31 ms·
Blockchain study finds zero success rate and vendors don't call back
- krmmalik 8y agoI've spoken to a number of vendors and come across similar findings as well. Though of course, this is just observational on my part and not a detailed investigation or study, but I have been getting much the same impression. There's a lot of unnecessary hype and people jumping on the bandwagon just because it's currently a buzzword. That said, I still have a lot of faith in what Blockchain will eventually be able to achieve. It might just take longer to get there than we thought. I remember when I was studying computer science in 1999, even though the internet had been out a while and there had been lots of talk about e-commerce no one had really solved the problem particularly well in terms of providing a platform to the average Joe, but by 2005 things were very different and then by 2015 there was no looking back. I think it's going to be the same for Blockchain.
- bognition 8y ago> I still have a lot of faith in what Blockchain will eventually be able to achieve. What does this even mean? Its a really beautiful solution its just lacking a good problem.
- snaky 8y agohttps://hackernoon.com/how-blockchain-technology-could-fix-the-node-js-ecosystem-bccc60832900 https://hackernoon.com/how-blockchain-technology-could-fix-t...
- fwip 8y agoThe solution offered is: "But instead of giving full maintenance or full publishing rights to new collaborators, the original developer would give new maintainers or a CI system only signing rights. So they would sign their releases and after a careful review the original author would countersign stating that he checked and approves these changes." This is 100% equivalent to the maintainer merging a pull request. The other half of the solution is "we need to pay open source maintainers," which doesn't need a blockchain either. Blockchain doesn't help this scenario at all.
- XMPPwocky 8y ago> We need an easier way to automatically distribute payments based on certain rules to open source developers. Has almost nothing to do with Blockchain. This is just called "micropayments"- and blockchains suck for them. At best, you end up doing little payments outside the blockchain, and then settling them occasionally on the blockchain. You may notice this same approach works quite well for "do little payments outside the existing financial system, and settle them periodically." > Code and modules need to be multi-signed and certificates should be inexpensive to get and easy to validate. Code signing is unrelated to blockchain. Certificates are already easy to get. GPG is free. Certificates signed by a CA sometimes cost money- code signing certs, at least in theory (in practice? hah, not really), cost because they need to be able to verify your actual identity. Certificates being easy to validate... this is a PKI problem. Blockchain provides nothing of value here. You might be able to do something like what Keybase does- having some centralized "identity" and making changes to same auditable- with a degenerate Merkle tree. You know what else does this? A HSM from like 2006, which, in each audit log entry, includes the hash of the previous one, to establish exactly this property- changes and edits can be detected. > One of our dependencies could become a malicious package in the same way we saw it with event-stream. But instead of giving full maintenance or full publishing rights to new collaborators, the original developer would give new maintainers or a CI system only signing rights. So they would sign their releases and after a careful review the original author would countersign stating that he checked and approves these changes. Not only has this got nothing to do with Blockchain, the proposal here is just "a new maintainer needs to ask the old maintainer for permission to publish for a while", which is quite silly- if the old maintainer is tired of bothering with the maintenance bit, the LAST thing they want to do is careful code audits. > Later, if our fictional project received an in-app payment there could be some logic within the runtime environment that based on the impact or contribution of this open source module to our project would automatically distribute a couple of cents of each payment to the author who can be determined based on the certificate. Well, no, the author can't be determined based on the certificate on your binary. The person (or persons) who signed it can be. Asking every contributor to sign every release in perpetuity is silly, of course. Incentivize them to do it with a cut of the profits? Great, now they just rubber stamp everything. Now, if you mean the maintainer of the module, sure. You know what else works quite nicely for this? Just having a payment address in your Git repo in some file with a well-known name. There's no point in the certificate, here! "Aha- a payment address! PayPal won't work, not much else that exists will, either. For those smaller payments, only a Blockchain-based approach would work." Well, that's true- for now. Similarly, "free, rapid person-to-person transfers" was largely just Venmo for a while. Then the sleeping giants that are the financial industry woke up, threw some pocket change at the problem, and created Zelle / Early Warning, which does the exact same thing. There isn't a good way to do microtransactions today because there isn't that much demand for microtransactions. If there is, it'll pop up quite quickly. This entire article is just... clown shoes. The parts that might work aren't novel and don't require anything besides a degenerate Merkle tree, and the parts that are novel or require a Real Blockchain(TM) are useless. Why is this? Because the article itself was written backwards! The author started out with "I like and know Blockchain. (more cynically, 'I benefit when $ETH goes up'.) Here is a problem. How can we apply Blockchain to it, and make the world more secure (and more cynically, 'make me richer and my skills more in demand')?" In so far as this article attempts to solve any problem, the problem is "Blockchain isn't used as much as I'd like it to be."
