9 ms·
All 90s GUIs have something that I miss[1]. I think the flat movement was a desire for hyper genericity .. but turns out that a bit (just a bit) of visual signa
by agumonkey 8y ago
All 90s GUIs have something that I miss[1]. I think the flat movement was a desire for hyper genericity .. but turns out that a bit (just a bit) of visual signal and faux skeumorphism (some widgets emulated actual LED keys found on hardware) is good.
ps: also, flat came after both the aqua trend where effects were everywhere and skeumorphism was pushed higher. Not that surprising in a way.
[1] beos, win311, macos classic, win95 (office97 era) and nt5
- marcosdumay 8y agoI mis those from the 90's GUIs: - Standard interaction widgets. There was no breaking the scroll, there was no button that you can't discover how to press. - Expert oriented interfaces. There was no action without a shortcut. The most complex software always had some CLI or an API (optionally with an intepreter). - Discoverability features. The sortcut descriptions were embedded on the same places you had to click to get the functionality. Buttons were clearly marked. There was almost always some text area telling you what was happening. I don't miss skeumorphism, but it was often used to mark real features, and those features were gone with the arbitrary skeumorphisms. Current GUI trends were created by people with no interest on making their software useful, instead they only keep an eye on showroom conversion rate. (Whether they are right or not on doing so, it's a problem nonetheless.)
- api 8y agoIt seems like today there is no thought put into interfaces at all beyond just what they look like.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIn my experience, today's recipe is "follow the trends of market leaders" (see e.g. everyone jumping on Material Design), and after that perhaps "optimize for conversion". Listening to UI/UX people, I often hear about not confusing the user, not burdening the user, removing obstacles. What I never hear is empowering the user, providing value to the user, enabling the user to fulfill their goals (as opposed to leading them through the path to monetization).
- snazz 8y agoAlthough you call into question Material Design, I’ll argue that it was a force for good since it added consistency among apps and moved a lot of app-specific functionality within the central left-side menu, making features and settings more discoverable.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI'm not really criticizing Material Design per se here, just people jumping to it (especially on the web) regardless of whether it makes sense for a particular product.
- agumonkey 8y agoI do believe css + web magazine envy shifted everything into ~presentation and not tool/use
- marcosdumay 8y agoOh, there's a lot of thought there. Back then, people didn't bother thinking about the interface at all, and just pushed the lib provided widgets on the same place they were everywhere (there were plenty of bad metaphors that became prevalent, there were many stuff that research showed that it shouldn't be done, but everybody did anyway). Today people are always optimizing (for the showroom), always redesigning. That's part of the problem, not of the solution.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Current GUI trends were created by people with no interest on making their software useful, instead they only keep an eye on showroom conversion rate. (Whether they are right or not on doing so, it's a problem nonetheless.) Yeah, I feel A/B testing is really the place where Satan secretly influences the world. I'm losing track of how many times I've seen user-hostile or application-debiliating decisions justified by "data" on user behaviour. Something is very wrong here.
- zapzupnz 8y agoHello, Office's Ribbon. # Runs horizontally. - Result: wastes precious vertical space on low-resolution widescreen displays (i.e. business displays and most notebooks) that should be dedicated to showing the document body. # Due to being horizontal, GUI items appear/disappear depending on window width. - Result 1: having two documents on screen can be disadvantageous compared to having one on screen because a lot of the GUI items aren't showing or are hidden in submenus, encouraging wasting screen real estate by only having one document on the entire screen. - Result 2: due to the Ribbon's horizontality, instead of having the elements stay on screen in a consistent manner and be easily scrollable, the interface constantly surprises the user by unexpectedly hiding even key GUI items. # No option to disable. - Result: if you wanted to have certain GUI items visible at the same time… well, tough. If the floating palette that inconsistently appears when the user places the mouse cursor over certain elements doesn't have your favourite item, then you're out of luck if the items you want to use exist under different tab groupings. iWork '09 and prior had the best design: a main toolbar with general items, a smaller context-sensitive toolbar underneath, and context-sensitive inspector windows. If the revamped iWork had simply docked those context-sensitive inspectors, rather than get rid of the context-sensitive toolbar, it mightn't have received such a poor response. The irony is that Office 2003 (and a few releases prior) already had inspectors on the side, and those would have been perfect given the prevalence of widescreen displays, leaving as much vertical space for the display of the document body as possible. LibreOffice seems to have three GUI modes; one like iWork, one like the old Office, and one like the Ribbon.
