10 ms·
The blog ends with the best and most insightful comment: And no human’s life is measurably better since Apple had the “courage” to remove the 3.5 mm jack. But
by BLKNSLVR 8y ago
The blog ends with the best and most insightful comment:
And no human’s life is measurably better since Apple had the “courage” to remove the 3.5 mm jack. But a lot of our lives are just a little worse.
The author also points towards active de-standardisation between Android and iOS:
"if only there was one universal audio port they both could use"
Apple gets an advantage from this with their iron-grip on compatible peripherals, but I don't know why any of the Android manufacturers would follow suit. The ugliness of the impracticality of fashion.
- abtinf 8y ago> "if only there was one universal audio port they both could use" Bluetooth?
- tanbog 8y agoIf I had a dollar for every time bluetooth failed between two devices...
- baroffoos 8y agoBluetooth has been better for me 80% of the time and then that last 20% is a huge pain where as AUX is consistently a little bit worse but it never totally lets you down.
- thrower123 8y agoI think I can count the number of times that I've managed to get bluetooth to actually work on the fingers of one hand. It's just trash. Give me a wired connection every day of the week, and it better be something universal like USB-A, micro-usb, HDMI or 3.5mm.
- Johnny555 8y agoI've never plugged my headphones into a jack and had them fail to work (ok, on my old cassette Walkman, I sometimes had to jiggle the plug around to get the headphones to work, but modern devices seem to have solved that problem (through gold plated connectors? I dunno)). But around once every 8 times I get into my car, I need to turn off/on Bluetooth on my car, my phone, or both to get it to connect. More rarely, I have to reboot my phone. I haven't used a Bluetooth headset with my phone in several years, but I had the same problem then. So I don't think Bluetooth is that reliable "works every time" standard.
- com2kid 8y agoCars are a special type of awful. As much as I prefer headphone jacks, I'll readily admit that my $15 BT headphones from Amazon connect every time I turn them on. Car BT implementations are actually an interesting world in of themselves, I've seen car BTs wreck havok with other BT peripherals attached to a phone. The level of "how?" was truly amazing.
- unclebucknasty 8y ago>Cars are a special type of awful Bluetooth pairing always seems a bit unclear. Do I start the scan on my phone or the device? Cars seem to be particularly bad in making this clear or otherwise don't work reliably per instructions. If you want a really bad Bluetooth experience, see Acura. Calls can require active "transfer" to Bluetooth devices when you're streaming, and there is otherwise clunkiness and competition for the car's audio system, for instance if you try to use car nav. And, woe be unto you if you have multiple in-range devices. There's a pretty good chance it'll vomit and you'll end up with mixed pairing profiles that essentially require you to restart the car and/or disable Bluetooth on one device. Not sure how they managed to get Bluetooth so wrong, but it's a solid contributor to an overall poor infotainment center design.
- fingerlocks 8y agoIt’s becauese they are all copy-pasting the sample code middleware. A few minor changes are made, like advertising name and what not, but I’ve seen literal dupes supplied by the same Taiwanese vendor. And like most sample code, the error handling is non-existent. Source: Previously worked on head unit FW.
- koolba 8y agoEqually annoying is if two people are both previously paired with the car (or speaker!) and it’s connects but not to the one you want.
- ams6110 8y agoYeah Bluetooth almost never works reliably for me. If it isn't connection problems, it's dead batteries. I refuse to buy or use wireless keyboards, mice, microphones, speakers, or headphones.
- mbell 8y ago> if only there was one universal audio port they both could use CTIA or OMTP?
- iv597 8y agoFor audio output (the majority usecase, I'd argue), this didn't matter much. Left and right audio output _always worked_, and in my experience, at least the play/pause button worked fairly universally as well.
- dwighttk 8y agoI probably wouldn’t have bought AirPods if my phone still had a 1/8” jack, and every time I have had to use wired earphones since have been worse than if I had my AirPods on me. So here’s one human who disagress with the first bit.
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoWhich is why, I'm assuming, the author added the last bit, which sounds like it covers your exact experience: every time I have had to use wired earphones since have been worse than if I had my AirPods on me
- dwighttk 8y agoI’m simply countering the absurd blanket statement “...no human’s life is measurably better...” Mine is. The statement is false.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mikewhy 8y agoBut airpods could have still been developed in a 3.5mm world.
- dwighttk 8y agoBut I wouldn't have bought them, and I would have only experienced two sets of crappy $20 bluetooth headphones and stuck by my assumption that bluetooth sucks, and my life wouldn't be any better.
- paulcole 8y agoWhat about the people who sell Bluetooth headphones? I’d think of some of them are doing better? Or what about the people who worked on the AirPods? Or god forbid the people who like AirPods (or other Bluetooth headphones) more than any wired ones?
