'm in "stand on the side and enjoy the show" camp myself, but looking at gameplays, the game is not that lacking. Its vertical slice that they can now build upon. I'm not aware if there's dynamic economy or sandbox wideopen yet, but I'm not losing anything holding out and bidding my time for final release.
- iamdave 8y agoI'm not aware if there's dynamic economy Kiiiind of? As in, you can see the framework of how it could work, and to a certain extent, specific actions by one player at-for example-the Grim Hex Orbital station can affect trade for another player, but it's a level of detail I wont bore you with by typing out a gigantic wall of text. But again, it's not fully fleshed out, and lacks a few elements, but it's not nothing, and what it is, is enough to have spawned a trade war among players, which we are having loads of fun with.
- Krasnol 8y agoThe only impressive thing about this is the exaggeration that is being played out here. Which is also a reason why I don't go to the related subreddit anymore. We are still talking about a absolute minimal part of what the end product is supposed to be and the cheering happening now is related to basic things that are not so bad anymore (FPS, server stability, etc.). Considering the time frame and the budget we're talking about here, its a joke...I wrote "everything" because it depends what the topic is with the fans the product is either not there "because it's Alpha" (even though with the PTU shouldn't it be pre Alpha?) or it's a great product because it's so fun now and so on. So maybe I should have rather said the product is in Shroedingers Box and we don't know what it is. In my opinion it's a terrible abomination and it reflects Roberts career and pretty much the worse things about the gaming industry today. I don't see a single good thing about what is happening there. I just hope nobody, ever will get the idea that this is a way of delivering a game or any kind of product.
- bovermyer 8y agoSaying the product lacks "everything" seems a little weird, considering how much there already is to do in the game. If I had to guess, I'd say you're either not a backer, or you haven't played recently.
- zamalek 8y agoTwo minutes on YouTube would demonstrate that the game isn't a scam. SC being a scam has become a meme/echo chamber, it doesn't really matter whether or not it's true. The game could launch and people would still call it a scam.
- iamdave 8y agoIt's really unfortunate the amount of FUD and cruft being spread about Star citizen, because it's an amazing experience that straddles the line between Simulator and MMORPG incredibly well for the state the game is at currently in the dev lifecycle. I haven't even played Elite:Dangerous in ages since the Alpha 3.1 update came out and Elite is one of my favorite space series of all time
- Laforet 8y ago>FUD I came into this thread looking for the acronym. Thanks for not letting me down. I mean, there are plenty of controversial topics being discussed on the internet, but I only see the F-word being used ad libtum when the topic is either cryptocurrency or Star Citizen. Perhaps these two have more in common than it looks?
- wlesieutre 8y agoThey aren’t starting a giant marketing campaign today, but Squadron 42 will need to be advertised as the release approaches. And AAA game advertising budgets are not small. They’re frequently as large or larger than the game’s development costs. For some examples, Shadow of the Tomb Raider and The Witcher 3 both had 35 million dollar marketing budgets. Grand Theft Auto V was 128 million. CoD: Modern Warfare 2 was 200 million. Since Roberts promised to only spend the crowdfunding money on game development, all that money has to come from somewhere. That means either signing on with a publisher, or taking outside investment.
- extrapickles 8y agoThey are completely crowd funded, and with how much they have raised (>$200 million), it would be silly for them to sign with a publisher or seek investment. In the beginning they were looking at signing investors, but they raised enough to not need that. Also, with the 2 million people who have already backed the game, they do not need to do traditional advertisements. They do have a presence at game conferences, and produce quite a bit of video about the development of the game as pretty much their only form of advertising.
- wlesieutre 8y agoThey raised that money in part by saying "We're going to spend this money on game development." I don't think they could turn around and spend $50M of it on advertising without inviting lawsuits.
- plopz 8y agoThey also said they were going to raise that money to make a game by 2014. A few people have successfully sued to get refunds but I don't think they care much about the original terms they used when raising money.
- Laforet 8y agoCIG's own legal argument is that they have already shipped the game in the form of 3.0 alpha, thus the ToS was amended to forbid any refund beyond the basic cooling off period following purchase. Challeges has so far not been successful.
