12 ms·
Google Employees Demand the End of Forced Arbitration Across the Tech Industry
- matte_black 8y agoIt's like you can't even run a tech company anymore.
- detcader 8y agoGetting rid of company-handled arbitration sounds less work for the tech companies?
- matte_black 8y agoNo? It's much faster and cheaper to deal with the arbitration yourself than to have all the dirty laundry aired out in public courts, which will almost certainly be a long, expensive process.
- detcader 8y agoIf only us men stopped using women like objects at such a rate that it bears statistically significant stress on the scale of the industry! Then most businesses would need to spend zero time and money.
- StreamBright 8y agoI am not sure what you are implkying here but most (95%+) men do not use women like object in western countries.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vedantroy 8y agoIf you don't want to have your "dirty laundry aired out in public courts", then don't have dirty laundry.
- matte_black 8y agoNo one tries to have dirty laundry, and if you are a company of any significant size there’s going to be dirty laundry regardless.
- munk-a 8y agoI don't accept this statement. If employees attempting to seek redress over HR issues would hurt the image of a company than that company has some really toxic stuff going on.
- Finch2192 8y ago"Yourself"? I am quite sure you are not aware of the issue here. We're talking about binding, or forced arbitration. Often times, people are unaware that they are being forced into arbitration, and when they are, it severely limits their legal recourse. There's little reason to support it, unless you're a huge company with liability concerns. Here's a good source on the matter: https://www.consumeradvocates.org/for-consumers/arbitration https://www.consumeradvocates.org/for-consumers/arbitration
- rcw4256 8y agoThen don't force it. If it truly is best for both parties, both parties will opt for it. It doesn't need to be required.
- beginningguava 8y agoI'd say it's a good thing overall for employees to have more power, it means that supply and demand is favoring workers. Look for big tech to push for more H1B Visas to shift things in their favor by saying there's a "talent shortage". The H1Bs don't have the luxury of protesting stuff like this because they can be deported if they get out of line plus it drives down wages
- karmasimida 8y agoOr Google would just grow dev centers elsewhere. No need for H1Bs in that case.
- dang 8y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? We've asked you several times. If you can't or won't stop, we're going to ban you. If you'd review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use this site as intended, we'd be grateful.
- ageek123 8y agoI love how the headline is "Google Employees" instead of "35 Google Employees." I guess the latter would make it too obvious that this is just Techcrunch pushing an agenda.
- detcader 8y agoEvery journalist has an agenda... remember NY Times' "enhanced interrogation"?
- tareqak 8y agoLet’s be honest and ask, “Who doesn’t have an agenda?”
- munk-a 8y ago> “Who doesn’t have an agenda?” People who are lying. And journalists having an agenda isn't a bad thing, they just need to stop listening to modern journalist "fair and balanced" lessons from college. When ever you're writing an article make it clear what your general opinion on the subject is so that people can incorporate it into their understanding of your statements. I'd much rather just have transparency of opinion than today's "fair and balanced". Today's news is (generally) written to avoid authors expressing their opinion openly, but sources and statistics will be cherry picked to reinforce their opinion. If that opinion was openly stated it'd be easier to confirm whether the statistics are reasonable neutral or misleading.
- tareqak 8y agoI totally agree. I actually find the "X has an agenda argument" misleading at best in that person stating it is implying that they don't have their own, or that their own agenda is beyond reproach.
- ddingus 8y agoAs long as that agenda is known, it can be factired into process to arrive at more equitable outcomes. Not talking honestly about agendas actually does everyone a lot of harm.
- mschuster91 8y agoFor the content of the article: it's amazing (in a negative way) with how much utter crap companies are able to get away. I get that the US takes pride in individual liberty, but allowing companies that much leverage including forcing employees to relinquish their right to a court of law is abhorrent. For the presentation of the article: anyone from Techcrunch reading? The site looks like shit on tablets. In a webview after 500ms the site goes blank, only the footer remains. In Chrome, the article is 40% of the screen, the right side is some ad. What the fuck?
- ummonk 8y agoCalifornia keeps trying to ban mandatory arbitration in contracts, and federal courts keep ruling against the state on the grounds that the Federal Arbitration Act pre-empts California law.
- TomMckenny 8y ago>the US takes pride in individual liberty In many states it is unlawful to negotiate Union favored closed shops. Not to mention arbitrary bans on alcohol sales and nude beaches and intermittent restrictions on teaching natural selection or climate change. In much of the county, language around liberty is not remotely about individuals but is used disingenuously to drive voters to act against their own interest.