- asynchrony 8y agoFaith is required to sustain belief in promises that are never delivered.
- dragontamer 8y ago> That said, I still have a lot of faith in what Blockchain will eventually be able to achieve. It might just take longer to get there than we thought. Why should anyone care more than say... the adoption rate of SkipLists or Bloom Filters? Blockchain IS a usable datastructure with some interesting properties. But so are Cuckoo Hashes. But no one is going around talking about how Cuckoo Hashes will take over the world. Its like XML or SOAP, or any other buzzword technology. There's certainly a benefit to the technology, but ultimately the engineering of stuff that uses it is relatively boring.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hudon 8y ago> in 1999, even though the internet had been out a while and there had been lots of talk about e-commerce no one had really solved the problem particularly well in terms of providing a platform to the average Joe I'm not sure why you focused on e-commerce as a use case, as well as the average Joe as the user. The article in question talks about them trying to find ANY industry use case. The Internet was useful pretty much from day 1. In the early 70s it already enabled digital file transfers and email communication. The use cases were easy to find...
- anongraddebt 8y agoThe percentage of people saying blockchain doesn't have a substantial use case, is about the same percentage as there were in the late 70's or early 80's saying the internet didn't have a substantial use case. Initially, few people thought file transfer over the internet was a substantive use case because the transmission speed was too slow. Then throughput capacity picked up, but people then shifted the argument to something like, "It's good for medium size file transfer, and I guess I can sometimes send this clunky email thing instead of picking up the phone or sending a fax." This process repeats itself, with goalposts ever shifting, until someone talks about the possibility of selling everything over the internet, starting with books, and most think it's nutty, but believe hearing "you've got mail" every morning might get mass adoption. I'm not sure whether 'blockchain' is a database or a universal computer or a new software primitive. Or whether we can even tell. What I know is that it is at the very least some sort of network infrastructure (in the most abstract sense of the term). Just like with the internet (another network infrastructure), the space of substantial use cases increases as more people and technologies are connected to it. Could it end up being a dud apart from some random use cases? Emphatically yes. Could it end up being pretty important? Possibly (we don't know). Ironically, the best evidence I have for being agnostic about the potential of 'blockchain' is the number of educated and non-educated people making wild claims about the benefits of decentralization, etc. When the telegraph arrived, a substantial mass of people said it would usher in world peace. When the internet arrived, a substantial mass of people made wild claims about breaking us free from corporate power, educating the masses, etc.
- deleted 8y ago
- kdowns 8y agoI'm really not surprised. The most interesting thing about your business shouldn't be your choice in data-store.
- kevindqc 8y agoBut it's immutable (until it isn't)!
- khawkins 8y agoWell put. Block chain certainly has applications but they're almost entirely a design choice. The reality of block chains is that they'll always be complicated enough that there will always be a man in the middle. Mt. Gox demonstrated that block chains will always be exploitable because the man in the middle is easily compromised. And anything that's worth going to the trouble of protecting with block chain is worth compromising.
- jMyles 8y agoHear hear. And this assessment is cause for optimism. Look at many of the upcoming cohort of blockchain-based projects: LivePeer, Fluence, Augur, dare I say NuCypher (I'm on this team) - all of them have far more interesting things to offer than their use of blockchain tech. They render unto the blockchain what is the blockchain's, but all do way more interesting things.