- 13415 8y agoThey might need a lot of marketing to undo the damage that has already been done. I'm one of those who have been super interested in it during the past years but I wouldn't touch Star Citizen with a 10 foot pole now, after those "pay hundreds of dollars for alpha access" horror stories I've heard. And just for the record, despite liking space sims I'm also not planning to pay $27,000 for a starter pack.
- iamdave 8y agoI'm also not planning to pay $27,000 for a starter pack. Well the good news is a Star Citizen starter pack these days runs about the same cost as your average AAA game these days, give or take a few bucks.
- wlesieutre 8y agoIf anyone's wondering, $45 gets you Star Citizen, optional $15 add-on to also get Squadron 42. $60 total for the MMO and the single player game. You can't add SQ42 at that price later, so if you're interested in single player be sure to hit that checkbox.
- theandrewbailey 8y ago> And just for the record, despite liking space sims I'm also not planning to pay $27,000 for a starter pack. What are you talking about? You can get in for $35. https://robertsspaceindustries.com/pledge/game-packages https://robertsspaceindustries.com/pledge/game-packages
- kingaillas 8y agoOP is referring to the $27000 Legatus Pack (seemingly not on offer anymore) which had almost every ship in the game and some other stuff. https://robertsspaceindustries.com/spectrum/community/SC/forum/3/thread/the-legatus-pack/1199988 https://robertsspaceindustries.com/spectrum/community/SC/for...
- munchbunny 8y agoI've been following Star Citizen loosely since the first day the original crowdfunding campaign was launched, but I never backed it. The reason is this: at the time, it looked impossibly ambitious. Budget an order of magnitude larger than others, studio without a history, and too many promises of really ambitious game mechanics wrapped into a single package. I think you can't really blame anyone for smelling another Peter Molyneux style story brewing. Since then, I've spent time watching and the main problem is the same one I had with games like Destiny 2 at launch or Elite: Dangerous (played both, wish I had waited two more years). There's a kernel of fun in there, but that's where it ends, and there are plenty of other games out there that have both the kernel of fun and a fleshed out execution. Star Citizen doesn't look bad, it just looks incomplete against its ridiculous ambitions, and I'm lumping this in among games that will probably become complete a few iterations after release. I would much rather have the game as promised, but I've seen this pattern too many times before and there are too many other great games in the meantime for me to hold my breath for it.
- otachack 8y agoI have a free key I received with a graphics card...back in 2010/11 :/
- wlesieutre 8y agoOne of the AMD ones with the branded Mustang version? If you're not interested in using it, you could probably sell that for around $100. EDIT: this one https://starcitizen.fandom.com/wiki/Mustang_Omega https://starcitizen.fandom.com/wiki/Mustang_Omega
- fivefive55 8y agoIs that ship really worth that much? I also have an AMD Mustang Omega. I knew it would be special someday!
- wlesieutre 8y agoThat seems to be the going price recently, yeah. https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen_trades/search?q=Omega https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen_trades/search?q=Omega No idea how people handle escrow on those gray market transactions, maybe there are trusted middlemen who will do it for a cut. I’d be iffy on trading a limited edition ship to some random person online.
- fivefive55 8y agoWow, that's pretty wild, I figured they would be pretty common. I probably would never sell it anyway, but maybe it'll be worth even more by the time the game actually comes out. lol
- fapjacks 8y agoYes, that is the price that it fetches in the open market! Because enough people feel it provides them with at least that much value in return. For all the weird detractors (who seem hell-bent on telling other people what they should or should not enjoy), Star Citizen is a great game with a great future providing value to a thriving community.
- gamblor956 8y agoIt's more of a game than the abomination that is Fallout 76.
- mgazzer 8y agoI am unsure what you mean by everything. The early demos can certainly do more than anything currently on the market...
- y-c-o-m-b 8y agoPersonally I think even if they fail (though I prefer they succeed!), they've still done a wonderful thing. They are pushing boundaries far beyond what I thought was possible in modern games and that in itself is a great accomplishment. It's going to push more game developers to do the same and given the success of Red Dead Redemption 2 - which also pushed boundaries beyond what I expected - it seems we're going to be getting some really massive and immersive games in the not too distant future.