- nathanaldensr 8y agoFalse dichotomy. The choice is not only between 3.5mm jacks and Bluetooth; there are thousands of models of devices that support and have supported both.
- paulcole 8y agoI was responding to this: > And no human’s life is measurably better since Apple had the “courage” to remove the 3.5 mm jack.
- Johnny555 8y agoThat's what he meant by "false dichotomy" -- airbuds and bluetooth headphones can still exist even if phones still have audio jacks.
- paulcole 8y agoReview what I quoted and tell me if that statement alone is true or false — without simply repeating “false dichotomy.”
- Johnny555 8y agoIt's unanswerable -- what were the bluetooth headset sellers selling before the iPhone ditched the headphone jack? Maybe they were selling higher margin (but lower cost) wired headphones that had a lot fewer support headaches. Few people call support to ask how to pair their 3.5mm jack with the phone. The Airbud designers could have designed the same product even if the iPhone still had a headphone jack, so it's hard to say definitively that their life is measurably better now.
- jamesrcole 8y agoPersonally, I detest wired headphones. I find they always get caught on things while I'm wearing them, and because of the neck problems I have that's a big issue for me (and as well as that, they'd always get tangled up in my bag, which was a bit of a hassle). So I'm personally glad they've removed the headphone jack, because it will help push wireless into the mass market (and bring down prices) at a faster rate than it otherwise would have. Now of course, there's lots of people who don't find it a positive like I do. My point is not that everyone should find the jack removal great, my point is that it's wrong to claim that it's a disadvantage for everyone. On a separate note, people like to shit on Apple for that "courage" claim, but even if removing the jack was a bad decision, I think it's fair to call it a courageous one, because they knew well that they'd get a lot of shit for making that decision. Look at what gets said every time the headphone jack issue is brought up on HN.
- nikofeyn 8y agobut that doesn’t really answer the question of “why remove it?” keeping the audio jack does not prevent the use of wireless headphones. and keeping the audio jack does not really pose a problem.
- jamesrcole 8y agoIt does answer it: as I said, it forces quicker uptake of wireless, and thus quicker reduction of cost.
- nradov 8y agoIf wireless enables quicker reduction in cost then when do iPhones keep getting more expensive?
- jamesrcole 8y agoI never said that. I said if wireless is the only option in those phones then this will cause more wireless headphones to be sold, and this will cause wireless headphones to become cheaper. (This is clearer if you read the earlier comments in this sub-thread. By the time the discussion got to the comment you were replying to, that context was being assumed).
- mh8h 8y agoRemoving the headphone jack makes the waterproofing easier and more effective.
- oliv__ 8y agoHow convenient
- btbuildem 8y agoThat sounds like a legitimate reason - they advertise water-resitance and waterproofing for the models lacking a headphone jack. But.. can't they just make a waterproof headphone jack??
- conception 8y agoYes.
- umichguy 8y agoSamsung does water resistant phone with their flagship S9. And they still have the 3.5.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y agoAnd the Samsung S5 has a headphone jack and even an easily-swappable battery, and still has waterproofing.
- nradov 8y agoFalse. Samsung devices have had good water resistance ratings while still retaining headphone ports. (In fact some of the older models even managed to do so with removable batteries.)
- wvenable 8y agoDoesn't seem to be an issue with Samsung phones.
- nikofeyn 8y ago
- craftyguy 8y ago> but I don't know why any of the Android manufacturers would follow suit. The obvious reason is a decrease in BOM which corresponds directly with an increase (however so slightly per unit) in margin. Apple made it "ok" to whack this functionality, so why wouldn't every manufacturer join in?
- grecy 8y ago> And no human’s life is measurably better since Apple had the “courage” to remove the 3.5 mm jack. But a lot of our lives are just a little worse. Eh, you could have said the same thing when they removed serial ports, 3.5" floppy drives, CD drives, etc. etc. etc. Yes, the world is moving forward. Yes, it's a little inconvenient.
- Endy 8y agoI don't know about you, but my computer still has 2 serial ports on the back, a 3.5" USB drive, and 100% compatibility with CDs via my CD-RW/DVD-RW optical drive. Who removed these things? Who would have the gall to tell me that my use-case is somehow invalid because I use older, more reliable hardware and methods?
