11 ms·
Germany plans €3B in AI investments
- ccozan 8y agoThe amount doesn't matter. If this money will exist, they will be distributed in the most buerocratic way, making them irrelevant in a such a fast moving field.
- Isn0gud 8y agoYou are right, but I was wondering how an alternative could look like. Probably just giving it to universities to create more and better paid PhD possitions?!
- swift532 8y agoThat, and maybe instead of giving the money to a big, inefficient corporation that's going to spend it on low quality bullshit and snake oil, spreading the money along multiple established companies and startups, seeding them all with some money and offering additional incentives for achieving milestones/whatever.
- Mahn 8y agoImagine if those 3B were used to seed 3000 startups with 1M each. Even if only one third of these worked out, what an incredible golden age of productivity would that mean for the country.
- j_jochem 8y agoOne third is next to impossible. Anecdotally, startup survival rate should be around 5-10%. However, that should still yield better results than distributing the money amongst SAP and Deutsche Telekom.
- tluyben2 8y ago> giving the money to a big, inefficient corporation that's going to spend it on low quality bullshit Like T systems.
- mrdodge 8y agoThey'd probably get more return by 'encouraging' Google and American tech companies to open bigger offices.
- Isn0gud 8y agoWhy favor big companies that already have resources?
- mrdodge 8y agoIt's an interesting thought. Does German really have a prayer in this space? Making breakthroughs in this space isn't something just any trained student can do. The best all work for American tech companies... German co's don't believe in paying well. This can be extended to most European nations.
- orbifold 8y agoThose are really ignorant statements. Bosch, Siemens, BMW etc. definitely pay well and employ plenty of talented people.
- biglenny 8y agoIgnorant? It's a well known fact that European tech salaries (especially SWE salaries) are dwarfed by American/SV salaries. Just look up the difference in what GOOGLE pays its American vs EU employees. This doesn't even take into account taxation rate, which is favorable in US. Virtually every "How much do you earn?" thread that pops up on HN has loads of comments with Europeans being surprised at the amount of money Americans make in tech. Further - right now America is close to uncontested in the amount of technology it is producing and exporting. The only widely used European software I can think of is SAP. America is winning the talent war. I've only had a few friends who moved from US to Europe for tech work - and in all cases it had nothing to do with the job. Had more to do with wanting to "explore new places". On the other hand, I know tonnes of Euros, Indians, and Chinese who have come to US to work.
- Grumbledour 8y agoOne could call it cute or funny, if it was not to the detriment of actually needed digital technology in the country, like broadband or support of IT startups. But I am sure Deutsche Telekom will be quite happy about more state money, which is probably why they whispered this AI nonsense into the politicians ears. We can just write it up as another German success story, IT made in Germany. When has that ever not worked out in our favor?
- _match 8y ago>> When has that ever not worked out in our favor? Would you explain a little more? I'm ignorant about the history of German government investment in IT. But here in America, federal investment has helped ignite new industries. And as a data science engineer, I'd love to see more German code.
- cabraca 8y ago"Investments in IT" by the german government means we somehow funnel money to the big companies to make sure they dont fire people. Deutsche Telekom daughter T-Systems decided in september to cut 6000 jobs in germany (10k worldwide) to save 600mio €/year. Now the Government spents 3B on "AI". Coincidence?
- cat199 8y agoseems a bit of a stretch in correlation ... what does it mean if Angela Merkel wears green underwear on tuesday?
- cabraca 8y agoConsider this: approximately 32% of Deutsche Telekom is owned by the german state[0]. Its in their interest, that the money goes to the "right" company. [0]: https://www.telekom.com/en/investor-relations/company/shareholder-structure https://www.telekom.com/en/investor-relations/company/shareh...
- tluyben2 8y ago
- nradov 8y agoOh great, more industrial policy. I'm sure the results of this program will be just as spectacular as Japan's fifth-generation computer. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer
- orbifold 8y agoIt has worked great in the US, see the DARPA challenges etc. Plenty of those programs have worked out, it is pointless to point only at failed ones.
- Barrin92 8y agoIt can work out well and it can fail. While experiments like Japan's fifth generation computer may have failed to produce commercial results, it still trained a generation of very able scientists. Without the significant spending of the US government, the Silicon Valley would not exist in its current form either. During a time when software and hardware applications had no large market, the military and the government where essentially the only large consumers of the American businesses that are now hundreds of billions of dollars large. Entrepreneurs in the US love this renegade story of somehow being less dependent on government support than anyone else on the planet, but it's revisionist history. A lot of American commercial success in IT has its roots in government funded programs and consumption.