- DonHopkins 8y agoBut what about the Emerging CD-ROM Industry? (I want to know more about Bill Gate's goat!) https://www.questia.com/magazine/1G1-6501528/microsoft-s-third-cd-rom-conference-the-industry https://www.questia.com/magazine/1G1-6501528/microsoft-s-thi... The 1988 Microsoft CD-ROM Conference held in Seattle in March, attracted about 2,000 industry insiders. The tone and ambience of the conference reflect a definite change in the industry. Most companies were represented not only by top management, but by their marketing personnel. Few blue-jeaned engineers or techies were found in the crowds. CD-ROM appears to have arrived. FINDING A PATHWAY TO THE FUTURE In his keynote address, Bill Gates, Microsoft's founder and chairman, reiterated his goat of making computers affordable and attractive enough to be "on every desk, in every home." Gates reported that less than 50,000 CD-ROM drives are currently in the marketplace. These are either in very narrow vertical markets, such as libraries, or are being used by the industry itself. The problem of low drive sales is compounded by the high cost of developing a multimedia product. Gates estimated that it costs $1 million for each disk product, an investment that many companies have been unwilling or unable to make. The lack of a "rich standard for audio-visual" components of CD-ROM development, and the limited tools available to developers today, are two other important reasons Gates cited for the slow growth of the CD-ROM industry.
- manmanic 8y agoI've been working on DLT / enterprise blockchain technologies since 2014 and have insight into hundreds of projects, a small number of which made it to live production. Here is the bottom line: yes, it's mostly hype, but this technology does have genuine use cases - when you want to build an interparty database-driven application, and cannot find a suitable place to put the database, because of business concerns or regulation. This is fairly niche, perhaps 1% of all interorganizational database applications, but there are certainly cases where it is the right solution. The majority of blockchain projects undertaken still do not make sense, but this is gradually getting better over time.
- ellius 8y agoI've only worked on a single blockchain application, but this was my experience too. I was actually pretty skeptical when I was told we'd be working on it and figured it was just a hype thing, but the use case involved a B2B process that was well-established and used a paid intermediary to correlate data across businesses. We were pretty happy with the result. I doubt we'll ever see a middleman-free decentralized utopia, but I agree that it's a technology with some genuine applications.
- davidgerard 8y agoWhat was it and where? If what you're saying is true, then this is noteworthy and I'd love to look more closely at the details.
- m-i-l 8y agoThe source for the article's "Blockchain study finds 0.00% success rate" headline is "We documented 43 blockchain use-cases through internet searches ... we found no documentation or evidence of the results blockchain was purported to have achieved"[0]. That isn't a huge sample size, and "internet searches" may have skewed the results towards the more dubious projects spending large amounts on SEO. But never-the-less I'd echo the interest in reading details of a successfully implemented use-case for public blockchain technology, beyond cryptocurrencies. Based on some of the comments here hinting that there might be some, and assuming they do indeed exist, I suspect that they are not solutions that could be achieved only with blockchain technology (like cryptocurrencies), or even solutions that are significantly better (in terms of cost, effort, time to market or some other metric) with blockchain technology, but simply solutions where blockchain has been made to work (i.e. other approaches could have been too and some of those may have been as good if not better). [0] http://merltech.org/blockchain-for-international-development-using-a-learning-agenda-to-address-knowledge-gaps/ http://merltech.org/blockchain-for-international-development...
- Animats 8y agoThat's bad. I thought someone would be using a blockchain for some kind of back-end settlement system somewhere, but apparently not. On the ICO front, the SEC is now cracking down effectively. First they went after the outright frauds, such as the coin backed by nonexistent land and diamonds. They won in court. Then they went after the ones that promised big returns and didn't deliver. The SEC won again. That settled the issue of whether an ICO is a security. It is if it passes the Howey Test.[1] With the legal ambiguity resolved, the SEC started sending inquiry letters to new ICO proponents with some pointed questions. Many new issuers backed off. Now the SEC has an assembly-line enforcement process running for ICOs; issuers can either buy the tokens back and shut down, register as a real security, or get hammered in court. List of 934 dead coins.[2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SEC_v._W._J._Howey_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SEC_v._W._J._Howey_Co. [2] https://deadcoins.com/ https://deadcoins.com/
- this_user 8y ago> That's bad. I thought someone would be using a blockchain for some kind of back-end settlement system somewhere, but apparently not. The problem in that area is not the previous lack of available technology, it is institutional inertia. You don't need a blockchain to speed up settlements, because the technology to do it did exist before. What you need is buy-in from a bunch of old and conservatively run institutions that do not particularly like change. The primary fallacy of all these blockchain proponents is only seeing problems as technical in nature when they really lie somewhere else. The same applies especially to smart contracts.