- masonic 8y agounlawful to negotiate Union favored closed shops Agency shop has the exact same effect, unless your employment predates the union. You are still constrained to the CBA and have to pay full dues.
- TomMckenny 8y agoJust pointing out that employment requirements such as non compete, inventions clause, forced arbitration and others are all legal under the (dubious) notion that employees can just work elsewhere. But a union membership requirement is outlawed. Seems a double standard.
- tanilama 8y agoHad Google ignored their demand, what would they fo then?
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoSome Googlers have already discussed a strike (as Google refused a number of other demands from the walkout) and have raised money to support Googlers who may be financially constrained in a strike situation. Some have resigned, and others have made plans to leave in the near future.
- matte_black 8y agoWhat exactly would a strike at Google do? Will the servers stop running?
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoSince a significant number of protesting employees are SREs (site reliability engineers), there's a non-zero chance that problems that arise would not be dealt with as promptly if there was a strike, depending on how many SREs joined the strike and what they were responsible for. At Google scale, technical failures arise regularly, so even in a short period of time, this would likely have some impact. It would certainly be an interesting way to test their resiliency to failure.
- CydeWeys 8y agoThere's a lot of room between "nothing" and "all Google services stop running". Reduced trajectory on new feature development, for instance. I'm sure you can figure this out if you think about it.
- deogeo 8y agoHow forced arbitration is legal in the US never made sense to me. If the clause was "In the case of a dispute, we win.", it'd be deemed invalid by the courts. But since it's "In the case of a dispute, we have an overwhelming advantage in a private court.", that makes it valid?
- shados 8y ago> In the case of a dispute, we win Wasn't there an article recently about some predatory lending practice where the lender made you sign a clause essentially letting them win in any dispute? And it got enforced a bunch?
- nowarninglabel 8y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18560153 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18560153 (which also links other comment threads on it)
- frei 8y agoConfession of judgement is what the clause is called.
- secabeen 8y agoWe should really pass a federal law prohibiting arbitration in contracts of adhesion.
- gpm 8y agoWe should just ban arbitration outright. It's a clear violation of the right to a fair and public trial (seventh amendment in the US, but more generally the human right), no matter what the courts say. Even if you believe that arbitrators attempt to be fair and correctly apply the law, there are numerous public policy issues with them, for some examples: - The well known principle that it's not enough for the system to seem fair, it must appear to be fair. - The lack of an appeals system. Real courts screw up all the time and there is 0 evidence to believe that arbitrators are better. - The lack of case law developed, leading to re litigating issues and no clarity for future controversies. - The lack of checks and balances, regardless of how fair arbitrators are today there is no way to stop them from becoming corrupt in the future.
- brightball 8y agoI know this won't be popular...but I don't understand why people are so anti-arbitration. Court cases are very expensive, regardless of the verdict. In the situation of running a business, you have a 1 business to many employees situation handling multiple cases simultaneously could get extremely expensive whether the cases are valid or not. People use the threat of legal fees to extort business owners all the time because all it takes is one bored attorney who's willing to take the case on contingency while the business is looking at $150-500 / hr fees to defend itself. Happens to doctors constantly. If you are a business that employees thousands of people the amount of potential legal costs could put you under entirely, because attorneys have to respond to every single claim that opposing attorneys make. These techniques exist almost solely to drive up legal costs. When your potential cost for an employee is far higher than the actual compensation you can afford to pay, it significantly increases your risk for every job you can create. This is usually a two way street as well. In nearly every contractor agreement I've read, the liability for the hired contractor is limited to at most the amount of compensation they receive from the business for the job they were performing.
- ct520 8y agoBut you soon realize arbitration is a scheme that simply screws you over. Check out all the good nytime articles on it... then see for yourself https://levelplayingfield.io https://levelplayingfield.io
- brightball 8y agoIs there a particular type of search I should be looking for on there? Glancing through employment related search seems fairly balanced with some going either way and many being settled.
- tareqak 8y agoHave you ever gone through forced arbitration? If being forced through the court system is undesirable / one-sided and forced arbitration feels the same, then there should be something in the middle that is fair for both workers and employers, right? I don’t see why this issue has to be a zero-sum game.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 40acres 8y agoHonestly seems like we may be headed toward unionization, it may not happen within the next 5 years or so but silicon valley mega-giants sell a bill of goods to their employees regarding how they are all about changing the world for the better, but when analyzing their day to day operations it's obviously a lot murkier. I think workers are really starting to see through the wool and demand that their companies act as ethically as they claim.
