7 ms·
So it cost $66 million and saved $40 million. That's impressive. I assume most of the saving is from grid stabilisation, rather than supplying/storing energy b
by benj111 8y ago
So it cost $66 million and saved $40 million.
That's impressive. I assume most of the saving is from grid stabilisation, rather than supplying/storing energy but still.
Why is this not more wide spread? These figures suggest this is a no brainer. Am I missing something?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 8y agoIt's new and the procurement cycles for these things are long. Also, Australia is coal country.
- sschueller 8y agoHow long do these batteries last?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoAt least a decade. This is why most grid services/frequency response revenue is going to be cannibalized from legacy thermal by utility scale battery storage. Energy arbitrage is still a thing, but a smaller percentage of revenue compared to grid services (at least in Australia). Disclaimer: TSLA investor
- qaq 8y agoif it lasts even 2 years it was already a good investment
- wirelessest 8y ago...if disposal is free
- LeonM 8y agoActually, lithium is quite valuable and can be recycled into new batteries. I don't have the numbers, but AFIAK, disposal is cashflow positive. Edit: see hwillis's comment down below, he/she is obviously more knowledgeable about the topic than I am. I was wrong.
- Scoundreller 8y agoI’ve heard quite the opposite: recycling lithium is difficult. Maybe the other metals in the batteries make it worth recycling, but not for the lithium recovery (with today’s tech).
- batmansmk 8y agoI read on Wikipedia quite the opposite: we don't recycle Lithium it because it costs 5 times more than freshly extracted lithium. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battery_recycling#Lithium_ion_batteries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battery_recycling#Lithium_ion_... If my math is correct, the battery needs to last at least 10 years to break even if you factor in the cost of recycling the lithium.
- et2o 8y agoRecycled lithium might cost 5x more. Not that the disposal cost of a battery is 5x the purchase price. If the battery pays for its purchase price in 2 years and the disposal cost is 1/2 the price of a new battery (doubt it's anywhere near that), then the it would still pay for the total cost of ownership in 3 years.
- 64738 8y agoFrom what I understand, used-up lithium batteries are fairly non-toxic and can be safely dumped in a landfill. Still not zero-cost, but probably about as low as you can get. And they can probably recover some of that cost by recycling some of the other metals from them.
- danans 8y agoEV batteries can be repurposed for small-scale grid storage applications, and therefore can have a second life for many years before they are finally broken down to raw ingredients for recycling: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-27/where-3-million-electric-vehicle-batteries-will-go-when-they-retire https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-27/where-3-m...
- village-idiot 8y agoLong enough for this to be a no brainer. Also the biggest issue with consumer batteries is typically heat management. Industrial batteries with proper thermal control systems will exhibit much better lifespans than a typical iPhone. Thus you should adjust your expectations for these batteries compared to what you’ve seen in consumer electronics.
- pedrocr 8y agoThat's true and the reason that electric cars will work much better than most expected, with no need for a battery change during the life of the car. Here though part of the reason for the huge savings in one year is the market was in such dire need they've worked the battery hard. The return on investment is still stellar I'm sure, beating even the best initial estimates. But the battery will most likely not last as long as in the original estimates either.
- gardnr 8y agoYour question is answered in the article.
- ReptileMan 8y agoWe are missing mostly production capacity. Also - what is the longevity of the battety? It may break even in two years time but if cells need to be recycled at the fourth year it may not be as good as it looks like.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- URSpider94 8y agoEven if it is scrapped after four years, if it keeps generating this kind of savings for that period, it’s still a 600% return on capital. Turning $40MM today to $240MM 4 years from now is a deal any business would take in a heartbeat.
- benj111 8y agoI think your maths is off. $40m * 4 = $160m $240m / $40m = 6 years Edit: Mixed up cost and income?
- SEJeff 8y agoTesla gives their powerpacks a 10 year full warranty but projects a 15 year lifespan.
- mikeash 8y agoMy car is almost four years old and its battery has lost about 1% capacity. These things don’t wear out that quickly.
- OldSchoolJohnny 8y agoJudging from the article I think it's a proof of concept or similar stage.
- benj111 8y agoBut its not like battery technology is advancing so quickly, and prices dropping so fast, that this is only just becoming profitable. Based on these figures this would have been profitable years ago. The only plausible reason I can come up with is that the 'savings' are very hard to attribute correctly, but then I still cant explain why no one before today noticed the potential savings and took a chance. Anyone with experience in the industry have any thoughts?
- codeulike 8y agoguess: Its a politics driven industry and no-one wanted to take the chance to try something that hadn't been tried anywhere else in the world at this scale before.
- gph 8y ago>But its not like battery technology is advancing so quickly, and prices dropping so fast, that this is only just becoming profitable I wonder if there was even the capability to manufacture such a large order at the given price point before Tesla built their gigafactory.
- chrisbrandow 8y agoBattery manufacturing is actually advancing fairly quickly. The costs has been dropping at a pretty steady, steep rate for last 15-20 years.
- cowsandmilk 8y ago(a) It takes several years to plan a project and then build it. So, this decision was made years ago, not "today". (b) Battery prices (and pricing for the balance of the system) have dropped pretty rapidly, I'm not sure why you're claiming otherwise. There have been recent years where these systems have dropped in price by ~25%[1]. That's not insignificant. [1] https://www.utilitydive.com/news/not-so-fast-battery-prices-will-continue-to-decrease-but-at-a-slower-pace/518776/ https://www.utilitydive.com/news/not-so-fast-battery-prices-...
- hwillis 8y ago> Why is this not more wide spread? These figures suggest this is a no brainer. Am I missing something? Grid infrastructure isn't exactly agile. It's politics.