- wyldfire 8y ago> What you need is buy-in from a bunch of old and conservatively run institutions that do not particularly like change. They are currently paying someone to shuttle certificates/titles/deeds/bonds as a part of settlements. This involves expense and risk and probably gates outstanding trade activity and maybe even the exchange's duty cycle to some extent. There's opportunity to those institutions to save some expense here (taking on [not insignificant] new kinds of risk).
- 8y ago
- tracker1 8y agoRelated, NIST's answer to do you need a block chain. https://imgur.com/a/RlUj9Ed?third_party=1 https://imgur.com/a/RlUj9Ed?third_party=1
- tuxxy 8y agoNot really surprising, to be honest. I'm really tired of the overused "blockchains are really slow databases" phrase. They're not, and if you're using one as that, you're doing it wrong almost 90% of the time. Here's a great question to ask yourself if you need a blockchain: Do I need game theoretical enforced security? There are many networks and protocols that can be improved with such security mechanisms. There are more that can't be improved. Just in another thread, someone asked the question if Tor could be improved with it. There's plenty to experiment with here and figure out what makes a blockchain application great. The entire idea is that you can incentivize good behavior and disincentivize or punish bad behavior. Consensus comes into play here when deciding, "Was this operation done correctly? If so, do this. If not, do that." This has the ability of enforcing correct operation in decentralized networks. My associates and I have taken to calling these "Decentralized Incentive Networks". Yes, there are many problems that have yet to be solved, but people are working on them. I'm really interested in seeing solutions to the oracle-problem, but I'm unsure if it will ever be solvable. Even then, a lot of these applications won't be fit for enterprise (or even small business) use. Many of these applications will benefit (and survive) from community adoption and rely on being open source. Hopefully, when the hype is gone, we will have made some really great technological advancements to peer-to-peer and distributed applications. This is where I think blockchain apps will find their niche.
- ethanwillis 8y agoThere's quite a few people working on the oracle problem. But there's always risk at some level. And even oracle solutions get broken down into decentralized/centralized platforms.
- kllrnohj 8y agoThe singular point of blockchain is to establish a paper trail. The singular point of Tor is not to have a paper trail. Those are literally opposites. Blockchain + Tor would be the sort of complete nonsense the article is talking about. Blockchain has nothing to do with security. It's not a security technology. It's a permanence technology. It ensures that something is never modified in the absence of a trusted authority which it does with security technology and distributed proof of work.
- TACIXAT 8y agoI used blockchain in a project successfully, but it is not a distributed consensus application. My problem was file sharing. Torrent files send a big list of SHA1 hashes, one for each piece of the file. I replaced that idea with a single block which contains the hash of the next block (as well as two other blocks so verification isn't linear one block to the next). This allows a single block to represent the entire file, allowing you to get blocks from many peers while verifying them. You can just send out a coverage map of what you have, and your peers can calculate what you can verify and send you a random block from that set. If anyone is interested, [1] and [2] are the project. No one is using it, but it's a peer to peer chat and file sharing system. 1. https://party-line.lol https://party-line.lol 2. https://github.com/tacixat/party-line https://github.com/tacixat/party-line
- oldgradstudent 8y agoIf I understand your short description, this sounds more like a Merkle tree[1] than a blockchain. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merkle_tree https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merkle_tree
- merlincorey 8y agoif I understand both Merkle trees and their short description, they would be better served by using a Merkle tree than their scheme.
- plorkyeran 8y agoDepending on how you define "blockchain", it's either the same thing as a merkle tree or most non-bitcoin things that claim to be using blockchains actually are just using merkle trees.
