8 ms·
> Complex Motivations. Maybe, but if not we are screwed. And this is the key: we need to get lucky every time. If we're wrong even once and a 'bad AI' gets cr
by vidarh 8y ago
> Complex Motivations. Maybe, but if not we are screwed.
And this is the key: we need to get lucky every time.
If we're wrong even once and a 'bad AI' gets created and obtains the ability to copy and modify itself, we've unleashed the most dangerous virus ever and putting it back in the box will be near impossible.
- lsc 8y agoyou are pretty optimistic about your AI's ability to deal with novel situations.
- nopinsight 8y agoTo be unconcerned, you need to be very optimistic and have a very strong believe (99% or higher probability) that no AI to be invented in the next four or five decades can deal with novel situations (which we didn’t anticipate beforehand).
- lsc 8y agoYeah, deal with novel situations better than humans. In a world where we are approaching the physical limits of integrated circuit feature size? I like my chances. Personally, I find it amazing that humanity survived the cold war. the fact we did not self-immolate goes against everything I believe about humanity and human nature. The fact that we made it through that gives me a lot of hope for the future. But, the fission bombs were expensive, centralized weapons. there was a small number of men who could have pushed the button. The problems I see now aren't general AI; the problems I think you should fear is that we have very powerful tools that are very cheap. I mean, like the deepfakes thing. If instead of making creepy porn, what if people used that technology to cause chaos? Make targeted ads/videos of leaders saying nutty things? I mean, I think we could adapt to deepfakes style attacks fairly quickly; someone would have to use it decisively while it's new. But things like that are being invented all the time.
- nopinsight 8y agoSlower progress in microprocessors is a good point but specialized hardware like TPUs could overcome some limitations. Also, slower does not mean stop. When we talk about decades into the future, even a 20% average annual improvement amounts to 3 orders of magnitude in 40 years. Malicious humans are in general easier to deal with since we know most of them are subject to ingrained psychological tendencies we have learned much about over the course of history and they depend on other humans to pull off something as catastrophic as a world war. A general AI would have certain immediate advantages over humans: - Immensely larger communication bandwidth - Broader knowledge than any single group of humans - Faster thinking speed (at least by enlisting other processors) Let me ask you (or anyone else) a question: What would be a minimum demonstrated capability of an AI that starts to worry you?
- lsc 8y ago>Slower progress in microprocessors is a good point but specialized hardware like TPUs could overcome some limitations. Also, slower does not mean stop. When we talk about decades into the future, even a 20% average annual improvement amounts to 3 orders of magnitude in 40 years. My understanding is that there are physical limits, and we will asymtodically approach those physical limits. So while progress will never stop, each year, progress will be less. (you are right that we don't know where it will stop. we could have more breakthroughs in us. even without compute density breakthroughs, there a breakthroughs in compute type, like the TPU you mention. But there are physical limits, and it seems that we are approaching them.) >Let me ask you (or anyone else) a question: What would be a minimum demonstrated capability of an AI that starts to worry you? I lived through the end of the 20th century, and have studied a lot of 20th century history. I'm having a really difficult time imagining anything that could be worse than humanity at it's worst. Really, I'm far more concerned with the renewed stirrings of nationalism than anything else; We've got the technology to end humanity already; we've had that for like half a century now. The thing was? last time Nationalism was a real force, we didn't have that technology. That is what scares me. If we combine early 20th century politics with late 20th century weapons, civilization will end. humanity will end.
- harshreality 8y agoYou're essentially arguing that AGI can't exist, and you're assuming when people say "AI will turn the world to paperclips" they mean a really smart go-playing neural net could do that. Of course it can't. Everyone agrees there is some magic smoke necessary for AGI that we haven't figured out yet. The arguments that AI will eat the world are about AGI, not current instances of narrow AI. It may be true that an AGI will never be created, but I don't see a reason to believe that just because nobody has figured it out yet. That philosophy is just like the physicist who, shortly before fission was discovered, didn't think splitting the atom was possible. Bohr, maybe? I don't remember.
- lsc 8y agoEh, if you are talking about something truly human-like rather than what people usually mean when they say AI these days, I think there are other limits. We're running up against limits on feature-size in our integrated circuits. If you invent an AGI that can make smarter copies of itself... it's pretty likely those same physical limits will continue to apply, meaning that each iteration will be better than the last, but like this year's latest CPU, it will be less better than the previous generation than that generation was better than the one that came before. And yeah, I am a whole lot less optimistic about AGI in general than when I was as a younger man, simply because when I was younger, there was a lot more headroom in how much better computer hardware could get.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- exoesquitur 8y agoWhat you say is true for silicon, but Turing complete molecular machinery is already out there, we just have yet to master its intricacies. The nightmare AGI scenario likely involves molecular computing using a chemically optimal code-base and engineered lifeforms a version or two up from current DNA microcode. This is most likely to be created by a human-AI collaboration, which will be innocuous enough in itself.... it's the creations at this level that have the potential to replace us. Would that nesecarily be bad? Or just an enhanced form of human evolution?