- simion314 8y agoabout RD2 , what do you mean it pushed boundaries? if are you referring at programming I want to know what you mean since I did not see anything new in it(just asking not want to contradict you). The graphics and animations are good but I seen similar on other games.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThe graphics and animations are more or less on par, it's the underlying mechanics where new ground is being driven. Star Citizen has taken the "simulation" approach to insane levels. There are so many things you can do in Star Citizen that just aren't possible in other games because of how they're designed. In a lot of games, each interior of a spaceship would be a map, and then you would have a map of each location you could exit the spaceship, and then you would effectively teleport at a doorway when you "exit the ship". (Think about how this works in Mass Effect. The "ship" that you run around on never actually "moves". It's much easier and more efficient to make a game this way for a lot of reasons. In Star Citizen, they actually move a ship around the map, and if you open the door, it opens the physical barrier between you and the outside world and you can see out of it. By keeping everyone and all objects "in space" all the time, Star Citizen allows some insanely different experiences that other games would have to specifically program functionality for.
- hartator 8y agoIn Battlefield 1942, you can steer a full aircraft carrier while other player spawn on it and small boats and aircrafts are taking off of it. And yes you can walk on it too. It was more than 16 years ago.
- dkns 8y ago> We may not have the resources that an Activision or EA have to launch one of their tentpole games GTA 5 had budget of $265M (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Development_of_Grand_Theft_Auto_V https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Development_of_Grand_Theft_Aut...). Assuming info on wiki is correct SC is nearing 200M (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Citizen#Funding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Citizen#Funding) which isn't too far off from GTA budget.
- siamakfr 8y agoI think they're referring to the marketing budget, which isn't accounted for in the development budget.
- squeaky-clean 8y agoThe quoted number is actually the entire budget, including marketing. > Media analyst Arvind Bhatia estimated the game's development budget exceeded US$137 million,[7] and The Scotsman reporter Marty McLaughlin estimated that the combined development and marketing efforts exceeded GB£170 million (US$265 million), making it the most expensive video game ever made at its time And here's wikipedia's source on the $137m https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2013-02-01-gta-v-dev-costs-over-USD137-million-says-analyst https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2013-02-01-gta-v-dev-...
- iooi 8y ago$265M was an estimate for both development and marketing, the estimate for the development alone was a bit over half, at $140M. So SC should already be over GTA V in terms of funding for development, as long as they're not forced to refund what they raised [1]. [1] https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/ne5n7b/star-citizen-court-documents-reveal-the-messy-reality-of-crowdfunding-a-dollar200-million-game https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/ne5n7b/star-citiz...
- e12e 8y agoBut gta v started with gta IV, right? The engine was overhauled and improved - but SC started from scratch, pretty much?
- fapjacks 8y agoThe thing about Star Citizen is that there's this super vocal minority of people that bought into some version of Derek Smart's bullshit. They decided that some aspect of Star Citizen is not exactly how games have worked in the past, or otherwise does not meet their expectations, and they are now rooting for failure -- any kind of failure. The fact of the matter is, the vast majority of backers (myself included) are happy with the way things have gone and are going. Or there are the few detractors who paid their $35 or whatever in 2014 being told in no uncertain terms that "this is a flexible project with flexible design goals and a flexible release schedule" and so are complaining about not having read about Star Citizen before buying into it. And so, as someone that has put multiple thousands of dollars into the game from the first week it was on Kickstarter, I am enormously pleased with how Star Citizen has been developed, and how it looks and plays now, and actually sincerely hope they push for a later release than 2019. I can wait for Chris Roberts' magnum opus.
- mattmanser 8y agoHow would you know? This sounds more like your opinion, or the opinion of an echo chamber like /r/starcitizen. Derek Smart seemed like an idiot, but the game still seems to be regarded as a total joke outside of that subdeddit (e.g. /r/games). I've no skin in the game apart from I loved the original wing commander, but it is funny looking over old threads in /r/starcitizen actually, here's one I just found where the top comment was saying it'd be too long if there wasn't a beta in 2018 (there wasn't) and that some Squadron 76 missions should have been released by then (they haven't): https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen/comments/4j211n/how_long_until_its_safe_to_say_the_game_is_taking/ https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen/comments/4j211n/how_lon...
- fapjacks 8y agoHave you played the game? I ask because you sound exactly like one of the people complaining because they can't for some reason handle how the game is developed, that its not going according to your expectations. If you don't plan to play Star Citizen, then why do you care how Star Citizen players feel about the game? CIG has been very clear from the start that Star Citizen's development will be unlike any other game before it, and they have been especially clear and emphasized that "it will be done when it's done".
