5 ms·
This just feels like an internally contradictory hit piece... It complains Google wasn't good at sales, but then lists "numerous companies" brought on. It comp
by crazygringo 8y ago
This just feels like an internally contradictory hit piece...
It complains Google wasn't good at sales, but then lists "numerous companies" brought on. It complains that the offerings are "learner than AWS" but then admits Google has shown up "extremely competitively". A competitor (of course) claims "Google is just not a factor" but close to the end the choice becomes a "close call".
So which is it? Considering how late Google got into the cloud game, it seems to be doing respectably well, given all of the catch-up it's needed to do first.
- larrymcp 8y agoTo me that's one ingredient in quality journalism, actually. I feel more confident in a piece if it tries to include multiple points of view, multiple interpretations etc. Always good to see the "critics said x, but supporters said y" habit as one indicator of impartial reporting.
- chairmanwow 8y agoI want to walk away from an article not with the pre-packaged opinion ofthe journalist/editor but with enough information to make my own decision. I don’t look to journalists for their commentary on the world we live in, but for updates on what is happening.
- Eridrus 8y agoI think everyone agrees that AWS is a clear leader, but both Microsoft and Google report bundled Office Suite/Cloud Computing revenue as a single number, so it's completely unclear who is actually in second place.
- epynonymous 8y agothat's a great point, and as i was reading this, i was thinking that perhaps aws should get into cloud office as well.
- oldmanhorton 8y agohttps://venturebeat.com/2018/07/19/microsoft-reports-30-1-billion-in-q4-2018-revenue-azure-up-89-surface-up-25-and-windows-up-7/ https://venturebeat.com/2018/07/19/microsoft-reports-30-1-bi... As far as I’m aware, azure and office get reported separately. Azure is “intelligent cloud” and office (along with some others) is “more personal computing”
- partiallypro 8y agoI wish this falsehood would die. Google isn't even #3 in cloud revenues, IBM is, Oracle is #4. Google is far, far, behind Azure and AWS. They have ~$1B/quarter in cloud revenues (that includes GSuite.) Even if you made the assumption that Office 365 made up 80% of Microsoft's quarterly cloud revenues it would still be bigger than Google's cloud (including GSuite.) This is based on their earnings fy 2018. I don't get why people are in denial that Azure is doing well. If you want to know why Google isn't doing -great- in the cloud, it's because people are afraid they will kill the project. It's because they don't have a "hook" like AWS and Azure have. AWS has a massive user base already, good reason to adopt it. Azure hooks into so many other Microsoft services and developer tools, good reason to adopt it. GCS has...what? Sure, some cool things, but we're talking about compute, compute where where the money is. Even if you adopt GCS for some edge or AI projects, that's not a lot of spend.
- Eridrus 8y agoI think part of the is ambiguity over what the "cloud" is; is hosted exchange/active directory cloud computing? Is hosted Oracle DBs cloud computing? I think analysts are estimating that 18% of commercial cloud revenue is Azure, which, you're right would put it ahead of Google, but what exactly is getting sold under the Azure umbrella? I'm pretty sure their Active Directory stuff gets sold as part of Azure. And while this may be splitting hairs, I think it matters what they're actually selling. If they're moving on-prem customers to SaaS, that doesn't seem like a particularly useful comparison, since we already know MS sells a tonne of proprietary software to enterprise.
- partiallypro 8y agoThe answer is, yes hosted Oracle DBs are the "cloud" and yes hosted AD is the "cloud," in so long as they are on a pool of resources. Why wouldn't it be? How is that any different than moving your MEAN, LAMP or whatever stack from bare metal to a cloud provider on a VM? It's not. What makes the "cloud" the "cloud," isn't some serverless, edge, kubernetes fancy whatever. Most people do not use/need that stuff. It's pooled resources and a toolset that allows you to scale, provision, monitor, etc in a simple way with no human interaction. That's it. Everything else is nuance. I think the ambiguity that people are so inclined to over engineer that they can't possibly imagine something so simple as a vanilla VM with a SQL SaaS hooked to it as "the cloud" because it's not complex enough.
- projectramo 8y agoAre those contradictory points? Lots of companies may not be good enough to count as “good.” If Walmart sold $10 million worth of goods its both numerous and bad. The leaner than AWS comment was when he made the decision in the past and the close call comment was more recent. The question isn’t whether you or I are happy with Goohle’s performance but how management and investors see it.
- hodgesrm 8y ago> Considering how late Google got into the cloud game, it seems to be doing respectably well, given all of the catch-up it's needed to do first. Google is still at 3% market share which puts it at the same level as IBM Soft Layer and Rackspace. [0] Given the technologies Google has developed for cloud-native/cloud-scale computing (Kubernetes, MapReduce, TensorFlow, etc.) not to mention outstanding apps like Gmail, this result has to be a disappointment to their investors. [0] https://www.skyhighnetworks.com/cloud-security-blog/microsoft-azure-closes-iaas-adoption-gap-with-amazon-aws/ https://www.skyhighnetworks.com/cloud-security-blog/microsof...
- crazygringo 8y agoI'd argue it's still way too early to call it a disappointment, and that we'll only know 5-10 years from now. Google had to invest massively to catch up to AWS purely technically, and it's only now that people are starting to consider it to be close. Then consider that companies will tend to pick a cloud provider and not revisit that decision for 5 or 10 years. This has to be a very long-term play where the results won't show up for many, many years. Greene's tenure should be judged in terms of market perception (e.g. if we were making the decision now instead of 10 years ago, would Google be viable?) as opposed to a large absolute increase in market share (so check back 10 years from now).
- chibg10 8y agoThe margins may well have shrunk significantly by the time the "long-term" materializes though. Cloud computing seems to me like an industry at high-risk of being commotitized after the initial gold rush -- similar to smartphones. If that's the case, I'm not sure it makes sense to prioritize the future over today.
- MediumD 8y agoAre smartphones really a commodity, when people spend hundreds of dollars more on the iPhone vs. Android competitors? With any platform certain aspects will become commotitized, but when you have to choose between building on one ecosystem or another, there will always be room for differentiation.
- pishpash 8y agoNone of these are contradictory. Numerous companies brought on then found the offerings were not up to par of AWS. And as one of only three major well known cloud providers they are competitive enough as to be a close call when counting pricing advantages, but still have very small market share and therefore not a factor were they to disappear -- people would just move to AWS.
- rajacombinator 8y agoGoogle is better than Amazon at engineering and product design so they should be able to beat AWS. My impression from trying GCE is that, like many other Google products that they end up killing off, they’ve never been fully committed to it.
- manigandham 8y agoWhy is that contradictory? You can bring numerous companies on, for whatever reason, without being good at sales. The marketshare remains very low because of it, even though the overall market has grown.