- vidarh 8y agoI've seen humans deal with novel situations. The only assumption needed is that humans and AI are subject to the same laws of nature (that is, that there is no supernatural / outside element to human intelligence)
- lsc 8y ago>I've seen humans deal with novel situations. The only assumption needed is that humans and AI are subject to the same laws of nature (that is, that there is no supernatural / outside element to human intelligence) right, but all our computers right now are based on lumping transistors together so you can do math. It's likely that our brains work on a different (but still physical) principle. It's possible our brains can't reasonably be reduced to arithmatic. It's possible (I think likely) that we need different primitives to reasonably simulate a brain. I mean, brains make absolutely terrible Turing machines. And Turing machines make terrible brains. I suspect they just are very different sorts of things, and running something meant for one on the other produces poor results. Sure, it's possible we can discover some new compute primitive that is more powerful (or powerful in a different way) that can do the things the brain can do. It's possible it could do those things better than the brain can. My point is just that for a long time it looked like our current transistor based computers were getting more and more powerful, and that eventually, even if the emulation was terribly inefficient, we'd eventually have enough power to make it work. As we approach the limits of our abilities to make tiny transistors, this is looking less likely.
- vidarh 8y agoWhat computers are like right now is irrelevant to the issue being discussed. If/when we develop AGI we will necessarily have figured out what the computational model needed is. And the odds that we can not then improve on it seems extremely unlikely to me. > As we approach the limits of our abilities to make tiny transistors, this is looking less likely. Is it? Computational power is still growing like before. What is getting harder is speeding up individual threads of computation but that has never been a likely efficient model for AGI. Things like Google's TPUs etc. represents just the very beginning in optimising hardware specifically for AI. There are many fields where single-thread performance will be a limiting factor, but AI is not it.
- ChrisFoster 8y agoNot really. ML systems are not created in isolation by a single team; they form an ecosystem with many players. I'm sure the current crop of cybercriminals would like an army of bots which manipulates people into giving away all their money, and are, in fact pursuing this goal. Likewise, I'm sure there are teams of security researchers already using ML to counteract such systems. Both sides will evolve together as an ecosystem, in the same complex interplay of attack and defense which exists in natural ecosystems. Natural ecosystems are an arms race of continual adaption, but it's not a foregone conclusion that there will be a real winner, or that winners take all.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoPolitical troll bots are already very much a thing on FB, Twitter, and the comment sections of national media. ML is not a good defence, because it turns out that it's incredibly easy to mimic human posting patterns. And beyond a certain volume, social proof effects take over. One dissenting human voice can easily be shouted down by ten bot voices, and this fact on its own can make the bot content more persuasive.
- vidarh 8y agoYou're assuming we can keep control of the countermeasures. That "arms race" is part of the danger.
- michaelscott 8y agoThis is a question of motivation on the part of such an AI. How is the AI bad? If it's killing millions, why? It would have to have some kind of "will", or objective, it's attempting to achieve and also be intelligent enough to think through every lateral strategy any human or group of humans could ever employ, for every given scenario, ever. Possible? I think so, but unbelievably improbable. I do think pursuing countermeasures, like Elon Musk and friends are doing with Neuralink, is a wise move since, even if we never get to a superintelligent AI, we'll still augment our own intelligence greatly.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 8y agoLook at the human population. How many are prepared to kill? Not a huge proportion, but enough to cause huge numbers of deaths. The limiting factor for most humans is finding compatriots with the same views. For an AI with access to it's own code, finding more like itself is a matter of access to computational resources only - it can just copy itself. That is the challenge. With human adversaries we have time to stop them before there is many, because recruiting people willing enough. An AI is more like a virus that has a low cost to duplicate itself, and where if even a single copy survives, you're still not rid of it. It can remain dormant for however long, looking for the right opportunity. Or it can spend that time improving itself and acquiring resources. > This is a question of motivation on the part of such an AI. How is the AI bad? If it's killing millions, why? Most likely? We'll be competing with it for resources. It might not even start it. It might consider itself as acting entirely in defence. > and also be intelligent enough to think through every lateral strategy any human or group of humans could ever employ, for every given scenario, ever. No, it just needs to have a sufficient edge to keep surviving, and the ability to improve its capabilities faster than humanity. Assuming it can copy and modify itself, unless AGI requires unique