- iooi 8y agoRelated discussion on HN about star citizen and their gross mismanagement/incompetence with their funds and time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17553371 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17553371
- mgazzer 8y agoThis story was a wash. A guy put a shit ton of money into a kickerstarter product and was expecting a fully fledged polished product. It's not a pre-order, buddy.
- leereeves 8y agoIf Kickstarter is a license to take millions of dollars then deliver something different four years late, why does anyone ever contribute to Kickstarter projects?
- mgazzer 8y agoIs it hard in this day in age to understand the difference of being part of bringing a product to life versus pre-ordering a product? Apple has set the bar so high that people turn off their brains.
- leereeves 8y ago"Being part of bringing a product to life" is usually something you're paid to do, not something you pay to do. Compared to being an employee collecting a salary or an investor collecting a share of the profit, Kickstarter is a terrible deal. Not a pre-order indeed. Not even a pre-order. Worse than a pre-order.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- izzydata 8y agoI get the impression that the future of gaming is not going to be massive AAA titles. They will start to not be economically viable very soon as we get to a max saturation of peoples time playing video games. With the over-abundance of good and "good enough" titles that took 1/100th of the time and money to create what sense does it make to have a 200 million dollar project?
- adrianN 8y agoFor the same reason it still makes sense to make very expensive movies even though anybody can invest a few grand into good equipment and make their own.
- learc83 8y agoThere are game types that just aren't possible without massive budgets. Huge open world games in particular can't be made without a large team of content creators[1]. For games like Red Dead Redemption, Breath of the Wild, etc... there isn't anything close to comparable coming out of a small studio anytime in the near future. Even CD Projekt Red, which is based in a low cost of living country spent $81 million developing The Witcher III. A small studio with a $2 million budget has absolutely no chance of making something that players who expect The Witcher III will think is good enough. And as technology (and budgets) progress, gamers expect more. More art, more story, more quests. The kind of content that we are nowhere near auto-generating. 1. I shouldn't say can't be made--can't be made up to the standards players expect. No Man's Sky and other games have tried, but procedural generation just doesn't come close to matching the quality and detail of more hand crafted open worlds.
- Ralfp 8y agoI would like to mention Avorion. Its sandbox space game developed by two guys with heavy emphasis on user-created content and procedural generation that I've bought on Steam sale two years ago for 7EUR and devs are still updating it adding new features and fixing issues: https://store.steampowered.com/app/445220/Avorion/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/445220/Avorion/ Its considerably small and limited in scope, yet game progression feels rewarding enough that some people (me included) have clocked hundreds of hours doing it. This is the kind of game I feel we need more of. Small games focused on limited number of features, continously improving those features.
- raesene9 8y agoI've been very interested in following the divergant paths of Star Citizen and Elite:Dangerous which are similar projects which started at roughly the same time (both kickstarted in 2012) E:D seem to have taken the route of getting an MVP out and functional and have been iterating on that base since then adding new content, play modes, platforms etc. As a result they had a playable game out in 2014. SC seems to have gone more for a big bang approach of only launching once they've got more in place with, from the blog post, an alpha in 2020.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoSC is already in playable alpha, and has been for years. It's Squadron 42 (the single player mode) that's planned for 2020.
- raesene9 8y agoyep but unless I'm misreading the original kickstarter https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/cig/star-citizen https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/cig/star-citizen promised the single player mode in 2014
- theandrewbailey 8y agoThat was before the funding took off, and Roberts decided to scale it up in response. Edit: The page reads "estimated". "Estimated" isn't "promised".
- fapjacks 8y agoWe have quite different interpretations of the word "promise". For the sake of your real-world relationships, maybe don't throw that word around so easily, at least without someone actually using that word in the first place.
- libraryatnight 8y agoI've watched people play the alpha on streams and jesus it looks boring and terrible.
- ghostbrainalpha 8y agoThe roadmap they created is pretty fucking incredible, and it definitely inspires me to put more effort into my Asana/Basecamp/Trello Boards... https://robertsspaceindustries.com/roadmap/board/2-Squadron-42 https://robertsspaceindustries.com/roadmap/board/2-Squadron-... But serious question, how long did it take to make this roadmap? Like was there a roadmap for the roadmap project?