- leoedin 8y ago
- rayiner 8y ago> Discoverability features. Everything was accessible via the menu! You could tell what was a label and what was a button! There were tooltips! There were no hidden gestures--some magic combination of taps and swipes that has you banging on your phone like a monkey. What's remarkable about GUIs today is that the software is hardware to use despite having less functionality and fewer features than ever. Compare new GMail to Outlook 98; Windows 2000 to Windows 10; the built-in PDF viewers in Edge/Chrome to the Acrobat PDF plugin; etc.
- agumonkey 8y agoless ergonomics, more resource consumption; what a win :) when I booted a win95 box last year, I thought to myself, with emacs and sbcl I'd use that as my daily driver
- vbezhenar 8y agoWindows 95 is not a real OS. Now Windows NT 4 is another matter.
- agumonkey 8y agowhat, I like remote people to visit me freely..
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nineteen999 8y agoOr remote people to BSOD you freely as well via some OOB data to the NetBIOS TCP port. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WinNuke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WinNuke
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoWhat does this mean? It's much more of a "real OS" than DOS at least, no? And it's certainly a platform that can be used to get computer things done, in a much more resource-efficient manner than modern systems.
- tomcam 8y agoNot normally a nostalgic person but I can’t escape the same conclusions
- qwerty456127 8y ago> Standard interaction widgets. There was no breaking the scroll, there was no button that you can't discover how to press... There was no action without a shortcut... The sortcut descriptions were embedded on the same places you had to click to get the functionality. Buttons were clearly marked. There was almost always some text area telling you what was happening. This still is the right way to design GUIs for applications to which it is applicable, many people (me included) still follow it and I would warn against thinking of it as of obsolete.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> This still is the right way to design GUIs for applications to which it is applicable, many people (me included) still follow it and I would warn against thinking of it as of obsolete. I'm grateful for all those people, yourself included. But the problem is that most software is moving to the Web, and the browser is treated as blank canvas. Everyone reimplements their own UI to their aesthetic taste, with no regard for accessibility and interoperability. It's the other reason (besides security) that Flash was bad; just calling it "DOM" doesn't make it suck any less.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoSadly, you are in the minority. Look at this [0]. This is why no one needed a baked in "dark mode" for Windows 98. There is no equivalent dialog in modern Windows. It's ridiculous how much computer interfaces have regressed in recent decades. [0] https://tinyurl.com/yco7jz92 https://tinyurl.com/yco7jz92
- qwerty456127 8y ago> This is why no one needed a baked in "dark mode" for Windows 98. Nevertheless there was and it looked really crazy. > There is no equivalent dialog in modern Windows The last version of Windows I used was Windows 7 and I'm pretty sure it was there. I was coding WinForms apps and it uses native system widgets stylable via these settings. Now I use Qt to develop cross-platform apps (on KDE5 as the primary environment), it follows the principle in almost every aspect (it doesn't let you change the colors easily however, you need to design a custom theme for this), it also suggest attaching a keyboard shortcut to every action and displays these right to the menu items.
- xte 8y agoTry Emacs as a WM (EXWM now) and you'll rediscover LispM GUI, far superior to '90-style UI CDE included.
- int_19h 8y agoI would dare say that CUA was the peak UX on the desktop, once it was fully fleshed out (roughly early 00s). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Common_User_Access https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Common_User_Access
- qwerty456127 8y agoHaiku has the most cozy UI skin I can name (I have also seen some even prettier but that was something completely exotic and I don't even know what OS that was), another one of this kind was QNX 6.0 Photon desktop. An the same time when it comes to icons - I enjoyed Windows 3.11 the most (Windows 98 was not bad too).