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoThe key to the statement is the "a lot of our lives are just a little worse" at the end, which is an argument that doesn't work for floppy drives, serial ports and, arguably, CD drives, as they were phased out well after commonly-used replacements were well into the mainstream. The use-case for the 3.5mm headphone jack is still well and truly within the mainstream, and will probably stay there for some time as per the comment in the blog: the right pair of headphones was the pair of headphones in front of you, or in your pocket, or mangled at the bottom of your bag. It didn’t matter. There's a lot of legacy-weight hanging around in people's houses, bags, and workplaces. Your point, however, isn't completely lost on me. I still miss CD drives occasionally, having to retrieve an older laptop in order to grab data from a disc I haven't yet bothered to archive to an ISO file. However, removing a CD drive from a laptop feels like a much higher percentage space saver than losing the 3.5mm jack from a smartphone.
- apostacy 8y agoAnother "courageous" thing that Apple did was release a computer in 1983 without any fans, which was extremely heavy because it had a giant heat sink, and would still overheat constantly.[1] And yes, this was apparently Steve Job's idea, as he felt that fans were "too noisy and inelegant". I imagine that he felt that fans were holding humanity back, and smugly told people who disagreed that they were clinging to obsolete technology. It got so bad, that Apple actually advised their customers to physically lift and drop their Apple IIIs to re-seat the chips that had popped out from the excessive heat.[2] Of course, if today Apple decided that fans were obsolete again, and the latest Macbooks were twice as heavy and still overheated, then it would become the new normal, and it would be hard to find computers that had fans anymore, and we would long for the days when we could just use computers for as long as we wanted without worrying about them overheating. And on the internet, commenters would say that it wasn't a big deal at all, and if you were some sort of power user that wanted to use your laptop for more than a few hours at a time, you should buy a $250 cooling pad for it. [1]: http://lowendmac.com/2015/apple-iii-chaos-apples-first-failure/ http://lowendmac.com/2015/apple-iii-chaos-apples-first-failu... [2]: https://www.tekrevue.com/apple-iii-drop/ https://www.tekrevue.com/apple-iii-drop/
- Bud 8y agoIt's not that insightful, since it's obviously false. The fact is that the much-improved water resistance made possible in part by ditching the headphone jack has made a lot of users' lives much better, because they have dunked their iPhones in water and the result has been no damage, as opposed to the expense and inconvenience of replacing their phones. It would have been more effective if the author didn't cherry-pick only the facts which support his argument.
- Johnny555 8y agoThe Galaxy S9 has the same water resistance rating as the iPhone, and it has a headphone jack.
- fingerlocks 8y agoI've always been skeptical about this claim. Apple's own 3.5mm -> lighting dongle is surprising resistant to water (I've spilled coffee on mine and it still works), but I can't find any information of whether the dongle itself is waterproof. I've looked. Also, Samsung made a phone with a waterproof 3.5mm female port. They weren't the first.
- tempestn 8y agoYeah, the 3.5mm port is certainly easier than the USB port to make waterproof. Probably easier than speakers and microphones too.
- addicted 8y agoI don’t know much about this, but from a layman’s perspective I completely agree with you. I find it hard to believe that of all the elements making waterproofing harder, the headphone jack was one of the larger concerns.
- DanBC 8y agoSpeakers and microphones just need a bit of gore tex. These are off the shelf parts, and companies like Apple etc can easily spec their own. https://www.gore.com/products/categories/venting?view=portable-electronic-vents https://www.gore.com/products/categories/venting?view=portab... I agree that it's also really easy to make 3.5 mm jack sockets waterproof.
- oxplot 8y ago> And no human’s life is measurably better since Apple had the “courage” to remove the 3.5 mm jack. But a lot of our lives are just a little worse Good old shortsightedness at play here. No one looks past this year or years to come when faced with changes. Here's what I think, based on history, is happening here: # Wires are more bad than good for average consumer: a. Neglected security based on assumption that since it's not wireless, it's immune to eavesdropping (think side-channel attacks). Wireless puts security upfront and center. b. Cables get lost, break, are not long enough, are not compatible, damage the connectors, bad cables damage the device, cost extra, etc. Wireless doesn't. c. Cables are cumbersome. They get tangled, you need to remember to carry them, have backups, etc. d. Cables have short range. Apple evidently cares quite a bit about user experience. Wires hurt user experience so they want to get rid of them, one by one. You can't push towards superfast, low power and generally more advanced mobile devices and accessories, if the industry has no reason to do so (because everything works and has for the past 50 years). It's tiring reading every day how someone is upset because their favorite feature is gone because they can't see past their front door.
- zouhair 8y agoOh, yeah, so how come now I have more cables now because of dongles?
- thrower123 8y agoNone of these are problems with headphones. Well, tangling, but I'll gladly deal with that over another battery to keep charged up.
- eksemplar 8y agoIt’s a bit of a cheap statement though. If keeping the headphone jack would have prevented Apple from making the iPhone X, then the argument wouldn’t hold any value. I would have hated if the XS was thicker, or if it still had bezels.