- mc32 8y agoUnionization is not a panacea. Unionization may be able to preserve jobs and defend employees from employer strongarming tactics but on the converse, it can protect employees who would have otherwise been fired for improprieties and other less attractive ideas as well as those simply not pulling their weight any longer.
- commandlinefan 8y agoThere's good and there's bad to unions, absolutely. There's good and there's bad to lack of unions, too, though. At some point, the negatives of unionization outweigh the positives - if employers were smart, they'd work to make sure that doesn't happen.
- sethammons 8y agoseems to me that employers are working to make sure that doesn't happen. Pay is very, very good. Most of us make multiples of median household income in our respective areas. Plus have better working conditions.
- heavyset_go 8y agoEngineer pay hasn't kept up with productivity gains, inflation and increases in cost of living expenses. The fact is that engineers create an increasing amount of value, and their compensation hasn't increased sufficiently to reflect that. In fact, Adobe, Apple, Google, Intel, Intuit, Pixar and eBay were found guilty of colluding to keep engineer pay artificially low through anti-poaching agreements[1]. [1] Apple, Google, Intel, Adobe will pay $415 million in anti-poach deal - http://fortune.com/2015/09/03/koh-anti-poach-order/ http://fortune.com/2015/09/03/koh-anti-poach-order/
- BMorearty 8y agoI am so glad to see this movement. We've needed this for decades. But please, let's not limit this to the tech industry. Forced arbitration should be made illegal as a condition of employment in the U.S. And if it's not something that can be legislated nationwide (the Supreme Court rejected Susan Fowler's appeal), let's do it state by state.
- munk-a 8y agoSadly a state-by-state approach would leave a lot of employees stuck without options in the most vulnerable positions. I am not unhappy to see this start in the tech industry, white collar workers have much more power to effect change in their workplace than blue collar workers... But I am similarly concerned that this might not be carried to other industries (or for it to be limited to a small number of companies that slowly reverse their policy due to "competitive issues")
- CydeWeys 8y agoThe idea would be to eventually transition from state-by-state to nationwide, it's just easier to do it one state at a time than try to go from 0 to 100 with the whole nation at once. Some advancements that have been made state-by-state and then finally nationwide, rather than nationwide all at once, include the abolition of slavery, gay marriage, and currently in process, marijuana decriminalization.
- tdhoot 8y agoThe case was Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis. Not Susan Fowler's appeal, but her lawyers filed a brief in support.
- pseudalopex 8y agoFederal law preempts state law. What can states do without Congress repealing the Federal Arbitration Act?
- kevin_b_er 8y agoIt cannot be done state by state, it has been ruled as a federal law and states are powerless to protect their citizens from predatory corporations at this time.
- throw2016 8y agoEvery single part of the economic system is organized into industry groups, lobbying groups, industry associations and everyone thinks its perfectly natural for them to group together to promote and push their collective interest. No individualism there. Google, Facebook, Twitter and others are part of multiple such industry associations and lobbying groups. But curiously when it comes to labor suddenly collective action becomes anathema? This is not logical. Isn't it high time anti-union propaganda and demonizing unions on the flawed logic of 'bad unions make all unions bad' ie some banks are corrupt so banking as a concept is bad is jettisoned for informed discussion. The key word in this case is 'forced'. If you prefer company managed arbitration then you should be able to 'choose' it. Similarly those who see it as fundamentally flawed should have the freedom to choose due process in a court of law as is the right of every citizen.
- winstonewert 8y agoThese companies presumably have these forced arbitration clauses in order to save money. There costs would increase if they no longer had these clauses. Where is that money going to come from? I'd suggest it probably comes from lower employee salaries. Further, the deck seems pretty stacked in favour of the company in court anyways. They have a team of lawyers each way more expensive than any lawyer I'll be able to afford. Not to mention the time and effort that would spent suing a company when I'd really rather be moving on with my life. So its not at clear to me that I'm worse off with forced arbitration. Without it, I'd have a lower salary and only slighter better chance of winning a suit against my employer.
- 0x262d 8y agogoogle has 50 billion dollars in cash lmao court is unfavorable but it's less unfavorable if you do a class action lawsuit, which is the whole point.
- winstonewert 8y agoGoogle having 50 billion dollars in cash is irrelevant. What makes you think they'd spend that on legal fees/settlements? Perhaps I've got a better chance of winning a class action suit, but it probably returns me as an individual a tiny amount of money. Still not a winning proposition.
- madhadron 8y agoYou don't have to sign the forced arbitration clause in many places. I didn't sign one at my current employer. I had to explicitly do a little extra paperwork to do so, but I don't have a forced arbitration clause.
- norswap 8y agoIt's anyone's guess why this is even legal in the US...