- xemdetia 8y agoIt felt like especially early on planning fueled contributions which they used to update and expand the existing plans which fueled more contributions. I think that's one of the reasons why it feels/felt kind of stupid to the outside observer where it felt like they were just planning to expand the game to chase more money rather than start working on the game.
- jdlshore 8y agoThey have a third-party contractor, Turbulent [1], that builds their website, including the roadmap visualization. The data from the roadmap comes from CIG's internal Jira. There's some sort of automated export once every week. I presume they tag Jira items in some way so they show up on the roadmap. They've been providing a roadmap for Star Citizen (the MMO counterpart to Squadron 42) for a year. It's been reasonably accurate about what will be delivered in the next quarter, with only a few things slipping. It's been mostly inaccurate about the following quarter. Longer term plans are almost always delayed. It's reasonable to assume the SQ42 roadmap will experience the same sorts of delays and I think plotting out a roadmap to this level of detail was a mistake. I think it reflects a culture of wishful thinking among CIG's upper management and the delays will inflame the fans and the press. [1] https://www.turbulent.ca/en https://www.turbulent.ca/en (To be clear: I don't think there's anything wrong with delays. Software is always delayed. The mistake isn't the delays; it's believing the estimates.)
- ghostbrainalpha 8y agoThey have 4 Tasks left to complete on the Roadmap in Q4 of 2018. So 9 days, and Christmas/New Years Eve Holidays to deal with. I think they are in real danger of fucking up their 2 roadmap within the first week of releasing it. I hope for their sake they didn't publish this without getting a few of those tasks basically finished ahead of time so they could at least start off in a way that made it look like they could follow their own schedule.
- wedn3sday 8y agoTheir roadmap is pulled directly from their JIRA database, so if a task slips a week or so due to holidays, the next update will reflect that. If you look back at their previous roadmap updates, they knock way more then 4 tasks out a week, but even if they miss their target they can "fuck up" the road map since it will just update with the new status next week.
- shmerl 8y ago> a complete overhaul of the game code to run on multiple CPU cores simultaneously Did they switch to Vulkan already to do it? In the past they said, that was the plan. Also, no word on Linux version in this announcement.
- 0xffff2 8y agoWhy would switching to Vulkan have anything to do with making the CPU code multithreaded?
- djinnandtonic 8y agoI never backed Star Citizen, though I keep an ear out for updates here and there. It seems like Derek Smart has come up in every thread about SC for a few years now. Why? Google tells me he developed a similar singleplayer game a long time ago and is currently working on some kind of online venture. Is he attached to the SC project?
- figgis 8y agoI never heard about the guy until today and spent a little while searching.. I can say I am absolutely stumped why this guy is getting any attention at all. All the profiles he's written about himself seem extremely conceited. His posts present hyperbole and opinions as fact. And to top it all off, the exact things he is criticizing SC for he has done himself with his most recent game Line of Defense... https://steamcommunity.com/groups/acpreport/discussions/3/483368526590539030/#c490124466457425075 https://steamcommunity.com/groups/acpreport/discussions/3/48... Dude has an entire subreddit where a majority of the users seem to be devoted to "calling his crap out": https://www.reddit.com/r/DerekSmart/ https://www.reddit.com/r/DerekSmart/ And of course encyclopediadramatica has their own page on the guy (of course nothing there should be taken at face value, just found it amusing after reading up on him): https://encyclopediadramatica.rs/Derek_Smart https://encyclopediadramatica.rs/Derek_Smart
- iamtom 8y agoYou appear to be a Star Citizen backer. The composition of those statements are a dead giveaway because it contains all the same talking points you guys spread around to attack him for voicing his opinions on the project. Line Of Defense isn't crowd-funded. It was released on Steam Early Access. His games traditionally take a long time to develop and release because they are complex, and he doesn't have a large team or resources. Comparing an indie funding his own games to a company that has taken over $200 million Dollars in crowd-funding, and also investor money, is laughably foolish.
- figgis 8y agoOr, crazy idea, I did my own searching on the guy and came to the conclusion I just posted above.. His twitter alone could be used in a psychology course.