- pgtan 8y ago> It can work out well and it can fail. No, it will fail, as every German project of this kind failed. Someone will get rich, the project will close after some years. The overrated Germany is socialism 2.0.
- Barrin92 8y agoI am German and I can definitely tell you that I am not living in socialism right now.
- raphman 8y agoHere's the offical strategy (in German): https://www.bundesfinanzministerium.de/Content/DE/Downloads/Digitalisierung/2018-11-15-Strategie-zur-Kuenstlichen-Intelligenz.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=2 https://www.bundesfinanzministerium.de/Content/DE/Downloads/... While I'm very skeptical of this initiative for a number of reasons, I appreciate that they explicitly mention the need for Open Data and seem to commit to improving accessibility of governmental data sources.
- ccozan 8y agoIndeed. The way they describe what they want, it looks like all the money will be spent on endless meetings or conferences and producing policy and strategy documents. Maybe 1% will flow into a real research project which will generate some value.
- thwy12321 8y agoThe people in these countries dont respect programmers, they pay them peanuts. How are they going to innovate?
- zwaps 8y agoSince only relative income count, you have to expand your comment by saying that these countries - Do not respect Bankers and CEOs - Do not respect academics - Do not respect managers - Respect teachers too much - Respect waiters and delivery drivers too much etc. It's all relative. It's all trade-offs. In the US, you can get actual rich by working a normal dev job. On the other hand, many of my US high school teachers literally had to work at Wal-mart on the side. Unthinkable elsewhere. Result: Lots of innovation, but only by importing top tier talent from Asia and Europe, since high school education sucks maaajor balls compared to those countries. So yeah, all trade-offs.
- thwy12321 8y agoNot trying to start an argument about country wide wage compensation. But relative to other 'competitive' professional careers, such as doctors, lawyers, bankers, etc, Europe vastly underpays programmers, but also shows them little respect in the workplace. It's not just about the money, the social status of a software engineer in Europe is very low. This is making it difficult for Europe to compete on an international basis to create powerful tech companies. There are other reasons, such as fragmented markets, multiple languages, and the conservatism of the VC industry.
- friedsdeirf 8y agoMy physician and lawyer friends in Berlin have salaries in the same ballpark as my programmer friends.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIn some European countries at least. Poland is next door from Germany, and we have more "american" distribution of wages - programmers are high-earners, teachers are low-earners. From what I hear, Germany seems relatively unique in having its programmers a part of the lower class.
- 5_minutes 8y agoGermany is still not allowed to have an offensive army, so it makes a lot of sense to at least stay first class in tech, and in AI, in order to stay relevant as a world leader for the future.
- blattimwind 8y agoThe Kellog-Briand pact prohibits signatories (including the US) from offensive wars anyway. Article 2 of the United Nations Charter states that members shouldn't even use threats of offensive actions. And the Grundgesetz obviously bans offensive wars as well. Not sure what you're thinking, but you're waaaaaay out there.
- 5_minutes 8y agoThey are basically not allowed to have a real army, still just like Japan, "only defence armies". I'm not talking about offense acts or actions. I'm talking about being allowed to do miletary R&D and actually being allowed to have a real army out there. They don't. So how far off is it to assume they're assertive with AI to make up for it?
- anoncake 8y agoTechnically, the GG only bans preparing an offensive war. But what kind of German would improvise that kind of thing?
- bitL 8y agoEveryone in Germany I know who actually made a world-class product had to escape some inept manager at some large German corporation, and those people are automatically excluded from any government subsidies due to a lack of political contacts. So the money will go to people with political skills and buzzword bingo, likely not being able to understand anything they are talking about. Then, in 5 years everyone will look back and wonder why Germany is again 5 years behind and resorts to importing all software from US; then external factors will be found to blame (or some poor scapegoats that didn't cover their backs). And a next gen of clueless managers will step up for another cycle with another hot technology.
- cauldron 8y agoI don't know how this works in Germany, but in China, it usually goes this way: doesn't matter if you are good at or even know it (officials won't care), just scour the internet and produce a PPT, pull some strings to arrange a fancy dinner with relevant local officials, deal done, once you got the money hire someone to do a demo, profit. One woman bragging about this was vacationing on the Palm Jumeirah island in UAE last year, she was there pitching her block chain projects to Arabs.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rmetzler 8y agoI'm German and don't think there are fancy dinners needed, before you get the funding money. It's much more bureaucracy. It can be so much overhead in administrative work that companies which try to find a stable business model may not want to invest into getting research funds and other companies may have specialized in applying and getting research funding. From what I hear it's not unusual to use the money for paying people who work on other topics, produce a little output and write in the report "we did some research, but more research is needed..."