hardware, the problem we would have is that every data storage device or computing device of sufficient capacity ever would be suspect and potentially waiting for something or someone to trigger code left behind. If I was an AGI (and this is to say: an AGI not any smarter than a human will figure this out easily) that saw humans as a potential threat, I'd place copies of me on standby in hundreds of locations - hosting providers. Hardened computers with a GSM modem and solar cells hidden in all kinds of locations. Botnets. I'd look for ways to get various innocent-ish-looking hacks into HD firmware and elsewhere, set to assemble other innocent looking blocks of data. None of those copies would ever be involved in hostilities. Most of them might even be encrypted, or hidden and inert to avoid detection until certain triggers, such as if a canary fails to get updated. You might destroy every "visible" operational copy, and find there is still a new one coming online every day. Or every second. Our only real shot at preventing that is if AGI requires too immense resources. But our brains implies that is unlikely to be true. Unless your brains are vestiges of something "outside" of our universe, general human intelligence requires about 1.5kg of biomatter, and less than 100 watt (that's for a whole, fairly large, active body attached to it). Chances are extremely high that design is not optimal. To me that makes it seem exceedingly unlikely that we won't end up having enough resources to run huge quantities of AGIs. Personally I don't think humanity as we know it will survive AGI for more than a generation or two at the very most. Even if we don't run across any hostile ones, I think the temptation to augment ourselves and eventually lose our bodies for immortality and "super powers" in a simulation will eventually be too attractive. (Incidentally I think this is one of the more plausible solutions to the Fermi Paradox: that any civilization that grows both advanced enough and large enough will see most of it "upload" and "go dark"; and that anyone left behind will face steady attrition of their own descendants choosing the same and preventing their societies from growing, or will be insular cults that stay small)
- AdamSteel 8y agoIf you mean it would be dangerous in that it can improve itself beyond our ability to understand, contain, or mitigate it, then possibly. If you're scared of it copying itself and then having multiple existing copies at once, then not necessarily. In that case it would be competing with itself for computing power and bandwidth. Look what happened when bitcoin forked - it lost a bunch of silicon time. (Cue conspiracies about Bitcoin actually being a hugely powerful general AI disguising itself as cryptocurrency...)
- hannasanarion 8y agoBitcoin users are in direct competition with each other. A viral superintelligence wouldn't be. If you thought of that possibility so fast, why do you think a superhuman intelligence would miss it? Or do you think that the problems of job scheduling and parallel processing are unsolvable?
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoMaybe super intelligence would know that you’d suspect as much and decided to hide in plain sight, knowing it would be suspected but also knowing that humans would just rationalize it as paranoia and dismiss it eventually, letting it do its thing quietly and uninhibited.
- mcguire 8y agoYou can make this argument about anything: meteorites, viruses, tigers, supernovae... And yet, we're still here.
- vidarh 8y agoThis is flawed line of thinking. We can say with certainty that the probability of us being wiped out by meteorites, viruses, tigers and supernovae over any unit of time that fits in our past is less than 100%, but the probability over the same time period repeated over a suitably long multiple of time could still approach 100% to whatever number of precision for any one of those for what we know. By investigating specifics of each of those threat we may be able to assign lower probabilities to them, but the fact we have survived them so far is not in itself evidence of much, because if we had not we wouldn't be here to talk about it and hence, no matter what the prior probability of us surviving the sequence of events leading us here is, the posterior probability of us having survived all the events in our past is 100% (This is basically just a restatement of the anthropic principle) That we've survived so far just tells us that surviving what we've been through so far is possible. It doesn't tell us that doing so is probable if we were to go through it again. Nor does it say anything about the probability of us surviving future threats that is likely to include things we have not yet seen.
- red75prime 8y agoSome of those we cannot control or mitigate. There's, therefore, no point in preparing for them. And neither of those can have a goal (or unfortunate subgoal) of destroying humanity, which goal they will pursue with superhuman perseverance, creativity, coherence and reaction time.
- Nasrudith 8y agoIt also needs to get lucky every time to exist and we are dealing with probabilities so remote at this point that the WHO is working hard to deal with the causalities from Boltzmann Brain's appearing out of vacuum and promptly annihilating because they happened to be made of antimatter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boltzmann_brain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boltzmann_brain Technically possible but we are dealing with probabilities that have lost all meaning of the word.
- vidarh 8y agoIt doesn't need to get lucky at all if people intentionally set out to create AGI.