- Terr_ 8y ago> Depending on how you define "blockchain" i.e.: Depending on whether the person saying "blockchain" is lying to make a quick buck from the hype-train.
- api 8y agoI said this in another thread but I'll say it again here. I am downright shocked at just how much of a failure this technology has turned out to be. How can this many brilliant people work on an area for this long and produce almost nothing of value? I suppose it happens in areas of "pathological science" like infinite energy machines, but those are areas where the tech doesn't work and probably violates laws of physics. In this case the tech does work in the general sense but seems to have little to no utility in most cases. When you consider scams and fraud it may even have negative utility. I'd like to be proven wrong. I keep waiting for that killer cryptocurrency app but it never arrives. Meanwhile the core use case of digital money seems almost abandoned. It's not even that good anymore for black and grey market commerce. It was in the beginning because the authorities didn't understand it. It was security through obscurity. Now they're developing both expertise and legal frameworks for dealing with it. It's no longer a free-for-all. I have trouble thinking of another technology that actually works that has attracted this much hype, brains, and investment and then failed this badly to deliver. It's not like fusion, which has a very clear use case but faces so far insurmountable technical challenges. It's not like nuclear fission power which works, has a clear use, but has downsides. I think the nearest comparison I can come up with are failed government mega-projects like the US Reagan-era "Star Wars" laser missile defense system, airplane-like space shuttles, or giant planned utopian cities that get built and then sit vacant. I'm also shocked and a little horrified at just how much fraud there is in this space. I'd expect some, but the sheer volume of fraud is breathtaking. Almost all ICOs seem to be scams. Many exchanges are likely scams. Tether looks like a scam. It makes me disappointed in humanity that there are this many bad actors out there just waiting for a new way to fleece people. Just... wow. What a waste.
- micksabox 8y agoWell said. I got swept up in the hype and my job suffered for it. This is a negative value. But I do think in terms of vision and coordination, blockchain has extended the horizons of what can be achieved.
- Terr_ 8y ago> suppose it happens in areas of "pathological science" like infinite energy machines I'd draw analogies to pyramid-schemes and "multi-level marketing", which are both "successful" but not in a good way. I feel the collective "blockchain" mind-scape is absolutely dominated by nontechnical aspects, like the idea you can "get rich quick", and the assumption that you can find a "greater fool" to ensure your profit from a dodgy-product or speculative buying. This crowds out "actual engineering" and tends to corrupt whatever is left.
- Elv13 8y agoI worked on a project called GNU Ring (https://www.ring.cx https://www.ring.cx) and we used a blockchain for the distributed name service (match strings to crypto signatures). By default there is a name server, but if you really, really care about getting tiny more anonymity, you can spend some CPU cycles and run your own name service locally or on a server you own. It also share the cost of running a distributed database among those who care about privacy while letting those who care less enjoy a simpler stack. A win, win.
- seandougall 8y agoDoes it share the cost, or does it duplicate the cost?
- yarrel 8y agoIt shares it. Each person pays for one node, not all the nodes.