- Faaak 8y agoAt least in Switzerland (Swissgrid loco), this is not true at all (for AS and frequency control) The complete process is documented end to end, free to see, and the enroll process in documented and "cheap" (~150kCHF, 100kCHF being for the warranty). You can start playing in the ancillary services field with 5MW, which is not that much. PS: If a company in CH needs help in that field (process approval or swissgrid-compatible IT systems), let me know !
- BeeOnRope 8y agoThe particular grid economics of Southern Australia are not reproduced everywhere else. It is all about the dynamics and regulations of the spot market, existing short term generating capacity, and the capabilities of the other market participants. The batteries didn't "save" $40 million of electricity, they enabled one entity (Southern Australia's power operator) to trade more efficiently against the other participants, who were the losers in this battery deployment in the form of reduced profits.
- tinus_hn 8y agoNote that the amounts are in AUD dollaridoos, it's $48m USD for saving $29m USD. The savings are because you can use the energy generated by green sources to charge the battery if you can't use it immediately. That's free energy you'd otherwise throw away.
- starshadowx2 8y agoIt's not in AUD, it's in USD. From the linked article for cost - "The French energy company revealed that the entire system cost 56 million euros (~$66 million USD)"
- zik 8y ago> The savings are because you can use the energy generated by green sources to charge the battery if you can't use it immediately Not true. The system is used for grid stabilisation rather than large scale power storage. It doesn't have the capacity to power South Australia for more than a few minutes at most.
- ph0rque 8y agoSo it paid for itself in 1.65 years, which comes out to an ROI of ~52%. Why is this not more widespread? There must be some barriers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mtgx 8y agoAnd battery storage is only getting cheap, I believe at a rate of roughly 15-20% per year.
- ams6110 8y agoYet we also hear that battery production is a bottleneck and the reason why automakers other than Tesla are so limited in their EV offerings.
- rootusrootus 8y agoOther automakers are limited in their offerings because they didn't commit with any enthusiasm until a few years ago, and the development time for a new car is at least that long. There are a whole bunch of new EV options coming to market in the next year or so.
- ZeroGravitas 8y agoI think part of the savings don't go directly to the battery owner, but instead prevent the electricity suppliers from price gouging the customer. Happens a lot with renewables. You personally don't capture all the value you provide. This is part of the reason that rooftop solar should get paid more than the going rate but even 1:1 rates get attacked as some kind of scam, even as they reduce peak load which may be literally 1000x more expensive than average.
- Scoundreller 8y agoCorrect. A proper grid system would pay a premium for the size of the solar grid that fulfills solar-induced demands. After that, solar should get paid grid rate. I have no idea if anyone has bothered to calculate what the solar-induced demand is.
- Tuna-Fish 8y agoThe South Australian grid was particularly degenerate, making this more profitable there than elsewhere. It does make at least some sense in most places, though.
- smoyer 8y agoI remember there being a day earlier this year where the prices for wind-generated electricity in west Texas flipped. If you have to pay people to take your electricity (instead of spinning a generator down), why not store it for a later demand period?
- olau 8y agoIt doesn't make sense to store something for later unless the storage costs are lower than the cost of reproducing what you need. A few periods per year of negative prices won't be enough to offset the investment in batteries.
- i_cant_speel 8y agoI was under the impression that large scale energy storage is one of the big problems with renewable energy that has yet to be truly solved.
- EmbarrassedFuel 8y agoDon’t forget the stochastic control problem that needs to be solved to stop the whole grid blowing up!
- Brometheus 8y agohttps://www.energymeteo.com/products/virtual_power_plant/the_virtual_power_plant.php https://www.energymeteo.com/products/virtual_power_plant/the...
- makomk 8y agoThe amount of energy that is stored in batteries like this isn't that big in grid-scale terms. For example, on the night that Texas wind generation flipped electricity prices into the negative back in September 2015, their wind turbines alone were pumping out almost 11,500 MW of power. This has a capacity of 129 MWh. It's useful for grid stabilization because it can start up almost instantly and fill in the gap until another generation source which can run for more than the 90 minutes the battery lasts can start up, but less practical for longer-term storage. (The 90 minutes capacity at full output is pretty much an inherent property of lithium battery tech, as I understand it. There's a slight capacity vs power tradeoff which can be tweaked, but only within a relatively narrow band, and the maximum charging rate is if anything even less flexible than the discharge.) Also, it looks like there's already a small-scale battery bank providing frequency stabilization using Samsung lithium ion batteries in West Texas: https://www.energy-storage.news/news/minimal-downtime-younicos-swaps-out-lead-acid-for-lithium-at-texas-notrees https://www.energy-storage.news/news/minimal-downtime-younic...
- jartelt 8y agoIt is beginning to happen in the US. Battery adoption on the grid has been slow because the utility companies like solving problems by building new generation plants (natural gas plants mostly) or by building new transmission lines. They have historically always done this and they make a guaranteed rate of return on this type of infrastructure. This has led to lots of un-needed generation capacity and expensive transmission projects passed on to rate payers. Regulators in many states are now finally forcing utilities to examine the use of alternative solutions to fix grid issues. They are finding that battery installations can do a better job than new generation or transmission in many cases and the batteries can be cheaper over the long run. It's just a matter of getting the utilities to try something new and get out of their typical playbook.
- neolefty 8y ago> I assume most of the saving is from grid stabilisation, rather than supplying/storing energy but still. Yes, the entire reported savings was by avoiding building a fast-response generator, which would cost tens of millions to maintain each year. From the article: > Has contributed to the removal of the requirement for a 35 MW local Frequency Control Ancillary Service (FCAS), saving nearly $40 million per year in typical annual costs The article several includes other significant benefits as well that aren't even included in the $40 million.