- everyone 8y agoAs far as I can tell, this game is still an utter clusterfuck. From a basic technical point of view, there have been fundamental flaws that have been there from its inception in 2011, that have never been fixed. They just keep throwing more crap on top of it making it buggier and buggier. Its the poster child for the sunken cost fallacy. From a gameplay perspective, it hasnt gotten to a point where Ive been been able to even speculate on that. Their gameplay concept seems to be: build a big online sandbox and then... fun will magically appear, and they've iterated on this less than 1 time so far, so my expectations are about as low as possible. Also any time I've played it, every kind of interaction (flying, walking, UI, everything) is a mess, and feels terrible. I dearly want this to be my dream game, but my professional opinion is that if it ends up being any kind of decently playable game at all it would be a miracle.
- h1d 8y agoI want to read about those flaws in detail but do you have any articles or blog posts links of such?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JeffL 8y agoIt's interesting reading this thread as one of the founders of Star Sonata, a space MMO that launched in 2004. Star Citizen has a lot of hype and a lot of money, but people seem to hate the game/results. Our players for the most part love our game and keep playing and subscribing even after more than a decade, but I can't for the life of me get the marketing right, so have been unable to bring in new players in any kind of numbers. I just wish 1% of the players who paid for Star Citizen even knew about Star Sonata. For a while back in 2007-ish Google ads were working really well and bringing in paying players at about $35 cost to acquire each and they were worth more than $200 over their lifetime, but something changed almost over night and Google ads got more competitive and almost no amount of money would bring people in. I'm sitting here with a game that people like and will pay for but can't figure out anymore how to acquire them.
- datamingle 8y agoPay a Twitch.tv streamer who plays similar games to play your game?
- aresant 8y agoThe "something" that changed is that private equity (and even banks) figured out how to financially model MMOs just like SAAS. I think Tomasz Tunguz illustrates this concept beautifully in considering SAAS / MMOs as annuities (1) With little incremental cost to each additional user, and predictable revenue over time, the customer acquisition cost becomes highly flexible if you can finance it (or leverage it). As a result it's become an arms race and a common VC model today is to spend 2 - 3x total annual revenue in marketing spend to land grab new channels while the "annuity" cost is low. If you're open to sharing more details you may spark somebody's attention on HN :) - I personally invest in SAAS / MMO / CRE + bring customer acquisition expertise (and a team) for cases exactly like this - although we try to target some minimum scale ($5m+ ARR / ASR) (1) https://tomtunguz.com/recurring-gross-margin-dollar-efficiency/ https://tomtunguz.com/recurring-gross-margin-dollar-efficien...
- JeffL 8y agoHappy to share more information but don't want to hijack the thread too much. Would love to talk to you about this stuff sometime if you'd be interested. My email is in my profile.
- jokoon 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Citizen#Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Citizen#Controversy Wow, the timeline is an horror story. I don't understand the appeal of space opera games like this. They will mostly be empty zones of players. I also have ideas to make an ambitious video game, with persistence and an open world. But I would rather start small and humble by releasing something that is playable, add cool features as the development progresses, but still providing basic features and playability at first, that would be slowly replaced by the more advanced features of the game. Making a game attractive quickly from the beginning is important, especially if you're using the crowdfunding model. Today it's possible to have a continuous evolution of a game, to constantly change and improve it. The hardest will always be to track player locations in realtime, on a large world, while keeping the game smooth enough. Once that is done, the sky is the limit. I don't understand why so many games focus on the content (because that can be an real time and money sink), while the only things that are attractive for such games are the gameplay and the multiplayer.
- erikpukinskis 8y ago> They will mostly be empty zones of players. They plan to have a complete Sims-like ecology of NPCs, and players will fit into that.
- Krasnol 8y agoYeah, they plan to have hundreds of systems. Now they have one planet and a few moons and not even that is finished. What is the time frame here? Decades? I mean seriously, why is anyone believing this?
- dabeledo 8y agoI don't follow the development of this game but I can imagine they have plans to allow user-generated content to be added to the game through some kind of system. And if they don't have plans, they should.
- 8y ago
- MR4D 8y agoIn other news, the main character will be renamed Duke Nukem.
- mesozoic 8y agoCongrats guys for making the world record Micro transaction sale of $46 million. All that without ever even making a game!