- drexlspivey 8y agoBlockchains make no sense when the "asset" they are tracking have to be imported from the outside world because they lose the trustless property which is the whole point. For example supply line tracking blockchains. "Look this piece of beef was at place X on time Y with temperature Z, I have a hash and everything". Yes but how do I know that you didn't swap the barcodes or you didn't fiddle with the GPS or the thermometer was working or a million other things ? Blockchain only makes sense if the asset is internal (i.e it gets created in it) because that makes it publicly auditable and you don't have to trust anyone. Cryptocurrency is the perfect use case and the reason they were invented.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- russdpale 8y agoI find this to be a little short sighted stufy. Perhaps he should ask the citizens of venezuela if it works? Or people paying taxes in bitcoin in Australia? No doubt, there is a lot of hype. No doubt, a lot of people, including techies, have lost sight of what is important. No doubt, many in the space are impatient, and do not understand that blockchain development, the real blockchain development is more like development of aircraft frames. Slow is smooth, and smooth is fast. No doubt, people are trying to apply it where it is not necessary. There are, however, a plethora of other use cases. The key though, in my opinion, is placing all of it under the hood, invisible to the user except where it is absolutely needed (ie, hi user! here is your wallet). The truth is that many businesses already run replicated, distributed databases on replicated, distributed servers, and it is plenty fast since they don't have to worry about solving advanced cryptographic math equations for incentive purposes. However, one problem facing generalized platform blockchains, such as ethereum, is that the current entire concept of business and how its modeled is far behind what a blockchain can deliver to a business and its interested parties. The problem, as I see it, is primarily one of control, and secondly, one of trust.. I mentioned the replicated distributed stuff earlier, and I think it safe to say no current business will ever open nodes to outside participants (such as customers, or resellers), or even inside participants (shareholders, employees). Unless shareholders demand it (for instance, to ensure a fair number of shares can ever be created), a completely internalized blockchain is pointless and no more trustworthy to society than what we already have. Another large problem is obviously power consumption. Every bitcoin maximalist needs to come to the realization that one of the strongest ways the established players will fight a new paradigm is by controlling power costs. For many in the developed world, bitcoin is out of reach, as mining equipment is expensive, and power makes it impossible to turn a profit. The best solution to this is green, _affordable_ energy sources and affordable mining equipment. Proof of Stake is not completely the answer. Finally, I point to this part of the "study": > We documented 43 blockchain use-cases through internet searches, No wonder they got terrible results. Doctors tell patients all of the time to not google your symptoms, it always ends with cancer. Does this mean doctors are a failure? The established financial systems took a thousand years to formulate into what we know today. Patience is power.
- simonw 8y agoMy favourite terrible blockchain idea is real estate on the blockchain. Because presumably that means that if someone guesses or steals my password, they now own my house.
- Alex3917 8y ago> Because presumably that means that if someone guesses or steals my password, they now own my house. You'll register your private keys with a PKI. In practice the worst case scenario would be needing to go to the DMV to register your new phone or something.
- theamk 8y agoSo if government can change my private keys, this is no longer decentralized system. How is it different from current system, where county office has a big database of all the documents?
- rplst8 8y agoThe way it works now is you rely on a third party to guarantee the property isn't owned by someone else, and then you buy insurance to protect the lender in case the third party screwed up.
- otabdeveloper2 8y agoPresumably, if this were really implemented, the way it would work would be something like this: you'd upload your legal documents to the blockchain, and sign them with your private key, your notary's/lawyer's public keys, the realtor's public keys, and the hash of the previous owner's legal documents, and so on. But of course this isn't really a blockchain, it's just a CMS with a PKI interface.
- lalaland1125 8y agoThis study is clearly flawed because they didn't consider the real use case of blockchain: illegal activity. Blockchain has truly transformed the fields of child pornography, ransomware, drug markets, and ponzi schemes. Regardless of your opinions of those fields, you simply have to accept that those areas wouldn't be possible to the extent they are now without Blockchain based cryptocurrencies.
- godDLL 8y agoAll that operated just fine before, with WebMoney, Paypal and some turkish mules that would take the prison time to cash it all out.
- theamk 8y agoI feel that ransomware at least would not be possible without Bitcoin. Before Bitcoin, there were no safe way to get ransom -- Paypal/Western Union would get blocked real fast, and physical transactions were detected in an old-fashioned way.
- harrygallagher4 8y agoI met a blockchain researcher this summer, I was asking her what sort of stuff she was working on and she started talking about supply chains. Like drexlspivey mentioned there are a whole host of problems with relying on data from the real world. My first thought was just... why do you need an immutable ledger for that? Not to throw buzzwords out, but why not just store transaction data in a database that scales well? If you're willing to spend all of these resources on developing some insane database for your supply chain you must have some real trust issues with your suppliers. I've never worked in an industry like that but I feel like being able to trust your suppliers is pretty important, and provided that you do trust them you could just use a conventional database for all of this and save tons of time and effort.