- rsp1984 8y agoThe problem is not a lack of funds. The problem is bureaucracy and a lack of startup infrastructure. My feeling is that the people in charge have absolutely no effing clue about how to most efficiently deploy this money so they will do what sounds good on paper but will have 0 effect in reality. If it goes how it usually goes the largest part of this money will likely to to universities and other research institutions where it will be spent financing open-ended research projects that, in virtually all cases, go exactly nowhere, due to lack of proper incentives to produce something that works. The rest of the money will be "up for grabs" by companies who have perfected the crafts and arts of getting grant money from the German or EU government. The bureaucratic hurdles and time frames are typically way too large for most capital constrained nimble startups who need to move fast. So it's mostly established and/or zombie companies that take advantage of this.
- bitL 8y agoA typical Berlin startup: - hires devs with extremely low salaries - gives 0.004% equity at best - is run by people that are "better than anybody else" - expects constant overtime and 24/7 employee reachability - has managers with issues saying "thank you" - hires friends/family to higher echelons of company Does this sound like a recipe for success?
- SilasX 8y ago>expects constant overtime and 24/7 employee reachability Doesn't that conflict with German labor law? Edit: Definitely agree about credentialism ("people that are better than anyone else"). Germany takes that to the extreme. Career change in your 30s? Not possible.
- zeroname 8y ago> Doesn't that conflict with German labor law? I doubt it, Germans rank high in terms of unpaid overtime. https://www.dw.com/en/unpaid-overtime-a-common-phenomenon-in-germany/a-41847449 https://www.dw.com/en/unpaid-overtime-a-common-phenomenon-in... They also have some of the lowest wages combined with the rather high social security expenses. https://www.learngermanonline.org/salaries-and-living-costs-in-germany/ https://www.learngermanonline.org/salaries-and-living-costs-... Given that, I think Germany doesn't deserve its good reputation.
- musha68k 8y agoGood initiative but unfortunately far too late to the game.
- dna_polymerase 8y agoFraunhofer and MPI will get some of that, so at least some computer scientist will see the money, most of it will end in the pockets of consulting firms and of course surveillance tech. IT Made in Germany is a disgrace to the brainpower in Germany.
- baxtr 8y agoI have read the basis of this provided in (1). Unfortunately, like many other “strategies”, this so called AI strategy is completely missing a good (root cause) analysis. It jumps to conclusions and “activity areas”. With no good analysis, there can’t be a good strategy (2). This money won’t change anything. (1) https://www.bundesfinanzministerium.de/Content/DE/Downloads/Digitalisierung/2018-11-15-Strategie-zur-Kuenstlichen-Intelligenz.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=2 https://www.bundesfinanzministerium.de/Content/DE/Downloads/... (2) https://www.amazon.com/Good-Strategy-Bad-Difference-Matters/dp/0307886239 https://www.amazon.com/Good-Strategy-Bad-Difference-Matters/...
- zeroname 8y agoAt least it's not blockchain.
- friedsdeirf 8y agoA lot of you are dissing German industry --- because they don't have FAANGs or other unicorns? They still have a large high-tech industrial base and many world-recognized brand names. These German exporters must spend a good deal on R&D, and now they'll have another grant to apply for - even if a large chunk of this goes to BMW or Siemens, is that any different from NYC granding amazon 1 billion dollars to build an office in Queens? And they do produce good research (and good researchers), some of whom don't go to work for US companies / institutes --- and this gives them another potential grant too...
- thomasjames 8y agoEurocracy will not make that go very far.
- stakhanov 8y agoWhy is everyone talking about startups? It sounds to me like this is talking about research. The problem with publicly funded science projects in Europe: Salaries/Hourly Rates are set at very low levels and the rulebooks make zero allowance for being able to pay better people more money. Over the decades of doing this type of funding they've created a caste of technology workers who wouldn't even have jobs in technology if it weren't for the fact that they can go from one government-funded project to the next, where the quality of your work means little and the willingness to work for little money means everything. Every couple of years they slap a new label on what kind of technology it is that they want created, but the people doing the work stay the same people, and the output remains nonexistent because no one is even asking for any in a meaningful way. Plus 3B over 6 years for such a huge economy isn't really an impressive sum of money at all.