- delinka 8y agoWe decided a couple decades ago that an 'immutable ledger' would indeed be useful. And you don't have to expend tremendous amounts of time an energy creating such a thing. See Hash Chain[1] at Wikipedia, and notice the second sentence. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hash_chain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hash_chain
- flyGuyOnTheSly 8y agoI find it a bit odd that this entire article and every comment (so far) doesn't even mention HyperLedger? [0] The open source private blockchain project championed by IBM, Intel, Cisco, etc... It's powering CLSNet right now. [1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperledger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperledger [1] https://www.coindesk.com/goldman-morgan-stanley-go-live-with-cls-ibm-powered-blockchain https://www.coindesk.com/goldman-morgan-stanley-go-live-with...
- sebringj 8y agoI remember random recruiters talking me into speaking with 4 blockchain companies for remote gigs. I had a hard time understanding the value proposition and asked the founders types of questions like, why is this knowledge base better than stack overflow or why does this rating system work better than other systems? It came down to answer the question because "blockchain blah blah". Not giving the actual value to the consumer. It was more touting what the technology allows rather than real value. The killer app of blockchain is crypto currency at this point IMO. Not much else but I'm rooting for Vitalik as that dude is a genius and I still feel like something amazing will come out of his work. I would guess if you are going to use blockchain for something, make it something that cannot function without it and is one of a kind in being a new thing that people will want, not a clone of an existing tech + blockchain.
- frogperson 8y agoTim Bray made a comment at re:invent this week that most of Amazon's internal work loads rely on DynamoDB and a ledger database that is the pre-cursor to the new QLDB service Amazon released this week. To qualify this, when Tim used the word 'most' I don't know if he meant "most data stored" or "most DB instances". He also didn't give any percentages, so it very well could be 99% Dynamo and 1% ledger DB. Lastly, Bray didn't include Aurora or Redshift in that list of "most used database at Amazon", but Dr Vogel's keynote alluded to a ton of internal Aurora usage. So, at least some people are claiming successful usage of blockchain in production. It's just not clear how much. Amazon seems to think there is a future in it, since they just released 2 new blockchain related services this week.
- needaccount 8y agoGreat level of precision in this measurement.
- thrkwaway 8y agoIMO the killer blockchain app is voting. It makes use of the features that are unique to blockchain: censorship resistance, decentralization, and trustless transactions. I've been working on a paper for the last 6 months that details a system that makes use of crypto innovations like zk-snarks and some other novel technologies that lays a blueprint for how to use this tech to provide a voting system that would be beyond any central party's influence and would securely allow for voting from mobile devices and a host of other things that are beyond the capabilities of centralized tech - at least beyond the ability to be done in a manner that anyone would trust. I've been watching the space since 2010 and can honestly say most projects are solutions in search of a problem.
- burntrelish1273 8y agoIn the gratuitous conflation of reality and fiction department: almost everything hyping blockchain reminds me of the unique, hilarious romcom Shooting Fish (1997) where a couple of con-artists fake a "next gen" AI computer Turing test with a dude in another room and a computer full of bricks. They also live in a water tower and fraudulently sell homeowners insulation that they move from house-to-house across shared attics.
- juliebooth 8y agoI live in USA Florida and i am a happy woman today? I told my self that any Loan lender that could change my Life and that of my family, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to Them. If you are in need of loan and you are 100% sure to pay back the loan please contact them and please tell them that Mrs Sharon Coolidge referred you to them. barrymoreloans12@gmail.com or you can text +19725345446
- arisAlexis 8y agotitle: "Where is your distributed ledger technology now?" Just being rational and before reading the article, you can deduct there is some kind of bias. "Any claim made for blockchain could be made for databases" We can deduct here that author has no deep understanding of the technology. "that's something we can confidently tell you for nothing: no, it isn't" Author is dismissive and angry (didn't adopt early?)
- Brahma111 8y agoOh Boy!! Another case of pre-determined surveys. CLS has already moved to production on blockchain. De Beers has done the same with Diamonds. Multiple insurance companies including our start-up are leveraging BC for direct claims settlement. Is it really difficult to understand that BC technology is not a hammer and all the use cases are not nails. You are trying to get rid of Big intermediaries, people. They are not going to make it easy. Every interaction between parties is going to be more difficult than the previous until critical mass is attained. But succeed it will and will most likely happen before we die.